Who stronger? Buddha or Jade Emperor?

kuti-kuti

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2018
Messages
71,109
Reaction score
25,229
Guanyin as a Bodhisattva also strong enough to subdue wukong. her 1 flick of finger is enough
 

Coaster

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2024
Messages
754
Reaction score
422
Similar to asking whether who is stronger: the Emperor or Confucious.

One is a ruler, the other is a teacher.
 

garettlim

Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2011
Messages
211
Reaction score
228
In Journey to the west, Buddha is stronger

In 封神演义 , a number of the 仙 became 菩萨

比如原著中专门指出,阐教的十二金仙中慈航道人成为佛教的观音菩萨,普贤真人成为普贤菩萨,文殊广法天尊成为文殊菩萨,以及阐教副教主燃灯道人成为燃灯佛祖。

I heard of this... so this suggests they wanted to leave and create new sect on their own...

But it also suggests that this new sect they created aka Buddhism is a newcomer and may not be as strong as the 3 pure ones.... who likely inherited most of pangu power?
 

mooseolly

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2009
Messages
29,468
Reaction score
13,200
Emperor jade is a deity and deities is still within the reincarnation cycle. Buddha has already bypassed this cycle.
 

Skoda29

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 29, 2016
Messages
31,033
Reaction score
10,246
Go and watch Creation of the Gods I: Kingdom of Storms to find the answer.
Got 3 parts.
 

bbfa gene

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 15, 2021
Messages
1,103
Reaction score
897
One is from the religion Buddhist
one is from the religion Taoism

the silly story joins them together to mess up chinese's beliefs.
you can write a new story with other gods inside. to mess up the future generation.
 

Aneosx

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2014
Messages
1,849
Reaction score
646
Jade emperor is like sg president...

The real taoist powers are the 3 pure ones 三清

元始天尊
道德天尊
灵宝天尊

Jade emperor is assistant of 元始天尊. Like his 童子 if im not wrong

Cannot compare to buddha pls... your mythology i dunno learn from where one... pls go revise
Buddha is Jie Yin Dao Ren and Zhun Ti Dao Ren disciple if im not wrong. Both these 2 sages are same lv as 3 qing. They once team up wit yuan shi and dao de tiam zhun to fight tongtian in feng shen yan yi.
 

garettlim

Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2011
Messages
211
Reaction score
228
many many levels below Buddha.

Buddha is 无上正等正觉 anuttarā-saṃyak-saṃbodhi; "peerless correct perfect enlightenment"

means is "utmost perfectness with nothing above"


" Jade Emperor" is an appointment, which in Buddhism context, only up to Bodhisattva level at most.

" Jade Emperor" in Taoism is only a high position in 仙班, meaning like a President in the Sg cabinet.

1444551520-2551669929.jpg


in Buddhism, all heavenly beings are considered as 天人 if they never attain Bodhisattva level of Buddhism.

天人 is subjected to reincarnation once he 享尽天福





fa123a6a7e80f463615ee7d58d35a8a2.jpg



You are using buddhism to measure another religion...
Emperor jade is a deity and deities is still within the reincarnation cycle. Buddha has already bypassed this cycle.

It really depends... bypassing cycle doesnt mean more powerful. It just means u forsake who u are and give up on all ur wants and desires... nothing is important anymore, including yourself and your loved ones. Of course no pain and 看开 超脱... cauz u dont matter to urself...

In taoism. Is about 无为... let things be according to law of nature.. so theres no need to bypass whatever cycle... their power is derived from law of nature... not from giving up on their own existence like buddhism

Theres no higher or lower. Is just what u want or desire and what their power is derived from... electrical or fuel energy?
 

Sango123

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 26, 2010
Messages
9,987
Reaction score
5,317
I heard of this... so this suggests they wanted to leave and create new sect on their own...

But it also suggests that this new sect they created aka Buddhism is a newcomer and may not be as strong as the 3 pure ones.... who likely inherited most of pangu power?
This version is purely from 封神演义. Many from 截教 lost in the fight and then join 西方教. In this version, even Buddha is from there.

可是,封神大战之后呢?西方教立即鸟枪换炮,一次性抓来截教上千仙人,看看名单吧!孔雀,圣人以下最强者,多宝道人,这个名字你可能不熟悉,但他的另一个名字,你一定不会陌生----如来佛祖;燃灯古佛,虽然不是抓来的,而是来头投靠,可是却给西方教带来了很多的合法性。
 

mooseolly

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2009
Messages
29,468
Reaction score
13,200
You are using buddhism to measure another religion...

It really depends... bypassing cycle doesnt mean more powerful. It just means u forsake who u are and give up on all ur wants and desires... nothing is important anymore, including yourself and your loved ones. Of course no pain and 看开 超脱... cauz u dont matter to urself...

In taoism. Is about 无为... let things be according to law of nature.. so theres no need to bypass whatever cycle... their power is derived from law of nature... not from giving up on their own existence like buddhism

Theres no higher or lower. Is just what u want or desire and what their power is derived from... electrical or fuel energy?
What you say is true but can also be interpreted as sacrificing many things to attain enlightenment which majority can’t achieve.

We get many ideas and thinking from folktales and novels like JTTW. If you watched it, Jade emperor is not a fighter and cannot handle Wukong but Buddha handled him with ease.



You see he just run away only when Wukong creating havoc. Then in the end ask Buddha for help.

 
Last edited:

Bumiputera

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2017
Messages
24,097
Reaction score
4,579
One is from the religion Buddhist
one is from the religion Taoism

the silly story joins them together to mess up chinese's beliefs.
you can write a new story with other gods inside. to mess up the future generation.
The silly story is the medieval china version of a not so simple story.

Heaven and the Buddhist figures in the story does not refer to the mythological counterparts in their respective religion but rather government bureaucrats.
 
Last edited:

garettlim

Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2011
Messages
211
Reaction score
228
This version is purely from 封神演义. Many from 截教 lost in the fight and then join 西方教. In this version, even Buddha is from there.

可是,封神大战之后呢?西方教立即鸟枪换炮,一次性抓来截教上千仙人,看看名单吧!孔雀,圣人以下最强者,多宝道人,这个名字你可能不熟悉,但他的另一个名字,你一定不会陌生----如来佛祖;燃灯古佛,虽然不是抓来的,而是来头投靠,可是却给西方教带来了很多的合法性。

I think is because of the so called 劫难, then need deities to sacrifice to overcome the heavenly disaster

But one solution is to get these ppl out of the 截教 so they can avert death lor

My memory failing me.. cant rmbr the details. But anyway myth and fiction rlly hard to tell apart...

All these stories from tang dynasty when the tang emperor tried to salvage his ruling power by introducing buddhism as a new player to balance out against taoism... so im not surprised these fiction stories try to depict buddhism as stronger
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top