Cool. You does sounds like you know your stuffs well.
I probably belongs in between those that 'believe what you you are told' & 'question what is reality'. Thing is, I cannot be the expert in all field to excel in understanding 'lighting strike' vs how effective 'surge protector' works.
I agree with you that Surge Protector is much less needed in Singapore when 80% population live in HDB flats with a centralized as well as better surge protection against lightning. Also, telephone lines in Singapore are buried in ground.
I use Belkin in my mum's place in Malaysia. Of course, mainly because choosing to 'conveniently' believing in what they claimed. If you can give me more & better advice, I am all ears.
In Malaysia, most people stays in terrace house, meaning, electrical surge protection is within each house. And it seemed my mum's house circuit breaker will be activated from time to time during lightning strike. So, electrical protection seemed to working.
Next, telephone lines in Malaysia is exposed on telephone poles. That is the best part, it catches lightning & the energy surge all the way to the phone lines in the house & continue to go into the telephone, the modem & 'BAM'! It melted the phone lines & killed the modem & router.
So, I have the Belkin protecting the telephone line & TV antenna now.
Seemed like, my mum didn't see any charred telephone line or dead modem for a long while... should I guess the Belkin Surge protector strip is working? I hope & choose to think so.
Let me know any other better solution than this. Thanks.
Sorry, I am no expert in electricity & didn't read through your whole explanation. That's why I am in between those 'conveniently' choose to believe & those 'hope to know more' category. Thanks.
You can immediately identify those who only repeat what they are told to believe. Who never ask questions. Who do not even know what the product does.
How does a 2 cm part inside that Belkin or APC stop what three miles of sky could not? It does not. How do its hundreds of joules absorb destructive surges that are hundreds of thousands of joules? It does not. Why do its numeric specs not even list protection from each type of surge? It is sold to people who automatically believe what they are told. Never ask why. Never demand numbers. Only believe the first thing they are told. Can also be sold the Brooklyn Bridge.
Surge protection has worked and been well proven even 100 years ago. Would earth direct lightning strikes so that operators never remove headsets and leave the room. And then is a scam that does not even claim surge protection in its numeric specs. Take a $3 power strip. Add some ten cent protector parts. Sell it for $25 or $150. Many will recommend the same protector selling for $150 only because it costs more money.
Your telco's switching computer in every CO is connected to overhead wires all over town. Suffers about 100 surges with each thunderstorm. Money is never wasted on scam protectors such as the Belkin or APC. Instead telcos use vastly cheaper protectors that earth even direct lightning strikes ... and remain functional.
Remember, if Belkin, et al grossly undersizes a protector. then the protector will completely fail - provide zero protection. That failure gets the most naive to recommend it. Effective protectors for every home earth direct lightning strikes – and remain functional.
Serious protection already exists inside every appliance. A surge too small to harm any appliances can destroy a scam protector. That failure promotes sales – especially among consumers who are not thinking. Effective protectors for much less money remain functional.
Your concern is a rare surge that typically occurs once every seven years. That surge can overwhelm protection inside appliances. That surge cannot be stopped, blocked, or absorbed by an adjacent protector. The effective solution was even patented over 100 years ago. Used in every telco CO, munitions dumps, and commercial broadcasting station so that numerous direct lightning strikes cause no damage. That same protector is installed in every house for about $1 per protected appliance. And is sold by far more responsible companies such as General Electric, Siemens, Square D, Polyphaser, ABB, Intermatic, and Leviton - to name but a few responsible companies. An effective Cutler-Hammer solution sells in Lowes and Home Depot for less than $50.
No, you still do not have surge protection. Those are only protectors. What Belkin and APC hope you never learn: a protector and protection are two completely different items. 'Whole house' protectors from responsible companies have the always required and dedicated wire to earth. A wire that must be short (ie 'less than 10 meters). Not just to any ground; single point earth ground. The protector connect destructive surges harmlessly to the only thing that does protection – single point eareth ground.
Belkin, APC, and the master of all scams (Monster) will not discuss earth ground. If they did, you would never buy their products. And you would spend less money. Effective protectors earth direct lightning strikes without damage. Even the protector remains functional. But again, technology well proven and repeatedly demonstrated for over 100 years. Not a plug-in scam sold on retail myths.
You should have numerous questions. Especially if you were taken by Belkin, et al retail myths. This old and well proven technology is virtually unknown to an overwhelming majority educated only by retail advertising. Effective protection even from direct lightning strikes uses a protector that costs about $1 per protected appliance.