[CONSOLIDATED] 柯文哲 Ko P Discussion Thread

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
Nothing is fake news. It's a fact that Ke is not a surgeon and had never done any surgery.

Ke is not a surgeon. He never did any surgery. Get it?

Hospital did not give him that surgeon designation.

He has been called a surgeon because his dept belongs to the surgical dept.

All along he then gives others an impression that he is a surgeon. When he is not.

A surgeon does operation. But Ke does not. He never did.

So now there are actual surgeon professors writing to say that perhaps Ke should refrain from calling himself a surgeon.

Here:
https://talk.ltn.com.tw/article/paper/1321939
this one and only 2019 article from 李道真 has already been struck off by the public as a papsmear on prof ke..
she alleged ke p was unable to perform a cardiovascular procedure thus should not be addressed as a surgeon.
no one is talking abt this nonsense now.
no need to harp on such an unsubstantiated fake news like a gospel.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
https://forum.doctorvoice.org/viewtopic.php?f=199&t=50353

https://talk.ltn.com.tw/article/paper/1321939




There are tons of interviews and articles in the past of him confirming that he doesn't really do operation or surgery, even though he is considered from the surgical dept.

Then later he continued to give people like you a false impression that he is a superior surgeon ..

That, in a nutshell, is Ke for you.

@luvbitez

then how you explain this video where Ke said himself he does/did not do any surgery?

Also he was questioned in the assembly by MPs, he also admitted.

He admitted on several other occasions too he does/did not do any surgery.

And that letter by the surgeon prof is not the only that pointed out that he should not use the title surgeon because he does/did not do any surgery.

There are many other articles, news, letters etc.

I wouldn't want to search and spoon feed them to you.

Anyway you wouldn't face the facts it's totally fine. Lol.

Just that need to be aware:
Ke is not a surgeon. He has never performed any surgery. But he calls himself one.

That's all.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
@luvbitez

then how you explain this video where Ke said himself he does/did not do any surgery?

Also he was questioned in the assembly by MPs, he also admitted.

He admitted on several other occasions too he does/did not do any surgery.

And that letter by the surgeon prof is not the only that pointed out that he should not use the title surgeon because he does/did not do any surgery.

There are many other articles, news, letters etc.

I wouldn't want to search and spoon feed them to you.

Anyway you wouldn't face the facts it's totally fine. Lol.

Just that need to be aware:
Ke is not a surgeon. He has never performed any surgery. But he calls himself one.

That's all.
yr chinese f9?

ke p: 我不會開刀只設計SOP

he was the one drafting the operating procedure but would not do it personally [on this particular case]

would not do it doesnt mean he cannot do it or has never done it before.

suggest u brush yrself up on the language.
 

feitz

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2000
Messages
11,308
Reaction score
615
iLa8pxq.jpg


Without a doubt, keP contribution in medical field is recognised in taiwan and world wide.

this is a 1450 SOP that when you cannot argue against topic A, just ignore topic A and keep repeating a falsehood like topic B.


Read HWZ Forum Rules!
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
Just that need to be aware:
Ke is not a surgeon. He has never performed any surgery. But he calls himself one.

yr rationale is similar to this scenario:
Dr Vijay is not the editor in chief for HWZ. He only gives instruction, design SOP n has never edited anything in forum but relying on the mods for moderation n programmers for coding. yet he calls himself the editor in chief, how can!
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
yr chinese f9?

ke p: 我不會開刀只設計SOP

he was the one drafting the operating procedure but would not do it personally [on this particular case]

would not do it doesnt mean he cannot do it or has never done it before.

suggest u brush yrself up on the language.
Lol .. he has never performed a surgery before. He is simply not a dr who can perform a surgery. Plain and simple.

You won’t accept that also no choice lol.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
Lol .. he has never performed a surgery before. He is simply not a dr who can perform a surgery. Plain and simple.

You won’t accept that also no choice lol.
u r becoming a joke.
a person in his senior position would not be hands on doing everything. its already given in the wiki page that he was instrumental in designing surgery procedures recognised internationally.
let me draws another comparison: Elon Musk not the creator of Tesla bcos he did not n cannot build any car all by himself…
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
iLa8pxq.jpg


Without a doubt, keP contribution in medical field is recognised in taiwan and world wide.

this is a 1450 SOP that when you cannot argue against topic A, just ignore topic A and keep repeating a falsehood like topic B.


Read HWZ Forum Rules!
No one is doubting his contribution in the medical field.

The issue here is, Ke has never performed a surgery, he doesn’t know how to perform a surgery, and there are real surgeon profs voicing out that hence Ke should not call himself a surgeon.

That’s the issue.

Surgeon = Dr who performs surgery

Dr who DOESN’T/CANNOT/DID NOT perform any surgery should not call himself a surgeon.

This is not my opinion lolol

I am just sharing this thing about Ke that you people don’t know about.

@luvbitez
 

lifezard

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2009
Messages
6,955
Reaction score
2,451
I believe that we went through the similar situation this Sep.
So, did you put your tick on the guy who is different from the other two ?

He is just telling the tw peasants what they want to hear.
The other two parties are greasy.
So, they have to vote for some one else.
It does not mean that he is the solution.

Did he not elect a super ASK for his VP candidate ?
Did he not get cosy with Terry Guo every day for 2 weeks so that he can partner or assist him with his P campaign ?
(Did he not mention that the political parties should not be too CLOSE with the big business organisation ?)

Was he unable to achieve a multi-party collaboration with KMT himself ?
(Did he not promise that he will set up a multi party government when he is elected ?)

Did he flip prata on the agreement that he signed with KMT ?
(Did he examine and review the agreement thoroughly before he signed ? If not, why ?)

What is the point of electing a person that can change his mind when the heat is on ?
He can promise you the moon landing and Disneyland any time.
If he cannot even adhere to the above stuff that he stand by, then what other promises do you believe that he will deliver ?
Then, what is the difference between him and the other parties ?
He may just become greasy after he is elected.

Once again, it is just my observation.
If you think that it is ok for him to flip prata, I am fine with it.

flip prata is his character flaw which should be separated from what the message he is trying to bring. he did acknowledge he made mistakes

what are his + and what are his - , we should be honest and not paint everything with him as bad just because you don't like him.

and if you say he is just saying what the taiwanese people want to hear why aren't the other 2 parties doing the same then? if it is that simple to gain more votes, they could simply have done that? why haven't they done that?
 
Last edited:

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
u r becoming a joke.
a person in his senior position would not hands on on everything. its already given in the wiki page that he was instrumental in designing surgery procedures recognised internationally.
let me draws another comparison: Elon Musk not the creator of Tesla bcos he did not n cannot build any car all by himself…
Surgeon = A dr who can perform surgery

This is plain and simple and recognised worldwide.

If you can’t/doesn’t perform any surgery then cannot call your surgeon.

Understand? Lol.
 

junjie433

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2008
Messages
37,300
Reaction score
6,109
iLa8pxq.jpg


Without a doubt, keP contribution in medical field is recognised in taiwan and world wide.

this is a 1450 SOP that when you cannot argue against topic A, just ignore topic A and keep repeating a falsehood like topic B.


Read HWZ Forum Rules!

Quoted"
On the advice of his professor, Dr. Chu Shu-hsun, Ko decided to specialize in surgery and critical care within the department of Emergency Medicine, working on the front lines of the emergency room. After working in emergency services for 11 years, Ko traveled to the United States in 1993 for a one-year clinical fellowship program on artificial liver research at the University of Minnesota under Wei-Shou Hu.
"

Maybe they will claim wiki detail as fake one. No doubt he is qualified as a surgeon because of his specialization.
 

lifezard

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2009
Messages
6,955
Reaction score
2,451
Surgeon = A dr who can perform surgery

This is plain and simple and recognised worldwide.

If you can’t/doesn’t perform any surgery then cannot call your surgeon.

Understand? Lol.

does it matter at this stage? the taiwanese are electing a president not finding a surgeon to perform their next surgery. what s the point of going that detailed the definition he is a surgeon or not? we all go to a surgeon of his own specialty when we need to be operated. you won't go to a plastic surgeon for a heart bypass will you?

at the rate this is going, someone is going to claim he is a quack and graduated from SPU very soon
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
Surgeon = A dr who can perform surgery

This is plain and simple and recognised worldwide.

If you can’t/doesn’t perform any surgery then cannot call your surgeon.

Understand? Lol.

you hv no proof of him not being able to perform surgery, only hotairs.
if he was not able to carry out surgery then he would not be promoted into a senior position designing surgical SOPs.
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
Quoted"
On the advice of his professor, Dr. Chu Shu-hsun, Ko decided to specialize in surgery and critical care within the department of Emergency Medicine, working on the front lines of the emergency room. After working in emergency services for 11 years, Ko traveled to the United States in 1993 for a one-year clinical fellowship program on artificial liver research at the University of Minnesota under Wei-Shou Hu.
"

Maybe they will claim wiki detail as fake one. No doubt he is qualified as a surgeon because of his specialization.

does it matter at this stage? the taiwanese are electing a president not finding a surgeon to perform their next surgery. what s the point of going that detailed the definition he is a surgeon or not? we all go to a surgeon of his own specialty when we need to be operated. you won't go to a plastic surgeon for a heart bypass will you?

at the rate this is going, someone is going to claim he is a quack and graduated from SPU very soon
I agree with all that you all said.

No one is doubting his medical credentials or contribition.

Just pointing out something which many people like @luvbitez have completely no idea about and mistakenly thinking Ke can do surgery when he can’t, simply because he has a “surgeon” title.

Ke does not and cannot do surgery. This is a “trivial” that blind followers like @luvbitez never knew until today and I am just pointing it out.

Black is black and white is white.

Surgeons are universally known to be able to do surgery.

If cannot do surgery then cannot be called surgeon.

This is not my opinion but also the opinion of other surgeon profs in Tw.

Understand @luvbitez ?
 

feitz

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2000
Messages
11,308
Reaction score
615
keP brought many of his belief and values from his career as a doctor into his political career.
things like:
- working 0730-2200 everyday.
- use of SOP. continous review and improvement to SOP.
- openess and transparent governence
- start by handling citizen's small problems will prevent big problems.
- use of people in government based on ability, regardless of party.
- use public money like if its your own.
TPP has been focusing on announcing their own governence policies in many areas, much more than KMT or DPP.
KMT and DPP mostly focusing on using media to smear keP. Their polices focus on not rocking the boat for their coporate political sponsors like big properties developers. it's no longer for their voter's or national interest.
Read HWZ Forum Rules!

why allow bongnino to highjack the topic on what possibilties KeP can bring to taiwan by flooding this thread with meaningless falsehood?


Read HWZ Forum Rules!
 

bongnino

Master Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
4,848
Reaction score
3,406
why allow bongnino to highjack the topic on what possibilties KeP can bring to taiwan by flooding this thread with meaningless falsehood?


Read HWZ Forum Rules!
Ke doesn’t and didn’t perform surgery in his hospital and that’s verified by himself publicly. It’s not a falsehood.

I am just pointing out a trivial fact that blind followers like yourself and @luvbitez don’t know about or mistaken about.

I.e. Ke has a surgeon title but he doesn’t and didn’t perform surgery.

And there are actual surgeon profs in Taiwan pointing that out and saying he should not be calling himself a surgeon.

It’s not my opinion lol.
 

Medicated Oil

High Honorary Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2011
Messages
170,309
Reaction score
78,165



flip prata is his character flaw which should be separated from what the message he is trying to bring. he did acknowledge he made mistakes

what are his + and what are his - , we should be honest and not paint everything with him as bad just because you don't like him.

and if you say he is just saying what the taiwanese people want to hear why aren't the other 2 parties doing the same then? if it is that simple to gain more votes, they could simply have done that? why haven't they done that?

Go and read what I wrote previously.
I mentioned that he is no different from the other two.
And I am stating the real actions that he did despite calling the incumbent out.
Dun think there is any painting at all.

Flipping prata is a MAJOR character flaw.
If you can accept that a politician who cannot adhere to his values and principles, then it is your choice and decision.
Dun forget that the welfare of the whole country are in his hands if he become the P.
He cannot AFFORD to make any mistakes which may lead to a possible war or conflict.

Lastly, I dun have any "liking" or "support" for any of one of them.
So, I am not blinded by any emotions in my observation.
If any one of them flip prata, I will still call them out when I spot them.
(Not expecting Ke P to be perfect or a saint. At least be consistent with what he whacked the DPP and KMT about and dun do what they did.)
 
Last edited:

feitz

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2000
Messages
11,308
Reaction score
615
Ke doesn’t and didn’t perform surgery in his hospital and that’s verified by himself publicly. It’s not a falsehood.
I am just pointing out a trivial fact that blind followers like yourself and
@luvbitez
don’t know about or mistaken about.
I.e. Ke has a surgeon title but he doesn’t and didn’t perform surgery.
And there are actual surgeon profs in Taiwan pointing that out and saying he should not be calling himself a surgeon.
It’s not my opinion lol.

why allow bongnino to highjack the topic on what possibilties KeP can bring to taiwan by flooding this thread with meaningless falsehood?



Read HWZ Forum Rules!
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top