[CONSOLIDATED] 柯文哲 Ko P Discussion Thread

likevegetable

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
47,987
Reaction score
7,265
I watch this whole drama and I think no one is right or wrong.

The princess is US educated and cultured. She follow the rule and personal information privacy. The public speculation of her citizenship is just speculative and she does not need to respond to any speculation. She only responsible to prove the case with election committee if they ask.

It is for the election committee to review and decide not the member of public to 公審her. You see my point?
Well, she definitely is entitled to whatever privacy she is entitled to, but she isn't helping the KP team much playing it the way she is currently playing it. Because it is a public interest issue cos it's in Art 27(3) of the Presidential and Vice Presidential Election and Recall Act.

Lai Pei-Hsia nipped the issue in the bud with a photo.
e6bee4be8e86a30cf863aaa112e53a4d


Even a letter from the US consulate would easily nip the issue in the bud even if say she lost or destroyed the original documents.
cci16042012_00001.jpg


https://law.moj.gov.tw/Eng/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=D0020053
Presidential and Vice Presidential Election and Recall Act
Article 27
The following persons may not apply for being registered as the candidate for President or Vice President:
3.Persons holding the nationality of a foreign country.
 

Medicated Oil

High Honorary Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2011
Messages
170,340
Reaction score
78,179
Well, she definitely is entitled to whatever privacy she is entitled to, but she isn't helping the KP team much playing it the way she is currently playing it. Because it is a public interest issue cos it's in Art 27(3) of the Presidential and Vice Presidential Election and Recall Act.

Lai Pei-Hsia nipped the issue in the bud with a photo.
e6bee4be8e86a30cf863aaa112e53a4d


Even a letter from the US consulate would easily nip the issue in the bud even if say she lost or destroyed the original documents.
cci16042012_00001.jpg


https://law.moj.gov.tw/Eng/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=D0020053
Presidential and Vice Presidential Election and Recall Act
Article 27
The following persons may not apply for being registered as the candidate for President or Vice President:
3.Persons holding the nationality of a foreign country.
What if she is holding the citizenship of another country instead of US ?
It is up to the authority on whether they can dig it out or they still want her to run and ONLY focus on checking for US citizenship.
That is why she is so yaya about it cos every one is on a wild goose chase.
 

TUV2008

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
May 31, 2008
Messages
77,831
Reaction score
28,201
Well, she definitely is entitled to whatever privacy she is entitled to, but she isn't helping the KP team much playing it the way she is currently playing it. Because it is a public interest issue cos it's in Art 27(3) of the Presidential and Vice Presidential Election and Recall Act.

Lai Pei-Hsia nipped the issue in the bud with a photo.
e6bee4be8e86a30cf863aaa112e53a4d


Even a letter from the US consulate would easily nip the issue in the bud even if say she lost or destroyed the original documents.
cci16042012_00001.jpg


https://law.moj.gov.tw/Eng/LawClass/LawAll.aspx?pcode=D0020053
Presidential and Vice Presidential Election and Recall Act
Article 27
The following persons may not apply for being registered as the candidate for President or Vice President:
3.Persons holding the nationality of a foreign country.

That’s why I said there is no who is right or wrong, it is a question of perspective.

Imagine if tomorrow the opposition goes and dig another story says she got what citizenship again then she has to prove again? It is no ending to prove all the public unfounded allegations.
 

Medicated Oil

High Honorary Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2011
Messages
170,340
Reaction score
78,179
That’s why I said there is no who is right or wrong, it is a question of perspective.

Imagine if tomorrow the opposition goes and dig another story says she got what citizenship again then she has to prove again? It is no ending to prove all the public unfounded allegations.
That is why the ball falls fully on the authority in verifying she dun hold any other citizenship of any country on Tuesday.
I am not sure whether they are ONLY checking for US citizenship.
It will kill all the questions about her citizenship.

BTW, the princess is in Dubai for COP28 with the Sg Inc Bin Center Master till 12th Dec 2023.
 

likevegetable

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
47,987
Reaction score
7,265
What if she hold the citizenship of another country instead of US ?
It is up to the authority on whether they can dig it out or they still want her to run and ONLY focus on checking for US citizenship.
That is why she is so yaya about it cos every one is on a wild goose chase.
If it's evidence of renunciation of any European nationalities some people were insinuating. It's up to those to prove that she has those first cos why does she need to go around proving something she doesn't have first? But the US one is straightforward cos she was born there (birthright citizenship).

They're definitely not going to be able to dig it out unless the US consulate cooperates. So i'm doubtful the EC will find anything substantial come 12/5. But the way she is dealing with the issue and the media in general during QA is problematic to the KP team.
 

likevegetable

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
47,987
Reaction score
7,265
That’s why I said there is no who is right or wrong, it is a question of perspective.

Imagine if tomorrow the opposition goes and dig another story says she got what citizenship again then she has to prove again? It is no ending to prove all the public unfounded allegations.
Agree, she really can bo hiew the european citizenship questions, but she really could have handled the US citizenship case a lot better. Actually her problem is with her way of interacting with journalists in general.
 

mgx-alander

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 19, 2008
Messages
98,748
Reaction score
15,731
That is why the ball falls fully on the authority in verifying she dun hold any other citizenship of any country on Tuesday.
I am not sure whether they are ONLY checking for US citizenship.
It will kill all the questions about her citizenship.

BTW, the princess is in Dubai for COP28 with the Sg Inc Bin Center Master till 12th Dec 2023.
Run for election campaign go dubai? :s14:
 

Medicated Oil

High Honorary Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2011
Messages
170,340
Reaction score
78,179
If it's evidence of renunciation of any European nationalities some people were insinuating. It's up to those to prove that she has those first cos why does she need to go around proving something she doesn't have first? But the US one is straightforward cos she was born there (birthright citizenship).

They're definitely not going to be able to dig it out unless the US consulate cooperates. So i'm doubtful the EC will find anything substantial come 12/5. But the way she is dealing with the issue and the media in general during QA is problematic to the KP team.
I think she already know what is the outcome and the mind game that she is playing.
That is why she is having fun with it.
 

TUV2008

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
May 31, 2008
Messages
77,831
Reaction score
28,201
Agree, she really can bo hiew the european citizenship questions, but she really could have handled the US citizenship case a lot better. Actually her problem is with her way of interacting with journalists in general.

Because from amdk culture perspective is very rude to ask personal question like if she granted permission by the parents to run for election, this is really a 管你屁事question and and the journalist deserved to be F
 

Medicated Oil

High Honorary Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2011
Messages
170,340
Reaction score
78,179
Run for election campaign go dubai? :s14:
She is still holding the legislator appointment at the moment ?
(Since you need a official post to represent your country or you are there as a reporter.)
And she is representing TW for the climate conference.
I dunno how it works since the DPP VP candidate have to resign from her official post.
 

Medicated Oil

High Honorary Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2011
Messages
170,340
Reaction score
78,179
Agree, she really can bo hiew the european citizenship questions, but she really could have handled the US citizenship case a lot better. Actually her problem is with her way of interacting with journalists in general.
She dun have any ground experience with reporters confronting her with harsh questions.
I guess her previous encounter with them are just licking her cos she is hosting some charity events.
That is why her elitist self emerge as her defense mechanism.

My suspicion is she is holding some citizenship with other country so she dun want the reporters to probe further.
And she know that the EC cannot dig it out.
 

likevegetable

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
47,987
Reaction score
7,265
She is still holding the legislator appointment at the moment ?
(Since you need a official post to represent your country or you are there as a reporter.)
And she is representing TW for the climate conference.
I dunno how it works since the DPP VP candidate have to resign from her official post.
Maybe not necessary since people like HGY campaigned for President while still being Taipei Mayor. Think Hsiao's resignation is more from a practical perspective since she's not going to be in the US in the near future to handle her ambassadorial work, so just full time campaign. Not like she's gonna keep the role whether she wins (becomes VP) or loses (get replaced by incoming president).
 

likevegetable

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
47,987
Reaction score
7,265
That is why the ball falls fully on the authority in verifying she dun hold any other citizenship of any country on Tuesday.
I am not sure whether they are ONLY checking for US citizenship.
It will kill all the questions about her citizenship.

BTW, the princess is in Dubai for COP28 with the Sg Inc Bin Center Master till 12th Dec 2023.
Give her General role and get her to 遠征. can go back to do what she does best and get her away from the local reporters :crazy:
 

menthol28

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
21,634
Reaction score
14,909
Because from amdk culture perspective is very rude to ask personal question like if she granted permission by the parents to run for election, this is really a 管你屁事question and and the journalist deserved to be F
But the reality is that even though she was born in USA , she is running for Taiwan VP now. She should be sensitive enough as a politician of 1-2 yrs
 

Medicated Oil

High Honorary Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2011
Messages
170,340
Reaction score
78,179
Maybe not necessary since people like HGY campaigned for President while still being Taipei Mayor. Think Hsiao's resignation is more from a practical perspective since she's not going to be in the US in the near future to handle her ambassadorial work, so just full time campaign. Not like she's gonna keep the role whether she wins (becomes VP) or loses (get replaced by incoming president).
The appointment holder can get some one to stand in for their post for this 1.5 months during the campaign.
Unless the princess is giving a speech herself, she can also get some one else to go in her place if she place some importance in her VP election.
 

likevegetable

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 8, 2017
Messages
47,987
Reaction score
7,265
The appointment holder can get some one to stand in for their post for this 1.5 months during the campaign.
Unless the princess is giving a speech herself, she can also get some one else to go in her place if she place some importance in her VP election.
Maybe her 團隊 wants her to go hokay? :crazy:
Use her nego skills for Taiwan, hide from local journalists, all the 小鷄s sigh in relief they dun see her black face at their rallies :crazy:
 

Medicated Oil

High Honorary Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2011
Messages
170,340
Reaction score
78,179
But the reality is that even though she was born in USA , she is running for Taiwan VP now. She should be sensitive enough as a politician of 1-2 yrs
She is not being bombed by the reporters since she is just a legislator of no importance.
And she is just a calefare who was being called up 3 hours before the registration.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top