[CONSOLIDATED] 柯文哲 Ko P Discussion Thread

tokong

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2015
Messages
48,730
Reaction score
16,187
If China wants Taiwan so badly, they will attack regardless who party is leading. Cannot count on the US to defend Taiwan, but end of the day, the threat is China and not USA, for Taiwan.

Even if KMT wins, and they really push for unification, it won't happen easily as the locals will prevent it.

End of the day, if China really wants Taiwan immediately, they will have to destroy the island and kill us.

Reunification won't make Taiwanese better off, if poor now, will still be poor reunified. Not like poor Taiwanese will suddenly become wealthy, there's no real benefits, despite how advanced and shiny the first tier cities are in China.
What you mentioned are very reasonable points. I mostly agree.

But as a leader/leaders, you just can't dump the issue aside and keep on avoiding it. For example, the HSR was first proposed by Malaysia side (not us), but did we avoid the issue? Our leaders did not avoid the issue but instead keep on speaking and having meetings with them and even if the first time was not successful, we did not avoid the topic at all, and we still assure them that we are keen to speak with you on a clean slate.

If Taiwan handles the China issue like we handle the HSR, I think Taiwan would be in a better shape than now.
 

charleslin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
Messages
38,557
Reaction score
2,171
What you mentioned are very reasonable points. I mostly agree.

But as a leader/leaders, you just can't dump the issue aside and keep on avoiding it. For example, the HSR was first proposed by Malaysia side (not us), but did we avoid the issue? Our leaders did not avoid the issue but instead keep on speaking and having meetings with them and even if the first time was not successful, we did not avoid the topic at all, and we still assure them that we are keen to speak with you on a clean slate.

If Taiwan handles the China issue like we handle the HSR, I think Taiwan would be in a better shape than now.
Dealing with the Chinese is not as straight-forward.

They will force their requirements on you, it takes two hands to clap. China threatened a lot more recently which caused the usual talks to cease.

While it's true if KMT was the leader it might have been slightly better in terms of talks but the more they tighten you, the more you lose negotiation power as well.

So the best case is to keep status quo, you happy I happy, and wait for CCP to self-implode, if it happens.
 

Courage

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
May 23, 2016
Messages
20,871
Reaction score
10,282
Who say KMT pushing for unification? That's misinformation. MYJ yes, but not HYY. War loving IB spreading fake news here
 

tokong

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2015
Messages
48,730
Reaction score
16,187
no link no talk, stop yr false news pls.

You go and find lor. As if it is my problem. you want to support dpp is your own problem, not mine. Why must I find for you the article which you are against? I can tell you straight that I want to see TW and China unify. I support KMT and I hate DPP and TPP.
 

TUV2008

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
May 31, 2008
Messages
77,831
Reaction score
28,201
i think the safest is voting DPP. At least they are with "generally" with good terms with it's neighbour.. like japan also said it will help taiwan .. if USA do the same.

i meant if KMT take over... i think winnie will pressure KMT to cut defense budget. and weaken the defence.. secretly hand over the weapon they obtain from the west.

one funny thing , our NS took 2 years and so many cycle of reservist.. and we are quite peaceful..... and taiwan is at constant thread with Aircraft carrier ... yet they only need to serve for a year... ( it used to be only 4 months, DPP increase to a year) And their youth kpkb...

HYY and ZSK said at the press conference the cross strait relationship should maintain status quo, then just maintains DPP as ruling party to maintain the status quo lo!

Vote for Lai!
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
You go and find lor. As if it is my problem. you want to support dpp is your own problem, not mine. Why must I find for you the article which you are against? I can tell you straight that I want to see TW and China unify. I support KMT and I hate DPP and TPP.
unless you can produce the “Taiwan mainstream English paper” you r making a blatant lie here.
 

evildoer

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2007
Messages
23,676
Reaction score
4,101
HYY and ZSK said at the press conference the cross strait relationship should maintain status quo, then just maintains DPP as ruling party to maintain the status quo lo!

Vote for Lai!
that's why i said it's the safest to vote for DPP..
 

charleslin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
Messages
38,557
Reaction score
2,171
You go and find lor. As if it is my problem. you want to support dpp is your own problem, not mine. Why must I find for you the article which you are against? I can tell you straight that I want to see TW and China unify. I support KMT and I hate DPP and TPP.
Ok let me ask you, what's the benefit of Taiwan and China unification other than making China more daring to expand their influence bigger in South China Sea?

Taiwanese suddenly all wealthier? All living good lives and Taipei will be very advanced like Beijing?

Peace? You think if Taiwan is absorbed into China tomorrow, USA and China will not continue using other nations to defend against each other to maintain power? It will just shift the power struggle to another nation, maybe Japan or Philippines.
 

charleslin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
Messages
38,557
Reaction score
2,171
From the current atmosphere and context, DPP high probability will win.

The 黑马 is KMT

Ke is gone case.
I think it's China helping DPP to win, despite them not wanting them to win. They just don't understand how people can have a freedom to choice, suppression works in China because they can't voice out, not in other countries.
 

spinex

Banned
Joined
Dec 13, 2004
Messages
2,368
Reaction score
1,193
Dealing with the Chinese is not as straight-forward.

They will force their requirements on you, it takes two hands to clap. China threatened a lot more recently which caused the usual talks to cease.

While it's true if KMT was the leader it might have been slightly better in terms of talks but the more they tighten you, the more you lose negotiation power as well.

So the best case is to keep status quo, you happy I happy, and wait for CCP to self-implode, if it happens.

That y when China is stronger and more powerful it mean less bargaining chip for Taiwan when it come to peaceful negotiation. Time is not on Taiwan side.

Best is engage in constant talk and good relationship first then see how it go.

Political situation in China will also change as time go by but if 2 sides also have good working relationships it is easier to talk on good terms.

Now becos of US and China competition and DPP is pro US for now it is not beneficial to Taiwan to form a good working relationship with China.

Think Taiwan should look to Asean countries as example. Vietnam and even Indonesia, they are neutral to both US and China and focus on their own country and people interest first. Which country can bring development and economic benefits to their country will be welcomed.
 

menthol28

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
21,634
Reaction score
14,909
Ok let me ask you, what's the benefit of Taiwan and China unification other than making China more daring to expand their influence bigger in South China Sea?

Taiwanese suddenly all wealthier? All living good lives and Taipei will be very advanced like Beijing?

Peace? You think if Taiwan is absorbed into China tomorrow, USA and China will not continue using other nations to defend against each other to maintain power? It will just shift the power struggle to another nation, maybe Japan or Philippines.
There's no benefits to reunification to Taiwan or the rest of the world, reunification only serves XJP and CCP their propaganda and make XJP legacy as CCP greatest leader.
In fact if china is successful in 武统, this will bloat up their ego so much that surrounding countries will face their hegemonic behaviors sooner than later
 

charleslin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
Messages
38,557
Reaction score
2,171
That y when China is stronger and more powerful it mean less bargaining chip for Taiwan when it come to peaceful negotiation. Time is not on Taiwan side.

Best is engage in constant talk and good relationship first then see how it go.

Political situation in China will also change as time go by but if 2 sides also have good working relationships it is easier to talk on good terms.

Now becos of US and China competition and DPP is pro US for now it is not beneficial to Taiwan to form a good working relationship with China.

Think Taiwan should look to Asean countries as example. Vietnam and even Indonesia, they are neutral to both US and China and focus on their own country and people interest first. Which country can bring development and economic benefits to their country will be welcomed.
All boils down to China not allowing Taiwan to be on its own.

The other nations don't have another country constantly bullying you that you are part of us, restricting inter country partnerships and negotiations.

If you were to objectively look at the region, Taiwan actually fare quite alright already, compared to other nations around SEA despite having a bully at your door step.

If you compare to Singapore, yeah it's not as great of course, but neither is anyone else in the region.

And Taiwan succeeding will make China look bad, so China does everything it can to ensure Taiwan's inability to do well, so to prove that democracy "doesn't work" and CCP way is the only way for Chinese.

And to add on - I can guarantee you Taiwan government cares about their own people's interests first over both Indonesia and Vietnam where corruption is still dominating politics. And it's not like Taiwan's corruption where small money get blown up, it's where the government works closely with big families to ensure power and control.
 
Last edited:

charleslin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
Messages
38,557
Reaction score
2,171
There's no benefits to reunification to Taiwan or the rest of the world, reunification only serves XJP and CCP their propaganda and make XJP legacy as CCP greatest leader.
In fact if china is successful in 武统, this will bloat up their ego so much that surrounding countries will face their hegemonic behaviors sooner than later
That's why it's easier for others to say, just give it up and unify and let there be peace. Problem is, there will be no peace, there is no stopping China's ambition to be the next power leader.

What if unifying Singapore with Malaysia and Singapore will now have access to natural resources like cheap fuel and water supply, I wonder would Singaporeans be willing to "unify".

Assuming we put aside the "rights & ownership" of the land, which CCP has never had over Taiwan island from the day they were founded anyway.
 

twosix

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2000
Messages
30,644
Reaction score
9,218
That's why it's easier for others to say, just give it up and unify and let there be peace. Problem is, there will be no peace, there is no stopping China's ambition to be the next power leader.

What if unifying Singapore with Malaysia and Singapore will now have access to natural resources like cheap fuel and water supply, I wonder would Singaporeans be willing to "unify".

Assuming we put aside the "rights & ownership" of the land, which CCP has never had over Taiwan island from the day they were founded anyway.
no way. why dun malaysia sell johore to sg instead? will malaysian agree? haha.
 

charleslin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
Messages
38,557
Reaction score
2,171
no way. why dun malaysia sell johore to sg instead? will malaysian agree? haha.
But Malaysia have resources, and will protect tiny Singapore le.

Like that Malaysia won't bully Singapore anymore, every now and then threaten to turn off the water pipe mah, will be more peaceful, why not?
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top