Cheapest 4 bay hdd enclosure

SiaoAngMoh

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2000
Messages
1,507
Reaction score
29
an ITX system with 4x HDD bay costing only S$170? that's too good to be truth, even S$280 is a steal. Amazon listed this microsever from $431 to >$700. maybe the cheapest have only casing/PSU + Mobo/CPU and no software. even that, I doubt HP will sell this at S$170. the hardware alone might already cost that much...

but I do hope it really cost that much, beat any 4bay HDD casing, not to mentioned overpriced NAS.

None of the microservers come with software. Just the hardware. Even the $400 ones. The reason the price is dropping, HP replaced this with the gen 8 microservers. These are gen 7s.

The motherboard has a USB port internally on the board to allow you to run the OS from a thumbdrive without wasting a SATA port, so you can use all the drives for your pool storage. This works with some linux distros and software like freenas.

I put my own copy of windows on it, using a 2.5" HDD connected to a SATA port.

If you read up on the web on the tweaks people have done to the server, it is impressive. People have squeezed in 9 HDDs into the box!! Personally thats a bit crazy to me but can be done. I'm about to upgrade mine from 5 drives (4 pooled drives, 1 OS drive) to 7 (6+1).
 

doomgaze86

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2007
Messages
814
Reaction score
22
None of the microservers come with software. Just the hardware. Even the $400 ones. The reason the price is dropping, HP replaced this with the gen 8 microservers. These are gen 7s.

The motherboard has a USB port internally on the board to allow you to run the OS from a thumbdrive without wasting a SATA port, so you can use all the drives for your pool storage. This works with some linux distros and software like freenas.

I put my own copy of windows on it, using a 2.5" HDD connected to a SATA port.

If you read up on the web on the tweaks people have done to the server, it is impressive. People have squeezed in 9 HDDs into the box!! Personally thats a bit crazy to me but can be done. I'm about to upgrade mine from 5 drives (4 pooled drives, 1 OS drive) to 7 (6+1).

Thanks for the suggestion... This guy's build is really cool. 4 x 3.5'' and 6 x 2.5'' drives crammed into this tiny little thing is insane..

Single review: HP ProLiant G7 N54L MicroServer Server System AMD Turion II Model Neo N54L 2GB 250GB LFF Operating System None 704941-001 - Newegg.com

I'll try and give FreeNAS a shot this weekend to see if it's something I can get used to before I pull the trigger on this microserver. Trouble is, there are so many options out there that I'm having trouble picking one. Right now I can't even decide if ZFS (via FreeNAS) is something I want to try, or if I should just do what you do and use Windows 8.1 with Drive Bender or DrivePool.
 

SiaoAngMoh

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2000
Messages
1,507
Reaction score
29
I ended up with Drive Bender after some trial n error.

If you use some sort of RAID system, the problem is the drives need to be the same size. This makes upgrading the system later on a pain in the behind. You could have a mirrored system in freenas using ZFS, but again, painful to upgrade.

Storage spaces in windows (included in win 8 pro, I think) is supposed to overcome this, but the write speed to the pool was very slow for me.

Drive Bender (and DrivePool) essentially manage the duplication on a file or folder basis, and don't care if the drives are different capacities. So upgrading the drives is easy.

The main advantage of DB or DP tho, the disks are still readable outside of the pool. They are NTFS formatted. Imagine your server died. You could remove the drives and plug them in to another system with DB/DP installed and you are back to where you were. Or, you could plug them into another PC one disk at a time and pull data off as needed. FreeNas or another RAID type solution cannot do this.
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
Bumping an old thread for more current situation analysis.

Am looking to refresh PC desktop to a laptop and migrate the current 2xHDD and couple of external 3.5" individual enclosure HDDs into a 4xHDD enclosure for better desk top space management.

Any good recommendations for such a multi HDD enclosure? I would think a seperate power unit and fan would definitely be desired. Thanks in advance
 

jtjt00

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
17,739
Reaction score
551
Bumping an old thread for more current situation analysis.

Am looking to refresh PC desktop to a laptop and migrate the current 2xHDD and couple of external 3.5" individual enclosure HDDs into a 4xHDD enclosure for better desk top space management.

Any good recommendations for such a multi HDD enclosure? I would think a seperate power unit and fan would definitely be desired. Thanks in advance
.
Get a NAS?
 

symbiote28

Master Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
Messages
2,619
Reaction score
224
sorry but i'm quite new to this setup and i wanna ask a few things to see if i can use this instead:

1. this 4 bay hdd is only meant for one desktop right? instead of installing HDD it into the case, we're essentially just installing it at the bay connected to the pc?
2. i have two desktops in total soon, so if i want to 'share' just between the desktops, i would need a NAS instead?
3. NAS works with any internal 3.5" HDD correct?
4. if i buy a NAS or this bay, are SATA wires provided?
 

batniss

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2015
Messages
16,610
Reaction score
578
sorry but i'm quite new to this setup and i wanna ask a few things to see if i can use this instead:

1. this 4 bay hdd is only meant for one desktop right? instead of installing HDD it into the case, we're essentially just installing it at the bay connected to the pc?
2. i have two desktops in total soon, so if i want to 'share' just between the desktops, i would need a NAS instead?
3. NAS works with any internal 3.5" HDD correct?
4. if i buy a NAS or this bay, are SATA wires provided?

1. Sort of
2. No. You can always share the folders. Windows supports sharing of folders between machines.
3. Yes, you want put 2.5" also can, SSD too.
4. No. Because u just have to push the hdd to sit into the sata slots directly.
 

symbiote28

Master Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
Messages
2,619
Reaction score
224
1. Sort of
2. No. You can always share the folders. Windows supports sharing of folders between machines.
3. Yes, you want put 2.5" also can, SSD too.
4. No. Because u just have to push the hdd to sit into the sata slots directly.

thank for this bro. so NAS is probably the setup to go if i want to access my files when i'm out of the house? like a personal cloud system? i current have a WD Cloud 2TB but the storage is not upgradable.
 

batniss

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2015
Messages
16,610
Reaction score
578
thank for this bro. so NAS is probably the setup to go if i want to access my files when i'm out of the house? like a personal cloud system? i current have a WD Cloud 2TB but the storage is not upgradable.

i won't say is the setup to go...

but definitely one of the easiest to implement on what you required.
 

Asure7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2009
Messages
5,252
Reaction score
309
Unless u buy top-end models for out-of-box consumer NAS, the speed is going to be quite frustrating if u always transfer big file sizes.
First time backup will take hours and hours.

I switched to probox RAID enclosure after a while. With USB 3.0, speed is close to native hdd and u also can do RAID 0/1/10 if u want to.

Only drawback is the main PC the enclosure is connected to must be on if other PCs want to access th files (using Windows file sharing).
If that’s too troublesome for u, then NAS will be better.
 

batniss

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2015
Messages
16,610
Reaction score
578
Unless u buy top-end models for out-of-box consumer NAS, the speed is going to be quite frustrating if u always transfer big file sizes.
First time backup will take hours and hours.

I switched to probox RAID enclosure after a while. With USB 3.0, speed is close to native hdd and u also can do RAID 0/1/10 if u want to.

Only drawback is the main PC the enclosure is connected to must be on if other PCs want to access th files (using Windows file sharing).
If that’s too troublesome for u, then NAS will be better.

I beg to differ. Lower entry nas could give you good transfer speeds for large files these days too. Of course you will still be bottlenecked by 1000Mbps tops.

NAS also has energy saving and etc. Unlike your probox which only keep files, the NAS could become a server to host all sorts of things.
 

symbiote28

Master Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
Messages
2,619
Reaction score
224
Unless u buy top-end models for out-of-box consumer NAS, the speed is going to be quite frustrating if u always transfer big file sizes.
First time backup will take hours and hours.

I switched to probox RAID enclosure after a while. With USB 3.0, speed is close to native hdd and u also can do RAID 0/1/10 if u want to.

Only drawback is the main PC the enclosure is connected to must be on if other PCs want to access th files (using Windows file sharing).
If that’s too troublesome for u, then NAS will be better.

thanks for the feedback. the main PC will always be on as i seldom turn off my PC. what is the speed for this? slower than an SSD? right now my PC is about 5 years old and i'm building another one which will comprise of m.2 nvme and a seagate 7200rpm. so with the enclosure connected to the new PC, speed will follow the components?

is the probox RAID this?

https://www.qoo10.sg/item/PROBOX-PROBOX-HFR2-SU3S2-K-SUK-4BAY-RAID-HDD-FOR-USB3-0-E-SATA/531776248?banner_no=1305330
 

kracie17

Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2017
Messages
268
Reaction score
1
thanks for the feedback. the main PC will always be on as i seldom turn off my PC. what is the speed for this? slower than an SSD? right now my PC is about 5 years old and i'm building another one which will comprise of m.2 nvme and a seagate 7200rpm. so with the enclosure connected to the new PC, speed will follow the components?

is the probox RAID this?

https://www.qoo10.sg/item/PROBOX-PROBOX-HFR2-SU3S2-K-SUK-4BAY-RAID-HDD-FOR-USB3-0-E-SATA/531776248?banner_no=1305330

uhm try not to get probox. i used to own one but encounter data integrity problem, i switched to NAS. now working as DAS (direct attached storage). in future, if need be, i can convert it back to NAS.
 

Asure7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2009
Messages
5,252
Reaction score
309
I beg to differ. Lower entry nas could give you good transfer speeds for large files these days too. Of course you will still be bottlenecked by 1000Mbps tops.

Not gonna dispute "good transfer speed" for the new entry-level NAS as i do not have any data on that.
But for the probox DAS, im getting typically native hdd speeds (>120 MB/s with WD Red 5400rpm) instead of the ~20-25 MB/s i used to get for entry-level NAS.
Entry-level NAS speed is typically bottlenecked by CPU/RAM and not the interface.

NAS also has energy saving and etc. Unlike your probox which only keep files, the NAS could become a server to host all sorts of things.

Since a probox is simply a DAS attached to a PC....
well, the PC itself can be server to host stuff too. You can even set up your own Cloud server.
But of course, it's not as simple and convenient as NAS that already comes pre-installed with Cloud services through mobile apps etc.

I find NAS is quite expensive though.
If TS is technically-inclined and wants an NAS, installing FreeNAS on HP ProLiant microserver would probably be the most bang-for-buck solution.
 
Last edited:

Asure7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2009
Messages
5,252
Reaction score
309
thanks for the feedback. the main PC will always be on as i seldom turn off my PC. what is the speed for this? slower than an SSD? right now my PC is about 5 years old and i'm building another one which will comprise of m.2 nvme and a seagate 7200rpm. so with the enclosure connected to the new PC, speed will follow the components?

is the probox RAID this?

https://www.qoo10.sg/item/PROBOX-PROBOX-HFR2-SU3S2-K-SUK-4BAY-RAID-HDD-FOR-USB3-0-E-SATA/531776248?banner_no=1305330

yeah that's the one im using... for about 3 years already.

speed? well, since you are probably putting in standard 3.5" hdd, for sure it's slower than SSD =:p
speed is close to native internal hdd through usb3.
 
Last edited:

Asure7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2009
Messages
5,252
Reaction score
309
uhm try not to get probox. i used to own one but encounter data integrity problem, i switched to NAS. now working as DAS (direct attached storage). in future, if need be, i can convert it back to NAS.

sorry to hear your encounter with data integrity issue.

I've used probox for 3-5 years (one 2-bay and another 4-bay) and so far have no problems (touch wood).
I'm quite paranoid about my data, so I actually run RapidCRC for all the files i transfer in... and once in a while do a data integrity check on all files too.
 

symbiote28

Master Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
Messages
2,619
Reaction score
224
thanks for the input guys. other than probox, which 2 bay NAS would you recommend? i'll probably buy one 4tb HDD first before the time comes to buy another one.
 

kracie17

Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2017
Messages
268
Reaction score
1
thanks for the input guys. other than probox, which 2 bay NAS would you recommend? i'll probably buy one 4tb HDD first before the time comes to buy another one.

although i think getting a 4 bay ver would be a good decision. you can think of it as future proof. use 2 bays out of the 4 and you can upgrade in future.. am currently using the ds416j. its budget yet simple enough to store data. :)
 

symbiote28

Master Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2006
Messages
2,619
Reaction score
224
although i think getting a 4 bay ver would be a good decision. you can think of it as future proof. use 2 bays out of the 4 and you can upgrade in future.. am currently using the ds416j. its budget yet simple enough to store data. :)

thank you for this! i'm looking at reviews and i think 2 bay would be enough for me. looking at the DS218play.

normally when you guys have a NAS, what's the storage on your PC slots? Just one single SSD? or an SSD with let's say a 1TB HDD?
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top