Man and woman charged with killing woman's 4-year-old daughter and burning her body

[buzzlightyear852]

Still waiting for novelle chua to be charged

Boycott her food catering biz first

 

[niefeng80]

these people love life is messy until cannot.

 

[bh2148]

 

[Ckcw23]

When you’re so f@cked up even a foreigner also cover your case.

 

[Forever84]

Why no hang???

 

[Lasogette]

Boycott her food catering biz first

Any links on what name

 

[Ckcw23]

Sad that all here look down on his profession

Actually I feel that got more to him sia. My theory is that he got very rich parents, that’s why he got so much money to do what he wants, then the moment he 闯大祸, they come back to minimise this background as much as possible to prevent embarrassment to their family amongst their high society friends.

 

[Ckcw23]

Someone here already said he knows him
Not rich

Who arh, got comment? Maybe he gangster background, could afford so much stuff.

 

[Joseph12]

Who arh, got comment? Maybe he gangster background, could afford so much stuff.

Go & scroll back
He said the guy very violent
Even to his family

 

[kpokpokpo]

Can these people who said so elaborate, guy here getting away with so many things?

 

[Ckcw23]

Go & scroll back
He said the guy very violent
Even to his family

Which page?

 

[Joseph12]

Which page?

Go & Search

 

[Joseph12]

Actually I feel that got more to him sia. My theory is that he got very rich parents, that’s why he got so much money to do what he wants, then the moment he 闯大祸, they come back to minimise this background as much as possible to prevent embarrassment to their family amongst their high society friends.

Who cares
DPP is asking for 30 years which effectively means 20 years
By the time he's out he's mid 50s

And this isn't like Europe and US
There's no commissary account you can deposit and buy nice things for yourself in prison

 

[Kingnoking123]

If the events described in the case of Megan Khung occurred in the United States, the actions of Foo Li Ping and Wong Shi Xiang would likely constitute multiple serious crimes under U.S. law. The specific charges would depend on the jurisdiction (state laws vary), but based on the details provided—prolonged physical and emotional abuse, starvation, and a fatal punch leading to the death of a 4-year-old child—the following crimes could apply:
1. Murder or Manslaughter

• First-Degree Murder: If prosecutors could prove that Wong Shi Xiang intentionally killed Megan with premeditation (e.g., the fatal punch was deliberate and planned), he could face first-degree murder charges. In many states, this carries a potential penalty of life imprisonment without parole or even the death penalty (in states that allow it, though it’s rare for non-premeditated child abuse cases).
• Second-Degree Murder: If the punch was intentional but not premeditated, second-degree murder might apply. This typically involves intent to cause serious harm resulting in death, without prior planning. Penalties can include life imprisonment or decades in prison.
• Felony Murder: If the death occurred during the commission of another felony (e.g., child abuse or neglect), both Wong and Foo could be charged with felony murder, even if they didn’t intend to kill Megan. Penalties align with murder charges.
• Manslaughter: If the death was unintentional but resulted from reckless or grossly negligent behavior (e.g., the punch was not meant to kill but was part of ongoing abuse), voluntary or involuntary manslaughter charges could apply. Penalties typically range from 5 to 20 years, depending on the state.

2. Child Abuse / Aggravated Child Abuse

• The prolonged physical abuse (caning, slapping, punching) and emotional abuse (forcing Megan to wear a soiled diaper on her head, eat from the dustbin, sleep in a planter box) would fall under child abuse statutes. In many states, this escalates to aggravated child abuse due to the severity, duration, and resulting harm. Penalties can include 10-30 years in prison per count, especially if it leads to serious bodily injury or death.
• Both Foo and Wong could be charged, as Foo actively participated and failed to protect her daughter, making her liable under child neglect or endangerment laws as well.

3. Child Neglect / Endangerment

• Starving Megan, depriving her of clothing, and forcing her to sleep outside in a planter box regardless of weather conditions would likely be charged as child neglect or child endangerment. These are felonies in most states when the neglect is severe or results in harm, carrying penalties of 5-15 years per count.
• Foo, as the mother, could face additional charges for failing to provide basic care and protection, a legal duty parents owe their children.

4. Torture

• Some states, like California, have specific torture statutes that apply when a person inflicts great bodily injury with intent to cause cruel or extreme pain and suffering. The prolonged, humiliating abuse (e.g., forcing a soiled diaper over Megan’s head, starvation, beatings) could qualify. Torture charges can carry life sentences.

5. Conspiracy

• If evidence shows Foo and Wong coordinated their actions (e.g., Wong teaching Foo how to inflict pain without leaving marks), they could face conspiracy to commit child abuse or conspiracy to commit murder. Penalties depend on the underlying crime but could add 5-10 years to their sentences.

6. Destruction of Evidence / Obstruction of Justice

• Burning Megan’s body to conceal the crime would likely lead to charges of tampering with evidence or obstruction of justice. In some states, disposing of a corpse to prevent discovery of a crime is a separate felony (e.g., abuse of a corpse), carrying 2-10 years in prison.

Penalties in the U.S.

• Death Penalty: While rare, some states (e.g., Texas, Florida) allow the death penalty for heinous murders, especially involving children. However, proving premeditation would be key, and this case might not meet that threshold based on the described spontaneity of the fatal punch.
• Life Imprisonment: More likely, both could face life sentences (with or without parole) for murder or aggravated child abuse resulting in death.
• Multiple Charges: Prosecutors often file multiple counts (e.g., each instance of abuse as a separate charge), leading to consecutive sentences that could total decades or centuries.

Key Differences from Singapore

• In Singapore, Wong pleaded guilty to culpable homicide (not amounting to murder), which is akin to manslaughter in the U.S., and Foo faced lesser charges for her role. The U.S. might pursue harsher charges like murder, given the intent to harm and the outcome, though plea deals could reduce them.
• The U.S. lacks Singapore’s mandatory caning punishment but compensates with longer prison terms or capital punishment in extreme cases.

Conclusion
If this happened in America, Wong Shi Xiang could face second-degree murder or felony murder for the fatal punch, alongside aggravated child abuse and torture, potentially leading to life imprisonment. Foo Li Ping could be charged with felony murder, aggravated child abuse, and child neglect, also risking life or decades in prison. Both could face additional charges for burning the body. The exact outcome would hinge on evidence, intent, and state laws, but the severity of the abuse and death would likely result in severe punishment.
Disclaimer: Grok is not a lawyer; please consult one. Don't share information that can identify you

 

[Kingnoking123]

If the events described in the Megan Khung case—where a 4-year-old girl suffered over a year of severe physical and emotional abuse, culminating in her death from a fatal punch, followed by the burning of her body—happened in China, the legal consequences would depend on the specifics of Chinese criminal law and how the case is interpreted by authorities. Here’s an analysis based on China’s legal framework and practices as of March 9, 2025:
Applicable Crimes in China

1. Intentional Homicide (Criminal Law, Article 232)
   • Wong Shi Xiang’s fatal punch to Megan’s stomach, resulting in her death, could be classified as intentional homicide. If intent to kill is proven (e.g., deliberate targeting of a vital area), this carries the possibility of the death penalty, life imprisonment, or a fixed-term imprisonment of at least 10 years. Even if the punch wasn’t meant to kill but caused death through reckless violence, it could still fall under this statute, though intent would be a key factor in sentencing.
   • Foo Li Ping’s participation in the abuse and failure to intervene might make her an accomplice, potentially liable for the same charge, though her role would be assessed separately.
2. Maltreatment of Family Members (Criminal Law, Article 260)
   • The prolonged abuse—caning, slapping, starvation, forcing Megan to wear a soiled diaper on her head, and making her sleep in a planter box—could be charged as maltreatment of family members, applicable since Foo was Megan’s mother. If the maltreatment caused severe injury or death, penalties escalate to 2-7 years’ imprisonment, but this charge might be subsumed by homicide if death is the focus.
   • Wong, as a non-family member, might not face this specific charge unless courts interpret his relationship with Foo as creating a de facto family duty.
3. Abandonment (Criminal Law, Article 261)
   • Foo’s failure to seek medical care after Wong dislocated Megan’s jaw or after the fatal punch could be considered abandonment, given her legal duty as a parent. This carries up to 5 years’ imprisonment, though it’s less severe and might be secondary to homicide charges.
4. Destroying or Concealing a Corpse (Criminal Law, Article 302)
   • Burning Megan’s body and scattering her ashes to conceal the crime would likely be charged as intentional destruction of a corpse, punishable by up to 7 years’ imprisonment. Both Wong and Foo could face this, with evidence suggesting they acted together.
5. Child Abuse Under Emerging Laws
   • While China lacks a standalone "child abuse" statute, the Law on the Protection of Minors (2020) and Anti-Domestic Violence Law (2015) emphasize protecting children from violence. Courts could use these to aggravate sentencing, especially since the victim was a minor. The 2015 Criminal Law amendment also extended abuse provisions to caregivers, potentially implicating Wong.

Likely Penalties

• Wong Shi Xiang:
  • For the fatal punch, courts might pursue intentional homicide. If deemed particularly heinous (e.g., targeting a defenseless child, prolonged abuse beforehand), the death penalty is plausible, especially with public outrage, as China often uses capital punishment in high-profile cases involving children. Execution could involve lethal injection or shooting, typically within months of sentencing unless suspended (a 2-year reprieve leading to life imprisonment if no further crimes occur). Without death, life imprisonment or 15-25 years is likely, factoring in the abuse and corpse destruction.
  • Posts on X suggest China might impose death for such brutality, reflecting public sentiment, though this isn’t definitive legal evidence.
• Foo Li Ping:
  • As the mother, Foo’s active role in the abuse and failure to protect Megan could lead to homicide as an accomplice (10 years to life) or maltreatment causing death (2-7 years, potentially more with aggravating factors). Her involvement in burning the body adds up to 7 years. Courts might lean toward 10-20 years total, harsher if her maternal neglect is emphasized, though likely less severe than Wong’s sentence absent direct evidence she delivered the fatal blow.
• Aggravating Factors:
  • The victim’s young age, the duration of abuse (over a year), its cruelty (e.g., starvation, humiliation), and the cover-up would push for maximum penalties. Public backlash, as seen in past Chinese cases, could pressure courts to impose exemplary punishment.

Differences from Singapore and the U.S.

• Singapore: Wong pleaded guilty to culpable homicide (not murder), facing 20-30 years and caning; Foo faced lesser charges (15-20 years). China might classify this as intentional homicide, potentially escalating to death, without caning (not a Chinese punishment).
• U.S.: Murder or felony murder could yield life imprisonment or, rarely, death; China’s death penalty is more commonly applied in practice.

Cultural and Legal Context

• China’s Confucian tradition historically views family discipline as a private matter, but modern laws increasingly intervene, especially post-2015 reforms. The lack of systematic child abuse codification might limit lesser charges, but high-profile cases often trigger severe responses. The 2019 sex offender database and 2021 mandatory reporting system show growing child protection focus, though this case predates full implementation.

Conclusion
If this happened in China, Wong could face the death penalty or life imprisonment for intentional homicide, with additional time for corpse destruction. Foo might receive 10-20 years for her role in the homicide and abuse, plus corpse-related charges. Outcomes would hinge on intent, evidence, and public pressure, with China’s tendency toward harsh penalties in child death cases suggesting a strong likelihood of capital punishment for Wong.
Disclaimer: Grok is not a lawyer; please consult one. Don’t share identifying information.

 

[fire]

Who cares
DPP is asking for 30 years which effectively means 20 years
By the time he's out he's mid 50s

And this isn't like Europe and US
There's no commissary account you can deposit and buy nice things for yourself in prison

So lenient, for the atrocity he had done should be at least life imprisonment

 

[kpokpokpo]

Which page?

61 you’re welcome

 

[Racking2322]

Who cares
DPP is asking for 30 years which effectively means 20 years
By the time he's out he's mid 50s

And this isn't like Europe and US
There's no commissary account you can deposit and buy nice things for yourself in prison

Hopefully with lots of caning

 

[Ckcw23]

He was violent and abusive to his own family. They are afraid of him. That was before the drugs. I guess the drugs made it 100 times worse.

I had always believe he would k*ll someone but I didn't expect it to be a kid.

Damn, well how does that explain the money he gets. Either he got underground stuff or he owe people money, or he just a good businessman.