Beware of New Money Making Scheme Emerging in Singapore

alexchia01

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
1,945
Reaction score
2
Good idea!

We should update this tread often and create awareness for investment scams in Singapore.

I'll add some too.
 

freedom2001

Senior Member
Joined
May 24, 2001
Messages
943
Reaction score
1
RBI Holdings Pte Ltd was seen promoting their Sri Lanka mud crab aquaculture investment at Suntect City property show on Oct 2014.

They claim to wish to supply local supermarkets with a continual source of crabs, thus they are aiming for 80 mud ponds, looking for investors.

Anyone familiar with this extremely lucrative, ultra high, guaranteed return, up to 15% returns per year and 45% profit sharing (based on a 100K investment) program?

Pls share.
 

archcherub

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Oct 21, 2001
Messages
4,162
Reaction score
4
RBI Holdings Pte Ltd was seen promoting their Sri Lanka mud crab aquaculture investment at Suntect City property show on Oct 2014.

They claim to wish to supply local supermarkets with a continual source of crabs, thus they are aiming for 80 mud ponds, looking for investors.

Anyone familiar with this extremely lucrative, ultra high, guaranteed return, up to 15% returns per year and 45% profit sharing (based on a 100K investment) program?

Pls share.

How can agriculture be guaranteed returns? One disease or some drought or flood and ur whole stock of livestocks or crops would all vanish.

Simple logic... Unless the crabs are immortals.


What a load of crabs. (pun intended)
 

archcherub

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Oct 21, 2001
Messages
4,162
Reaction score
4
Good idea!

We should update this tread often and create awareness for investment scams in Singapore.

I'll add some too.

Yeah bro..
One more..
http://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/money-mind-210/ufun-new-scam-mlm-4859181.html

Stay clear of anything that screams scam!
 

archcherub

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Oct 21, 2001
Messages
4,162
Reaction score
4
S$50m lost in alleged scam

another scam bites the dust.
gee... don't people ever read newspaper or internet before they put their hard earned money down?

S$50m lost in alleged scam - Channel NewsAsia

SINGAPORE: About 150 people have lodged a police report, after a company they had invested in became uncontactable.

The investors, who comprised both local and Chinese nationals, had invested a total of S$50 million. Individual investments ranged from S$40,000 to S$8 million.

Under the so-called “Sure Win 4 U” scheme set up by a Malaysian company, the money received would go towards funding professional gamblers.

Alleged victims were lured by returns of as much as three times their investment at the end of two years. The scheme promised a monthly payout of between five and nine per cent on investment. The money earned would be in the form of online credits, which could only be converted into cash by the company's team leaders.

Alarm bells started ringing in September last year, when investors were unable to contact team leaders from the firm. The company's Kuala Lumpur office was abandoned when an investor visited in October.

Police confirmed they have received a report, adding that it was inappropriate to comment at this time.

Madam Lao, who invested S$200,000 in the scheme, said: "I was thinking we are going to retire, and this seemed like a good platform because memberships numbered over 100,000 from all over the world. And this is the first time we have invested in such things. I did not know this was actually a scam case."

- CNA/xk
 

archcherub

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Oct 21, 2001
Messages
4,162
Reaction score
4
I attended CTL seminars and was very interested. Lucky for me, a quick google search made me realised what a scam it was. The lady made a marketing mistake of providing the properties address in her brochures, and I did a google search (actually it pointed to zillow.com for the property values) and realised it is cheaper for me to fly SIA business class over to get an attoney, buy the property and fly back.... than to buy from CTL.

The google search took me probably 5minutes top.

Wonder why these people who are capable of good salaries and decent savings to invest cannot even figure out a proper google search before they invest tens of thousand dollars...

_____________________________
Singapore Seen | Singaporeans lose thousands after US property scheme turns sour

Singaporeans lose thousands after US property scheme turns sour

Almost all his savings were wiped out. This included money for his family, two schoolgoing children and holiday plans.

Mr Kenneth Ng, 43, never imagined himself to be a real estate investor, but after listening to a speaker at a property seminar, he invested almost all of his $80,000 savings.

The supply chain executive, who earns $8,000 a month, bought a "fixer-upper" in the US city of Memphis for US$55,000 (S$74,500).

A fixer-upper is real estate slang for a property that needs maintenance work, such as redecoration, reconstruction or redesign, before it can be lived in. That was in 2013. Mr Ng never got the promised returns.

The property guru who made the sales pitch? She stopped taking calls and answering e-mails. Then out of the blue, Mr Ng received letters from lawyers in the US telling him to pay up or the property would face foreclosure.

Mr Ng, who has never been to the US, sent two cheques of US$4,000 and US$5,000 to keep the bank at bay. He is not the only one to put their trust in the US property scheme - others had invested in houses in Indianapolis.

One investor bought two properties - the first in Memphis, the other in Indianapolis - through the same scheme. She even made a video 10 months ago, praising the scheme and the woman behind it.

Now, the same investor is singing a different tune, saying that her cheques to the banks to stop the foreclosure of her homes are currently stuck at a US lawyer's office.

And the promised returns? She said she only received one month's worth of rent from the Memphis property. The investor, who spoke to The New Paper on Sunday, declined to be identified and is holding out for money to be returned.

A group of these investors contacted TNPS to tell their story. Some are civil servants. A couple are in between jobs, but most have regular jobs.

All of them have put their trust in a woman who allegedly told them she would handle everything, from the loans to legal letters.

There was nothing for the investors to do other than to wait for their money to grow at returns of between 14.5 and 22.3 per cent.

They were told they would own the properties, which would be repaired before being rented out within three to six months. And when values go up, they would be flipped. It was just too easy.

Mr Ng said: "I'm not familiar with the US property market - none of the investors are. But the presentation by CTL Property was good and its founder Clara Tan was very convincing,"

He met her at real estate seminars held at Marina Bay Sands, first in December 2012 and again in February 2013.

"What drew many of us in was, CTL is a one-stop shop, offering full services from tax submissions, tax filing, getting legal representations and so forth," he said.

He said like him, the other investors even signed over their power of attorney - that meant legally, she could decide for them.

"I'm not a detailed person, so when CTL said it will hold all the documents, I didn't demand a copy of the contracts for myself," Mr Ng said.

That was the start of a massive headache. CTL Group and its founder and director, Ms Clara Tan, were hot in the property scene between 2008 and 2012.

Her seminars on topics such as maximising rental yield, spotting prime property below market value, need-to-know tips for foreign markets and the power of leverage saw robust turnouts, and were sometimes over-subscribed.

Believing in her business model, several Singaporeans invested their hard-earned savings in her projects in Memphis and Indianapolis, where she said she "flipped" properties.

When the US housing bubble burst and the 2008 banking crisis followed, owners in many US cities, including Memphis and Indianapolis, were badly hit.

Many simply abandoned the properties they could no longer make payments for. The Singaporean investors bought over these houses.

Their money was supposed to be used to repair dozens of homes in some of the most down-and-out neighbourhoods of the two cities. The investors paid in full and the cost was supposed to cover all renovations. There were not supposed to be bank loans.

They also owned the US properties but to minimise work on their part, they signed the power of attorney over to Ms Tan's company for CTL to manage the properties.

But only one of the 12 investors TNPS met received a title deed. The rest never got their documents because they were told the documents would all be posted online on the company's website. It never happened.

In Indianapolis, Ms Tan's company popped up in county land sales records of 2013 as the buyer of at least 18 low-priced homes in Center Township. These purchases stood out, because at least eight were sold by non-profit group New Day Residential.

In May 2013, the president of New Day Residential was among five people charged in a kickback and bribery scandal involving vacant homes sold by the city-run Indy Land Bank.

One John Hawkins pleaded guilty to wire fraud in an alleged scheme to reap kickbacks from the sale of abandoned properties last June.

On Sept 2013, The Indianapolis Star reported that CTL Global Holdings had already resold some of its Indianapolis properties "at prices sharply higher than it paid for them to buyers with Asian names".

For instance, records in 2013 showed two side-by-side houses bought by CTL were sold by the Land Bank to New Day for US$2,500 (S$3,390) in March.

They were resold that same month to CTL for US$10,000 and in April, CTL "flipped" the houses for US$38,334 each to the current owners. Both homes remain unrenovated.

"The first sign of trouble was six months after, when the property management company engaged by CTL started communicating directly with us, the investors," said Mr Kenneth Ng. The property management company in question is in the US.

Mr Ng's troubles were echoed by many other investors and The New Paper on Sunday met with seven of them on Jan 24. A 60-year-old investor told TNPS on Friday that he bought two properties in Indianapolis and paid in full, spending about $100,000 in all.

"I was given the two title deeds but in the US, the homes were not really under my name - it was under CTL Global Holdings LLC," he said.

The purchases were finalised in July 2013 and he was receiving rental payment from one of the properties until September last year.

The investors were supposed to receive rental income, ranging from US$400 to US$600 (S$540 to S$810), three to six months after they became owners of the houses. The delay was to ensure renovations to the houses were completed and tenants secured.

But after six months, the seven investors claimed they had received no returns from the rentals. Instead, US banks sent them letters for mortgages unpaid and warned of foreclosing the properties.

"The last we heard was that 12 properties owned by Singaporeans have been foreclosed and six are waiting for foreclosure," said another investor, a civil servant who wanted to be known only as Ms Tan.

"With 12 properties foreclosed and each costing about US$50,000, our losses amount to US$600,000," she added. At first, the investors claimed, Ms Clara Tan called them regularly to update them.

But around mid-2014, the calls slowed down and eventually died. The investors grew worried when US banks wrote to them, telling them to make good the mortgage payment or their properties might face foreclosure.

The investors then wrote to Ms Tan repeatedly. They also called and even visited her Pemimpin Drive office and home address, a condominium at Upper Thomson Road. She could not be reached.

One investor, however, managed to get her on Skype sometime in November and she claimed she was being detained in Indianapolis by the US Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and her passport had been impounded.

Some investors decided to group together to find some way to get themselves out of trouble. They made separate police reports on Jan 17 and 18,and reported to the Council for Estate Agencies on Jan 29.

Police confirmed the reports had been lodged and would only say that they were looking into the matter. TNPS also contacted FBI Special Agent and Media Representative (Indianapolis) Wendy Osborne.

Are they looking into land purchases by CTL Global and is it linked to a land bank scandal? Is the FBI or another law-enforcement agency holding Ms Tan? Ms Osborne would only say that the FBI does not confirm or deny investigations.

Often, when a Singaporean is in trouble overseas, a relative might contact the Ministry of Foreign Affairs for assistance. But an MFA spokesman says the ministry has not been approached for assistance.

The New Paper on Sunday team visited the CTL Global office at One Pemimpin twice, and the door was locked on both occasions. Calls to the numbers listed on the website also went unanswered.

A check with neighbouring offices found that no one had been seen going in or coming out of the unit since three months ago. Twice, the team visited her condominium, but nobody answered the door even though Chinese New Year decorations were up.

An e-mail sent to Ms Tan also went unanswered. But TNPS understands that Tan and CTL Global are not only foraying into Cambodia, but have also conducted webinars (seminars via the Web) since Jan 8 to attract investors from the country.
 

archcherub

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Oct 21, 2001
Messages
4,162
Reaction score
4
The more i read these scams, the more i think singaporeans are really dumb to give their money away
 

empowerme

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2013
Messages
29
Reaction score
0
These scammers are well trained in human psychology and know what "greed" buttons to press
 

empowerme

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2013
Messages
29
Reaction score
0
I don't think UFUN is a scam, it's more of a Bitcoin want-to-be, which is likely to fail miserably.

UFUN is surely a scam. Already it's Thai operations have been raided by the police. You can do a quick google of the news in bangkok post.
 

empowerme

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2013
Messages
29
Reaction score
0
anyone went Invest Fair 2014 and came across any of these suspicious firms?
Plenty of them these years.

FYI Sunday Times, 3 August 2014, Invest page has a few pages on all these alternate investments, schemes...

"Different Scams, Same Goal"

and recent additions to MAS Investor Alert List

EcoHouse Group (EcoHouse) - brazil property developer
Zochwell Group - projects and investment portfolio in South east Asia, especially Myanmar
Aureus Capital - consistently high returns via currency tradings....

Wait for 1 - 2 years to see what is going to happen.....

Yeah, these so called "Investment Fair" have been swarmed by dodgy operators. They have become hardsell, cross selling events with little substance...
 

wahkao3

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2005
Messages
26,835
Reaction score
19
http://www.cracked.com/personal-experiences-1620-amway-5-realities-multi-billion-dollar-scam.html

For those who still is not convinced of how MLM loses you more money than making money...
MLM is not a scam
the products are real products that ppl can use

if you are truly capable at selling, you can really make it big.
The ppl who accuse MLM of being a scam are the ones who lack sales and marketing skills.. instead of blaming their own lack of competency skill, they blame the system.


Its the same everywhere regardless where u work.
 

chemicalorange

Junior Member
Joined
May 11, 2008
Messages
69
Reaction score
0
RBI Holdings Pte Ltd was seen promoting their Sri Lanka mud crab aquaculture investment at Suntect City property show on Oct 2014.

They claim to wish to supply local supermarkets with a continual source of crabs, thus they are aiming for 80 mud ponds, looking for investors.

Anyone familiar with this extremely lucrative, ultra high, guaranteed return, up to 15% returns per year and 45% profit sharing (based on a 100K investment) program?

Pls share.

I went to Invest Fair 2015 and here's what I know so far from my conversation with one of the agents.

Business Info:
They own fish farms in SG, Malaysia and Sri Lanka. In SG, they have 1 in Pulau Ubin and opening soon, 1 in Kranji. SG and Malaysia farms rear fish while the Sri Lanka one will rear Sri Lankan crabs. Last time, they only had 1 fish farm at Pulau Ubin but their stock mass died and because of that, they decided to diversify to Malaysia and Sri Lanka. They are also exploring to expand to Papua New Guinea with a farm rearing salmons destined for the Aussie market as the location is suitable for deep sea farm fishing but they foresee trouble if the supply produced cannot keep up with the demand ordered. They also have hatcheries and fish feed production facilities that are destined for their own farms but they want to expand them to cater to the mass market. RBI is the owner of these farms and they are the one responsible for their maintenance, R&D, finance, etc.

What's the money used for?
For expansion purposes as described above. They have a quota cap of SG$5 million and once they reached that, they will stop getting new investors. They are also planning to launch their IPO in 3 years times and investors will be offered a 75% on the shares which means that an investor can get 4 times more shares.

What happen if the fish died?
They diversify to other countries so that the other farms can continue to keep the business going. The Sri Lanka one is insured while the others are not. The dead fish will be turned to fish feed and sold off too. In the most extreme case where they folded, they would have a net asset value of us$5 million that can be used to pay back to investors (I think).

Other info?
I cant find much other than the company's website. There's no complains and comments from anyone that has invested in it. I also can't find any financial statements and research material to read.

I didn't ask why they didn't try to get bank loans or get big investors like Temasek to be interested in them. The aquaculture industry is growing globally due to the demand for farmed seafood and that should get a few big investors to be excited about. I think the return is high and can be achieved but the risk is high as well.

My opinion?
I am hesitant to say its a scam until I see some evidence of feedback. I like the clear direction of their plans but the lack of info about their finances is the one that deters me from investing especially since this is a bond. Its also good that some of the farms are in Singapore which you can have access too. Things like this have to do research and can't just sign on the day itself even if its just for a small returnable deposit.



As a suggestion to SPH (the owners of HWZ and InvestFair), there should be an MAS booth at events such as InvestFair where visitors can get advise, learn about policies governing investment products, report any unethical activities, etc.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top