Cheapest Insurance ?

Sofiawotson

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2014
Messages
46
Reaction score
0
Which medical insurance company is the cheapest?

I'm 25 college student and I need to get a medical insurance. I live in River Valley Road.

Which company is the cheapest?
I was thinking of Aviva but I'm not sure.

Thanks in advance guys
 

bigmice

Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2010
Messages
235
Reaction score
0
NTUC is the cheapest shield plan, cover 90%
100% cover Pru cheapest for private, Great eastern is cheapest for gov A ward.
 

chopra

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2003
Messages
50,456
Reaction score
661
Updated on 2nd July
summary2.jpg
summary.jpg
 

Chennie

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2014
Messages
64
Reaction score
0
My opinion

AIA is the second cheapest in terms of premium for health coverage.

However, it is also the only one that provides CI reimbursement in the event of critical illness.

Furthermore, it has the longest duration of reimbursement covered should you be down due to a CI (200 days, which is even longer than Pru's 180).

Just my opinion, feel free to discuss more with me ^^
 

Aerial86

Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2013
Messages
324
Reaction score
0
AIA is the second cheapest in terms of premium for health coverage.

However, it is also the only one that provides CI reimbursement in the event of critical illness.

Furthermore, it has the longest duration of reimbursement covered should you be down due to a CI (200 days, which is even longer than Pru's 180).

Just my opinion, feel free to discuss more with me ^^

Back your statement saying that AIA is the only one that provides CI reimbursement, when you also say Pru's is 180 days..

And maybe you want to also explain how is AIA is the second cheapest in terms of health coverage?
 

Chennie

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2014
Messages
64
Reaction score
0
Back your statement saying that AIA is the only one that provides CI reimbursement, when you also say Pru's is 180 days..

And maybe you want to also explain how is AIA is the second cheapest in terms of health coverage?

Sure, using an age band of shall we say 30:

AIA and Aviva charge around 240, Prudential charges about 200 (Cheapest) with Great Eastern and the rest sitting at 270 and above.

If you then look at the Pre and Post Hospitalisation benefits. AIA offers 100 days , Great Eastern and Pru offer 120 and 180 (respectively). However, AIA chooses instead to offer an extension to 200 days for Post Hospitalisation and Psych Treatement if it is due to a Critical Illness (which is when you need the additional days coverage the most! (Great Eastern and AIA are the only ones offering the psych treatment coverage and GE only has 120 days)

Info is sourced from MOH Healthshield Comparison.
 

Aerial86

Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2013
Messages
324
Reaction score
0
Oh so your premiums is calculated based only on the CPF portion without rider.. So for the second point, does this mean other than AIA, the rest of the insurer does not cover post-hospitalization treatment due to CI? If the rest also covers, does this also means AIA only provide Post hospitalization treatment for 100days unless it is due to CI?

Thanks for helping to clear the air here...
 

Chennie

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2014
Messages
64
Reaction score
0
Oh so your premiums is calculated based only on the CPF portion without rider.. So for the second point, does this mean other than AIA, the rest of the insurer does not cover post-hospitalization treatment due to CI? If the rest also covers, does this also means AIA only provide Post hospitalization treatment for 100days unless it is due to CI?

Thanks for helping to clear the air here...

No problem! Happy to exercise my brain (^_^)

And yeah, I am only using the CPF portion without the rider. I believe each firm will have their own subset of riders which may or may not add on to the non-CPF medisave premium. For example: AIA has Essential which is paid in cash, this portion is definitely cheapest in the market since AIA charges a bit more on the non-cash portion (hence why it is not the cheapest).

The rest of the insurers DO cover CI, I must make that clear!

All insurers will usually cover it but from my knowledge you have to add a rider on to do so. AIA has it built-in. Basically, the difference is, other companies are opt-in, AIA is already there. What AIA has that others don't have is an additional 100k reimbursement for CI treatment (however this is not cash in-hand like a Critical Illness Plan, this is only REIMBURSEMENT).

Post hospitalization is 100 days if not due to CI, which most people have reacted negatively to. However, one point that I like to bring up with respect to this is the following:

AIA focuses on the shorter-term because the shorter-term problems are more likely to occur. This is evidenced from the fact that they even pay out for short-stay ward (6 hours with PRE AND POST COVERED, no others have this).

Long waits are more common with public hospitals, but with AIA cover, visiting the private hospitals is not an issue (and of course coverage is the same). You can get quick treatment and the best service; in which case 100 days is enough.

The situations under which you need more than 100 days is usually when something very serious has occurred, a good planner will have assisted you in planning for this (yes, I know this statement is a poor one since 'good' agents are almost non-existant) and therefore you should still be well covered.

Remember an insurer only offers something BIG when they have more to gain than to lose. The reason they are offering 180 is because there are fewer claims past 100 days and therefore its just an additional selling point.

Hope this helps a bit more!

P.S. I myself am on AIA.
 

tigerliongoose

Junior Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2013
Messages
33
Reaction score
0

Chennie

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2014
Messages
64
Reaction score
0
Taking the cheapest plan now only makes sense if the premium is "lock-able"

Shield plan premiums CANNOT be locked-in, and you have to think deeper than that.

Here is a more appropriate way to choose the cheapest shield plan:

The comparison between Medishield Life vs Private Integrated Shield Plan FAQ: How to select the right shield plan. Medishield Life vs Private Integrated Shield Plan comparison

That article is GREAT! It covers many important aspects of how to pick the best shield plan.

One thing that wasn't covered however, in the section of "How to pick the best plan" and that was the comparison between the CPF portion of the plan (basic premium) and the cash part of the plan (rider).

Some companies make the medisave portion much cheaper, especially in the higher age bands to use as a selling point.

However, as the article highlights, the deductibles and co-payments alone can wipe you out (easily running into thousands of dollars with the present cost of healthcare) hence, to decide on the best plan that will be most affordable in the long-term, information on the rider premium quotes is important.

Some companies choose to make their medisave portion cheaper, but charge you more on the cash portion (the rider). Hence you will definitely need to consider this as a big part of the cost. What you are paying out of hand is usually a much greater concern to most people, compared to what is going out of your medisave (o3o).

As the article says however, you should choose a plan that fits you, because if you really do the mathematics between all the companies (CPF portion + rider) they are all essentially the same with only a tiny margin inbetween.
 

chopra

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2003
Messages
50,456
Reaction score
661
As the article says however, you should choose a plan that fits you, because if you really do the mathematics between all the companies (CPF portion + rider) they are all essentially the same with only a tiny margin inbetween.

tiny is subjective.

but I agree. have you seen my table?

aia agent, feel free to use it. ur aia is better (currently) for Ward 'a' full coverage.

do remind urself that this comparison amongst different products will change when pap introduces shield life.
 

IFAadvisor

Suspended
Joined
Dec 18, 2013
Messages
125
Reaction score
0
Shield plans are not plans you change year on year based on coverage and premium. Do note you practically drop your coverage when you swap during time of swapping since every Singaporean can only have one such plan. Even you have successfully applied to a new plan, you are subjected to more checks during a claim in the first 3 years as compared to one who is on the plan for 5 years.

One should really understand why one needs medical attention and type of attention one is seeking instead of focusing on the premium. The premium changes every 2-3 years or when government introduces new schemes or make changes. So in terms of premium, you may win this year, next year the other company may win.

How long can one stay in the hospital, and how can you be admitted in a hospital. In government wards, the doctor will try their best not to ward you while a private practice will do otherwise (though must be deem necessary).

My 2 cents worth, get one that suits your risk appetite. Perks is good, 90 days to 120days, you are paying $ for it. Not now, it maybe later as claim experience of insurers changes. With a claim of up to $600,000, why do one need to think about more perks where most CI will cost you 200k-400k range. The only case I got that burst this limit is when client suffered coma in ICU for months.
 

Chennie

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2014
Messages
64
Reaction score
0
tiny is subjective.

but I agree. have you seen my table?

aia agent, feel free to use it. ur aia is better (currently) for Ward 'a' full coverage.

do remind urself that this comparison amongst different products will change when pap introduces shield life.

Yeah, I've heard of that. Still, the present benefits stand and I have always recommended Ward 'A' full coverage, since it gives people flexibility. When you're sick you want the best care and that was what happened in my family when we had no proper insurance.

It's why I became an agent, to understand better about these things.

At present AIA I think is providing very good cover and if people are satisfied with the benefits, I hope that's what will matter lol
 

Chennie

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2014
Messages
64
Reaction score
0
Shield plans are not plans you change year on year based on coverage and premium. Do note you practically drop your coverage when you swap during time of swapping since every Singaporean can only have one such plan. Even you have successfully applied to a new plan, you are subjected to more checks during a claim in the first 3 years as compared to one who is on the plan for 5 years.

One should really understand why one needs medical attention and type of attention one is seeking instead of focusing on the premium. The premium changes every 2-3 years or when government introduces new schemes or make changes. So in terms of premium, you may win this year, next year the other company may win.

How long can one stay in the hospital, and how can you be admitted in a hospital. In government wards, the doctor will try their best not to ward you while a private practice will do otherwise (though must be deem necessary).

My 2 cents worth, get one that suits your risk appetite. Perks is good, 90 days to 120days, you are paying $ for it. Not now, it maybe later as claim experience of insurers changes. With a claim of up to $600,000, why do one need to think about more perks where most CI will cost you 200k-400k range. The only case I got that burst this limit is when client suffered coma in ICU for months.

Very true, focus on the benefits. Not on the premium.
 

keentolearn

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2014
Messages
97
Reaction score
0
Helping a friend ask

Anyone on NTUC IncomeShield? Wondering how long it takes to get reimbursed..

My Pru agent (aka my aunt) told me Pru is one of the fastest insurers in terms of disbursement of funds. I was in a pte hosp 11-13 Dec, paid full sum to hosp, Pru disbursed fund to hosp on 20 Dec.

I would say this is quite fast?
 

JoePilot

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2011
Messages
10,132
Reaction score
239
Pru is indeed the fastest. U can see the comparison on MOH website.
 

sogoofy1203

Member
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
267
Reaction score
0
Best insurance company

hey buddy, if you want good privileges on your insurance plan in Singapore then you will not have the privilege of a plan that comes cheap..I know of an insurance provider (Zurich) which offers some good general as well as life insurance plans in Singapore which are affordable and I've taken the plan for myself through them. They offer good privileges on the insurance plans in Singapore. Check for more info on their website.
 
Last edited:

tatose

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2008
Messages
995
Reaction score
98
hey buddy, if you want good privileges on your insurance plan in Singapore then you will not have the privilege of a plan that comes cheap..I know of an insurance provider (Zurich) which offers some good general as well as life insurance plans in Singapore which are affordable and I've taken the plan for myself through them. They offer good privileges on the insurance plans in Singapore. Check for more info on their website.

I don't want to hijack this thread so much but I'm also a participant in their plans...pm me if too sensitive.

Do you have ILP with Zurich? How do you go about knowing all the funds (got seminar bo?) and doing fund transfer? Hows the agent who servicing you. I long time bo kajiao my Z-agent, moi-ish also very busy for some time. Need to hear more from newcomers before inquiring directly.

For TS, price premium for medical plans are not very important, especially for shield-plans. What important are:

1) Your insurability.
2) What can be insured.
3) How much can your insurance protect you from medical treatment costs (VERYISH IMPORTANT, a little more money each day can prevent you from spending additional huge chunks in emergencies).
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top