The moment you close Citi immediately it becomes a worthless investment vehicle again since you need to step it up another year. You can withdraw what you need from SSB too, it's better as you just lose some interest on what you withdraw but the rest of your money in there are still viable.
SGS and other corp bonds are available for the shorter term giving the same rate as Maxigain.
Why wouldn't you draw from BOC and Maybank for emergency needs? They are your most liquid options available, seems foolish to tap into your less liquid options when they are available.
Sure they might pay out the highest interest at the moment, but I presume that any emergency scenario is temporary and you will fill the gap back pretty quickly. Unless you are old and retired, when you can't work anymore to put back the money you took out from your emergency funds.
There is no right and wrong method just diff.
1. Citi as long as u do not withdraw the interest won't drop to 0
2. Likewise to compare for like for like, if u close SSB it become worthless
3. If emergency it definitely won't be small amount. Let's say u need 100k..u will close BOC to earn 2.5% from SSB?
I rather wipe out the 100k from Citi and maintain the 60k in BOC den 60k from Maybank and 40k in BOC
Again u are not comparing like for like..
Corp bond and banks savings are diff. One with risk one is almost risk free
I don't think a normal salaried worker can cover 100k in a few months time.
Honestly it seems foolish to tap onto a vehicle that gives u the most liquidity yet higher interest. Both SSB and Citi are underpaying the illiquity