Synology DS412+ Sharing

DiscMan

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2001
Messages
1,119
Reaction score
0
Just got a Synology DS412+ 2 weeks back. This is my second Synology NAS after the DS1511+. Stock for the Synology DS412+ was limited in Singapore. I had to place an order with the distributor who is also nice enough to hold the set for me until I went down to collect it.

I noticed that there hasn't been much discussion on the DS412+ here so thought just share some of my views with regards to this.

At the top, are a layer of brown cartons which you will see later that house the Power Brick, Power Cords, 2 x black LAN cables and of cause, the typical disclaimers, quick guides and an installation disk. Taking all these out, below sits the Synology DS412+ frame nicely wrapped with a white foam layer. Unwrapping the outer white foam layer reveals the cool black body of the Synology DS412+. The 4 x HDDs Bay is covered by a shiny plastic cover that, for some, may find it to be a dust and finger print magnet. On the right side of the front are the Status and Disk LEDs, a USB 3.0 port and a bright blue power button, starting from the top to the bottom.

The Box
IMG_6704.jpg


Accessories
IMG_6715.jpg


The DS412+ itself
IMG_6726.jpg


Unwrapping the outer white foam layer reveals the cool black body of the Synology DS412+. The 4 x HDDs Bay is covered by a shiny plastic cover that, for some, may find it to be a dust and finger print magnet. On the right side of the front are the Status and Disk LEDs, a USB 3.0 port and a bright blue power button, starting from the top to the bottom. At the rear of the unit is another bunch of USB 3.0 ports, eSATA port, Power port and, of cos, 2 x Gigabit LAN ports. At the top of these are 2 big fans that will cool down the HDDs inside the unit when it gets too hot. Surprising, the fans are pretty silence and I don’t even notice them turning unlike the ones I have in my PCs and other NAS.

The rear view
IMG_6730.jpg


Removing the nice shiny front cover reveals the 4 HDDs Bays. Unlike the DS1511+ in which the locking mechanisms for the HDD caddies are at the front, for the Synology DS412+, there is a small release mechanism which says “Push” at the top of each bay. These when pushed in, will then allow you to take out the caddie individually to be installed with the HDDs.
The HDDs bays
IMG_6740.jpg


Zooming into the back plane of the Synology DS412+ after taking out all the 4 caddies, will show the circuit board with the 4 x SATA connectors to which the HDDs will slot into, guided by the metal rails at the top and bottom of the unit.
IMG_6747.jpg


LEDs in action
IMG_6770.jpg

IMG_6778.jpg


After installing my 4 x Samsung F4 2TB HDDs into the Synology DS412+, the moment of truth comes along with the powering on of the unit. The unit immediately starts beeping after I pressed the power button in the front. The status light goes amber but the HDDs LEDs are all green. This is normal as I’ve yet to install the DiskStation Manager (DSM) 4.0 into the setup. Using the latest copy of the Synology Assistant and DSM 4.0 downloaded from Synology’s Down Center, it took me around 5 – 10 mins to complete the installation (and stop the irritating beeping) and to be able to log into the unit for configuration of the HDDs.

I'll cover the software and the speed test portions again in the next part.
 
Last edited:

DiscMan

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2001
Messages
1,119
Reaction score
0
Using the latest copy of the Synology Assistant and DSM 4.0 downloaded from Synology’s Download Center, it took me around 5 – 10 mins to complete the installation and to be able to log into the unit for configuration of the HDDs. Presented to me was the very familiar DSM desktop, very much like a typical GUI based OS will provide for us. Clicking onto the Control Panel will bring you to all the window that allows you to complete all the configurations you wish to make onto your Synology NAS. For me, usually I touch on the following ones as the basic setup: System (Network, DSM Settings, Regional Options, Notification, Power) and File Sharing and Privileges (Win/Mac/NFS, FTP, User, Group, Shared Folder). These will be the fundamentals you will need to do to get your NAS up and running on the DSM 4.0.

DS412-Control-Panel.jpg


After that, you can also explore the additional features provided by the packages that you can install using the Package Centre. For me, after getting the basic settings up and I’m able to see the HDDs, I quickly launched the Storage Manager to check the status of the 4 x Samsung Spinpoint F4 that I’ve placed inside. Luckily, all seems to be ok. Also, since I’ve transferred the HDDs from another NAS, the Storage Manager knows that there is an invalid RAID group in the disk and also informed me that I’ll need to erase the disks if I wish to use them. The setting up of the new SHR (Synology Hybrid RAID) RAID5 array, with 1 redundancy disk, took around 5 hours inclusive of the additional bad sector checks.

DS412-Storage-Manager-2.jpg


Notice the low temperature of the HDDs that this unit is operating at? I’ve not even turned on the air-con in my study room yet!

By default, the File Station package is installed as this allows you to browse your NAS, remote or mounted drives as well as your local PC drives that you are accessing the web interface from all in one screen. With this, you will be able to conduct file operations very easily. The good thing about using this interface is that it allows you to copy/move files from remote folders into your NAS directly without going through a PC. This will enable lengthy file operations to take place as a background job in the NAS directly without you having to u leave your PC on throughout the process. This is extremely useful if you need to transfer files between 2 NAS that are in operations.

DS412-File-Station.jpg


The additional features of a Synology NAS is delivered through the Package Center whereby Synology as well a Third Party Vendors will deliver their Add-ons to the Synology DiskStation Manager (DSM), enhancing it’s capabilities even further. Below is a screen showing a sample of the available packages. You can find out even more at the Synology DSM Applications page.

DS412-Package-Centre.jpg


For this round, I’ve installed the Download Station to give it a try. The installation is as easy as installing an App off your iTunes App Store or your Android Play Store, after which the Package Center will complete the installation and an new application icon will appear onto your DSM’s Start Menu. You can also create a shortcut on the DSM Desktop by dragging it directly from the Start Menu to the Desktop. A simple click onto the Download Station icon will then launch the application with a simple user interface as shown. For the Download Station, it supports quite a number of downloading formats including torrents, FTPs and even NZB. This means that I won’t have to have a dedicated PC running my newsreader software with this in place.

DS412-Download-Station-2.jpg


The next application that caught my eye is something call the Cloud Station which is currently still in the Beta mode. Based on the description available on the website and the app, this application will function very much like your own personal storage cloud, not only within your own LAN but also over the Internet! I’ll find some time to give this app a more in-depth drilling to see if it really lives up to its claims.

DS412-Cloud-Station.jpg


Next is to test the Speed of the new NAS!
 
Last edited:

DiscMan

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2001
Messages
1,119
Reaction score
0
I think most people will be most interested in how this new baby will perform in a real world environment. I was pondering around on which tool to use for the performance testing or should I just use a huge file copy operation and check on the speed of the copying natively using the Windows Explorer features. After some research, I decided on using a free tool call the NAS Performance Tester, reason being it’s simple to use and the results are simple to understand. Basically this tool just do a write and read operation on a mapped remote drive of the NAS with options to control the file size to be used and the number of iterations to be conducted.

For this speed test, I’ve chosen to write / read a 2000MB file and loop it for 5 times to obtain an average speed for the tests. In order to ensure that the bottleneck of the test will not be on the local HDD of my PC, I used the DataRam RamDisk Utility to create a 3GB RAM Disk to run the NAS Performance Tester from. I will run the speed test for the 3 NAS (all connected to the same DLink 8 port Green Switch with my test PC) that I’ve got,
1. D-Link DNS-320 ShareCenter 2-Bay Network Storage Enclosure with 2 x 1.5 TB Western Digital Caviar Green on RAID 1
2. Synology DiskStation 5-Bay Network Attached Storage DS1511+ with 5 x 3 TB Western Digital Caviar Green on SHR RAID 5
3. Synology DS412+ with 4 x 2 TB Samsung Spinpoint F4 on SHR RAID 5

The D-Link DNS-320 has been my trust worthy workhorse since I used it to replace my old DLink DNS-323. It’s really a value for money gadget for people who are looking for a NAS that serves it’s purpose yet without having to burn a hole in the pocket. Actually I’ve got 2 units of these at home. I’ve been using one as my 24×7 NAS to serve as a HD media storage and also a FTP server for my 3 x IP Cams at home. For this particular one that is undergoing the speed test, it’s actually my monthly backup storage which I used to keep copies of my critical files. Hence, usually I only power it on once a month.

For the D-Link DNS-320, the Average Write Speed is about 23MB/sec and the Average Read Speed is about 47MB/sec. Pretty impressive I would say for a sub S$150 piece of equipment. Frankly, the test figures are actually very good considering that I noticed that my usual file copy operations with it doesn’t seem to go beyond 20MB/sec.

NASTester-for-DNS320-1.jpg


The Synology DiskStation 5-Bay Network Attached Storage DS1511+ is my other backup NAS that stores a copy of my media files and a second copy of my critical files stored in the DLink DNS-320. Sound a bit kiasu right? but better be safe than sorry.. Using the same test parameters as before with the DLink D-Link DNS-320 , I ran the test again the Synology DS1511+. The results this time round show the Average Write Speed is about 85MB/sec and the Average Read Speed is about 80MB/sec. This brings the Synology DS1511+ performing more than 3 times faster than the D-Link DNS-320 in terms of writing and double that for reading. I’ve also captured the resource utilization of the DS1511+ during the speed test and it shows that the CPU and RAM of the unit is not even “stressed” even at the peak of the network activities. Makes me wonder why did I upgraded the memory of the Synology DS1511+ to 3GB when I purchased it the last time.

NASTester-for-DS1511on-RAMDrive.jpg
DS1511-Resource-Monitor.jpg


Something that puzzled me is that the Write Speed is faster if not on par with the Read Speed. I would expect that reading of data is much faster than writing, similar to the case for the test in the D-Link DNS-320. While I try to find out the reasons behind this phenomenon, at least for now, the write speed would be the minimum figures I would expect the NAS undergoing the tests to be performing at.

And now, it’s the turn for the Synology DS412+. For this, it shows that the Average Write Speed is about 97MB/sec and the Average Read Speed is about 93MB/sec! Meaning that the Synology DS412+ even out performs the Synology DS1511+ by almost 10%!!! In terms of resource utilization, the loading is almost similar to that of the Synology DS1511+ during load!!!

NASTester-for-DS412on-RAMDrive.jpg
NASTester-for-DS412on-RAMDrive-Try-2-Resource.jpg


Comparing the 3 test results, the new kid on the block, the Synology DS412+ seems give to the old man, the Synology DS1511+, a run for the money while the D-Link DNS-320 has been out classed by the Synology family. Below is a summary of the results.

Final-Results.jpg
 
Last edited:

Mankul

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
18,509
Reaction score
0
looking forward to your complete review. planning on my first NAS. can this work with a UPS that has auto shuddown feature?

I'm waiting for personal cloud functionality from syntology that has drop box app feature for android devices as well as windows.
 

Kopi Gao

Banned
Joined
Jan 21, 2012
Messages
868
Reaction score
159
Hi Discman, looking to get my first NAS as well.

May I know:

1. How much did you get the DS412+? An indication price will do.
2. Is it more "future-proof" to get a 4-bay rather than a 2-bay one?
3. Do you always need to "ON" the NAS 24x7?

Sorry to ask stupid questions (if they appear to you) but your advice much appreciated yeah. :)

Many thanks bro!!
 

DiscMan

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2001
Messages
1,119
Reaction score
0
looking forward to your complete review. planning on my first NAS. can this work with a UPS that has auto shuddown feature?

I'm waiting for personal cloud functionality from syntology that has drop box app feature for android devices as well as windows.

Hi,

I'm doing the speed testing yesterday nite so should be able to complete the review over the weekend. With regards to UPS connectivity on the DS412+, i dont have one to test it out but according to a link i found at the synology forums, it seems that it should work. maybe it would be good to just drop an email to their support to confirm this. They have been quite responsive to me so far. Note that it's Synology support not our local distributors or dealers.. :p

I presume you meant the Cloud Station when you meant the personal cloud functionality. It's out in beta already but I noticed that there are only clients on PC and Mac available for downloading. Yet to check out if there are apps on the mobile platform as well.
 

DiscMan

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2001
Messages
1,119
Reaction score
0
Hi Discman, looking to get my first NAS as well.

May I know:

1. How much did you get the DS412+? An indication price will do.
2. Is it more "future-proof" to get a 4-bay rather than a 2-bay one?
3. Do you always need to "ON" the NAS 24x7?

Sorry to ask stupid questions (if they appear to you) but your advice much appreciated yeah. :)

Many thanks bro!!

Hi Bro.. no question is stupid IMHO... :)

The local prices for Synology products are pretty much controlled by the distributor. Hence, unless you want to order from overseas like Newegg or Amazon when they are on sale, dont think our prices will make much diff.

As for 4 or 2 Bays, I started off with 2 Bays from DLink, moving to 4 Bays from DLink as well and then on to Synology products. What i can say is check out your real needs for the NAS. It doesnt really pays to "future-proof" technology as prices of IT products only goes down n not up.. :D For my case, I was considering between getting a DX510 to extend my DS1511+ or just get a DS412+. In the end i went for the later as i want to leave this DS412+ 24x7 and want a smaller power footprint.

Whether to leave a NAS 24x7 is also dependent on your usage, cos I'm using it to record my IP Cams, so I will always have a NAS that is on 24x7.

Hope this helps. :)
 

DiscMan

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2001
Messages
1,119
Reaction score
0
compare to DS1511+ whats the diff?
whats make you to change to this?

The DS1511+ is an older product so the specifications may be slighter lesser than the DS412+. However, the DS1511+ is expendable to 3GB of memory and 2 x DX510 so enable 15 Bays in total. For the DS412+, it's memory is not expendable (although i've seen a website saying that you can do it if u dare to take it all apart) and you cant add another expansion unit to it. On the other hand, DS1511+ only has USB 2.0 ports whereas the DS412+ has USB 3.0 ones. and the list goes on n on...

Anyway, I'm not changing out of the DS1511+ but both plays a different role in my setup. The DS1511+ is mainly used as a backup whereas I'm keeping the DS412+ running 24x7 for my IP Cams. Will be replacing my existing DNS-320 with this... :)

Hope this answer your questions. :)
 

chong

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
5,081
Reaction score
73
Samsung F4 2TB? This drive had big problems with an earlier DSM release on the 1512+. The symptom is that the drive will click every ~21sec, and eventually develop bad sectors and need replacement.

It's fixed on the later DSMs for 1512+, but I don't know if the 412+ is affected in the first place, nor if the fix also affects the 412+.

More details here if u interested: http://forum.synology.com/enu/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=49877
 

DiscMan

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2001
Messages
1,119
Reaction score
0
Samsung F4 2TB? This drive had big problems with an earlier DSM release on the 1512+. The symptom is that the drive will click every ~21sec, and eventually develop bad sectors and need replacement.

It's fixed on the later DSMs for 1512+, but I don't know if the 412+ is affected in the first place, nor if the fix also affects the 412+.

More details here if u interested: Synology Inc. Online Community Forum - NEW NAS Experience -View topic - DS1512+: HD204UI Load_Cycle_Count increasing every 21sec

Hi.. thanxs for the headsup.. i'll go check this out later tonite when i'm home.. hopefully the DSM i'm using already got this fixed.. :o
 

aLpHa-Ev7

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
1,270
Reaction score
0
Good stuffs TS. Awaiting your benchmark results. Yes, i have ordered one as well but currently out of stock. Will equip them with WD 3TB Green drives.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top