Langkawi or Tioman better?

[Fito24]

Wish to go either one with my GF for a short holiday.

Any bros here went any of the above mentioned and can advise me which one would be a better choice?

[socrates]

Langkawi more expensive and if going so far which requires me to fly i would rather go to Krabi or Phuket whihc has similar if not better scenery and more value for money.

Krabi
http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f346/moonrei/krabi/IMG_0376.jpg

Tioman cheaper, nearer and more affordable. can stretch your dollar here more.

For me I prefer Perhentian islands. Though far but it is value for many, fewer poeple, more romantic, great waters and scenery

http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f346/moonrei/perhentian/beachview.jpg

[mastermember]

I think no harm going to all if you have the moolah!