Lianhe Zaobao -新加坡城市规划之父刘太格逝世 享年87岁 Liu Thai Ker.........RIP

hoolala

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
May 28, 2003
Messages
14,530
Reaction score
21,494
He is the one who proposed 10M and then keep bringing it up, so gahment gotta keep coming out and clear the air.
And u confirm he was not asked to be test balloon?
 

Ethan_

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2007
Messages
63,519
Reaction score
10,508
He is the one who proposed 10M and then keep bringing it up, so gahment gotta keep coming out and clear the air.
Is it? Thought incumbent like working towards that goal of sort?
 

hardindex

Banned
Joined
Dec 20, 2010
Messages
17,982
Reaction score
11,129
very short-sighted person, his failure to consider UHI in many towns in SG.


You’ve touched on a very real critique of Singapore’s urban planning legacy — the Urban Heat Island (UHI) effect.





🌡️ What the UHI Effect Means


  • The UHI effect occurs when built-up areas trap heat due to dense concrete, asphalt, and limited greenery.
  • In Singapore, this manifests as higher night-time temperatures, reduced wind flow, and increased reliance on air-conditioning.
  • Studies show that parts of Singapore can be 2–4°C hotter than surrounding rural or coastal areas because of this effect.




🏗️ Liu Thai Ker’s Planning vs. UHI


  • Liu Thai Ker’s housing and town planning emphasized high-density concrete blocks to maximize land use efficiency.
  • While this solved the housing crisis and created integrated towns, critics argue it prioritized efficiency over environmental cooling.
  • At the time (1970s–1990s), climate adaptation was not yet a mainstream planning concern, so UHI mitigation wasn’t central to his designs.




🌳 Later Corrective Measures


Singapore has since pivoted strongly to address UHI:


  • Greenery integration: Vertical gardens, rooftop greenery, park connectors.
  • Cooling urban design: Wider streets, ventilation corridors, reflective materials.
  • Singapore Green Plan 2030: Explicit targets for tree planting and sustainable infrastructure.
  • Nature-based solutions: Bishan-Ang Mo Kio Park’s river naturalization, Marina Barrage’s water catchment doubling as recreation.




⚖️ Balanced Perspective


  • Liu Thai Ker’s contribution was nation-building through housing — without his concrete-heavy approach, Singapore might not have solved its housing crisis.
  • But yes, the environmental side effects (UHI, reduced biodiversity, heat stress) became apparent later, requiring new generations of planners to adapt.
  • In hindsight, his work reflects the trade-off between urgent housing needs and long-term environmental sustainability.




Would you like me to map out how Singapore’s current cooling strategies (like tree canopy expansion and reflective materials) directly counteract the UHI effect created by earlier concrete-heavy planning? That would show how the city is actively correcting the imbalance left by Liu’s era.


n
 

focus1974

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
May 12, 2007
Messages
91,255
Reaction score
32,822
He supported the 10m plan.

of course ..
he wont see the day of it mah..
and more population equal more property appreciation ..

his level should have multiple properties and big and expensive ones too.
 

hardindex

Banned
Joined
Dec 20, 2010
Messages
17,982
Reaction score
11,129
Absolutely — ancient Roman design is a fascinating case study in passive cooling and climate adaptation. While Liu Thai Ker’s concrete-heavy approach in Singapore amplified the Urban Heat Island effect, Roman builders often integrated cooling strategies directly into their architecture and urban layouts.





🏛️ Cooling Features in Roman Design


  • Aqueducts & Fountains
    • Water was central to Roman cities. Aqueducts supplied public fountains and baths, which not only provided drinking water but also cooled the surrounding air through evaporation.
    • Piazza fountains acted like natural “air conditioners” in open spaces.
  • Thermal Mass & Thick Walls
    • Roman buildings used stone, brick, and concrete with high thermal mass, absorbing heat during the day and releasing it slowly at night.
    • This stabilized indoor temperatures, reducing extremes.
  • Atriums & Courtyards
    • Houses (domus) often had open-air courtyards with shaded colonnades.
    • These spaces promoted airflow and created cooler microclimates inside homes.
  • Orientation & Ventilation
    • Roman architects carefully oriented buildings to maximize shade and cross-ventilation.
    • Windows and openings were strategically placed to channel breezes.
  • Baths & Cooling Pools
    • Public baths (thermae) weren’t just for hygiene — cold pools (frigidarium) offered relief from heat.
    • Their large halls with vaulted ceilings also encouraged air circulation.
  • Urban Layout

  • Roman streets were often narrow and shaded, reducing direct solar exposure.
  • Arcades and porticos provided shaded walkways for pedestrians.




🌍 Lessons for Modern Cities


  • Romans understood that water, shade, and airflow were essential for livability in hot climates.
  • Modern planners in Singapore and elsewhere are rediscovering these principles — integrating green corridors, water features, and shaded walkways to counteract UHI.
  • In a way, Rome’s passive cooling strategies anticipated today’s climate-resilient urban design.




Would you like me to compare Roman cooling strategies with Singapore’s current Green Plan 2030 measures (like tree canopy expansion and park connectors)? That would show how ancient wisdom and modern sustainability converge.



Never consider people, his designs only squeeze more people and completely ignore comfort. Terrible in his job really
 

Kiwi8

Honorary Member
Deluxe Member
Joined
May 3, 2001
Messages
137,742
Reaction score
16,626
He is the one who proposed 10M and then keep bringing it up, so gahment gotta keep coming out and clear the air.
It is not that simple.

More like he was the gahmen's test balloon, gahmen always will want a higher population as long as they do not get too big backlash in the polls.

Look at the uproar over the Population White Paper at that time, PAP shrank their balls for the moment. Now voters are oblivious that the population is increasing towards the level prescribed in the Population White Paper again.
 

sciprof

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2006
Messages
22,853
Reaction score
1,727
Now is aiming 20mil. Take mrt need to squat on eachother
 

bombshell

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2022
Messages
17,677
Reaction score
14,273
It's better to plan for 10m then not have a plan.
Since we are heading to 10m either way and the planner has died, GG to us all.
RIP.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top