AIO Water Cooling, yes or no?

zystttt

Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2010
Messages
346
Reaction score
0
Current Specs:

CPU: I5 3570k OC'd 4.2 GHz @ Offset Mode -0.05, Vcore 1.228 avg.
Cooler: Deepcool Gamma XX 400 with 2 Corsair SP120 High Perf. (2300RPMmax) Push pull.

Idle Temps: ~45.
Load Temp: ~70.

Intend to overclock further to 4.5 for the heck of it.

Should I go water cooling or is my Deepcool enough?

Looking at Swiftech H220X, H100i GTX.

Any suggestions will be appreciated!
 

jedi5diah

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2009
Messages
6,480
Reaction score
0
confirm must aio/better fan cooler for normal oc...then custom water cooling for hardcore oc lol...
 

kevince

Junior Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2001
Messages
90
Reaction score
0
whats a nice aio cooler available in sls? initially thinking of corsair h100i but heard from reviews that it is pretty noisy...
 

escksu

Banned
Joined
Nov 24, 2011
Messages
8,391
Reaction score
3
Rectify what

The temps acceptable what imo. Alot better than hasweel.

If ts want push some more and encounter thermal issues, should get better cooler

Sent from microwave oven using GAGT

3570K is ivy bridge, using sh!tty TIM....TS wants good temp need to delid.

Temp is good because TS is only running at 4.2GHz 1.22V. Once TS goes to 4.6GHz and ~1.3V, the temp will shoot over 80C already.
 

enenyi

Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2011
Messages
5,927
Reaction score
5
Current Specs:

CPU: I5 3570k OC'd 4.2 GHz @ Offset Mode -0.05, Vcore 1.228 avg.
Cooler: Deepcool Gamma XX 400 with 2 Corsair SP120 High Perf. (2300RPMmax) Push pull.

Idle Temps: ~45.
Load Temp: ~70.

Intend to overclock further to 4.5 for the heck of it.

Should I go water cooling or is my Deepcool enough?

Looking at Swiftech H220X, H100i GTX.

Any suggestions will be appreciated!
Big question: wad r u overclocking for?

If for fun, ur current air cooling can already make 4.5GHz. I did 4.6GHz on my i5-3570k before using Xigmatek Gaia. Benchmark achieved, nothing much to talk about.

If to sustain OC speeds for productivity (e.g. video editing or rendering), then the Deepcool Gammax can't sustain the OC for long before the chip overheats. In that case, getting a simple cooling like Corsair H60 will do. I'm using Corsair H100i GTX to run on 4.6GHz stable, but the money spent on an AIO cooling is not enough to justify increasing clock speed by 100MHz from 4.5 to 4.6GHz.

If for performance, forget it. i5-3570k can only bring u so much performance increase, even if u magically bring it up to 5.0GHz stable. Just get a Haswell-E chip. :s13:
 

zystttt

Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2010
Messages
346
Reaction score
0
Where to buy?

If ur casing can fit 120mmx3
get fractal s36.


Currently overclocking for the hell of it, however intending to venture into film making in the near future so for rendering purposes as well. With your Xigmatek at 4.6 how much was your temps at load? I'm currently on ~70 at prime95 blend with only 4.2. Pretty worrying imo, thus intend to get a better cooling.

Will a H60 suffice? I've seen people on the net like Tomshardware stating that a Hyper 212 Evo is better than a H60, which is why I'm actually looking at better loops, particularly the H220X since it is a semi and is available to upgrade to custom loop.

Can I know whats your voltage on running 4.6GHz? I am aware of the 'silicon lottery' but its always better to have someone to compare to, especially in our slightly higher ambient.

Thanks!

Big question: wad r u overclocking for?

If for fun, ur current air cooling can already make 4.5GHz. I did 4.6GHz on my i5-3570k before using Xigmatek Gaia. Benchmark achieved, nothing much to talk about.

If to sustain OC speeds for productivity (e.g. video editing or rendering), then the Deepcool Gammax can't sustain the OC for long before the chip overheats. In that case, getting a simple cooling like Corsair H60 will do. I'm using Corsair H100i GTX to run on 4.6GHz stable, but the money spent on an AIO cooling is not enough to justify increasing clock speed by 100MHz from 4.5 to 4.6GHz.

If for performance, forget it. i5-3570k can only bring u so much performance increase, even if u magically bring it up to 5.0GHz stable. Just get a Haswell-E chip. :s13:
 

enenyi

Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2011
Messages
5,927
Reaction score
5
Where to buy?




Currently overclocking for the hell of it, however intending to venture into film making in the near future so for rendering purposes as well. With your Xigmatek at 4.6 how much was your temps at load? I'm currently on ~70 at prime95 blend with only 4.2. Pretty worrying imo, thus intend to get a better cooling.

Will a H60 suffice? I've seen people on the net like Tomshardware stating that a Hyper 212 Evo is better than a H60, which is why I'm actually looking at better loops, particularly the H220X since it is a semi and is available to upgrade to custom loop.

Can I know whats your voltage on running 4.6GHz? I am aware of the 'silicon lottery' but its always better to have someone to compare to, especially in our slightly higher ambient.

Thanks!
A closed loop cooler will always win over air cooling, no matter if it is a noctua or just a simple deepcool product. No fight. Air cooling is dependent on ur ambient air temps within the casing itself, liquid cooling can perform well even if ur internal casing temps are like 50 degrees.

I'm on 4.5GHz stable now. At 4.6GHz CPU-Z reported 1.276V, although BIOS was reading about 1.32V.

And since u going into film making stuff and rendering, torturing the i5-3570k with hours and hours of heavy load will cause it to break down and cry earlier than u expect. Instead, spend some money get an X99 board and i7-5820k or i7-5960X (depending on whether u wan 6 cores or 8 cores). Soldered TIM on Haswell-E chips win the TIM paste on the i5-3570k chip hands-down. And rendering scales well with 6 cores instead of 4. I'm also currently at the stage where I find my i5-3570k failing me in render timings, and I know that running the chip at 4.6/4.7GHz doing rendering for hours is gonna hurt the chip even more.
 

SEvsNK

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2004
Messages
22,594
Reaction score
514
spend $100 for a new cooler to overclock a few hundred mhz for fun and u won't even see any performance increase. Use the money and treat your family to a nice dinner

If you really really want to see an upgrade or something new, save the money and get an X99 system
 

epos

Master Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2000
Messages
2,973
Reaction score
3
HTd3K3Hr.jpg

2 hours 1080i to 720p x264 transcoding. noise is the same as my previous TRUE with Scythe 120mm which did 80C.
 

Krabs.

Honorary Member
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
141,094
Reaction score
9,598
not worth the risk of leak if u only want to squeeze 2-300mhz further
 

soufigo

Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2008
Messages
425
Reaction score
0
I dont know much about ivy bridge, but temps looks ok to me. Dont worry too much. Real world applications you wont get as high temps as you get during stresstesting.
 

longsiew

Supremacy Member
Joined
May 5, 2005
Messages
7,500
Reaction score
0
AIO not necessary better than air cooler.

Some high end air cooler perform better than AIO.
 

enenyi

Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2011
Messages
5,927
Reaction score
5
AIO not necessary better than air cooler.

Some high end air cooler perform better than AIO.
On the condition that the casing is well ventilated by casing fans. Coz liquid cooling has the advantage of drawing air outside (or close to outside) of case. Air cooling depends on ambient temps within the casing. SO In the case where u run like 3 or 4 pieces of high-end GPU at full load, the heat generated by these GPUs will end up being sucked into the CPU air cooler. If intake of air for CPU air cooling is already 40-50 degrees, the exhaust of air from the air cooler will be much higher, hence CPU cannot be effectively cooled.

This is the logic behind liquid cooling vs air cooling. Of course there are variables in the equation, and expensive air coolers like the Noctuas can win cheap liquid cooling solutions like Corsair H60. But still, these air coolers are limited by the temps of the intake of air to their fins.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top