how to mitigate a sudden spike of inflation during retirement

Joined
Nov 20, 2014
Messages
261
Reaction score
1
Hi guys,

I have a question which i have been trying to find the answer for like since i got to know about the "your age in bond rule". It seems on Singapore context, this is a debatable topic,

my question:
As we enter into retirement, applying the age in bond rule would means our assets allocation will be heavily weighted in bonds. Given this is the case, a retiree will have a more risk to inflation as compare to someone who started out in the early age whereby a young investor's allocation would overweight in equity.

So in order to mitigate a sudden spike in inflation, US advisers would recommend Treasury Inflation Protected Securities(TIPS) for those who are in retirement age. Now for a retiree Singaporean, by owning US TIPS does not makes sense because:

1. Singapore inflation might be different from US Inflation
2. There is currency risk when we take up foreign bonds

So in this case, how should a Singaporean retiree mitigate a sudden spike in inflation?
 

highsulphur

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2011
Messages
78,056
Reaction score
40,530
Properties in singapore tend to hedge well against inflation. Having an investment property which rental income that hopefully track inflation will help.
 

focus1974

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
May 12, 2007
Messages
91,023
Reaction score
32,691
yes.. i really seriously absolutely believe people should not rely on stocks and bonds for your retirement and inflation... it does not happen. .. u needd very active management of your portfolio.

Better to go with properties.
 

doody_

Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
7,508
Reaction score
7
Inflation seems quite overrated. Costs don't shoot up overnight, especially for basics. 2015 still has chicken rice going for $3. In 2004 it was around $2. That's 10 years.

By retirement, big ticket items are all paid up, so no huge shocks there, like the property market over the last 5 years.
 

Bedokian

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2007
Messages
2,196
Reaction score
7
The greatest fear would be hyperinflation, like Germany in the 1920s, Zimbabwe and Argentina recently. If one's assets are 100% local, then it will be engulfed in this hyperinflation.

Some suggested textbook solutions include having overseas assets and commodities (especially precious metals), since these are independent of local inflation conditions. I feel this can be a good ground for discussion.
 

SBC

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2001
Messages
19,586
Reaction score
1,218
I recommend to start planning early & to include multiple stream of income.

This shall include SRS, stocks, property rental & insurances.
Many here may not believe in insurance. Many are supporting BTIR.
 

Mecisteus

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2002
Messages
55,998
Reaction score
12,366
Just hold some foreign denominated assets. Currency of denominations must be those of the strong ones. ie USD or EUR.
 

Shiny Things

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2009
Messages
9,605
Reaction score
854
So in order to mitigate a sudden spike in inflation, US advisers would recommend Treasury Inflation Protected Securities(TIPS) for those who are in retirement age. Now for a retiree Singaporean, by owning US TIPS does not makes sense because:

1. Singapore inflation might be different from US Inflation
2. There is currency risk when we take up foreign bonds

So in this case, how should a Singaporean retiree mitigate a sudden spike in inflation?

Yeah, unfortunately there's not a good way to do this.

If you don't have access to inflation-linked bonds, then equities are an OK (if dirty) inflation hedge. But in most situations, you don't want to own a whole ton of equities when you're retired, like you said - so I think the answer might be, unfortunately, that spiky inflation is just something you have to take the risk of.

I think the best way to fix this would be to introduce inflation-indexed bonds in Singapore. A lot of other countries issue linkers - why not Singapore as well?
 
Joined
Nov 20, 2014
Messages
261
Reaction score
1
Thanks guys for the input. I'm hearing alot of voices here, so i summarize what i collected so far.

Inflation are contributed by two factors:

1. rising cost of living - which someone identified property rental cost is a contributing factor, which is why invest into property helps to mitigate this part.

2. a weak currency - contributes to a more expensive imports which translate to higher cost of living. So by owning some asset class that's not SGD base would help when SGD weakens.

So i am getting the solution: given a situation without local TIPS for a retiree, one has to own local REITs, foreign bonds and Gold as part of our retirement portfolio.

I am also getting insurance as a possible option but i feel this is very subjective and it may contributes to a lengthy discussion so i won't be touching on this.

I happen to come across this ETF, iShares Global Government Bond
Its yield is lower than our government bond and i'm thinking it maybe because of Japan.

Given the case of US TIPS, if inflation is higher than expected core inflation, the value of TIPS increases and so does the coupon. So by considering weakening of SGD, owning a basket of diversified developed nation's government bond would have an effect similar to TIPS in local currency. Am i right? If this is so then as a bond, IGLO would be the best alternative bet for inflation linked bonds.

reference: Singapore core inflation



Yeah, unfortunately there's not a good way to
I think the best way to fix this would be to introduce inflation-indexed bonds in Singapore. A lot of other countries issue linkers - why not Singapore as well?

I would like our government to issue some inflation linked bonds but it seems like thats not going to happen in near future.

Debate on budget 2013
The high premiums that investors are likely to have to fork out for inflation-linked bonds have been cited as a key reason for Singapore's central bank holding out on issuing them any time soon.
 

bakuten

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2007
Messages
13,698
Reaction score
1,463
Hard assets.
Fully paid properties...ur property is not gonna become smaller/bigger regardless of how much more or less it is worth in dollar terms. Worst come to worst can still rent out partially.

Gold you hold in your possesion.

Stay away from debts.

Sent from Samsung SM-N910G using GAGT
 
Last edited:

Shiny Things

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2009
Messages
9,605
Reaction score
854
Thanks guys for the input. I'm hearing alot of voices here, so i summarize what i collected so far.

Inflation are contributed by two factors:

1. rising cost of living - which someone identified property rental cost is a contributing factor, which is why invest into property helps to mitigate this part.

2. a weak currency - contributes to a more expensive imports which translate to higher cost of living. So by owning some asset class that's not SGD base would help when SGD weakens.

So i am getting the solution: given a situation without local TIPS for a retiree, one has to own local REITs, foreign bonds and Gold as part of our retirement portfolio.

I disagree with gold - I think it's just a terrible investment - but other than that, yeah, the other two are better hedges for inflation than what I suggested.

The problem is, they're also relatively high risk, and I'm not sure they're great bets for a retiree. REITs are one thing - I can see the argument there - but foreign bonds are essentially a punt on foreign exchange; if inflation stays stable (which is a pretty safe bet in most first-world economies, even in Singapore with its weirdly housing-market-procyclical monetary policy), then what you end up with is just a really risky bet on currencies, which is the sort of thing retirees should stay well away from.

I bet the MAS is probably reconsidering issuing linkers now that inflation's down around zero. They should do this.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 1, 2015
Messages
22,282
Reaction score
5,571
Sudden spike in domestic currency or globally?
For me, I do have commodities etf which invests in hard,soft and agriculture.
 

Shiny Things

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2009
Messages
9,605
Reaction score
854
Sudden spike in domestic currency or globally?
For me, I do have commodities etf which invests in hard,soft and agriculture.

If a country has a short spike of high inflation, it's going to cause the domestic currency to drop relative to foreign currencies. So anything that's denominated in a foreign currency - foreign stocks, foreign bonds - will hold its value; and perhaps counterintuitively, local equities will do well, because it'll take more dollars to buy one share of a given company. This is pretty much what we saw in Japan when Abenomics tried to stimulate inflation: the yen plunged and the Nikkei took off like someone shoved a rocket up its clacker.

Gold and other commodities would hold their value as well, but they wouldn't do any better from an inflation-protection point of view than, say, sticking the money in overseas bonds. (In fact, the bonds would do better, because gold has a negative yield; bonds at least give you some positive yield, unless you're talking about European or Swiss govvies.)

Also, commodities do really badly when inflation is low, interest rates are high, or both, as you've probably seen over the last few years.
 

bin8lee

Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2015
Messages
402
Reaction score
0
If a country has a short spike of high inflation, it's going to cause the domestic currency to drop relative to foreign currencies. So anything that's denominated in a foreign currency - foreign stocks, foreign bonds - will hold its value; and perhaps counterintuitively, local equities will do well, because it'll take more dollars to buy one share of a given company. This is pretty much what we saw in Japan when Abenomics tried to stimulate inflation: the yen plunged and the Nikkei took off like someone shoved a rocket up its clacker.

Gold and other commodities would hold their value as well, but they wouldn't do any better from an inflation-protection point of view than, say, sticking the money in overseas bonds. (In fact, the bonds would do better, because gold has a negative yield; bonds at least give you some positive yield, unless you're talking about European or Swiss govvies.)

Also, commodities do really badly when inflation is low, interest rates are high, or both, as you've probably seen over the last few years.

marked~~~~
 
Joined
Nov 20, 2014
Messages
261
Reaction score
1
I disagree with gold - I think it's just a terrible investment - but other than that, yeah, the other two are better hedges for inflation than what I suggested.

The problem is, they're also relatively high risk, and I'm not sure they're great bets for a retiree. REITs are one thing - I can see the argument there - but foreign bonds are essentially a punt on foreign exchange; if inflation stays stable (which is a pretty safe bet in most first-world economies, even in Singapore with its weirdly housing-market-procyclical monetary policy), then what you end up with is just a really risky bet on currencies, which is the sort of thing retirees should stay well away from.

I bet the MAS is probably reconsidering issuing linkers now that inflation's down around zero. They should do this.

Thanks Shiny Things for your input. Always appreciate your sharing on the thoughts that's on your mind as well as others opinion on this matter.

I would really like MAS to issue inflation linked bond when i am about to retire, but if its not possible then i guess a diversified foreign developed country's government bonds would be the next 'insurance' against a sudden spike of inflation which a retiree's portfolio would be at risk of given the overweight in bonds. The more i think about it, the more i think foreign bond has a TIPS feature.

I see a couple mention hard assets and i think its a valid option.

incidentally i came across our minister mention there is a point about a SSB which has a sort of inflation protection feature. e.g when inflation is high, interest rate will be adjust to tame inflation. Given the case, if one holds SSB, he can sell off the lower yield SSB (because inflation was low back when the person subscribe it) without any capital loss and buy into a new SSB that gives higher yield, therefore is inflation adjusted.

While the bond (SSB) is not inflation-linked, the full redemption feature allows bondholders to mitigate the risks of soaring inflation and higher interest rates
source

I don't really understand this part. First, i have always understand intermediate term interest rate are driven by the market base on yield curve and so the government only control short term rates to tame inflation.

second, i understand that our short term interest rate move in the same tone as US short term rates. In addition, Singapore uses norminal effective exchange rate (NEER) as an additional tool to control inflation instead of just relying solely on interest rate. I think NEER and interest rates work hand in hand but i don't really see this link to SSB as being able to adjust according to inflation. for instant, we have get hit with high inflation, but if US does not adjust interest rates (which SG would follow suit), then NEER adjustment has no material impact to SSB's yield.
 

Mecisteus

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 16, 2002
Messages
55,998
Reaction score
12,366
incidentally i came across our minister mention there is a point about a SSB which has a sort of inflation protection feature. e.g when inflation is high, interest rate will be adjust to tame inflation. Given the case, if one holds SSB, he can sell off the lower yield SSB (because inflation was low back when the person subscribe it) without any capital loss and buy into a new SSB that gives higher yield, therefore is inflation adjusted.

source

I don't really understand this part. First, i have always understand intermediate term interest rate are driven by the market base on yield curve and so the government only control short term rates to tame inflation.

second, i understand that our short term interest rate move in the same tone as US short term rates. In addition, Singapore uses norminal effective exchange rate (NEER) as an additional tool to control inflation instead of just relying solely on interest rate. I think NEER and interest rates work hand in hand but i don't really see this link to SSB as being able to adjust according to inflation. for instant, we have get hit with high inflation, but if US does not adjust interest rates (which SG would follow suit), then NEER adjustment has no material impact to SSB's yield.

basically, he is trying to say that in a rising interest rate environment, bond prices are likely to go down. the beauty of this SSB is that you are able to redeem ANYTIME at 100 and not incurring a capital loss. then you have the option to buy higher yielding SSB.
 

Futureskid

Member
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
429
Reaction score
1
Thanks guys for the input. I'm hearing alot of voices here, so i summarize what i collected so far.

Inflation are contributed by two factors:

1. rising cost of living - which someone identified property rental cost is a contributing factor, which is why invest into property helps to mitigate this part.

2. a weak currency - contributes to a more expensive imports which translate to higher cost of living. So by owning some asset class that's not SGD base would help when SGD weakens.

So i am getting the solution: given a situation without local TIPS for a retiree, one has to own local REITs, foreign bonds and Gold as part of our retirement portfolio.

I am also getting insurance as a possible option but i feel this is very subjective and it may contributes to a lengthy discussion so i won't be touching on this.

I happen to come across this ETF, iShares Global Government Bond
Its yield is lower than our government bond and i'm thinking it maybe because of Japan.

Given the case of US TIPS, if inflation is higher than expected core inflation, the value of TIPS increases and so does the coupon. So by considering weakening of SGD, owning a basket of diversified developed nation's government bond would have an effect similar to TIPS in local currency. Am i right? If this is so then as a bond, IGLO would be the best alternative bet for inflation linked bonds.

reference: Singapore core inflation




I would like our government to issue some inflation linked bonds but it seems like thats not going to happen in near future.

Debate on budget 2013
U have too much theory in your mind. To hedge against inflation, invest in what u think with highest ROI, that will beater inflation worries. If u think u can t achieve it, then put money in where ur lifestyle would be affected.
The rise and fall of gold did not equate to ur own inflation lifestyle, the fall of energy price did not make ur gasoline much cheaper too. Too many external factors involved, except u controlling ur lifestyle to fight inflation.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top