Air ticket SQ or jal

junny1

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2007
Messages
532
Reaction score
0
Hi guys,

Want to book flight to kansai area, osaka airport. Understand that most of you, if taking full fledge flight, will prefer jal than SQ because of the cheaper air ticket price. But now i view the jal schedules i realise that every flight has connection flight meaning singapore will fly to tokyo Then from tokyo to osaka. This will take few hours longer. But SQ is direct flight to osaka. Hmm i wonder why jal dont have direct flight? What will you guys those now though jal is cheaper. Cheaper or go for connection flight in tokyo?
 

junny1

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2007
Messages
532
Reaction score
0
Although jal is cheaper compared to SQ, jal do not have direct flight to KIX- osaka? Pls help
 

Rolleing Stone

Junior Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2016
Messages
30
Reaction score
0
That really depends on how much you judge your time is worth, and how many hours you are saving in total.

I would rather pay a bit more to save time, although if the difference is huge, like ~$500, then I'll reconsider.

As for why JAL does this, I remember someone saying that ANA and JAL's hub is in Tokyo, so international flights will just go there before transiting to other cities, which are domestic flights.
 

Zeltos

Master Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2001
Messages
3,219
Reaction score
219
SQ allow 30KG checkin whereas JAL is 20KG. SG direct flight and JAL need transfer. U choice?
 

thwysg

Master Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2010
Messages
3,645
Reaction score
810
SQ allow 30KG checkin whereas JAL is 20KG. SG direct flight and JAL need transfer. U choice?

Are you sure it's still 20kg?

It's already 2x23kg for checked-in luggage for JAL.

https://www.jal.co.jp/en/inter/baggage/checked/
 

James Tang

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
9,694
Reaction score
335
Both ANA and JAL don't have direct KIX flight, even though KIX is ANA's home base.

I believe this is more for cost analysis by the airline.Perhaps this is one of the reasons why these 2 airlines are cheaper.

We actually wanted to book SG-KIX on ANA for their business class. And found out that we have to waste another few hours for transit in Tokyo, causing us to lose half a day (and the flight timing is not as desirable as well)

So we booked SQ Business class instead for direct flight. Now we are arriving early in the morning at KIX and will have a full day to walk around, as compared to ANA in the afternoon.
 

junny1

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2007
Messages
532
Reaction score
0
Both ANA and JAL don't have direct KIX flight, even though KIX is ANA's home base.

I believe this is more for cost analysis by the airline.Perhaps this is one of the reasons why these 2 airlines are cheaper.

We actually wanted to book SG-KIX on ANA for their business class. And found out that we have to waste another few hours for transit in Tokyo, causing us to lose half a day (and the flight timing is not as desirable as well)

So we booked SQ Business class instead for direct flight. Now we are arriving early in the morning at KIX and will have a full day to walk around, as compared to ANA in the afternoon.

I did a simple comparison between SQ-KIX and JAL-tokyo-KIX for my schedule.

The price difference is about ~$340. Timing wise maybe JAL has more options? I would still prefer direct with SQ though.
 

qhong61

Banned
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
72,439
Reaction score
12,048
Hi guys,

Want to book flight to kansai area, osaka airport. Understand that most of you, if taking full fledge flight, will prefer jal than SQ because of the cheaper air ticket price. But now i view the jal schedules i realise that every flight has connection flight meaning singapore will fly to tokyo Then from tokyo to osaka. This will take few hours longer. But SQ is direct flight to osaka. Hmm i wonder why jal dont have direct flight? What will you guys those now though jal is cheaper. Cheaper or go for connection flight in tokyo?
Time is money when on holiday.
 

junny1

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2007
Messages
532
Reaction score
0
Looking at this option, not sure if this ok

SQ flight direct to KIX
Departure to KIX: 1.30am to 8.45am
 

James Tang

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
9,694
Reaction score
335
Looking at this option, not sure if this ok

SQ flight direct to KIX
Departure to KIX: 1.30am to 8.45am

Yeap this is the timing I chose.... red eye but if you could sleep in flight, you get a full day!
 

James Tang

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
9,694
Reaction score
335
What about your flight back to sg? What time did you book?

1100 from KIX-SG. Working next day so want to have some time to rest. Also will be going to airport early to walk around and use the ANA lounge haha
 

junny1

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2007
Messages
532
Reaction score
0
1100 from KIX-SG. Working next day so want to have some time to rest. Also will be going to airport early to walk around and use the ANA lounge haha

i am looking at this timing also to return from KIX to SG with singapore airline. but that means the last day need to factor out because early morning have to go airport already. hmm
 

James Tang

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
9,694
Reaction score
335
i am looking at this timing also to return from KIX to SG with singapore airline. but that means the last day need to factor out because early morning have to go airport already. hmm

Well, your other choice is close to Midmight @ 2350, touch down around 5.30am at Changi.

To me the choice is obvious unless you want to take another day off haha
 

junny1

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2007
Messages
532
Reaction score
0
Well, your other choice is close to Midmight @ 2350, touch down around 5.30am at Changi.

To me the choice is obvious unless you want to take another day off haha

seems like no favourable timing. arrive at 8.45am also can't check in until 2pm and check out 12pm also if leave late then luggage is another problem.
 

thwysg

Master Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2010
Messages
3,645
Reaction score
810
seems like no favourable timing. arrive at 8.45am also can't check in until 2pm and check out 12pm also if leave late then luggage is another problem.

Just drop your luggage at the hotel concierge and let them know that you'll be back later in the day or evening to check in.
 

chemcutie

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
753
Reaction score
4
I took JAL on my last trip to Sapporo. (Since sg to cts no direct flights during my period of travel) while it's cheap, I din really like it for the following reasons (not sure if it's the same for the kix route)

1)midnight flight to Tokyo haneda , only breakfast was served. In the case we got Tokyo soup stock for breakfast (my parents typical uncles and aunties din like the soup)

2) though I transit at haneda, we landed at the international terminal, while the flight to Sapporo was at domestic terminal. Due to this difference during our to leg of the trip, we hand to take our baggage lug it to the check in counter outside (public area of international terminal) before taking a bus to the domestic terminal. If u have only 1.5hrs transit and gg with elderly parents or young kids this may be a prob
3) domestic flight to Sapporo is really like budget air. It's rather squeezy... ours was a refurbished 777... no space to walk...

My Nov trip to Osaka I taking direct to KIX.. as I believe will save the hassle. Though cos of cost issue, I am flying to Nagoya... in any case cos my frens have not taken Shinkansen before, it's wasn't really an issue for us... and the additional $50 vs $300 for a better timing SQ flight, we felt this is better.

In a separate note, if u wanna rest on a train or dun wish to reach Osaka before noon, there is the kintetsu pass that can be bought and use to go to Osaka namba and 5days worth of trips on kintetsu within the network http://www.kintetsu.co.jp/foreign/english/ticket/krp_plus.html
 
Last edited:

ash like snow

Master Member
Joined
Jul 9, 2014
Messages
4,247
Reaction score
19
if wanna fly into 1 way HND/KIX, better not to take JAL/SQ right? since the price would be as expensive as return trip?
 

junny1

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2007
Messages
532
Reaction score
0
I took JAL on my last trip to Sapporo. (Since sg to cts no direct flights during my period of travel) while it's cheap, I din really like it for the following reasons (not sure if it's the same for the kix route)

1)midnight flight to Tokyo haneda , only breakfast was served. In the case we got Tokyo soup stock for breakfast (my parents typical uncles and aunties din like the soup)

2) though I transit at haneda, we landed at the international terminal, while the flight to Sapporo was at domestic terminal. Due to this difference during our to leg of the trip, we hand to take our baggage lug it to the check in counter outside (public area of international terminal) before taking a bus to the domestic terminal. If u have only 1.5hrs transit and gg with elderly parents or young kids this may be a prob
3) domestic flight to Sapporo is really like budget air. It's rather squeezy... ours was a refurbished 777... no space to walk...

My Nov trip to Osaka I taking direct to KIX.. as I believe will save the hassle. Though cos of cost issue, I am flying to Nagoya... in any case cos my frens have not taken Shinkansen before, it's wasn't really an issue for us... and the additional $50 vs $300 for a better timing SQ flight, we felt this is better.

In a separate note, if u wanna rest on a train or dun wish to reach Osaka before noon, there is the kintetsu pass that can be bought and use to go to Osaka namba and 5days worth of trips on kintetsu within the network http://www.kintetsu.co.jp/foreign/english/ticket/krp_plus.html

i think in the jal booking page you can see which airport is it you will land. most are international airports.

Are you taking SQ to osaka in your nov trip? i dont know because i am looking at direct flight also for SQ to KIX. but is there any better timing to explore? I do not see any flight to nagoya though, can you help?
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top