HWZ Forums

Login Register FAQ Mark Forums Read

Commentary: When it comes to insurance, less is more for young adults starting out

LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 11-10-2020, 09:08 AM   #1
High Honorary Member
mrclubbie's Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2008
Posts: 178,513
Commentary: When it comes to insurance, less is more for young adults starting out

Commentary: When it comes to insurance, less is more for young adults starting out

You don’t have to be insured from head to toe, especially when you are just starting out, says Dawn Cher.


SINGAPORE: Over the last two weeks, I came across several online posts about Singaporeans with multi-million dollar life insurance policies.

This got me thinking: How much is too much? How do we decide on what type of insurance policy to buy and when?

In my parents’ time, insurance was a simple affair: In most cases, because disposable incomes were lower, many went without them.

If they did get insurance, they had one adviser they trusted to recommend a handful of plans that covered basic needs.

Today, the environment looks vastly different. There is insurance for health, business, travel, homes, even retrenchment. There are new plans covering cyber risks, your pets and even events like your weddings, too.

According to the Life Insurance Association, the number of life policies has more than tripled over the last 20 years, and we pay almost four times more in annual premiums for life insurance compared to 10 years ago.

Financial blogs and social media have also driven interest in personal finance and insurance.

With young people getting their information from social media, insurance agents have also taken to Instagram and Facebook to market their products.

Many produce and share bite-sized infographics to artfully illustrated case studies. While these tidbits can be useful, they also can be potentially misleading when read without context.

An OCBC survey last year found Singapore millennials are keen to invest and buy insurance policies, but less than half feel knowledgeable enough to do so. The sheer variety of information sources out there can be challenging for someone starting out.


Insurance is important. One useful approach is to think about it as outsourcing your biggest financial risks to a third party.

Instead of taking on the risk of a potential financial setback, you pay the insurer to bear that risk instead so you can have peace of mind.

In the event that something happens to you, the insurer pays a sum of money to you or your loved ones. If nothing happens, then the insurer gets to keep the premiums you paid.

Unless it’s an investment-linked product or a life-term policy, where you get a payout after the tenure is over. Given the high medical costs in Singapore, unexpected medical bills should be the first risk you may want to outsource.

My sister – a fitness instructor – was recently hospitalised for a sudden bout of appendicitis, and the hospital bill for such a treatment can easily set you back by at least S$20,000.

We do have national insurance plans like MediShield Life which provides protection against large hospitalisation bills in Class B2 and C wards in public hospitals.

Singaporeans can also use MediSave to pay for such bills, there are also withdrawal limits of S$450 a day for hospitalisation costs, and a variable surgical limit based on the complexity of your procedures.

In an emergency, you may want to skip the queues at a public hospital and head to a private one. Here is where you will need an Integrated Shield Plan so you can pay the difference.

Large bills can be stressful and savings may not be enough. Even if you are young and healthy, a good medical insurance plan should be high on your list.


The statistics are depressing but one in four in Singapore are expected to develop cancer. This is where a Critical Illness (CI) plan can come in – to cushion the financial impact of a long drawn expensive illness.

A CI plan can be bought either as a rider (think of a rider as an additional benefit) to a base-life plan or you can purchase this as a standalone plan, increasingly offered by more insurers in recent years.

If you get a CI rider on top of your life plans for protection, ensure that you find out exactly when payments kick in – some payouts only happen when the disease is diagnosed at a later stage – that is, you don’t get a payout if you are diagnosed at Stage 1.

Early Critical Illness (ECI) plans start payouts after you’ve been diagnosed at the very early stages but typically cost more.


There are products that double up as protection as well as savings. Some parents buy an endowment policy for their children so that they can draw out the cash for their child’s university fees in the future.

With two in five millennials struggling to stick to their saving plans, endowment policies could help enforce this discipline.

Many insurance agents also recommend investment-linked plans for both protection and for building your nest egg. But these can come with administrative costs. I cancelled my investment-linked policy after realising how much I was really paying.

These were for sales and distribution charges (agent commission, fund management charge, administration charges, fund switching charges) and my investment units were also sold (on a monthly or yearly basis) to pay for insurance charges and policy fees.


One question I often get is: “What is the best plan?" A better question to ask yourself should be, which is the best plan for me?

Insurance is highly personal – what someone else does or buys may not necessarily be the best solution for you.

Someone who has ageing parents and multiple children to look after may require a life plan with greater coverage, whereas another without dependents may not need it at all.

Think about your personal circumstances and work out your goals – do you want to take a break from employment to study or you want a comfortable nest egg by a certain age?

As a young working adult in the early years of your career, you may not be drawing a sizeable income just yet, so there’s no rush to buy everything.

Your needs will also evolve as you get married, have children, and when your parents retire. One strategy is to layer your insurance policies to ensure you get the protection during these prime years, and pare it down in your later years once you have fewer dependents.

Each insurer offers plans with different benefits, payment terms and premium levels. Think about which ones you prioritise and are willing to pay for.

Most agents will insist the plans they offer are the “best”. If you talk to someone from Prudential, they will recommend you Prudential policies – that’s the only ones they can sell you.

Ask the same question to an AIA agent and you will likely get a completely different answer.

Many financial advisers advocate spending no more than 10 to 20 per cent of your monthly income on insurance. But I would say, even that is not a hard and fast rule

If you are starting out with a lower income, you may want to stagger your insurance purchases. Focus on the policies you need the most right now.

When I was single, I only had life insurance. After I got married, I increased the amount of coverage on my life through additional term plans.

When my baby was born, I bought more life insurance and added critical illness and early critical illness plans. The more you pay for insurance, the less you have for retirement or just extra cash for holidays or other life events.

Ultimately, it is helpful to think of insurance as something that moves and changes with your own life.

Most importantly, avoid simply signing up with a policy without looking carefully at what you really need and how much you can afford to pay for.
mrclubbie is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2020, 09:22 AM   #2
Supremacy Member
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 8,574
To be honest, you can actually DIY

(1) go for a good term plan
(2) go for a solid healthcare plan
(3) some accident plan if you are in some high risk groups
(4) home insurance
(5) travel insurance if you go on holiday

The rest all invest in equity, bonds to get more returns. In my opinion, you don’t really need the rest. Keeping more $ is better because there are no baojiak jobs now. Once 50, I think very difficult to find job. Seriously don’t know how to tong till 67. Actually many of these benchmark is on civil service
htngwilliam is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-10-2020, 10:36 AM   #3
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 1,288
Disability income insurance should come before 3.
fr33d0m is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-10-2020, 02:02 PM   #4
Junior Member
Join Date: Jul 2019
Posts: 76
(1) go for a good term plan
(2) go for a solid healthcare plan
(3) some accident plan if you are in some high risk groups
(4) home insurance
(5) travel insurance if you go on holiday
Do you need term plan if no dependents (kids, wife)?
I think if good credit card you already have travel insurance, just need to book flight with the card (but cannot travel anyway......hahahaha)
2474265 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 17-10-2020, 03:15 PM   #5
Arch-Supremacy Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Posts: 13,003
Do you need term plan if no dependents (kids, wife)?
You don’t need life insurance (insurance that pays cash to someone upon the death of the policyholder) of any sort if you have no dependents or can self-insure. “Term plan” just means some plan that lasts for a term, a period of time. You probably need a term plan even if you don’t have dependents, just not life insurance. In particular, Disability Income Insurance (DII) is a “term plan,” and most early to mid career working adults in Singapore need DII.

I think if good credit card you already have travel insurance, just need to book flight with the card (but cannot travel anyway......hahahaha)
No, I disagree. Unfortunately there are no credit cards issued in Singapore that even come close to offering adequate travel medical insurance for many destinations.
BBCWatcher is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18-10-2020, 06:04 AM   #6
Join Date: Nov 2000
Posts: 3,714
Unfortunately there are no credit cards issued in Singapore that even come close to offering adequate travel medical insurance for many destinations.
What do you think is lacking with Citibank PremierMiles's? https://www.citibank.com.sg/gcb/cred...pdf/Policy.pdf

It seems to cover the common essentials.
CrashWire is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 18-10-2020, 07:37 AM   #7
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 119
i own citibank premier miles before. when i cancel this card, amex sent me offer for a card very similar to citibank premier miles card as well.

to me, travel insurance is still the one which cover my needs. not credit card insurance. credit card insurance is more of a coverage in terms of death or anything happen upon the plane.

for travel insurance, what is important is, anything happen, i can take air ambulance n come back sg.

insurance depends on individual needs. what kind of coverage do u wan yourself to hv n what your loved ones would have when u r gone. u nv what will hit u. nv assume that u r young, illness will not find u. but its up to individual and family history. all abt risks.
Ipod is online now   Reply With Quote
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Terms of Service for more information.

Thread Tools

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are On