Do you agree with Dr Chee proposal to cut our defence budget by 40%?

sevenoaks

Banned
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
3,486
Reaction score
0
John Low:

SDP: Cut defence budget to fund healthcare proposed policies.

Healthcare is important. But is it in such a bad shape, that we need to compromise our defence budget to accommodate Santa Claus policies?

Our SAF have never been tested in real war fare before. And I thank our founding prime ministers for their urgency in building a world class military, in such a sort period of time. So far we have managed to deter anyone who thinks Singapore is an easy target.

SDP's healthcare paper states that we are in a relatively safe region compared to Israel, hence we do not need to spend so much.

I wonder if we are overly kiasu in building a strong military even though we are in peaceful times, or are we enjoying peaceful times BECAUSE we have a world class military.

Here were past incidents with out neighbours, least we forget and take our peace for granted.

1. 1991
Malaysia and Indonesia conducted a joint military exercise. The largest ever during its time. Code-named Malindo Darsasa (Total Wipeout) 3AB, it involved an airborne assault by paratroopers in Johor, a mere 18 km away from us. The scheduling of the airdrop was on 9 August, Singapore’s 26th National Day.

2. 1998
The Little Red Dot is a friendly term referring to Singapore, but it was not so when it was coined.

Former Indonesian President B.J. Habibie put down Singapore in an article published in the Asian Wall Street Journal of 4 August 1998. It quoted Habibie's remark that he did not have the feeling Singapore was a friend, and had him pointing to a wall map, saying: "It's O.K. with me, but there are 211 million people (in Indonesia). All the green (area) is Indonesia. And that red dot is Singapore."
from http://singaporedesk.blogspot.sg/…/secret-origins-of-little…

Singapore's population was 4 million then. I remember I was still a student then. And the impression was, if you dont wish to be compliant, it is ok. but go home and look at your own size.

I remember we chose to keep quiet then, knowing that aggravating the situation is not to the country's benefit.

3. 2013

“Singapore shouldn’t be like children, in such a tizzy.” Said Indonesia Coordinating Minister for People’s Welfare Agung Laksono, commenting on the haze issue.

This was in response when Singapore was covered with 300 PSI haze and we expressed our concern and offered help.

Not only were we labelled as "behaving" like children, our offer to help was turned down unless we offered ridiculous amounts of money.

"If it is half a million dollars, it is better we use our own budget."

Again we kept quiet and chose to focus on solving the problem and not the name calling.

http://www.eco-business.com/…/indonesian-minister-says-sin…/

4. 2014

Indonesia decides to name a navy ship after two Indonesian Marines that took part in a bombing at Mcdonald house at Orchad road in 1965. The bombing killed 3 people and injured 33 others.

Although Singapore repeatedly expressed concern over it, Indonesia went ahead and named the Navy ship KRI Usman Harun. Models that looked like the two marines were spotted during an international defence event in Jarkata. Indonesia later on expresses regret over the incident at the event. Even then, the minister that expressed regret, received a lot of back lash from his own citizens.
http://news.asiaone.com/…/mfa-concerned-over-1965-bomber-lo…

How did we respond? We did not keep quiet, but neither did we retaliate. We responded by not allowing this Navy ship to ever dock in Singapore and that our Navy will not sail with her in any joint exercise.

In 2015, when an Airasia plane went missing, we lent our Navy to help search for the missing plane and did not withdraw even when Indonesia sent KRI Usman Harun to join the search.
http://www.todayonline.com/…/indonesia-deploys-usman-harun-…

---------

Why did we bend over backwards so many times? To avoid direct conflict with our neighbours. Regardless of how superior our military is, a war will not be beneficial to anyone.

SO. I urge all Singaporean voters to think. Do we enjoy this peace and prosperity BECAUSE we have such a military budget, or are we over kiasu and can do with less?

Even if you think we are overly kiasu, the next question would be, is our current healthcare support system so inadequate that we need to reallocated our defence budget to healthcare?
 

Mancunian2

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2006
Messages
82,865
Reaction score
7,420
Jason chua,
are you still involved in degree mills businesses?
 

dxdx999

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2014
Messages
29,842
Reaction score
4,470
Jason chua,
are you still involved in degree mills businesses?
 

honeypanda

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 18, 2014
Messages
1,337
Reaction score
86
why not.
no matter how much it is, we still serve 2 year ns while the job are being displaced.
 

xLupDup

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2013
Messages
10,919
Reaction score
2,058
If healthcare is self sustainable then why not defence?

Given our generals calibre and our generous budgets since last 10 years, why are we not coming up with cutting edge technology that other countries need?
 

Lss

Honorary Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2002
Messages
123,367
Reaction score
14,887
in a word yes. but without affecting the army's ability/readiness in any way.

we should be able to cheaper better faster. im sure we can achieve the same or more with less money.
 

mysticmooon

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2011
Messages
1,217
Reaction score
8
wan lan leh.

defense budget is just suggestion leh. sure will be debated and be taken down.

THE MOST IMPORTANT PART IS THE LAND COST IN BTO PRICES...AND CPF

KNN BTO 99 YRS LEASE. GOVERMENT STILL TAKE BACK LAND. WHY DO WE NEED TO OAY LAND COST?

GIC TAKE CPF TO REINVESTMENT AND MAKE SO MUCH MONEY BUT GIVES ONLY 2.5%?

WTF LOH. AT LEAST GIVES 5 PERCENT LA.
GIC CHAO CHAO 15 PERCENT EVERY YEAR.

MOST IMPORTANT IS WHY RAISE MEDISHIELD LIFE PREMIUMS KNN.

WE HAVE SO MANY INSURANCE FRIENDS WHO IS TRYING TO SELL US PRIVATE MEDICAL INSURANCE EVERY MONTH. WE DONT NEED MEDISHIELD LIFE LIAO LA....
 

.看你的头.

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 28, 2009
Messages
5,626
Reaction score
327
lol

army so big still bend backwards, what does it say about us? :s8::s8::s8:

would you fight for the strongest military in the world if the govt keeps kowtowing to enemies?
 

gravity_infinity

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
May 10, 2013
Messages
56,976
Reaction score
9,320
I like Chee Soon Juan but I honestly think 40% ish too much. Cut ministerial salaries and scrap the President role better. Speaker of Parliament should not have an official car either. When making budget cuts must ringfence defence, health, and education spending. See the UK, Tories cut everything so jialat but changed the 50p top earners tax rate to 40p.

his defence budget i dont really agree.

with everyone upping their stakes in south china sea issue.


but i agree with his manpower screening process for pmet to ensure no degree mills like jason chua company.

also health care reforms is good.
 

samloi

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Messages
29,195
Reaction score
2,565
40% is too much I think. But looking at the money wasted sometimes.....maybe 20-30% bah
 

MioFan

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2010
Messages
1,079
Reaction score
0
Sorry but our military must remain strong. Singapore is small so other countries always want to bully us. The best way to deal with bullies is to warn them that if you hurt me, I will hurt you very badly.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top