[CONSOLIDATED] 柯文哲 Ko P Discussion Thread

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
A doctor is an earned title. It's for life. Dun be so sour lah.

Even angmo also call him a surgeon.

https://weai.columbia.edu/events/dialogue-chairman-taiwan-peoples-party-dr-ko-wen-je#:~:text=Ko Wen-je is chairperson,Taiwan University College of Medicine.

Ko Wen-je is chairperson of the Taiwan People’s Party and a possible candidate in the 2024 Taiwan presidential election. He was mayor of Taipei from 2014 to 2022. Before entering politics, Dr. Ko was a leading transplant surgeon at National Taiwan University College of Medicine.
That is why it is misleading. And real actual surgeons and experts in Taiwan are raising the issue, that Ke should not go by the surgeon designation.

https://talk.ltn.com.tw/article/paper/1321939

If you know chinese, do yourself a favour by reading.

Also @luvbitez lol.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
He goes by the designation "Transplant Surgeon".

Any one will think he does organ transplant surgery.

But the fact is he doesn't do any surgery.

So that is a misleading title that many fans don't know.

And there are actual surgeons and profs n Taiwan voicing out on that, saying he should not go by the surgeon title.

https://talk.ltn.com.tw/article/paper/1321939
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
lol no one is disputing those titles.

The issue is with calling himself a wai ke yi sheng aka a surgeon who does surgery.

Because that gives people the wrong impression that he actually does surgery, which is a very high-level medical skill.

You were also mistaken just hours ago today that he does surgeries. And that's a wrong fact.

https://talk.ltn.com.tw/article/paper/1321939

This is a letter of people explaining the whole issue.
thats another forum like edmw..
its like talking abt Dr Vijay having a name card with “phd comp SC” under his name then u argue he should not use it while not doing anything on computer science.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
thats another forum like edmw..
its like talking abt Dr Vijay having a name card with “phd comp SC” under his name then u argue he should not use it while not doing anything on computer science.
He never did any surgery before. He simply does not do surgery.

Get it?

In medical field, having the "surgeon" designation means you do surgery.

There is no other way about it bro lol.

That's why real actual surgeons are voicing out to say, that hey Ke shouldn't go by the surgeon designation.

Understand?

It's not me or my opinon my gosh lol.

It's just cold plain hard facts.

Surgeon = do surgery

Ke does not do any surgery gosh.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
He never did any surgery before. He simply does not do surgery.

Get it?

In medical field, having the "surgeon" designation means you do surgery.

There is no other way about it bro lol.

That's why real actual surgeons are voicing out to say, that hey Ke shouldn't go by the surgeon designation.

Understand?

It's not me or my opinon my gosh lol.

It's just cold plain hard facts.

Surgeon = do surgery

Ke does not do any surgery gosh.
he WAS a practicing medical doctor, surgeon, professor for 30years in the hospital. even if he is not in the profession, its ok for him to be addressed as Dr Ke (surgeon).
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
he WAS a practicing medical doctor, surgeon, professor for 30years in the hospital. even if he is not in the profession, its ok for him to be addressed as Dr Ke (surgeon).
lololol bro I am not talking about was or is past or present.

He simply DOES NOT DO SURGERY. He never did in the past too.

And people are taking issue with him calling himself a surgeon.

Because to anybody, surgeon = do surgery.

And he does not do any surgery. Not in the past, not present, not future.

And real surgeons are therefore taking issue with him calling himself a surgeon.

Ke has all along tried to bluff that he is an actual surgeon.

Get it?

How come you don't get it ah? Lolol.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
he WAS a practicing medical doctor, surgeon, professor for 30years in the hospital. even if he is not in the profession, its ok for him to be addressed as Dr Ke (surgeon).
He was a medical doctor, a professor in critical care and trauma, a specialist in ECMO.

But he was never a surgeon and never did any surgery.

He simply does not do surgery.

And now real actual surgeons who do surgery in Taiwan are vocing out to say that he should never call himself a surgeon because he never does any surgery at all.

Get it?

Surgeon = do surgery

But Ke does not do any srugery.

omg explain to you really can vomit blood lolol.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
He never did any surgery before. He simply does not do surgery.

Get it?

In medical field, having the "surgeon" designation means you do surgery.

There is no other way about it bro lol.

That's why real actual surgeons are voicing out to say, that hey Ke shouldn't go by the surgeon designation.

Understand?

It's not me or my opinon my gosh lol.

It's just cold plain hard facts.

Surgeon = do surgery

Ke does not do any surgery gosh.
u r making a hot air claim that he has never done any surgery so cannot be called a surgeon.
his job title was given by the hospital n doctorate n professorship conferred by the uni. these r titles for life.
u r very strange being unable to recognise this.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
He was a medical doctor, a professor in critical care and trauma, a specialist in ECMO.

But he was never a surgeon and never did any surgery.

He simply does not do surgery.

And now real actual surgeons who do surgery in Taiwan are vocing out to say that he should never call himself a surgeon because he never does any surgery at all.

Get it?

Surgeon = do surgery

But Ke does not do any srugery.

omg explain to you really can vomit blood lolol.

its useless trying to convince something out the ordinary. take a deep breath.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
u r making a hot air claim that he has never done any surgery so cannot be called a surgeon.
his job title was given by the hospital n doctorate n professorship conferred by the uni. these r titles for life.
u r very strange being unable to recognise this.
huh? Lol err he called himself a surgeon.

His hospital doctorate and professorship never called him a surgeon. Lol.

that's why you need to get your facts right.

and it is not my claim. It's the claims of actual surgeons in Taiwan. Go read up.

https://talk.ltn.com.tw/article/paper/1321939
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
its useless trying to convince something out the ordinary. take a deep breath.

自由廣場》柯文哲不應自稱外科醫師​

2019/10/02 05:30
◎ 李道真
柯文哲經常在公開場合自稱「外科醫師」,似頗引以為傲。但是媒體早就披露,柯是個不開刀的醫生。
二○一○年九月十九日,自由時報記者王昶閔專訪五十一歲的柯文哲時,提到柯在台大醫院是不看門診、不開刀的醫生。二○一四年十一月十七日,民報記者蘇元和報導,連勝文遭槍擊事件時,柯文哲承認他是創傷醫學部主任,在台大醫院是不開刀的醫生。
根據維基百科的定義,外科醫師是執行開刀的醫師。至於開刀,是指專業人員透過器械(刀子或剪刀)劃開皮膚,進入人體組織,以排除病變、改變構造或植入外來物的處理過程。
柯文哲專責葉克膜治療,而葉克膜是將體內的靜脈血引出體外,經過人工心肺進行處理後注入病人動脈或靜脈系統,以暫時取代心肺功能。基本上,它的處置過程主要是血液導管的插入和擺置,並沒有在體內執行「摘除」或「植入」的動作,不符合上述「開刀」的定義。
因此,柯文哲確定是沒有在執行「開刀」的醫生,根據維基百科的定義,當然也就不能被稱為「外科醫師」。
沒錯,柯是台大心臟外科的成員,但這並不代表他是執刀醫師。至於柯是自願不上手術台,或因其他因素被排除在手術台外,筆者沒興趣知道。只是熟悉外科文化的筆者認為,外科體系的優質醫師成員通常會擠破頭去站上手術房舞台,鮮少會甘於只在手術房外照顧病人。
除了不會開刀,筆者認為柯也不具備外科醫師的特質。外科醫師經常是低調保守又木訥無趣。相對於柯文哲的口無遮攔,甚至抓頭搞笑,根本是不同族類。
也許柯文哲內心深處一直存在著對執刀醫師的羨慕之情,因此甘冒被質疑的風險,不時標榜自己是「外科醫師」,以撫慰他生涯中的最大遺憾。但筆者還是建議他應該自稱「重症醫師」或「創傷專家」,因為那更符合他的專業和人們對他的印象。
資訊發達的時代,一個政治人物的學經歷是無法逃過選民嚴格檢驗。真的假不了,同樣的,若有誤導或謊報情事,也很容易被起底而遭譏笑,甚至被貼上「欺世盜名」的標籤。
(作者為成大醫院神經外科特聘教授)
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406

自由廣場》柯文哲不應自稱外科醫師​

2019/10/02 05:30
◎ 李道真
柯文哲經常在公開場合自稱「外科醫師」,似頗引以為傲。但是媒體早就披露,柯是個不開刀的醫生。
二○一○年九月十九日,自由時報記者王昶閔專訪五十一歲的柯文哲時,提到柯在台大醫院是不看門診、不開刀的醫生。二○一四年十一月十七日,民報記者蘇元和報導,連勝文遭槍擊事件時,柯文哲承認他是創傷醫學部主任,在台大醫院是不開刀的醫生。
根據維基百科的定義,外科醫師是執行開刀的醫師。至於開刀,是指專業人員透過器械(刀子或剪刀)劃開皮膚,進入人體組織,以排除病變、改變構造或植入外來物的處理過程。
柯文哲專責葉克膜治療,而葉克膜是將體內的靜脈血引出體外,經過人工心肺進行處理後注入病人動脈或靜脈系統,以暫時取代心肺功能。基本上,它的處置過程主要是血液導管的插入和擺置,並沒有在體內執行「摘除」或「植入」的動作,不符合上述「開刀」的定義。
因此,柯文哲確定是沒有在執行「開刀」的醫生,根據維基百科的定義,當然也就不能被稱為「外科醫師」。
沒錯,柯是台大心臟外科的成員,但這並不代表他是執刀醫師。至於柯是自願不上手術台,或因其他因素被排除在手術台外,筆者沒興趣知道。只是熟悉外科文化的筆者認為,外科體系的優質醫師成員通常會擠破頭去站上手術房舞台,鮮少會甘於只在手術房外照顧病人。
除了不會開刀,筆者認為柯也不具備外科醫師的特質。外科醫師經常是低調保守又木訥無趣。相對於柯文哲的口無遮攔,甚至抓頭搞笑,根本是不同族類。
也許柯文哲內心深處一直存在著對執刀醫師的羨慕之情,因此甘冒被質疑的風險,不時標榜自己是「外科醫師」,以撫慰他生涯中的最大遺憾。但筆者還是建議他應該自稱「重症醫師」或「創傷專家」,因為那更符合他的專業和人們對他的印象。
資訊發達的時代,一個政治人物的學經歷是無法逃過選民嚴格檢驗。真的假不了,同樣的,若有誤導或謊報情事,也很容易被起底而遭譏笑,甚至被貼上「欺世盜名」的標籤。
(作者為成大醫院神經外科特聘教授)
@luvbitez

Person who wrote the above is 成大醫院神經外科特聘教授 aka a real actual surgeon professor.

It's not my opinion "out of the ordinary" LOL.

You can go dispute this actual surgeon professor 成大醫院神經外科特聘教授 not me thanks lolol.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142

自由廣場》柯文哲不應自稱外科醫師​

2019/10/02 05:30
◎ 李道真
柯文哲經常在公開場合自稱「外科醫師」,似頗引以為傲。但是媒體早就披露,柯是個不開刀的醫生。
二○一○年九月十九日,自由時報記者王昶閔專訪五十一歲的柯文哲時,提到柯在台大醫院是不看門診、不開刀的醫生。二○一四年十一月十七日,民報記者蘇元和報導,連勝文遭槍擊事件時,柯文哲承認他是創傷醫學部主任,在台大醫院是不開刀的醫生。
根據維基百科的定義,外科醫師是執行開刀的醫師。至於開刀,是指專業人員透過器械(刀子或剪刀)劃開皮膚,進入人體組織,以排除病變、改變構造或植入外來物的處理過程。
柯文哲專責葉克膜治療,而葉克膜是將體內的靜脈血引出體外,經過人工心肺進行處理後注入病人動脈或靜脈系統,以暫時取代心肺功能。基本上,它的處置過程主要是血液導管的插入和擺置,並沒有在體內執行「摘除」或「植入」的動作,不符合上述「開刀」的定義。
因此,柯文哲確定是沒有在執行「開刀」的醫生,根據維基百科的定義,當然也就不能被稱為「外科醫師」。
沒錯,柯是台大心臟外科的成員,但這並不代表他是執刀醫師。至於柯是自願不上手術台,或因其他因素被排除在手術台外,筆者沒興趣知道。只是熟悉外科文化的筆者認為,外科體系的優質醫師成員通常會擠破頭去站上手術房舞台,鮮少會甘於只在手術房外照顧病人。
除了不會開刀,筆者認為柯也不具備外科醫師的特質。外科醫師經常是低調保守又木訥無趣。相對於柯文哲的口無遮攔,甚至抓頭搞笑,根本是不同族類。
也許柯文哲內心深處一直存在著對執刀醫師的羨慕之情,因此甘冒被質疑的風險,不時標榜自己是「外科醫師」,以撫慰他生涯中的最大遺憾。但筆者還是建議他應該自稱「重症醫師」或「創傷專家」,因為那更符合他的專業和人們對他的印象。
資訊發達的時代,一個政治人物的學經歷是無法逃過選民嚴格檢驗。真的假不了,同樣的,若有誤導或謊報情事,也很容易被起底而遭譏笑,甚至被貼上「欺世盜名」的標籤。
(作者為成大醫院神經外科特聘教授)
wot from a forum post carries no weight.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
wot from a forum post carries no weight.
lolol err that's not a forum post..

that's the national broadsheet newspaper.

And the person who wrote that is an actual real surgeon professor.

But anyway you happy can le. lol.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
Lol should try and come to terms and accept that .. Ke bluffed and called himself a surgeon, when he never does any surgery.

nobody says anything abt him on this except u n the forum post. pls stop propagating fake news.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
lolol err that's not a forum post..

that's the national broadsheet newspaper.

And the person who wrote that is an actual real surgeon professor.

But anyway you happy can le. lol.
im not happy u r spreading a fake news that Ke P has not been a medical surgeon.
even he is not practicing now, he gained the deserved title over a course of 30years in practice!
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
nobody says anything abt him on this except u n the forum post. pls stop propagating fake news.

im not happy u r spreading a fake news that Ke P has not been a medical surgeon.
even he is not practicing now, he gained the deserved title over a course of 30years in practice!
You can't accept that Ke never did surgery but call himself a surgeon.

It's not about past or present.

He never did surgery in the past.

He admitted it himself in an interview. Watch it.

It's not fake news lol.

Ke never did any surgery in the past but calls himself a surgeon and that is wrong.

That is not my opinion or fake news, that's official and also written out by real actual professor surgeons.

Ke also admitted that himself in an interview.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top