Hello Wahkao3. Thank you for sharing your findings. Are you referring to the index or individual stocks?
I need to clarify what I said. I am referring to trend trading strategies on Forex specifically. Will trend trading work on commodities? I don't honestly know. Will trend trading work on Stocks? I don't know. Will trend trading work on the forex spot market? I am fairly certain that it doesn't.
I have a gut feel that trend trading strategies may work on indexes but you would really need a lot of time to do the testing...
The markets are more whipsawy now as compared to the past, as confirmed in an interview with Richard Dennis who is one of the top trend followers in his time, by jack d schwager, in the market wizards book, and I highly suspect its because its the entrance of hedge funds, and hedge funds do a lot of spread trading say long audusd short some nzdusd, to spread out the risk, if the view is long dollar also with more market making firms dealing in options they provide liquidity to sell options knowing it's a adverse trade, and buy stocks to hedge it to convert into synthetic puts, and these actions cause price action to be less informative in the medium term. Richard Dennis also mentioned a way to overcome this is to lower either to smaller time frames or longer time frames for trends.
Personally if I want to see if a trend is genuine, I would see if there is fundamentals backing it, or if it holds well after breaking out from the trading range and not fall back into the trading range, as this would gauge that, nobody dares to sell this market if it broke upwards