[CONSOLIDATED] 柯文哲 Ko P Discussion Thread

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
I don't think KMT will give KP so much advantage to win.
ppl keep thinking it's a "given advantage" but that is not true ...

results that fall within margin of error is so called inconclusive, or a draw, cos results are close.

so why did Ke agree to sign the agreement to let hou win if results fall within margin of error?

It's because .. of this thing called kmt's grassroot foundation and resources.

This is sth that Ke doesn't have. And he recognises that. that's why he signed an agreement that gives kmt a so-called "advantage".

Because you got to recognise that kmt has solid grassroot foundation and resources that you do not have.

Without those you cannot win with your slim margin (of error).

get it?

But then he signed le later on shamelessly breach it ..
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
I don't think KMT will give KP so much advantage to win.
it's like for eg ...

one day pap becomes like kmt.

need to alliance with a new, young party called "POP".

POP thinks their leader should be PM ... his support based on polls wins PAP. but falls within margin of error.

So... under this scenario:

PAP ... with their history and grassroot foundation and resources, should just let POP's rep be PM?

an alliance means to combine resources and campaign together.

So PAP should let POP use their funds, grassroot campaigns .. logistics etc ... just to help POP's leader be pm?

Does this make sense?



If POP's support is A LOT higher than PAP .. then yes ... POP will have the ultimate say.

But with a support that is is higher but falls within margin of error ... means

POP cannot win without PAP's years of grassroot foundation, MPS etc. ...

and hence POP needs to recognise that advantage that PAP has.

And cannot compete on 50-50 equal level playing field with pap on who to become PM.

Because POP is new and does not have any grasssroot foundation and resources.

He expects to compete on 50-50 equal footing on who to become pm?
 

Deadmaninc75

Banned
Joined
Apr 14, 2020
Messages
3,980
Reaction score
701
ppl keep thinking it's a "given advantage" but that is not true ...

results that fall within margin of error is so called inconclusive, or a draw, cos results are close.

so why did Ke agree to sign the agreement to let hou win if results fall within margin of error?

It's because .. of this thing called kmt's grassroot foundation and resources.

This is sth that Ke doesn't have. And he recognises that. that's why he signed an agreement that gives kmt a so-called "advantage".

Because you got to recognise that kmt has solid grassroot foundation and resources that you do not have.

Without those you cannot win with your slim margin (of error).

get it?

But then he signed le later on shamelessly breach it ..
He no resource to mobilise all his supporters
 

zoossh

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2000
Messages
86,729
Reaction score
19,251
Vote for blue = sell out the country

Vote for white = vote for senile ke

Vote for green = status quo
Will need another 1-2 generations for blue to die out

then Taiwan can truly have democracy with the incumbent and opposition all green, aka no foreigners

Sg need to watch this carefully as we have a larger migrant population unlike tw whose migration is mostly 70 years ago. Despite of that 70 years, the foreigners still sees themselves as foreign boss of the island.

So if sg is not careful, we will face the same problem. Perhaps we already have that
 

likevegetable

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
47,985
Reaction score
7,264
2:16 san pa ran pa


ahNhwwH.png


ppl keep thinking it's a "given advantage" but that is not true ...

results that fall within margin of error is so called inconclusive, or a draw, cos results are close.

so why did Ke agree to sign the agreement to let hou win if results fall within margin of error?

It's because .. of this thing called kmt's grassroot foundation and resources.

This is sth that Ke doesn't have. And he recognises that. that's why he signed an agreement that gives kmt a so-called "advantage".

Because you got to recognise that kmt has solid grassroot foundation and resources that you do not have.

Without those you cannot win with your slim margin (of error).

get it?

But then he signed le later on shamelessly breach it ..

But is it a shameless breach if one side says that they win a losing fight of -4.98% in a result that has a ±3% confidence margin while the other side says that they did not?

https://news.tvbs.com.tw/politics/2308761
20231118085926-7fcecfcd.jpg
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
But is it a shameless breach if one side says that they win a losing fight of -4.98% in a result that has a ±3% confidence margin while the other side says that they did not?
margin of error varies based on the sample size.

In some polls, the margin of error is greater than 3% for sure.

The result is 6-0 or 5-1 if really go strictly by the book .. and the official margin of error.

Ke knows and is aware.

Hence he decided to shameless breach it without proper justication and even created falsehood of "kmt wants me to give up 6%..." nonsense.
 

testart

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2012
Messages
95,823
Reaction score
15,257
I remember Ke P saying DPP are very drama during the election campaign.

He says especially Chen Ju will be very dramatic when she speaks in Taiyu.

But he himself also cries drama?


 

menthol28

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
21,634
Reaction score
14,909
margin of error varies based on the sample size.

if margin of error is +/- 3% ... then 34% vs 40% means the 34% wins, based on the agreement that was signed.

This was agreed upon by Ke himself because:
1 - He overrated himself thinking he will win by more than margin of errors in most of the polls
2 - he recognised that kmt has all the resources and grassroot foundations in southern taiwan which his tpp badly desperately needs and by agreeing to the margin of error clause, will reflect that

But later on he faced pressure from ppl like huang shan shan and then decided to breach the the agreement...
Your point of argument that Ke is dishonoring the 6 points argument is so wrong, one sided and baseless. Point 3 whereby Ke agreed to have an handicapped by using margin of error, in which line of the agreement you saw that 3% was indicated in the agreement????? +/-3% Margin of error was interpreted by KMT using their own assumptions.
Margin of error can be any percentage and it also has to do with what type of surveys done, and all the 9 surveys were done differently by different companies and all will have different margin of errors. Contractually and legally and morally KMT and Ke was not wrong, both parties stood by what they thought was difference in percentage in margin of errors. You keep saying others are Ke 粉。。。 What are u
 

regis6

Master Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2011
Messages
3,152
Reaction score
713
margin of error varies based on the sample size.

In some polls, the margin of error is greater than 3% for sure.

The result is 6-0 or 5-1 if really go strictly by the book .. and the official margin of error.

Ke knows and is aware.

Hence he decided to shameless breach it without proper justication and even created falsehood of "kmt wants me to give up 6%..." nonsense.
The margin of error varies and the maximum margin of error is 6%. That is facts and not falsehood. What kp did is to keep highlighting the maximum impact.

While keep emphasise on the margin of error but never state clearly what is the range of the margin of error. Then they say no such thing as 6% which is not accurate.
 

Courage

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
May 23, 2016
Messages
20,868
Reaction score
10,282
This thread is so bizarre. It's like hyena and leopard arguing who is the stronger predator between them in the savanna
 

menthol28

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
21,634
Reaction score
14,909
errr myj as a witness is requested by Ke. get your facts right lol.

Also this "letting kmt have 3% advantage" was also given by Ke himself.. Kmt did not ask. He himself proactively, initiated to give.

kmt did not accept his offer.

What was accepted and stated in the agreemen was "any results that fall within margin of error" means How wins.

becos margin of error means the study is inconclusive, too close.

And in that scenario kmt wins because kmt has resources and grassroot foundation in the south which tpp desperately needs and tpp recognises that.

Ke signed that agreement because of that.

But later on decided to breach it and came up with false dishonest narrative to justify it.
Was this 3% in the agreement signed by the 4 of them or you made up this agreement yourself?
https://www.wealth.com.tw/articles/d70b533f-ba7d-494c-8365-24f5d25d3ca8
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
Was this 3% in the agreement signed by the 4 of them or you made up this agreement yourself?
https://www.wealth.com.tw/articles/d70b533f-ba7d-494c-8365-24f5d25d3ca8

err bro read more widely .. and follow their statements more closely.. espc Ke.

he was the one who ownself offered 3% advantage ...

also I stated.. that kmt did not take up his offer.

what was taken up was the margin of error stated clearly in the agreement.

which Ke later shamelessly breached without dime or reason lol.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
Was this 3% in the agreement signed by the 4 of them or you made up this agreement yourself?
https://www.wealth.com.tw/articles/d70b533f-ba7d-494c-8365-24f5d25d3ca8
it's ok to defend Ke ... but try and read more widely and follow their statements more closely and set the facts right.

I am not taiwanese or ke fen or kmt fen and am totally neutral in this affair.

but i am a staunch believer and defender of facts and truth lol.

truth is ... agreement which Ke signed stated clearly results which fall in margin of error, means Hou wins.

Ke is completely aware and signed it willingly because giving kmt this "advantage" is to recognise kmt's grassroot foundation and resources.

But then later he shamlessly breached it without dime or reason lol.

The above is -- Fact. which I will staunchly defend.
 

menthol28

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
21,634
Reaction score
14,909
err bro read more widely .. and follow their statements more closely.. espc Ke.

he was the one who ownself offered 3% advantage ...

also I stated.. that kmt did not take up his offer.

what was taken up was the margin of error stated clearly in the agreement.

which Ke later shamelessly breached without dime or reason lol.
Dun need to say Ke keep saying what, KMT everyday also say many things....
Let's keep this based on facts, like what you mentioned Ke is not honouring on what he signed and this is whole argument is based on the 6 points agreement signed by Ma, Zhu, Hou and Ke correct? If it is, can you show me anywhere in the agreement was there a percentage point indicated ? It was just stated as margin of error correct?
End of the day your reasoning is as skewed as it is and keep saying you neutral.
Let's keep to the facts, take a look at the agreement and tell me again Ke is wrong. I day both Hou and Ke has different interpretations
 

likevegetable

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
47,985
Reaction score
7,264
it's ok to defend Ke ... but try and read more widely and follow their statements more closely and set the facts right.

I am not taiwanese or ke fen or kmt fen and am totally neutral in this affair.

but i am a staunch believer and defender of facts and truth lol.

truth is ... agreement which Ke signed stated clearly results which fall in margin of error, means Hou wins.

Ke is completely aware and signed it willingly because giving kmt this "advantage" is to recognise kmt's grassroot foundation and resources.

But then later he shamlessly breached it without dime or reason lol.

The above is -- Fact. which I will staunchly defend.
Just putting my own neutral pov as well. I feel as if KMT's interpretation of point 3 requires some mental gymnastics to come to a conclusion to.

It's akin to saying, only if there is 0% chance of a KP win (KP-error% vs Hou+error%) will KP get a point (or in other words, if there is a 0.00001% of a Hou win, Hou gets a point).

Both interpretations, measuring the error margin and the above fits within point 3.

But it gives me a 奸商 feeling to use the earlier method to interpret a win, and I'm not surprised White won't be placated by this kind of result.

Just my interpretation and feeling on the matter.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
Dun need to say Ke keep saying what, KMT everyday also say many things....
Let's keep this based on facts, like what you mentioned Ke is not honouring on what he signed and this is whole argument is based on the 6 points agreement signed by Ma, Zhu, Hou and Ke correct? If it is, can you show me anywhere in the agreement was there a percentage point indicated ? It was just stated as margin of error correct?
End of the day your reasoning is as skewed as it is and keep saying you neutral.
Let's keep to the facts, take a look at the agreement and tell me again Ke is wrong. I day both Hou and Ke has different interpretations
lol you are the one who cannot keep to facts ...

I have always said the agreement stated only margin of error.

that margin of error differs based on sample count.

I mentioned =/- 3% because that's how the nonsensical, false and dishonest "kmt wants me to give up 6% pt" came about ...

I did not say the agreement stated 3% lol.

and in fact this 3% was offered by Ke himself.

kmt did not take up that offer. but took up the margin of error agreement instead.

then Ke signed already then shamelessly breached and went back on everything lolol.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
Just putting my own neutral pov as well. I feel as if KMT's interpretation of point 3 requires some mental gymnastics to come to a conclusion to.

It's akin to saying, only if there is 0% chance of a KP win (KP-error% vs Hou+error%) will KP get a point. Both interpretations, measuring the error margin and the above fits within point 3.

But it gives me a 奸商 feeling to use the earlier method to interpret a win, and I'm not surprised White won't be placated by this kind of result.

Just my interpretation and feeling on the matter.
you can say that ... but one CANNOT twist or bend statistical and scientific margin of errors, validated and recognised worldwide and internationally.

based on the results which fall between margin of error ... facts are facts and cannot be twisted or bent by kmt or anyhow.

It is simply a case of Ke refusing to honour the agreement despite signing it ...

for whatever reason.

He simply cannot accept becoming VP.

He simply facing too much pressure from ppl like huang shan shan hence he cannot honour the agreement.

for me, stats and science are facts and science and cannot be twisted or bent or demanded by the kmt or anyhow.

how many pct margin of error jiu shi means how many pct margin of error.

It is just that Ke wouldn't face up to it. That's all.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top