Home Automation Enthusiasts

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
Is Aqara Gateway and Xiaomi Gateway the same? If not, what are the differences?

There is really a new Aqara Gateway which is different from the Mijia Gateway that we are all using. Apparently, the new Aqara Gateway will NOT work with Mijia products. Here is a listing on Aliexpress on the new gateway. The new gateway has the word "Aqara" in the middle of the gateway while the Mijia one has the Mijia logo.

Unless you need Apple Homekit support, you should go with the Mijia ones for better compatibility with sensors.
 

LiLAsN

Master Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2008
Messages
2,704
Reaction score
514
Is Aqara Gateway and Xiaomi Gateway the same? If not, what are the differences?

There is really a new Aqara Gateway which is different from the Mijia Gateway that we are all using. Apparently, the new Aqara Gateway will NOT work with Mijia products. Here is a listing on Aliexpress on the new gateway. The new gateway has the word "Aqara" in the middle of the gateway while the Mijia one has the Mijia logo.

Unless you need Apple Homekit support, you should go with the Mijia ones for better compatibility with sensors.

Ah... So the Aqara looks like an updated version of the original Xiaomi hub. Just that, now you have more devices to control and more ways to control it.

For example, I have a ceiling light in the bathroom and the Yeelight LED lightstrip in the kitchen that I can now command to change colours using Alexa soon. The other benefit is also to control the main switches that are Aqara switches that you have at home whereas with my current Xiaomi hub, all zigbee connected devices cannot be controlled via Alexa.

The question now is, do you need it? Because both my kitchen lightstrip and the bathroom ceiling light are automated by motion sensors and I doubt I'd want to change the colours of those lights.
If Wifi is down, my lights will still work since in the Automate command, I control the Aqara switch too meaning my Wifi controlled ceiling light will still turn on since it behaves like as if I turned on the physical switch. Not to mention, I won't be able to control the switches with Alexa without my Wifi too in the process.

Take note, you can already control the ceiling light, the light bulb in my store room, the kitchen lightstrip and even my vacuum with Alexa. Just that the names appear in Chinese in the Alexa app. So I just have to create a group and rename them with an English one.

So I can just say, "Alexa, start Vacuum." and watch the Xiaomi vacuum does its job as it already does.

This Aqara hub, as stated allows for more control such as saying Alexa, turn all switches off. Or I'm leaving. And allows the Aqara hub to control the Aqara main switches to switch off to save power. Along with controlling LED colours like the Philips Hue with your voice.

Provided you want those features, then by all means, upgrade to this hub. Else, the current Xiaomi hub still works and the main things you want to control are wifi based and therefore, Alexa can see them. Just give them an English name via Alexa's group and you can easily control them by voice. No Aqara hub needed.
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
There is really a new Aqara Gateway which is different from the Mijia Gateway that we are all using. Apparently, the new Aqara Gateway will NOT work with Mijia products. Here is a listing on Aliexpress on the new gateway. The new gateway has the word "Aqara" in the middle of the gateway while the Mijia one has the Mijia logo.

Unless you need Apple Homekit support, you should go with the Mijia ones for better compatibility with sensors.

For future proofing with Alexa, better to just get the aqara eco system..
 

muhammad007

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2002
Messages
540
Reaction score
2
Hi, I have recently started to read up on home automation and interested to do some works for my new house which is under renovation now. Your assistance will be much appreciated!

Based on my research and friend's advice, I would be getting a google home mini and broadlink pro+. Next I would be getting is light switches. But the light switches I have seen, does not seem to have the whole box. Need to install in false wall is it? Can I fix it to the current switch box? Same size?
 
Last edited:

wahjohreno

Master Member
Joined
May 15, 2017
Messages
3,382
Reaction score
216
Hi, I have recently started to read up on home automation and interested to do some works for my new house which is under renovation now. Your assistance will be much appreciated!

Based on my research and friend's advice, I would be getting a google home mini and broadlink pro+. Next I would be getting is light switches. But the light switches I have seen, does not seem to have the whole box. Need to install in false wall is it? Can I fix it to the current switch box? Same size?


I recently finished renovating my 20 year-old resale flat. Bought it last year from the original owners. So it's a total rip out and redo situation. So of course, it' the perfect chance to implement home automation.

My biggest piece of advise to anyone who has the opportunity to renovate is, ensure all your light switch points have neutral wires. This way, you have many choices for light switches. Automating lighting to me makes the biggest impact on convenience, so it's rather important. If you don't install neutral wires, then you're pretty much limited to using much more expensive ecosystems like Hue.

Decide now which ecosystem you want to install. Z Wave? Zigbee? Then you can research what switches are available for each ecosystem and find out the requirements for the switch size and more depth. This will affect what your electrician needs to do to accommodate them (might be a lot of digging bigger/deeper holes on your walls to fit dimming modules..etc).

I use Fibaro, and I chose to use dimming/switching modules that are installed behind regular switches. Why I chose to use modules over all-in-one switches is, the switches still work manually even if the modules fail. Downside is, dimming modules require single-gang switches, and on/off switches require double-gang (nothing more) switches. So my whole house has many single-gang and a few double-gang light switches. For example:

tOH9AIR.jpg





So, all in all, extensive planning is required. But the basic requirement for anything you want to automate remains the same. Lighting, curtain motors and door motors require neutral wires at their switch positions. Do this, and you are covered for anything you want to do, whether it's now or in the future. On/off electric switches are far easier as you can simply buy wifi switches that don't require anything different.
 

Aditshar

Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2017
Messages
218
Reaction score
0
There are lots of home automation system you can choose from in the market currently.

Since you brought up broadlink RM pro and google home mini, the most 'basic' setup you can do is to swapped the lighting switches to TC2 or any other non-neutral smart switches.

For older HDB hse, the switch housing is outside the wall. For HDB BTO, the switch housing is inside the wall. You dont require extra housing to install the switches. Just buy the UK type switches. It will fit nicely.

Before buying the smart switches, Identify your current switches gangs and also if those switches that are 2 ways, you need to make them into 1 way. You dont want to make a mistake of the wrong no. of switch gang.

Once you get the switches installed, you can setup the software. The setup will be the tricky ones but the satisfaction is worth it.

Hi, I have recently started to read up on home automation and interested to do some works for my new house which is under renovation now. Your assistance will be much appreciated!

Based on my research and friend's advice, I would be getting a google home mini and broadlink pro+. Next I would be getting is light switches. But the light switches I have seen, does not seem to have the whole box. Need to install in false wall is it? Can I fix it to the current switch box? Same size?
 

Jacky2000

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2000
Messages
1,306
Reaction score
1
Hi all,

I was planning for my house renovation, May I know if I want to have hue lights in a 3bedroom unit, how many light bulbs should I get?

Understand hue light can change from warm to bright, which is much easier to manage than deciding now should I get White or warm light for my home.
 

rasserie

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
6,071
Reaction score
4
just remember zwave can be more expensive than zigbee. i mix the two together in my own test ecosystem. using a PI and a zwave daughterboard with a xiaomi gateway and couple of zigbee sensors and switches. i used the PI mainly to run IFTTT and interact with other zwave sensors especially motion.
 

jamie136

Junior Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2018
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
how to build a smart home

Hi ,

My house will start renovation in Nov. Heard about smart home and home automation. Planning to buy below devices :

smart plug (is tp-link good?)
lightbulb & smart switch
sensor
door lock

I've got a Google home mini.

Any recommendation? Is there any brand or alternative?

:)
 

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
Hi ,

My house will start renovation in Nov. Heard about smart home and home automation. Planning to buy below devices :

smart plug (is tp-link good?)
lightbulb & smart switch
sensor
door lock

I've got a Google home mini.

Any recommendation? Is there any brand or alternative?

:)

add neutral to your light switches!
 

thenakedshades

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2013
Messages
6,731
Reaction score
113
I recently finished renovating my 20 year-old resale flat. Bought it last year from the original owners. So it's a total rip out and redo situation. So of course, it' the perfect chance to implement home automation.

My biggest piece of advise to anyone who has the opportunity to renovate is, ensure all your light switch points have neutral wires. This way, you have many choices for light switches. Automating lighting to me makes the biggest impact on convenience, so it's rather important. If you don't install neutral wires, then you're pretty much limited to using much more expensive ecosystems like Hue.

Decide now which ecosystem you want to install. Z Wave? Zigbee? Then you can research what switches are available for each ecosystem and find out the requirements for the switch size and more depth. This will affect what your electrician needs to do to accommodate them (might be a lot of digging bigger/deeper holes on your walls to fit dimming modules..etc).

I use Fibaro, and I chose to use dimming/switching modules that are installed behind regular switches. Why I chose to use modules over all-in-one switches is, the switches still work manually even if the modules fail. Downside is, dimming modules require single-gang switches, and on/off switches require double-gang (nothing more) switches. So my whole house has many single-gang and a few double-gang light switches. For example:

tOH9AIR.jpg





So, all in all, extensive planning is required. But the basic requirement for anything you want to automate remains the same. Lighting, curtain motors and door motors require neutral wires at their switch positions. Do this, and you are covered for anything you want to do, whether it's now or in the future. On/off electric switches are far easier as you can simply buy wifi switches that don't require anything different.

Thats a very nice machine set up there! :D
 

zhiping1980

Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2005
Messages
387
Reaction score
0
Hi guys, I would like to know how do I integrate the aqara hub homekit to work with Google assistant/home.
 

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
For my existing installation, I see 2 neutral wires at the light. One from mains/previous light, the other to mains/next light. One way to add neutral line is between light and switch. If I am not wrong, this will end up with 3 neutral lines at the light? Another way I can think of is pulling the neutral line from mains to the switch if it is physically possible.
 

ksapple

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2012
Messages
27,529
Reaction score
4,896
Any advice for Zigbee smart home device??

Like nothing leh?

Currently my home is running on zwave(US).

Cuz getting new echo plus tat is also a zigbee hub soo want to try zigbee
 

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
Is there a better way to explain to the wireman (Malaysian, not understand us) about adding neutral.

2.) for a house that do not have neutral,is it too late to add ?


Actually if your wireman doesnt know what is neutral, it might not be a wise decision to let him do your wiring for you because anyone who has been doing electrical work for some time would have come into contact with such terms for sure and would be very familiar

But anyway.

The live cable or L is very often referred to as Fire Line or Fire Wire

The neutral is also referred to as Zero Line.

Any house can do, its just the level of complexity and difficulty. Hence during renovation is the best time to do as its more straightforward, hence will be faster and cheaper.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top