c9l9 questions

Tommy Lee

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2015
Messages
1,389
Reaction score
0
"operate in a field environment" - This is missing from the L9 deployment code.

The reason why they didnt put "cannot operate in a field environment" so that the superiors can bend the rules. It was explicitly stated there in the older version. (If you go for reservist, you can probably see the old chart pinned somewhere in the camp)

The older versions of the PES Status actually exclude L3 too.

ftj4md.jpg


Here is the old version b4 PES B2 was implemented.
You can see that they have clearly stated the type of jobs for L9. None of them are field jobs.
So if I'm b2l3, where can I go?

Sent from an anti-troll hero wannabe using GAGT
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,383
Reaction score
5,901
"operate in a field environment" - This is missing from the L9 deployment code.

The reason why they didnt put "cannot operate in a field environment" so that the superiors can bend the rules. It was explicitly stated there in the older version. (If you go for reservist, you can probably see the old chart pinned somewhere in the camp)

The older versions of the PES Status actually exclude L3 too.

ftj4md.jpg


Here is the old version b4 PES B2 was implemented.
You can see that they have clearly stated the type of jobs for L9. None of them are field jobs.
Last time the law says cannot have casino, then they change the law... Do you refer back to the old law? no...

Same theory here.
 

MoxLotus

Master Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2007
Messages
2,982
Reaction score
4
Last time the law says cannot have casino, then they change the law... Do you refer back to the old law? no...

Same theory here.

still it doesn't change the fact that L9 is not suppose to do field duty since it is not mentioned in the new version.

EDIT: Just checked with someone who knows the SAF directive, basically you can bring L9 to outfield, but they are not suppose to perform any active duty. e.g. sentry
 
Last edited:

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,383
Reaction score
5,901
still it doesn't change the fact that L9 is not suppose to do field duty since it is not mentioned in the new version.

EDIT: Just checked with someone who knows the SAF directive, basically you can bring L9 to outfield, but they are not suppose to perform any active duty. e.g. sentry
If they intend to keep the original meaning, they wouldn't have alter the wordings, the fact that they alter the wordings mean they have the intention to change the meaning. What's their intention or what they plan to do I do not know.

What I am trying to point out to you is technicality here, and not so much about the content.

Not explicitly mentioning something can be done doesn't mean it can't be done. Laws, rules or what not are usually written in such a way that it prohibits something and not the other way round, but not saying that can't happen.

Is like there is no laws, rules or regulations that say we cannot have dinner at home. Does that mean we can't have dinner at home?

Whether you want to say they didn't explicitly state certain wordings hence they can bend the rules or not, I wouldn't argue about how you interpret it.

But for you to say, it didn't specifically say can do something, hence cannot the "something" can't be done just doesn't make sense.

Who is this "someone" you are referring to? Is this "someone" just like any "someone" who is able to access directives and you are basically just taking his interpretations for it?
 

MoxLotus

Master Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2007
Messages
2,982
Reaction score
4
If they intend to keep the original meaning, they wouldn't have alter the wordings, the fact that they alter the wordings mean they have the intention to change the meaning. What's their intention or what they plan to do I do not know.

What I am trying to point out to you is technicality here, and not so much about the content.

Not explicitly mentioning something can be done doesn't mean it can't be done. Laws, rules or what not are usually written in such a way that it prohibits something and not the other way round, but not saying that can't happen.

Is like there is no laws, rules or regulations that say we cannot have dinner at home. Does that mean we can't have dinner at home?

Whether you want to say they didn't explicitly state certain wordings hence they can bend the rules or not, I wouldn't argue about how you interpret it.

But for you to say, it didn't specifically say can do something, hence cannot the "something" can't be done just doesn't make sense.

Who is this "someone" you are referring to? Is this "someone" just like any "someone" who is able to access directives and you are basically just taking his interpretations for it?

There is a reason why it is phrased in that manner. Do you expect a 1 page thing to cover all the do's and don'ts ? Thats why there are directives to elaborate and further clarify the details.

Anyway the best way to clarify all this is to call NS hotline. don't need to debate over this here lol. And no matter what the SAF rules is, it all depends on the unit. if the unit fuked up, L9 or not doesnt even matter.
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,383
Reaction score
5,901
There is a reason why it is phrased in that manner. Do you expect a 1 page thing to cover all the do's and don'ts ? Thats why there are directives to elaborate and further clarify the details.

Anyway the best way to clarify all this is to call NS hotline. don't need to debate over this here lol. And no matter what the SAF rules is, it all depends on the unit. if the unit fuked up, L9 or not doesnt even matter.
yea lor. even though a law might be damn clear, it is still subjected to interpretation hence there is such thing as a court who will decide the law.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top