Ask a Bicycle Question - Part 5

Status
Not open for further replies.

IronMac

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2012
Messages
9,006
Reaction score
11
IGB is pretty reliable... Literally tuning and maintenance free compared to derailleur system.

Relatively speaking. The maintenance is much less with an IGH.

In IGB, you cann change the gear without peddling. So if lets say you were using a very high gear and then u did an emergency stop. So at stationary, you can change the gear without peddling and start off with a small gear.

For those on derailleur, the cyclist will have to stand on his pedals and move off as he cannot change gear while stationary.

Agree but this is more important for commuters I think.

But on long distances, derailleur is much efficient than IGB due to lesser weight involved and larger gear ratios.

I don't agree with this. Maybe this is true with the Shimano IGH but not with the Rohloff Speedhub where it is more efficient than derailleur systems. Rohloffs are pretty much the gold standard when it comes to touring bikes.
 

MIVEC525

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2003
Messages
27,952
Reaction score
4,769
depends...i like bell for its simplicity but kindda useless on road.

using orp with their extension cable for combining bell with light sake
so far so good but has its drawback as well. Some pedestrian seem to be too accustom to traditional bell tone that when i use the friendly tone they look skyward :s13:

Silicone constructions means that there is light leakage from rider POV which may cause disruption to night vision. I tilt down more rather than shine directly ahead as it may blind motorist or fellow cyclist and cut an inner tube to wrap around the front of the light to protect my night vision.

More of a light for creating presence than lighting the pathway ahead at night. Keeping my torch strap still

Keeping my old school cateye bell still in case i no time charge orp :o

Where to buy the extention cable? Thks!
 

Xiuzhi

Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2001
Messages
484
Reaction score
0
Relatively speaking. The maintenance is much less with an IGH.



Agree but this is more important for commuters I think.



I don't agree with this. Maybe this is true with the Shimano IGH but not with the Rohloff Speedhub where it is more efficient than derailleur systems. Rohloffs are pretty much the gold standard when it comes to touring bikes.

Thanks guys for all the info....so I can have more confidence buying this bike knowing it can last me a long time without maintenance....
It's quite a pricey bike to start with though....
Any other recommendations on a Matt black hybrid that look similar like the focus planet? Can be using a derailleur system too
 

tremor

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2001
Messages
37,616
Reaction score
1,284
No leh.

It's the same. Both 622mm.
700c == 29inch

Yea u r right the wheels are 622mm. But the tyres height or depth is different between off road tyres and road tyres. That's why the overall height of road bikes are 28" and 29er is 29".
 

likehotbutter

Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2010
Messages
5,798
Reaction score
823
Let me know what helmet u eventually bought.

I am looking for one that got visor, and hopefully with a shade sticking out as well. Dunno have or not

Most mtb helmets have visors if you arnt into that Aero fever

Even with heavy grip and resistance from the mtb tyres on normal roads and smaller crankset, still can go faster than foldie with thinner road tyres and larger crankset?

Lmao when u said track tires I thought you meant baldies ala velodrome track. Normally we call them trail tires.

Other than what other posters have mentioned, you have to see the type of trail tyre and mtb type also. XC frames can be lighter than a foldie. XC cranks also comes with relatively high gearing. Drypack trail tires are almost bald and offer similar low resistance.


Yea u r right the wheels are 622mm. But the tyres height or depth is different between off road tyres and road tyres. That's why the overall height of road bikes are 28" and 29er is 29".

I think its still more reliable to base off an arbitrary rim diameter as a standard vs mounted tire diameters when comparing? Since trail tires also come in a number of varieties? You'd never know and that's why the industry uses it as a common denominator.

Eg I've mounted 700x35 cyclocross tires on my HT 29er for XC rides at the green corridor with 29x3 knobbies on the full sus for more gnarly stuff. Both 622mm rims but very different profiles.
 

Geylang Prawn Seller

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
12,342
Reaction score
2,579
actually dura ace stuff is really really good, their chain doesnt rust.

their crank is amazing stuff, i cant wait to use the 9000 (or the new one) soon, but most likely not since im transting to the bb386 crank

just go and try helmet, no point buying one that it doesnt fit well.

I like giro, ogk (best)


i suspect the chainline no good thats why break under load

maybe the linking pin wasn't put in properly. there are strict rules as to put it on the leading half of the link etc

bro when you want my 10 speed chain?
 

erwinrommel

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2007
Messages
27,904
Reaction score
3,157
I don't agree with this. Maybe this is true with the Shimano IGH but not with the Rohloff Speedhub where it is more efficient than derailleur systems. Rohloffs are pretty much the gold standard when it comes to touring bikes.

Touring maybe yes. I agree with you that speed and weight isn't important in this case. Reliability and simplicity will be the key factors.

But one has to consider the cons of full IGB before delving into it. There are only 14 gears and it has to cover all terrain with it. And he cannot change gear when pedaling. He has to coast before he can change gear. :s22: Not to mention one has to use a spanner to remove the wheel in the event of puncture or rim cleaning.

I have used IGB for about 2.5 years before removing it in favor of external derailleur system with FD and RD. My speed increased by at least 6-8 kmh easily with a 1.5kg weight reduction. Rohloff speedhubs are about 1.8kg excluding the weight of the wheel... will be pretty tiring on it for long distance.
 

Phyber

Master Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2004
Messages
4,185
Reaction score
0
Felt so happy~ Ytd rode the longest i ever rode so far.
From Khatib to Punggol (via Yishun Dam, and Punggol Barat/Timor route)
and back, total 24.77km :D

Too bad it was getting dark, but I felt I could push all the way to Pasir Ris :D
(Need to slowly train up to that tho, will be a nice goal to have. :) )

Really damn fun!! Now i understand why pple enjoy long distance cycling!
 

beast

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
1,351
Reaction score
2
Long distance cycling is fun but how do those solo cyclist manage when is time to go toilet. The bicycle locks available are too vulnerable to prevent theft. They could not possibly carry their mtb or road bike into the toilet rite?

do they endure it for hours till they complete the route?
 

Phyber

Master Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2004
Messages
4,185
Reaction score
0
Long distance cycling is fun but how do those solo cyclist manage when is time to go toilet. The bicycle locks available are too vulnerable to prevent theft. They could not possibly carry their mtb or road bike into the toilet rite?

do they endure it for hours till they complete the route?

Mmm...i guess the amount they sweat is alot. I never felt the need to go toilet until i reached punggol to relieve myself. Just lock the bike outside awhile and go for a quick piss lor, can't be u piss for an hour rite? :D

That said, the Punggol Barat/Timor area is recommended to have a buddy cyclist. Its quite foresty and night time can be quite dark. (I don't ride on roads, not very confident, plus those were some heavy vehicles at that location)
 

Cryogenist

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2005
Messages
1,755
Reaction score
105
Long distance cycling is fun but how do those solo cyclist manage when is time to go toilet. The bicycle locks available are too vulnerable to prevent theft. They could not possibly carry their mtb or road bike into the toilet rite?

do they endure it for hours till they complete the route?

If going for a piss, I will bring inside the toilet and park very near the urinal area.

If going for big business, I will bring the whole bike onto the cubicle. Very troublesome but doable.
 

Gixxerfied

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
May 24, 2008
Messages
84,918
Reaction score
2,912
Delivered ytd by CRC..

WO02Hyr.jpg


Anyway, CRC free standard shipping until 4th June..

pjwFak5VO64tOUf1X5i8Yi5W6f4IKOh7Unv6EThaxSDdUyX9ncYXBMQJ_TqSXvSUHAeEe_CxlWhYTQyiUXLg19ERb1M6SQcly-9NmNNo6qlNBKMT5uMUJyg9DtNiN0A52h2-7VSke6xdGA2E1mcYpCE2sc4JzcmOD6vTNA=s0-d-e1-ft
 

IronMac

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2012
Messages
9,006
Reaction score
11
Thanks guys for all the info....so I can have more confidence buying this bike knowing it can last me a long time without maintenance....

It all depends on what you mean by maintenance and how much you ride, what conditions you ride in, etc. No one answer fits all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top