[CONSOLIDATED] 柯文哲 Ko P Discussion Thread

Swordsman

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2002
Messages
92,483
Reaction score
2,468


Taiwan justice system is a Joke..
Even i am not a taiwanese.. i also 看不惯..

he doesn't deserve to die although he took 9 lives (Burn alive).. Reason is because his intended target did not die. (y) (y)

You feel safe go taiwan meh ?

Taiwan is the country in the world that is most difficult to get death penalty.
 

spinex

Banned
Joined
Dec 13, 2004
Messages
2,368
Reaction score
1,193
All boils down to China not allowing Taiwan to be on its own.

The other nations don't have another country constantly bullying you that you are part of us, restricting inter country partnerships and negotiations.

If you were to objectively look at the region, Taiwan actually fare quite alright already, compared to other nations around SEA despite having a bully at your door step.

If you compare to Singapore, yeah it's not as great of course, but neither is anyone else in the region.

And Taiwan succeeding will make China look bad, so China does everything it can to ensure Taiwan's inability to do well, so to prove that democracy "doesn't work" and CCP way is the only way for Chinese.

And to add on - I can guarantee you Taiwan government cares about their own people's interests first over both Indonesia and Vietnam where corruption is still dominating politics. And it's not like Taiwan's corruption where small money get blown up, it's where the government works closely with big families to ensure power and control.

Historically Taiwan was part of China at least even in Ming and Qing dynasty till civil war between ccp and kmt. So for Taiwan to gain independence it can only be done if both side mutually agree. Just like Spore gain independence becos Malaysia also agree to it. Also when Spore join Malaysia as a federation i think there is a clause that allow us to quit the federation if we dont want. The situation between China and Taiwan is not so clearcut.

I cited Indo and Viet foreign policy as an example that it is better Taiwan maintain a more neutral stance vs pro US to maintain their status quo as not to get involve in US China relationship.

Democracy nowadays also manipulate to enrich politicians. Just like dpp which is an opposition and people vote them.

But once absolute power come in with majority in legislative their blantant corruption and abuse of power also come in.

Personally hope KP win. He may not have the majority in legislative council but at least the normal running of the country can be back on track. But this is good becos there is check and balance against his power as president. So dpp and kmt form majority at legislative council, KP run the country as president.

If there is new law to be passed and the law doesnt favour just any parties in particular likely will also be passed by majority.

No corruption, no abuse of power and really no gov controlling of mass media solely for their own purpose only. All these basic values has been eroded away under dpp which is suppose to be democratic.
 

charleslin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
Messages
38,557
Reaction score
2,171
Historically Taiwan was part of China at least even in Ming and Qing dynasty till civil war between ccp and kmt. So for Taiwan to gain independence it can only be done if both side mutually agree. Just like Spore gain independence becos Malaysia also agree to it. Also when Spore join Malaysia as a federation i think there is a clause that allow us to quit the federation if we dont want. The situation between China and Taiwan is not so clearcut.
Taiwan island was ceded to the Japanese by Qing.

After which it was handed over control to RoC.

It was never CCP who got control. CCP take control of mainland China by defeating RoC, but Taiwan island has been and is still under RoC since then.

Cannot use claims just because last time part of today still assume rights over it.
 

spinex

Banned
Joined
Dec 13, 2004
Messages
2,368
Reaction score
1,193
Taiwan island was ceded to the Japanese by Qing.

After which it was handed over control to RoC.

It was never CCP who got control. CCP take control of mainland China by defeating RoC, but Taiwan island has been and is still under RoC since then.

Cannot use claims just because last time part of today still assume rights over it.

Taiwan ceded to Japan doesnt mean Japan has the rights because they are war crimminal and commit war crimes occupation.

ROC occupied whole of China plus Taiwan after ww2 exactly because this land belong to China originally.

Civil war between ccp and kmt after ww2 so CCP won the war in mainland and Kmt retreat to Taiwan to defend it position.

Technically they are still at war because no peace treaty or agreement has been signed because both claim rights over Mainland and Taiwan. This is the interlocking issue.

So even assuming Taiwan changed it mind now and try to sign peace treaty with China and claim Taiwan is not part of China and Taiwan will not seek to claim mainland as ROC. Do you think China will want to accept ?

If today the position of Taiwan and China switched. Kmt occupied mainland and ccp taiwan. You think taiwanese in mainland also will accept to let taiwan be separated from them ?

That is the harsh reality. Stronger and bigger nation will not allow their land to be separated or breakaway from them.

I have cited example of Cadelonia region of Spain, automnous region voted overwhelming to be separately from Spain. In the end, the democratic Spain gov term it as illegal and will not recognise the voting because the majority of Spanish people did not agree for Caldelonia to be independent.
 
Last edited:

Sango123

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 26, 2010
Messages
10,665
Reaction score
5,631
Wah i am in a TW game group and one of the guy is in 凯道

They are now discussing about the election and another guy said TW bookie say Green win by 40万
 

twinbaby

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2014
Messages
5,604
Reaction score
1,596
From me:

我会支持国民党是应为你是代表中华民国的象征, 我也喜欢 蒋万安,徐巧芯,卢秀燕, 韩国瑜。但是,我不太喜欢侯友宜选总统,他没有气质,英文不好,表达能力只是旋绕在口号,我宁愿郭台铭选是应为他没市长的包袱,要不然朱立伦也可以。
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
Taiwan ceded to Japan doesnt mean Japan has the rights because they are war crimminal and commit war crimes occupation.

ROC occupied whole of China plus Taiwan after ww2 exactly because this land belong to China originally.

Civil war between ccp and kmt after ww2 so CCP won the war in mainland and Kmt retreat to Taiwan to defend it position.

Technically they are still at war because no peace treaty or agreement has been signed because both claim rights over Mainland and Taiwan. This is the interlocking issue.

So even assuming Taiwan changed it mind now and try to sign peace treaty with China and claim Taiwan is not part of China and Taiwan will not seek to claim mainland as ROC. Do you think China will want to accept ?

If today the position of Taiwan and China switched. Kmt occupied mainland and ccp taiwan. You think taiwanese in mainland also will accept to let taiwan be separated from them ?

That is the harsh reality. Stronger and bigger nation will not allow their land to be separated or breakaway from them.

I have cited example of Cadelonia region of Spain, automnous region voted overwhelming to be separately from Spain. In the end, the democratic Spain gov term it as illegal and will not recognise the voting because the majority of Spanish people did not agree for Caldelonia to be independent.

taiwan was ceded to japan - 100% correct.
after ww2 japan had requested roc n prc to sign an agreement accepting return of taiwan but both refused to..
legally, japan has more grounds to claim for an reunification than china if taiwanese so agreed.
 

tokong

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2015
Messages
48,735
Reaction score
16,191
@TUV2008 very sian max hor
tomorrow can spend whole day in front of computer

in fact tmr i aim to relak at home and follow the going-on of their election. sure a lot of juice one. planning to order pizza hut 45 dollar combo and enjoy the day
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
From me:

我会支持国民党是应为你是代表中华民国的象征, 我也喜欢 蒋万安,徐巧芯,卢秀燕, 韩国瑜。但是,我不太喜欢侯友宜选总统,他没有气质,英文不好,表达能力只是旋绕在口号,我宁愿郭台铭选是应为他没市长的包袱,要不然朱立伦也可以。
國民黨是歷史遺留下來的殘物,
隨著時光的流逝,
在台灣已無意義可言。
舊的不除新的不來,
而且還是個沈重的包袱,
所以台灣人必須義無反顧根除國民黨!
 

menthol28

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2007
Messages
21,634
Reaction score
14,909
taiwan was ceded to japan - 100% correct.
after ww2 japan had requested roc n prc to sign an agreement accepting return of taiwan but both refused to..
legally, japan has more grounds to claim for an reunification than china if taiwanese so agreed.
No, after WW2 ROC under KMT took control of Taiwan. The recognized government of that time was ROC, PRC mot even formed yet. PRC was formed on oct 1949 after KMT fled to Taiwan.
So your part whereby Taiwan was not accepted by ROC or PRC is totally not true.
 

junjie433

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2008
Messages
37,304
Reaction score
6,111
I just want to lol at him.

That means all the 3 parties agenda the same.

Just pack up and throw a dice and any one of them can be president.

People want to see any good idea on China and TW issue, Lai gave this answer is really throwing own feet a big rock.

Maintain status quo is not a solution. It is just an interim middle ground. You are passing this hard baton to the young gen where they don't know the idea of 统一大业

you don't want unification now, that is ok, but you must tell ppl how and when you are going to start a meeting on it with china. the talks can take 10 years 20 years, you still need to face the issue what. dpp is good at avoiding.

Ya all 3 parties don't want to rock the boat.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
No, after WW2 ROC under KMT took control of Taiwan. The recognized government of that time was ROC, PRC mot even formed yet. PRC was formed on oct 1949 after KMT fled to Taiwan.
So your part whereby Taiwan was not accepted by ROC or PRC is totally not true.

it’s correct KMT took control but there wasnt any formal state agreement with japan bcos both refused to sign.
 

luvbitez

Banned
Joined
Feb 11, 2001
Messages
10,727
Reaction score
6,142
1732hrs

E86eLwp.jpg


1752 hrs

yK86gz8.jpg
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top