Anyone looking at Landed?

holasingapura

Master Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2019
Messages
3,263
Reaction score
464
Landed largely valued by land size, quite different from strata landed.

imo, strata landed is much more similar to condo, think of it as a 3/4 story penthouse.
 

Pynchmail

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2007
Messages
335
Reaction score
42
Strata landed is still a relatively new housing form in Singapore. If you look at places such as New York, London and Hong Kong, their strata landed equivalent, known more commonly there as Townhouses or Townhomes are as expensive as condo on a PSF basis, and are seen as highly desirable. Many of them have off street parking. Here, we still value cluster a lot lower on a PSF basis compared to condo. Of course, compared to pure landed, having your own land is still the best. The price differences remain quite big though.
 

drkcynic

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
57,429
Reaction score
26,943
Strata landed is still a relatively new housing form in Singapore. If you look at places such as New York, London and Hong Kong, their strata landed equivalent, known more commonly there as Townhouses or Townhomes are as expensive as condo on a PSF basis, and are seen as highly desirable. Many of them have off street parking. Here, we still value cluster a lot lower on a PSF basis compared to condo. Of course, compared to pure landed, having your own land is still the best. The price differences remain quite big though.

The most coveted form of FH housing in Singaporean's eyes is still pure FH landed regardless. A strata is merely a poorer cousin. You can't fight that perception. You mentioned it is widely accepted overseas but ultimately these landed can only be sold to Singaporeans, and relatively rich Singaporeans at that. Will they pay premium dollar for your strata? My bet is no.

Also while strata landed is relatively new in SG as you said, it is not priced low. Most strata landed I have seen are around the 2-2.5m mark. At this price range I can get a pure FH landed. The choice is obvious to me.

I personally will get a FH condo before I get a FH strata landed. Reasons are that there are many more favourably located FH condos than FH strata landed, and I can sell FH condos to foreigners as opposed to FH Strata landed.
 

mikeeeey

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2002
Messages
16,055
Reaction score
854
I am viewing D19 now, Kovan area. More options within my price range (below 3). Serangoon area is 3.5 and above so I think Kovan will catch up eventually (with Serangoon moving up even more).
I always thought kovan is more expensive as compared to sgn gdns as most kovan landed are FH whereas sgn gdns are 999 majority, with some FH and some 99
 

theMKR

Banned
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Messages
70,857
Reaction score
13,515
Strata landed is still a relatively new housing form in Singapore. If you look at places such as New York, London and Hong Kong, their strata landed equivalent, known more commonly there as Townhouses or Townhomes are as expensive as condo on a PSF basis, and are seen as highly desirable. Many of them have off street parking. Here, we still value cluster a lot lower on a PSF basis compared to condo. Of course, compared to pure landed, having your own land is still the best. The price differences remain quite big though.

strata landed cannot anyhow modify. Some ppl like, some ppl dun like...

best is still rebuilt to something u like...
 

Clazav

Master Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2014
Messages
2,584
Reaction score
485
My reason is proportion and mindset. Landed majority are freehold/999. So when majority of landed are fh/999, once u got a 99 landed, u are in the worse category. Take for example, 60 years lease to 99 years. Everyone shy away from getting a 60 years leasehold.

why are u ok with leasehold condo?
 

Clazav

Master Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2014
Messages
2,584
Reaction score
485
True, the true landed is ultimately the better one. But to have a budget of 2-3mil, you can't have a good range of landed choice, but with this budget, u can select a wide range of strata landed. The same reason why ppl buy condo and not landed. So the issue is, whether u have the money, and whether u are lucky to find a good deal.

The most coveted form of FH housing in Singaporean's eyes is still pure FH landed regardless. A strata is merely a poorer cousin. You can't fight that perception. You mentioned it is widely accepted overseas but ultimately these landed can only be sold to Singaporeans, and relatively rich Singaporeans at that. Will they pay premium dollar for your strata? My bet is no.

Also while strata landed is relatively new in SG as you said, it is not priced low. Most strata landed I have seen are around the 2-2.5m mark. At this price range I can get a pure FH landed. The choice is obvious to me.

I personally will get a FH condo before I get a FH strata landed. Reasons are that there are many more favourably located FH condos than FH strata landed, and I can sell FH condos to foreigners as opposed to FH Strata landed.
 

Clazav

Master Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2014
Messages
2,584
Reaction score
485
I'm lazy to modify. And I don't have the artistic sense. And more importantly, I have no money 😂

strata landed cannot anyhow modify. Some ppl like, some ppl dun like...

best is still rebuilt to something u like...
 

drkcynic

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
57,429
Reaction score
26,943
True, the true landed is ultimately the better one. But to have a budget of 2-3mil, you can't have a good range of landed choice, but with this budget, u can select a wide range of strata landed. The same reason why ppl buy condo and not landed. So the issue is, whether u have the money, and whether u are lucky to find a good deal.

I agree after viewing a few pure landed. It is always something not good, some shortfall here and there which keeps it at the 2-3m mark, especially those on 2000sft and above land. It is turning out to be quite challenging to find a good unit.

Meanwhile stratas at 2-2.5m are all nicely renovated, though i beg to differ on the locations, most of them are not great (not near mrt/amenities and such). 1 question I have for strata though, is that many have said for strata just pay the maintenance but is it really that simple? I mean for the water seepages issues, interior issues, pest controls etc, i would reckon owner still need to be out of pocket? That will be no different from a pure FH? The maintenance only covers the facade and the facilities isn't it? And it could be quite costly when those stuff ages and you are forced to pay to maintain them. While for pure landed you can keep the facade basic if you wish and you won't incur high monthly outlays.
 
Last edited:

Pynchmail

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2007
Messages
335
Reaction score
42
1 question I have for strata though, is that many have said for strata just pay the maintenance but is it really that simple? I mean for the water seepages issues, interior issues, pest controls etc, i would reckon owner still need to be out of pocket? That will be no different from a pure FH? The maintenance only covers the facade and the facilities isn't it? And it could be quite costly when those stuff ages and you are forced to pay to maintain them. While for pure landed you can keep the facade basic if you wish and you won't incur high monthly outlays.


I think you are right. For things like water seepages, interior issues and pest controls for your own unit etc, you will still be out of pocket. In a condo, you also need to pay these out of pocket. I think maintaining a strata landed is not much different from maintaining a condo, but without lift, security guard, gym, huge common areas, maybe can be cheaper too.
 

theMKR

Banned
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Messages
70,857
Reaction score
13,515
strata landed is limited by GFA rite?

landed is limited by envelop control...

so cannot anyhow extend ur house....
 

Pynchmail

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2007
Messages
335
Reaction score
42
strata landed is limited by GFA rite?

landed is limited by envelop control...

so cannot anyhow extend ur house....

Strata landed is limited by envelop control too, example site coverage and height control. So you are right, cannot anyhow extend your house.
 

Clazav

Master Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2014
Messages
2,584
Reaction score
485
Well in some way, if it is controlled, then got to trust the gov that they wouldn't anyhow increase supply which might lower the uniqueness of strata landed.


Strata landed is limited by envelop control too, example site coverage and height control. So you are right, cannot anyhow extend your house.
 

theMKR

Banned
Joined
Nov 3, 2016
Messages
70,857
Reaction score
13,515
Strata landed is limited by envelop control too, example site coverage and height control. So you are right, cannot anyhow extend your house.

as in envelope control + GFA right?

so cannot anyhow build mezzanine to increase floor space?
 

mikeeeey

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2002
Messages
16,055
Reaction score
854
True, the true landed is ultimately the better one. But to have a budget of 2-3mil, you can't have a good range of landed choice, but with this budget, u can select a wide range of strata landed. The same reason why ppl buy condo and not landed. So the issue is, whether u have the money, and whether u are lucky to find a good deal.
few weeks back, the ex-dj Daniel Ong was selling a terrace in sgn gdns for 2.88mil

pretty good price. it was not a rebuilt i think but all newly furnished inside. sold within a week if im not wrong
 

Pynchmail

Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2007
Messages
335
Reaction score
42
as in envelope control + GFA right?

so cannot anyhow build mezzanine to increase floor space?

I think strata house built on landed zone will be limited by envelope control, and strata house built on condo site will be limited by GFA.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top