Which song is better? 千千闕歌, 夕陽之歌 or 风中的承诺??

[tameimpala]

paging opinion of ppl who hear the songs before: all of them got same music but different lyrics (and it was actually adapted from japanese 夕焼けの歌 lol)

which version you like the most??

​

 

[Tobecontinue]

Which ever u like the most lor.

 

[Dinoboyboy]

im from the negative peepur crub, naturally I will gravitate towards the more pessimistic version which was the one by anita.


Read HWZ Forum Rules!

 

[bigrooster]

Anita’s version the meaning closer to original and most melancholic. While I like Priscilla’s singing a lot but for this one I vote for Anita.

 

[moonlighter_sg]

I like Anita version. Hear liao very emo..

 

[sales69]

Anita. Reflect her own life.

 

[asmartng]

All are very nice song

 

[TA20222025]

 

[moonlighter_sg]

This song is written for lao zarbor who cannot find partner.

 

[kelhot2001]

千千阙歌 my vote

 

[maddyrem]

I vote for Ah mui. She sounds the best for this song.

 

[hardindex]

千千闕歌​

 

[Schwarzenegger]

paging opinion of ppl who hear the songs before: all of them got same music but different lyrics (and it was actually adapted from japanese 夕焼けの歌 lol)

which version you like the most??

​

Actually during that era, Priscilla and Anita were fighting for the queen of pop in HK, but Priscilla eventually lose out to Anita and went to Canada to escape the defeat.

 

[ChinTuaKi]

夕陽之歌....in the end the song reflected her life...and the last song she sang before she said "bye bye"......really is 巨星陨落​

the lyrics is also so wow....especially this sentence 奔波中心灰意淡　路上紛擾波折再一彎　一天 想到歸去但已晚

just wow

 

[Whimsica]

The 3 songs are different.

One is about thinking of past/lost love, the other is about farewell and the third is about life and the end of something.

The me today will find the lyrics and singing styles of Lee E-Jun and Priscilla Chan too cringe-worthy, although I used to have Lee E-Jun's song sang in ktv by atbs.

My vote goes to Anita Mui's version, nicely sung with emotion and very apt as I walk into the sunset of my life.

 

[spunkbrat]

 

[m0n0n0ke]

千千阙歌 my vote

Plus one to this

 

[sonicboyz]

中风的承诺 ​

 

[kage]

Free to listen just listen to all loh ....

 

[Geminiboy]

Anita. Her voice and the lyrics go with the music.