Fastest ISP?

[kappak]

ST 2GB
Summary:
1. HLJ is the slowest
2. Taiwan is the fastest
3. Signal turn weak from strong compare from east to west

1st Test


2nd Test


3rd Test

 

[hwzlite]

eh you running a home datacentre is it

Anyway, how you setup your home connection? You establish a VPN tunnel to your colo?

M1 500Mbps fibre

Same same on M1 500Mbps fibre roaming on this morning weekend traffic.
Bestest from 电信 福建厦门(CN2-咕咕云) 57.9ms & 华东 福建厦门(CN2-咕咕云) 57.9ms :

 

[jasonho]

VQ fixed IP - 1Gbps normal plan.

 

[cyberet]

May I know if this is MR gamer or normal?
Been looking for good connection to China for long time liao.

this was my MR business account
shouldn't be a big difference as its the lowest 300mbps plan.

Recently noticed MR interconnect with local ISPs abit slow as my VPN drop to 20-50mbps from the usual 100mbps during peak period. For most users this isn't important, unless you need to VPN home extensively

based on past experience, gamer/normal also not much difference unless you want that extra service of asking tech support to optimise to game servers. (they do not optimise to websites/etc, only to game servers. I tried before)

 

[cyberet]

consolidated results in table format

MR Biz	MR Gamer	MR 1gbps Ultra	Starhub	VQ Fixed IP	M1 500mbps	M1 2nd hop	ST 1gbps	WC Gateway	Simba gateway
平均	平均	平均	平均	average	平均	平均	平均	平均	平均	area	区域
143.3ms	146.1ms	183.7ms	207.4ms	207.3ms	213.1ms	215.1ms	215.4ms	225.8ms	218.7ms	Whole network	全网
76.5ms	121.0ms	136.6ms	144.1ms	108.3ms	392.7ms	434.0ms	128.4ms	134.5ms	400.8ms	move	移动
73.2ms	75.3ms	169.3ms	191.4ms	373.1ms	241.1ms	246.9ms	87.7ms	92.8ms	353.3ms	China Unicom	联通
82.8ms	86.2ms	301.4ms	432.6ms	279.7ms	347.1ms	359.6ms	321.6ms	360.0ms	379.6ms	telecommunications	电信
50.0ms	61.7ms	257.1ms	382.3ms	297.9ms	331.0ms	344.1ms	219.5ms	228.5ms	364.2ms	South China	华南
78.8ms	80.8ms	238.4ms	328.2ms	276.6ms	320.8ms	335.9ms	205.1ms	244.2ms	358.2ms	North China	华北
78.6ms	87.8ms	236.2ms	304.2ms	263.3ms	310.8ms	324.4ms	203.2ms	209.7ms	369.4ms	East China	华东
74.3ms	74.9ms	199.8ms	271.9ms	301.8ms	316.0ms	327.7ms	178.9ms	187.9ms	365.6ms	Central China	华中
104.0ms	135.2ms	231.2ms	295.4ms	284.2ms	316.6ms	339.1ms	190.5ms	209.2ms	380.9ms	northeast	东北
99.9ms	145.1ms	283.9ms	362.0ms	336.6ms	337.1ms	356.1ms	195.3ms	353.8ms	389.8ms	northwest	西北
76.7ms	76.8ms	268.0ms	351.1ms	295.0ms	340.8ms	360.2ms	262.6ms	283.9ms	395.2ms	southwest	西南
49.1ms	56.3ms	57.3ms	61.0ms	61.5ms	84.2ms	64.7ms	59.7ms	73.8ms	86.5ms	Hong Kong, Macao and Taiwan	港澳台
64.5ms	67.1ms	68.1ms	73.7ms	105.0ms	81.1ms	75.6ms	84.0ms	97.1ms	87.3ms	Asia	亚洲
182.5ms	181.7ms	185.1ms	192.5ms	205.5ms	213.9ms	215.1ms	296.0ms	314.2ms	173.7ms	Europe	欧洲
246.9ms	244.7ms	247.5ms	268.9ms	291.1ms	285.5ms	296.1ms	365.9ms	408.0ms	246.1ms	Africa	非洲
216.4ms	217.1ms	217.3ms	221.1ms	219.3ms	211.4ms	213.9ms	237.1ms	222.7ms	226.4ms	North America	北美洲
338.5ms	333.7ms	336.2ms	339.4ms	345.3ms	311.4ms	333.3ms	347.7ms	340.7ms	336.8ms	South America	南美洲
99.6ms	98.2ms	99.8ms	100.3ms	100.8ms	119.5ms	102.9ms	117.8ms	142.4ms	128.8ms	Oceania	大洋洲

 

[lobukong]

MR 1G ultra, ping for China very different from business plan.

全网	新加坡(腾讯云) 1.8ms/瑞典哈兰省法尔肯贝里市(glesys.se) 1575.8ms	183.7ms
移动	上海(移动云) 61.6ms/辽宁沈阳LM2(移动) 264.4ms	136.6ms
联通	湖南湘潭(联通云) 94.2ms/安徽滁州(电信) 323.8ms	169.3ms
电信	福建厦门(CN2-咕咕云) 57.1ms/浙江杭州(天翼云) 394.0ms	301.4ms
华南	海南海口(联通云) 110.7ms / 广东广州(青云) 489.4ms	257.1ms
华北	北京(移动云) 77.3ms / 内蒙古呼和浩特(bgp) 334.1ms	238.4ms
华东	福建厦门(CN2-咕咕云) 57.1ms / 上海(阿里云) 833.6ms	236.2ms
华中	湖南长沙(移动云) 71.4ms / 河南郑州(天翼云) 345.6ms	199.8ms
东北	辽宁大连(联通云一区) 139.1ms / 吉林长春(天翼云) 336.8ms	231.2ms
西北	宁夏银川(联通云) 228.8ms / 新疆乌鲁木齐(天翼云) 362.9ms	283.9ms
西南	贵州贵阳(移动云) 77.7ms / 重庆(电信) 380.4ms	268.0ms
港澳台	香港(无忧云) 32.7ms / 台湾台北市(imcloud.tw) 260.0ms	57.3ms
亚洲	新加坡(腾讯云) 1.8ms/哈萨克斯坦阿拉木图(ishosting.com) 406.9ms	68.1ms
欧洲	意大利伦巴第大区米兰广域市 141.3ms/瑞典哈兰省法尔肯贝里市(glesys.se) 1575.8ms	185.1ms
非洲	南非约翰内斯堡(oracle.com) 116.0ms/南非约翰内斯堡(oneprovider.com) 311.7ms	247.5ms
北美洲	美国加利福尼亚州洛杉矶(bgp.la) 164.2ms/美国弗吉尼亚州阿什本(misaka.io) 330.2ms	217.3ms
南美洲	波多黎各圣胡安(oneprovider.com) 248.3ms/智利瓦尔迪维亚 385.3ms	336.2ms
大洋洲	澳大利亚西澳大利亚州珀斯 47.9ms/澳大利亚新南威尔士州悉尼(AMAZON-LIGHTSAIL) 158.9ms	99.8ms

 

[Mach3.2]

MR biz plan getting the more expensive premium routes i suppose. Their consumer plan have similar latency when compared to their competitors' consumer plans.

 

[Groudon]

MR Gamer, for a long time it's been that the Gamer has direct China routes where the non-Gamer doesn't, seems it's still the same.

区域	最快/最慢	平均
全网	新加坡(Zeofast) 1.9ms/瑞典哈兰省法尔肯贝里市(glesys.se) 880.5ms	146.1ms
移动	上海(移动云) 62.0ms/辽宁沈阳LM2(移动) 267.5ms	121.0ms
联通	广东深圳(联通云) 41.6ms/江苏无锡(联通云) 202.4ms	75.3ms
电信	广东广州(天翼云四区) 40.0ms/陕西西安(移动云) 452.2ms	86.2ms
华南	广东广州(阿里云) 39.8ms / 广东广州(移动云) 205.6ms	61.7ms
华北	天津(天翼云) 71.5ms / 内蒙古呼和浩特(移动云) 94.7ms	80.8ms
华东	福建福州(联通云) 52.0ms / 江苏无锡(首云) 247.4ms	87.8ms
华中	湖南长沙(联通) 49.1ms / 湖北武汉(百度云) 253.3ms	74.9ms
东北	辽宁大连(联通云一区) 86.9ms / 辽宁沈阳LM2(移动) 267.5ms	135.2ms
西北	陕西西安(天翼云二区) 68.5ms / 陕西西安(移动云) 452.2ms	145.1ms
西南	贵州贵阳(联通云) 59.7ms / 西藏拉萨(天翼云) 109.7ms	76.8ms
港澳台	香港(阿里云) 32.8ms / 香港(PoloCloud) 208.9ms	56.3ms
亚洲	新加坡(Zeofast) 1.9ms/哈萨克斯坦阿拉木图(ps.kz) 301.2ms	67.1ms
欧洲	意大利伦巴第大区米兰广域市 140.9ms/瑞典哈兰省法尔肯贝里市(glesys.se) 880.5ms	181.7ms
非洲	南非约翰内斯堡(oracle.com) 116.5ms/南非开普敦(AMAZON) 319.8ms	244.7ms
北美洲	美国加利福尼亚州圣克拉拉(腾讯云) 168.0ms/哥斯达黎加圣何塞省圣何塞(oneprovider.com) 289.4ms	217.1ms
南美洲	波多黎各圣胡安(oneprovider.com) 252.3ms/乌拉圭蒙得维的亚省蒙得维的亚(antel.com.uy) 366.3ms	333.7ms
大洋洲	澳大利亚西澳大利亚州珀斯 48.8ms/澳大利亚新南威尔士州悉尼(GCP) 133.7ms	98.2ms

or to me, fastest means lowest latency to destination

It really does depend on what activity you're doing, lowest latency may not always be the best, but yes lowest latency numbers do look good

 

[Mach3.2]

Now we're missing starhub. Probably would be quite similar to the consumer non-gamer MR plans if i were to wager a guess.

 

[seowbin]

It really does depend on what activity you're doing, lowest latency may not always be the best, but yes lowest latency numbers do look good

It's true. If the link is congested , lowest latency might not get you the best thoughtput

However, here too many people obsessed with the 2.5g or 10g ... wanna combine 2 x cheapest plan together to get higher throughput but they might not get the desired result

Most direct feedback of user experience is latency and packet loss liao.

 

[seowbin]

Now we're missing starhub. Probably would be quite similar to the consumer non-gamer MR plans if i were to wager a guess.

Maybe all busy watching starhub tv, no time to surf net or their result too lousy. It broke their heart. Haha

 

[lobukong]

MR Gamer, for a long time it's been that the Gamer has direct China routes where the non-Gamer doesn't, seems it's still the same.

区域	最快/最慢	平均
全网	新加坡(Zeofast) 1.9ms/瑞典哈兰省法尔肯贝里市(glesys.se) 880.5ms	146.1ms
移动	上海(移动云) 62.0ms/辽宁沈阳LM2(移动) 267.5ms	121.0ms
联通	广东深圳(联通云) 41.6ms/江苏无锡(联通云) 202.4ms	75.3ms
电信	广东广州(天翼云四区) 40.0ms/陕西西安(移动云) 452.2ms	86.2ms
华南	广东广州(阿里云) 39.8ms / 广东广州(移动云) 205.6ms	61.7ms
华北	天津(天翼云) 71.5ms / 内蒙古呼和浩特(移动云) 94.7ms	80.8ms
华东	福建福州(联通云) 52.0ms / 江苏无锡(首云) 247.4ms	87.8ms
华中	湖南长沙(联通) 49.1ms / 湖北武汉(百度云) 253.3ms	74.9ms
东北	辽宁大连(联通云一区) 86.9ms / 辽宁沈阳LM2(移动) 267.5ms	135.2ms
西北	陕西西安(天翼云二区) 68.5ms / 陕西西安(移动云) 452.2ms	145.1ms
西南	贵州贵阳(联通云) 59.7ms / 西藏拉萨(天翼云) 109.7ms	76.8ms
港澳台	香港(阿里云) 32.8ms / 香港(PoloCloud) 208.9ms	56.3ms
亚洲	新加坡(Zeofast) 1.9ms/哈萨克斯坦阿拉木图(ps.kz) 301.2ms	67.1ms
欧洲	意大利伦巴第大区米兰广域市 140.9ms/瑞典哈兰省法尔肯贝里市(glesys.se) 880.5ms	181.7ms
非洲	南非约翰内斯堡(oracle.com) 116.5ms/南非开普敦(AMAZON) 319.8ms	244.7ms
北美洲	美国加利福尼亚州圣克拉拉(腾讯云) 168.0ms/哥斯达黎加圣何塞省圣何塞(oneprovider.com) 289.4ms	217.1ms
南美洲	波多黎各圣胡安(oneprovider.com) 252.3ms/乌拉圭蒙得维的亚省蒙得维的亚(antel.com.uy) 366.3ms	333.7ms
大洋洲	澳大利亚西澳大利亚州珀斯 48.8ms/澳大利亚新南威尔士州悉尼(GCP) 133.7ms	98.2ms

It really does depend on what activity you're doing, lowest latency may not always be the best, but yes lowest latency numbers do look good

I didn't know this info until now.
Will consider MR gamer next time.

 

[Mach3.2]

consider MR gamer next time.

Ya loh, I don't really see the value add until he posted his results

 

[cyberet]

wow, I'm surprised. thanks, good to know the difference between MR business/normal/gamer

updated my table

 

[HiHelloBye]

StarHub (1G)

 

[cyberet]

so in summary



China - MR Gamer, avoid M1

HK - M1 worst performer (20ms slower then the rest)

Asia - VQ is 30ms slower than the best performer

Europe - avoid ST (almost 100ms slower than the rest)

NA - ST is 20ms slower then the rest

Oceania - M1/ST is about 20ms slower than the rest

 

[xiaofan]

so in summary

China - MR Gamer
HK - mostly similar
Asia - avoid VQ
Europe - avoid ST
NA - mostly similar
Oceania - mostly similar

China - MR Gamer and then Singtel, avoid VQ and M1?
HK - mostly similar
Asia - avoid VQ
Europe - avoid ST
NA - mostly similar
Oceania - mostly similar

 

[cyberet]

MR Gamer just blows everyone else out for China
I would say avoid M1 for China as most of its result for China is more than 300ms

 

[seowbin]

simba gateway- 210.10.78.1
end user (at home) should be 2 to 3ms more at least

区域	最快/最慢	平均
全网	新加坡(AMAZON-LIGHTSAIL) 0.7ms/印度尼西亚雅加达(阿里云) 532.1ms	218.7ms
移动	山东济南(移动云) 336.7ms/云南昆明(移动云) 437.3ms	400.8ms
联通	广东广州(联通云一区) 307.5ms/新疆和田(联通云) 427.1ms	353.3ms
电信	福建厦门(CN2-咕咕云) 56.7ms/陕西西安(移动云) 507.6ms	379.6ms
华南	广东广州(联通云一区) 307.5ms / 海南三亚(电信) 422.0ms	364.2ms
华北	北京(百度云) 307.6ms / 山西太原(天翼云) 408.6ms	358.2ms
华东	福建厦门(CN2-咕咕云) 56.7ms / 福建福州(移动-云端) 438.3ms	369.4ms
华中	湖北武汉(联通云) 322.3ms / 湖北咸宁(电信) 433.2ms	365.6ms
东北	黑龙江哈尔滨(天翼云) 343.8ms / 辽宁沈阳(移动云) 444.3ms	380.9ms
西北	青海西宁(联通云) 344.7ms / 陕西西安(移动云) 507.6ms	389.8ms
西南	贵州贵阳(联通) 334.5ms / 四川成都(阿里云) 465.0ms	395.2ms
港澳台	香港(腾讯云-轻量) 33.2ms / 香港(无忧云) 330.5ms	86.5ms
亚洲	新加坡(AMAZON-LIGHTSAIL) 0.7ms/印度尼西亚雅加达(阿里云) 532.1ms	87.3ms
欧洲	法国普罗旺斯－阿尔卑斯－蓝色海岸大区马赛(ZENLAYER-MRS1) 133.7ms/瑞典哈兰省法尔肯贝里市(glesys.se) 394.3ms	173.7ms
非洲	肯尼亚内罗毕(web4africa.com) 164.7ms/加纳大阿克拉地区阿克拉(web4africa.com) 345.9ms	246.1ms
北美洲	美国加利福尼亚州洛杉矶(GCP) 170.6ms/美国纽约州纽约(DIGITALOCEAN-NYC3) 496.1ms	226.4ms
南美洲	智利圣地亚哥(GCP) 271.5ms/阿根廷圣菲省罗萨里奥 387.7ms	336.8ms
大洋洲	澳大利亚维多利亚州墨尔本(GCP) 86.0ms/澳大利亚南澳大利亚州阿德莱德 265.3ms	128.8ms

 

[seowbin]

Whizcomm gateway - 202.133.192.1
end user (at home) should be 2 to 3ms more at least

区域	最快/最慢	平均
全网	新加坡(VULTR) 1.7ms/陕西西安(移动云) 1417.4ms	225.8ms
移动	广东佛山(移动) 63.5ms/天津(移动) 268.6ms	134.5ms
联通	广东深圳(联通云) 44.7ms/安徽滁州(电信) 346.4ms	92.8ms
电信	福建厦门(CN2-咕咕云) 60.5ms/陕西西安(移动云) 1417.4ms	360.0ms
华南	广东深圳(联通云) 44.7ms / 广西南宁(天翼云) 380.3ms	228.5ms
华北	天津(联通) 77.9ms / 内蒙古呼和浩特(bgp) 422.9ms	244.2ms
华东	福建厦门(CN2-咕咕云) 60.5ms / 江西南昌(电信) 423.3ms	209.7ms
华中	湖南湘潭(联通云) 71.5ms / 湖北十堰(电信) 397.6ms	187.9ms
东北	辽宁沈阳(联通云一区) 92.4ms / 辽宁沈阳(天翼云三区) 362.8ms	209.2ms
西北	宁夏银川(联通云) 90.7ms / 陕西西安(移动云) 1417.4ms	353.8ms
西南	贵州贵阳(移动云) 84.5ms / 四川成都(阿里云) 463.0ms	283.9ms
港澳台	香港(CN2) 35.7ms / 台湾台中市(远传电信) 258.1ms	73.8ms
亚洲	新加坡(VULTR) 1.7ms/阿联酋迪拜酋长国迪拜(AMAZON) 439.8ms	97.1ms
欧洲	法国法兰西岛大区巴黎(Azure) 151.0ms/瑞典哈兰省法尔肯贝里市(glesys.se) 1353.5ms	314.2ms
非洲	南非约翰内斯堡(oneprovider.com) 117.3ms/南非约翰内斯堡(华为云) 518.9ms	408.0ms
北美洲	美国加利福尼亚州洛杉矶(GCP) 167.6ms/哥斯达黎加圣何塞省圣何塞(oneprovider.com) 310.5ms	222.7ms
南美洲	波多黎各圣胡安(oneprovider.com) 269.0ms/阿根廷布宜诺斯艾利斯(oneprovider.com) 388.7ms	340.7ms
大洋洲	澳大利亚维多利亚州墨尔本(ZENLAYER-MEL1) 87.7ms/澳大利亚维多利亚州墨尔本(VULTR) 254.4ms	142.4ms