Power Consumption - Desktop Vs Laptop

Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
48,310
Reaction score
7,450
Assuming Desktop 100W.
Assuming Laptop 35W.

Running them 24/7.

Annual Wattage for Desktop = 876000
Annual Wattage for Laptop = 306600

Assuming 1kWatt = ~30 cents.

Annual Electric Bill for Desktop = ~$263
Annual Electric Bill for Laptop = ~$92

Savings per year from electricity = $171

Of cos you need to factor in price difference between Desktop and Laptop and this calculation only applies if you 24/7.
 

yusoffb01

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2008
Messages
16,876
Reaction score
1,791
Assuming Desktop 100W.
Assuming Laptop 35W.

Running them 24/7.

Annual Wattage for Desktop = 876000
Annual Wattage for Laptop = 306600

Assuming 1kWatt = ~30 cents.

Annual Electric Bill for Desktop = ~$263
Annual Electric Bill for Laptop = ~$92

Savings per year from electricity = $171

Of cos you need to factor in price difference between Desktop and Laptop and this calculation only applies if you 24/7.

This is why we should use tablets less than 5w
 

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
Assuming Desktop 100W.
Assuming Laptop 35W.

Running them 24/7.

Annual Wattage for Desktop = 876000
Annual Wattage for Laptop = 306600

Assuming 1kWatt = ~30 cents.

Annual Electric Bill for Desktop = ~$263
Annual Electric Bill for Laptop = ~$92

Savings per year from electricity = $171

Of cos you need to factor in price difference between Desktop and Laptop and this calculation only applies if you 24/7.
lol desktops and laptops don't run at full power all the time. :s22:

And 65W for a laptop makes more sense since most models comes with 65W power brick...

And lastly using TDP as a generally number as actual power consumption figure is simply inaccurate.
 
Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
48,310
Reaction score
7,450
lol desktops and laptops don't run at full power all the time. :s22:

And 65W for a laptop makes more sense since most models comes with 65W power brick...

And lastly using TDP as a generally number as actual power consumption figure is simply inaccurate.

Already say liao is ASSUMING mah.
 

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
You come up with a better maths calculation lor.
:D
Let a be CPU power at full load for desktop Celeron G1820
Let b be IGP power at full load for desktop Celeron G1820
Let c be CPU power at full load for notebook Celeron 1037U
Let d be IGP power at full load for notebook Celeron 1037U

Let’s consider that an average person spends 3 hours a day on their PC on video playback + 3 hours a day on intensive work & web surfing:

So according to these CPU & GPU utilization and system power consumption chart:

video-1.png


power-1.png


power-2.png


power-3.png


power-4.png

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/athlon-5350-sempron-3850_9.html#sect0

a = 47 – 24 = 23W
b = 47 – 24 = 23W
c = 35 – 27 = 8W
d = 43 – 27 = 16W

Desktop Celeron G1820’s system power consumption per day:
[(24 + 15.7a/100 + 22.2b/100) + 68] / 1000 x 3
= [(24 + 3.611 + 5.106) + 68] / 1000 x 3 = 0.3022 kWh

Notebook Celeron 1037U’s system power consumption per day:
[(27 + 18.3c/100 + 36d/100) + 50] / 1000 x 3
= [(27 + 1.464 + 5.76) + 50] / 1000 x 3 = 0.2527 kWh

Energy savings of low-power notebook Celeron 1037U over desktop Celeron G1820 per day:
0.3022 – 0.2527 = 0.0495 kWh

Electricity bill savings PER YEAR on low-power notebook Celeron 1037U over desktop Celeron G1820:
0.0495 kWh x 365.25 x $0.2035 = $3.68

So this proves my point that desktop can be as energy-efficient as a ULV notebook/ultrabook for common usage pattern with such meagre savings over a year of usage daily
 
Last edited:

Mighty_Orange

Master Member
Joined
May 16, 2013
Messages
2,748
Reaction score
1
what u guys think of Asus monitors? Especially for their eyecare series. I was attracted to Mac's screen feature of not so tiring using it for long. but i still cant shift myself off windows.

My short term option is to continue on with my lenovo laptop with buying of one 23-24 inch monitor.

Currently thinking between Dell and Asus.

Seems that Dell is quite famous with their monitors while Asus is less talked about.
 

Mighty_Orange

Master Member
Joined
May 16, 2013
Messages
2,748
Reaction score
1
Laptops are usually also more expensive than desktops, negating the advantage of power savings through the cost premium, if portability is not the concern to focused user group.

thanks. its really conclusive enough to form a conclusion that there is sort of power saving relative to desktops.
 

monikernemo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2014
Messages
7,268
Reaction score
1
what u guys think of Asus monitors? Especially for their eyecare series. I was attracted to Mac's screen feature of not so tiring using it for long. but i still cant shift myself off windows.

My short term option is to continue on with my lenovo laptop with buying of one 23-24 inch monitor.

Currently thinking between Dell and Asus.

Seems that Dell is quite famous with their monitors while Asus is less talked about.

Most likely marketing gimmick... If you want to spend some money, definitely go for ASUS. Dell seems to be 'pocket-friendly'

thanks. its really conclusive enough to form a conclusion that there is sort of power saving relative to desktops.

Even though it is apparent that desktop uses more power than laptop, it is not conclusive that one should always choose a laptop over desktop for usage. Like moneyface bro pointed out, the savings is really negligible and to add on, it will only scale well enough to be significant (even so, $100+ dollars saving per year) if and only if on full load for 24/7. For daily mundane tasks, rarely your pc will be on full load usage, let alone 24/7.

With monitors turned on, the energy usage will become much closer and less significant.

I feel that one should only use laptop if you need to work with on a project using multiple computers/ work while on the go.
 

Piezoq

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2010
Messages
1,567
Reaction score
0
I read from somewhere here mentioned that for power consumption, desktop is higher than laptop, is this true?

Im now using a ideapad laptop for just basic usage like Microsoft office (word, ppt, excel), YouTube and music, and feeling comfortable with everything for 4 years (with just 1 break down), except wanting a monitor.


struggling whether should I:

(1) Buy just a monitor, connect to current laptop, and when laptop is spoiled can buy a desktop or laptop.

(2) Just buy a desktop.

(3) Buy a Aio, but really worry the device heat up easily.

If you're a happy laptop user, get a monitor.

Energy cost is not a substantial part of the equation because:

1. The air-con/fridge will be the main consumer of electricity.
2. Your mobile bill (including the price of the phone) is significantly greater, amortized monthly.
3. A taxi ride is easily $30 or more.

People buy lappies to:
1. reduce desk clutter (easy to keep, portable etc)
2. match their furniture.
3. have the option of bringing a computer with them.

Energy costs? I hear this argument once in a blue moon, although the argument is usually true (but not very relevant).
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top