Investor sues DBS over option advice

lcornwisky

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
5,014
Reaction score
1
dbs.jpg


She claims bank misled her into buying 'useless' options to protect margin positions
Selina Lum

SINGAPORE - A Singapore businesswoman, who lost US$6 million (S$8.4 million) in forex trades, has sued DBS Bank, seeking to restore her accounts to their levels before the bank closed out her trading positions.

Ms Florence Suryawan, 53, alleges that the bank had misled her into buying options meant to protect her against volatile forex markets.

These options, which work like insurance, turned out to be "useless" for hedging her investments.

In September 2011, the falling Australian dollar caused Ms Suryawan, who was acquiring the currency through structured products known as accumulators, to suffer massive losses.

After DBS closed out her positions, the total balance of her accounts with the bank fell from US$6.2 million to about US$410,000.

But the bank says it was not responsible, contending that Ms Suryawan was a sophisticated and experienced investor who relied on her own judgment in deciding to buy the options.

A hearing into the lawsuit started in the High Court yesterday.

Ms Suryawan has diverse business experience, from manufacturing to digital media.

A private banking customer of DBS, she accepted its offer of a margin trading facility with a limit of US$50 million in August 2008. By the end of that year, forex trading became her full-time pursuit.

In 2010, she started investing in accumulators, "buying" the Australian dollar at regular intervals below the prevailing market price for a fixed period of time. If the price rose within a certain range, she would make a profit, but a price drop could lead to huge losses.

Between August and September 2011, as the market was volatile, she bought nine options from DBS. She said the bank's employees described them as insurance to protect her margin positions.

On Sept 22, when an employee called her about her falling margin level, she reminded him of the options and was "astonished" when he replied that the ones she bought did not protect her.

Ms Suryawan said she was dazed that the bank unwound and closed her positions after the phone call.

Her lawyer, Mr Nicholas Narayanan, argued that DBS was negligent in advising her about the options, and made false representations about the protection offered.

He also argued that DBS was not entitled to close out her positions as she did not make a valid margin call on Sept 22.

But Senior Counsel Ang Cheng Hock, for DBS, contends that she understood how the options worked and that the bank was not obliged to give investment advice.
 

satayxp

Banned
Joined
May 10, 2004
Messages
151,806
Reaction score
5,152
On Sept 22, when an employee called her about her falling margin level, she reminded him of the options and was "astonished" when he replied that the ones she bought did not protect her.

Ms Suryawan said she was dazed that the bank unwound and closed her positions after the phone call.

Her lawyer, Mr Nicholas Narayanan, argued that DBS was negligent in advising her about the options, and made false representations about the protection offered.

He also argued that DBS was not entitled to close out her positions as she did not make a valid margin call on Sept 22.

so-called customer service eh?

But Senior Counsel Ang Cheng Hock, for DBS, contends that she understood how the options worked and that the bank was not obliged to give investment advice.

this senior counsel is either ignorant or obviously being mischievous
 

lcornwisky

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
5,014
Reaction score
1
to have a margin of 50 million need at least 10 million, wow some are very rich, the more i read it the more it feels like gambling....lol....i think these products are only offered to private banking clients
 

Wood41

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2002
Messages
8,631
Reaction score
2
The banks are motivated in making $$ by making you trade & the rich clients think that more $$ can be generated by trusting the 'professionals' ......
 

Mancunian2

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2006
Messages
82,865
Reaction score
7,420
private bankers are mostly noobs in derivatives,
rely on them for advice sure die one
 

IronMac

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2012
Messages
9,006
Reaction score
11
In this case, there is no way that she can claim that she is an unsophisticated noob investor. She's had 3 years of fulltime forex trading before buying these options.
 

lcornwisky

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
5,014
Reaction score
1
anyway 6 million usd is some serious money, small time market makers have 1 million dollar usd limit i think
 

Wood41

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2002
Messages
8,631
Reaction score
2
Unlikely she will win , the bankers would know for sure these would happen for some of their clients.
Forms & declarations etc would have been signed by her & written by lawyers to cover them.
 

Sai777

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2011
Messages
17,061
Reaction score
2
she is not a angel

she knows the risk when she signed up $50m margin, especially when she is doing this full time. She obviously knows what she is doing.
 

limster

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2000
Messages
13,131
Reaction score
4,114
She would have been better off putting the money into WL Policy or ILP.
 

Rmondo

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2013
Messages
880
Reaction score
0
Unlikely she will win , the bankers would know for sure these would happen for some of their clients.
Forms & declarations etc would have been signed by her & written by lawyers to cover them.

You'd be surprised, banks lose more often than you think. Just that majority of the times they don't make it to the news, and its typically quiet settlements.

With private banking clients, the amount of admin paperwork to cover the bank's ass would typically be lesser than your normal man on the street to provide convenience etc.

It's going to boil down to, if the trade was client directed or an advised trade. If DBS can't prove it was client directed, it doesn't matter if the client is what they alleged to be 'sophisticated' based on what the RM was alleged to have misrepresented.

That's like having an insurance agent tell me the returns of ILP are guaranteed and low risk. It really doesn't matter if I am sophisticated or not, it's clear misrepresentation.
 

focus1974

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
May 12, 2007
Messages
91,022
Reaction score
32,690
You'd be surprised, banks lose more often than you think. Just that majority of the times they don't make it to the news, and its typically quiet settlements.

With private banking clients, the amount of admin paperwork to cover the bank's ass would typically be lesser than your normal man on the street to provide convenience etc.

It's going to boil down to, if the trade was client directed or an advised trade. If DBS can't prove it was client directed, it doesn't matter if the client is what they alleged to be 'sophisticated' based on what the RM was alleged to have misrepresented.

That's like having an insurance agent tell me the returns of ILP are guaranteed and low risk. It really doesn't matter if I am sophisticated or not, it's clear misrepresentation.


actually.. private client . we have already signed all the idenmity forms and whaatever collateral and loan limiit forms as well as accreditatd investor status form ... and risk profile... After that, no more forms liao.. all communication can be done verbally.

and always if we wan to do a trade.. we call the banker their mobile or the FIXED Line , but they will call us back on the fixed line to confirm the trade as the conversation is recorded.

So i'm sure the woman knows what is happening.. she is just trying to recoup her capital ... it's like those casino gamblers.. lose liao..says they are technically not VIP customers and they didn't know this and didn't know that.
 

Maeda_Toshiie

Supremacy Member
Joined
May 12, 2007
Messages
6,310
Reaction score
3
to have a margin of 50 million need at least 10 million, wow some are very rich, the more i read it the more it feels like gambling....lol....i think these products are only offered to private banking clients

At least HNWI, if not higher.
 

limster

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2000
Messages
13,131
Reaction score
4,114
News from Wall Street Journal on Dec 4, 2008: Shares in Citic Pacific fell sharply after the company disclosed larger losses than previously estimated from its foreign-exchange contracts due to the weakness of the Australian dollar. Citic Pacific Ltd shares have fallen 62% since Oct 20, when Citic Pacific disclosed that it faced losses of more than HK$15 billion on leveraged positions on the Australian dollar. Citic Pacific made bets on the Australian dollar that went bad when the U.S. dollar unexpectedly rallied. The positions were taken through an arrangement that gave Citic Pacific limited upside, but unlimited downside.
https://colinchua.wordpress.com/200...rs-the-hk-press-calls-it-fx-i-kill-you-later/

Accumulator="I-kill-you-later" limited upside/unlimited downside.

If the investor googled accumulators and Australian dollar, he probably would read about the Citic Pacific disaster.
 

Shiny Things

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2009
Messages
9,605
Reaction score
854
FX accumulators! This is right in my wheelhouse.

So, first and foremost, I'm not going to make any value judgments about whether the client or DBS is at fault here.

On one hand, this lady is a high-net-worth investor, and at some point the assumption has to be that the client knows what we're doing. When I was a market-maker I wouldn't have expected to get sued by one of my hedge-fund clients just because they lost money on a trade: the non-reliance language in the trade confirmation is there for a reason, and the default assumption among professional clients is that we all know what we're doing and if you screw up it's your own fault. There's absolutely an argument for protecting smaller investors from being sold terrible products, but at some point (especially if you're an "active forex trader" like this lady was) you have to learn to act like a professional and take your losses.

On the other hand, though, accumulators (and TARFs in particular, which is what I bet the client was trading) are horrendously f*cking complicated products. They're complicated to price, complicated to hedge, and this is my personal opinion but I don't think they're actually useful for anything.

If the client was told they're a "hedge", then that's just flat-out wrong, because TARFs are a terrible hedge for linear spot risk: if the market goes against you (so you need the hedge), the TARF knocks out almost immediately, but if the market goes in your favour (so you don't need the hedge) the TARF extends its maturity and the amount leverages up so you're actually overhedged.

Think about that for a sec. A product that underhedges you when you need the hedge, and overhedges you when you don't need the hedge, isn't a very good hedge!

So you might well ask "why would anyone buy a TARF anyway, they sound terrible". The answer is that in return for that terrible risk profile, you get paid phat cash; TARFs are usually structured so that they have an 80-90% chance of early-redeeming and handing you a pile of cash, and a 10-20% chance of not early redeeming and costing you a much larger pile of cash. Incidentally, the net expected value of those two outcomes is always negative - banks aren't charities, they're not going to give away something with a positive expected value for nothing. And because TARFs are so horrifically complex - you basically can't price them without at least a Bloomberg terminal and those run SGD $3,000 a month - it's easy for banks to hide a lot of value in them by fiddling with the trade parameters (the strike, the final payment type, the leverage ratio, the payout cap, the... etc etc etc) and you'd never know you were being taken for a ride.
 
Last edited:

wahkao3

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2005
Messages
26,802
Reaction score
24
private bankers are mostly noobs in derivatives,
rely on them for advice sure die one
agreed
reminds me of my conversation here



=========================
My financial adviser asked me what is my risk appetite, I say I am low risk, but want high return

Yesterday I asked my financial adviser for good investment can make me huat big big, she asked me what is my risk appetite.

me: I am low risk taker
FA: Ok, I recommend you bond mutual fund the return is 2%
me: U siao ah! inflation already 5%. U only offer me 2%.
FA: Because your risk appetite is low risk, only mutual fund return 2% and very low risk.
me: I am looking for high return, low risk. Why you recommend me this kind of nonsense mid risk, low return product?
FA: In market no such thing as high return,low risk. High return will come with high risk
me: Then what for I need you? What is your value add? You are just going to get in the way and suck commissions. If I want high return high risk, I can easily find it everywhere. I can go MBS, even faster.

What chiu all think huh? I answer like that satki or not? :o

34898financial%20advisor.jpg
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top