徐克《射雕》负评如潮 金庸迷叹：武侠已死

[Chocoz]

（综合讯）引颈长盼，万众期待的《射雕英雄传：侠之大者》（简称《射雕》）终于在大年初一星期三（1月29日）于中国上映。短短三天，据称票房已累计达4.62亿人民币（约8653万新元），不过网络上却负评不断，网友批评“像是赛亚人打架”，不是武侠片，更有金庸迷看了电影后，感叹“武侠已死！”

由徐克执导，找来顶流艺人肖战和庄达菲主演，梁家辉、梁家仁与胡军特别演出。从开拍以来，《射雕》都备受瞩目，直到去年年底，片商释出预告片，肖战与庄达菲扮演的郭靖及黄蓉在片中首次曝光，再加上千军万马的打仗场面，十分吸睛，让《射雕》成为今年蛇年贺岁片中最值得期待的一部电影。

据悉，《射雕》的内容是改编自金庸原著第34回至第40回，是过去影视剧较少详细拍摄的部分，亦即桃花岛上巨变江南七怪身死，郭靖和黄蓉产生隔阂暂时分离，后来终于和好并抵抗蒙古入侵的过程。

观众反应两极 网批打斗戏靠特效“像看赛亚人打架”

可是，影片在大年初一于中国上映后，尽管票房频传捷报，但网络的反应却出现两极化。有网友大赞画面磅礡精彩，称赞肖战是史上最帅郭靖，不过在大陆影音平台bilibili（哔哩哔哩）却出现许多影音创作者拍摄影片痛骂是烂片，怒斥“武侠已死”，认为明明是武侠片，但是打斗戏却几乎都是依靠特效，很少肢体接触，只是肖战在镜头前摆摆姿势，像看“赛亚人打架”。

也有中国网友指出一开始看到《射雕》预告片时，磅礡画面让大家对打斗、战争剧情相当期待，不过实际上电影只有一开始蒙古打金国短短一段。之后整整两个半小时的片长，几乎有两小时都是郭靖在找黄蓉，还上演三角恋，着重感情戏，而且黄蓉和华筝还为了三角恋的问题大打出手，把原本的武侠小说改编成“垃圾古装偶像剧”。

被指票房造假

除此之外，《射雕》疑似还存在票房造假的问题，有部落客透露他买票时显示那一场差不多都坐满了，应该有两三千人左右，但实际入座后发现大约只有30名观众，其余部落客也遇到场内没多少人的状况，中国网友对此笑称可能要看深夜场才能体会到满座的盛况，因为那时都被“鬼”坐满了。

https://www.zaobao.com.sg/entertainment/story20250201-5815072

Audience reactions:
https://weibo.com/tv/show/1034:5130468669194268


At least these remakes are consistent in their quality:

 

[xcodes]

this is still the best version ...

 

[soulblader_89]

https://www.zaobao.com.sg/entertainment/story20250201-5815072

Audience reactions:
https://weibo.com/tv/show/1034:5130468669194268


At least these remakes are consistent in their quality:

wash money one la....confirm

 

[focus1974]

徐克 is same as 王晶 .. in terms of quality of movies..
they produced crappy movies but year after year.. still got investors willing to invest in the movies

 

[Atilas]

Nowadays, the actors and actresses can only shoot laser and use special effects. No more blow-to-blow fighting.

武侠剧 will also become 仙侠剧.

 

[Travis_Touchdown]

dunno huai his works getting from bad to worse... his earlier works ish better...

 

[whatheheck]

Nowadays, the actors and actresses can only shoot laser and use special effects. No more blow-to-blow fighting.
武侠剧 will also become 仙侠剧.

sian. next time become AI 大炮仙传

 

[FireEmblem]

Yah now the new actors only need to looks like 小鲜肉, cannot do any physical fights but only cgi

 

[Lifetime warranty]

I don't watch all this any more.. finding that really can't fight the old one

 

[nonameless]

The last live 武侠 is done by Japanese - samurai X

 

[cet87]

 

[Vincentlow82]

I thought I was watching demon slayer.

Fire breathing technique.

 

[lightningflash]

Review so bad? Was planning to watch

 

[NuaMan]

How to translate this post title from Chinese to English ?

徐克《射雕》负评如潮 金庸迷叹：武侠已死​

Is it :
Tsui Hark <<Shoot kukubird>> with so much negative reactions until die ?

 

[Chocoz]

Review so bad? Was planning to watch

5-star reviews many many
https://www.gv.com.sg/GVMovieDetails?movie=4232#/movie/4232/cinema/114

How to translate this post title from Chinese to English ?

徐克《射雕》负评如潮 金庸迷叹：武侠已死​

Is it :
Tsui Hark <<Shoot kukubird>> with so much negative reactions until die ?

Floods of Negative Reviews for Tsui Hark's Legends Of The Condor Heroes, Jin Yong Fans Lament: Wuxia is Dead

 

[radish]

to be fair i havnt watched it but i seen enough reviews to know its not really worth my money to buy a cinema ticket which is not cheap today.

徐克 do know how to make gd movies, 英雄本色、蜀山、倩女幽魂、黄飞鸿、刀, 狄仁杰、笑傲江湖、龙门飞甲、七剑 are all really gd movies

英雄本色 is modern wuxia, 刀、 龙门飞甲、 七剑 、笑傲江湖 are pure wuxia. so it will be wrong to say he dont know how to make wu xia just bec these youngsters havt watched these older movies.

as much i gathered in this new movie he failed to connect with audience when he attempted to use fresh meat as lead, over focus on romance, basically wokish idea that clouded the theme?

 

[Cowbellc]

https://www.zaobao.com.sg/entertainment/story20250201-5815072

Audience reactions:
https://weibo.com/tv/show/1034:5130468669194268


At least these remakes are consistent in their quality:

Seriously ever since wuxia movie bcum like sci fi kungfu, fly here n there, explode better than nuke, it had failed to doom

 

[Sango123]

Now really too much focus on CGI.... no more proper fist fight by those old school HK 武术指导

 

[Goodshot]

Review so bad? Was planning to watch

Super bad , duoban only 5.3 , even cheap B rate movie got more score

 

[PikaPika33]

recent wuxia dramas i see very boring

they focus more on the romantic, interaction and faces

the fighting and wuxia itswlf is very condenses

no feeling