MaxiGain is good for people; with extra cash to stash with no intention of touching it for a long period, who do nothing & earn interest, but provided the 1 month SIBOR remains above 1.8 with bonus interest counter already at max. (This May & June interest earned were above 2.5% for $70k to $150k)
If you can fulfill the multiplier's salary credit + 3 eligible categories with transaction >$5k monthly, then go for DBS Multiplier. Great as the funds are not lock-in.(interest earnings at 2.3% for $100k)
The choice between Maxigain or Multiplier really depends on your consumption of financial services and whether you need to use the funds, as you have rightly pointed out.
I personally don’t like the Maxigain because it is like a fixed deposit as it penalises you if you withdraw the money (having lower balances vs the previous month = lower bonus interest).
In addition, the maximum interest on Maxigain is well below the 3.65% pa that Multiplier pays you. Also, it takes 1 year to build up to the maximum bonus rate.
For Maxigain, assuming 1M SIBOR remains at 1.80% pa, the base rate is ~1.26% pa (I rounded it down to 1.20% for ease of calculation). You build up gradually by 0.10% pa bonus interest every month until you hit 1.20% pa bonus interest over 12 months. For the first year, your average total interest is 1.75% pa. For the second year, your average total interest is 2.40% pa. Hence, your average total interest for both years is 2.075% pa. And there’s a $150K cap.
I may as well put it in Maybank’s iSAVvy account and earn 2.00% pa with no cap on amount and no restrictions on withdrawals. My monthly balances can be higher or lower than previous months and there’s no penalty (via reduction in bonus interest rates). And I get the 2.0% pa immediately. Of course, to do so, you need to continuously rotate your funds between 2 Maybank iSAVvy accounts but that’s a small inconvenience to pay for the flexibility it offers.
That’s just my personal choice.