Debt consolidation Plan

Status
Not open for further replies.

melbourne10

Senior Member
Joined
May 12, 2010
Messages
975
Reaction score
1
Minlaw:

2. Can I get a debtor who has been made a bankrupt repay his loan?

Once a debtor is declared bankrupt by the High Court, you can no longer commence or continue with any legal action against the bankrupt to recover monetary claims that arose before the bankruptcy.

Creditors who are owed debts which arose before the bankruptcy are advised to file a Proof of Debt with the Official Assignee online.

3. How do I recover my claims against a bankrupt?

If your claim was incurred prior to the making of the Bankruptcy Order, you can submit a Proof of Debt (Form 23)to the Official Assignee.

If you are the creditor who commenced the bankruptcy proceedings, you should also file a Proof of Debt against the bankrupt.

Debts that are incurred after the date of the making of the Bankruptcy Order are not provable (claimable) against the bankruptcy estate. If a bankrupt borrows from you without informing you of his status as a bankrupt, you should immediately provide feedback to the Official Assignee, using the “First Incident Report” form.
 

DNA9179

Master Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2007
Messages
4,635
Reaction score
14
Errrr, do I have to spend on LV bag just to accumulate debts on my credit card? I was paying my minimum every mth without fail, my reno loan and courts was paid every mth too till an unexpected circumstances had to happen. But I give up to explain cause at the end of the day, no matter what explanation I gave, my husband always say that I'm at fault. I'm the one bringing making everybody in trouble.

Now uob and posb he is unsuccessful in getting a personal loan for me.

And uob lawyer just sent me a letter via courier saying that uob are considering filing a writs seizure on my property.

So much stress and yet I'm trying to hold it in. Trying to go for ccs but the appointment is always on the day that I'm working. Planning to take mc one of this day to go for the talk. I hope this time no more disruptions So that I can go for ccs asap.

And to those who get approval on their dcp, congrats to all of u! So good to you all getting all the help that u can get! 😁

As for me since my rating is HX and I'm having arrears it's no use for me to even try DCP at all I guess.

really suggest u try CCS. Jiayou
 

ohsoon

Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2006
Messages
446
Reaction score
0
Anz waive my early repayment fee $150
SCB also waive my early repayment free for 2 loans add up $500 .
Cimb not willing to waive early repayment free
 

DNA9179

Master Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2007
Messages
4,635
Reaction score
14
Anz waive my early repayment fee $150
SCB also waive my early repayment free for 2 loans add up $500 .
Cimb not willing to waive early repayment free

Oh, that i will go down to anz or call to request the waiver for my early repayment fee of $100. thanks for this info
 

gho_sam

Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2008
Messages
231
Reaction score
23
For me it was $150 early repayment fee 😭 no negotiation was possible at all with ANZ. But other banks were kind enough to listen to me and attempted to put a special request for waiver.

I think it's up to the CSO who you speak too and he/she is willing to go that extra mile to make this request for you follow up with you on the outcome.

I was successful with DBS, HSBC & OCBC. $450 is a lot of money and so it's definitely worth the time and energy spent on topic.

So good luck to you, and remember to call them as early as possible (don't wait for final statement).

ANZ charged me $100 early repayment fee. They dun waive your late fees, i wonder will they waive early repayment fee or not.

The rest of the bank i haven't receive any final statement yet so dunno have any fee or not. I think the normal interest can't be waive bah
 

oceanicmanta

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
9,672
Reaction score
1,382
From reading this thread, it seems CCS comes with lower repayment EIR compared to DCP.

However, it also seems that more have applied to DCP instead of CCS.

Curious to know why ? Is it bcos
- DCP shorter process / CCS takes longer & more effort
- not true that CCS is lower EIR
- CCS less likely to succeed
- applied DMP but rejected
- dont know about CCS

Asking this bcos I m helping a relative with his CC debt & now filling up CCS forms for submission.

Thanks
 

DNA9179

Master Member
Joined
Aug 18, 2007
Messages
4,635
Reaction score
14
From reading this thread, it seems CCS comes with lower repayment EIR compared to DCP.

However, it also seems that more have applied to DCP instead of CCS.

Curious to know why ? Is it bcos
- DCP shorter process / CCS takes longer & more effort
- not true that CCS is lower EIR
- CCS less likely to succeed
- applied DMP but rejected
- dont know about CCS

Asking this bcos I m helping a relative with his CC debt & now filling up CCS forms for submission.

Thanks

Actually, CCS is just an abbreviation for Credit Counselling Singapore. I think u are referring to the program, DMP Debt Management Program by CCS.
I may not be the best person to ans all the Q but since i attended the talks at CCS, i'll try to ans the above.

-DCP process is definitely shorter. DMP u need to attend the talks, collect and submit the application for DMP, wait for them to book an appt for consulting which is about 1 month, review all the relevant document then submit to all the banks and wait.
-From what i know yes the interest is lower
-The reason for CCS to assist you for the DMP isn't because u wanna get lower interest, it's more for those ppl who reach a point where they having hard time paying even the min payment. If they review your case and find that your case isn't that strong, they might not help you with the DMP. so it's more for desperate cases.
-I would say most ppl here applied for DCP and also reg to attend the CCS talk as backup plan
 

gho_sam

Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2008
Messages
231
Reaction score
23
Check this out


https://restartingmylifeblog.wordpress.com

It's from Carlingford I Guess, a very nice write up of DMP & DCP as well.

From reading this thread, it seems CCS comes with lower repayment EIR compared to DCP.

However, it also seems that more have applied to DCP instead of CCS.

Curious to know why ? Is it bcos
- DCP shorter process / CCS takes longer & more effort
- not true that CCS is lower EIR
- CCS less likely to succeed
- applied DMP but rejected
- dont know about CCS

Asking this bcos I m helping a relative with his CC debt & now filling up CCS forms for submission.

Thanks
 

franco8822

Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2008
Messages
223
Reaction score
0
Errrr, do I have to spend on LV bag just to accumulate debts on my credit card? I was paying my minimum every mth without fail, my reno loan and courts was paid every mth too till an unexpected circumstances had to happen. But I give up to explain cause at the end of the day, no matter what explanation I gave, my husband always say that I'm at fault. I'm the one bringing making everybody in trouble.

Now uob and posb he is unsuccessful in getting a personal loan for me.

And uob lawyer just sent me a letter via courier saying that uob are considering filing a writs seizure on my property.

So much stress and yet I'm trying to hold it in. Trying to go for ccs but the appointment is always on the day that I'm working. Planning to take mc one of this day to go for the talk. I hope this time no more disruptions So that I can go for ccs asap.

And to those who get approval on their dcp, congrats to all of u! So good to you all getting all the help that u can get! 😁

As for me since my rating is HX and I'm having arrears it's no use for me to even try DCP at all I guess.

A writ of seizure from UOB? So serious?
 

sgman88

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2016
Messages
12,171
Reaction score
1,144
Anyone can advice me on how to nego with the banks on the payment? I'm really trying very hard to pay the minimum and arrears but I couldn't keep up anymore while waiting for CCS and previously time wasted on DCP applications. Some banks have sent me letter to ask for an immediate payment otherwise they will cancel facilities. CCS only asked me to pay the best effort payment which is too Low for the banks.

I would suggest u heed ccs advice, do what ccs told you. Trust them cos they r quite experience. Answer every call from the creditor n let them know u r already seeking help from ccs. But more importantly do not stop paying, that's to proof u r sincerely wanted to pay your debt. But if u stop, meaning making $0 payment, then it is difficult to help already. Lastly don't understand y u need to negotiate when ccs is doing the job for you?
 
Last edited:

Sdanni28

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2017
Messages
46
Reaction score
0
You may an appointment with UOB and explain that you are trying to get help from CCS.

Errrr, do I have to spend on LV bag just to accumulate debts on my credit card? I was paying my minimum every mth without fail, my reno loan and courts was paid every mth too till an unexpected circumstances had to happen. But I give up to explain cause at the end of the day, no matter what explanation I gave, my husband always say that I'm at fault. I'm the one bringing making everybody in trouble.

Now uob and posb he is unsuccessful in getting a personal loan for me.

And uob lawyer just sent me a letter via courier saying that uob are considering filing a writs seizure on my property.

So much stress and yet I'm trying to hold it in. Trying to go for ccs but the appointment is always on the day that I'm working. Planning to take mc one of this day to go for the talk. I hope this time no more disruptions So that I can go for ccs asap.

And to those who get approval on their dcp, congrats to all of u! So good to you all getting all the help that u can get! 😁

As for me since my rating is HX and I'm having arrears it's no use for me to even try DCP at all I guess.
 

jyjnee

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2012
Messages
48
Reaction score
0
Because I'm still waiting for my 1st face to face appointment with CCS which is in two weeks time. So meanwhile they asked me to make best effort payment. But banks kept saying "before CCS approach us, we still need you to clear your arrears" etc. It seems like my best effort payment is not good enough for them. In this case, what should I do?

I would suggest u heed ccs advice, do what ccs told you. Trust them cos they r quite experience. Answer every call from the creditor n let them know u r already seeking help from ccs. But more importantly do not stop paying, that's to proof u r sincerely wanted to pay your debt. But if u stop, meaning making $0 payment, then it is difficult to help already. Lastly don't understand y u need to negotiate when ccs is doing the job for you?
 

pororokia

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2017
Messages
585
Reaction score
4
encountered exactly the same scenario.

pressured by banks while arranged for ccs talk. just try to pay the min, if min cant pay, at least try half the min and stall for time.

yes confirm under tremendous pressure, just tahan while u do your best together with the ccs officer to try to get the dmp approved.
 

pororokia

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2017
Messages
585
Reaction score
4
i got my dmp approved within 2 mths including the first ccs talk.

can be done one, dont give up hope!
 

jyjnee

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2012
Messages
48
Reaction score
0
Thanks. So good that your DMP got approved. I'm also worried that my DMP might not get approved because I have some unsecured credit which I took up less than 1 year ago.

encountered exactly the same scenario.

pressured by banks while arranged for ccs talk. just try to pay the min, if min cant pay, at least try half the min and stall for time.

yes confirm under tremendous pressure, just tahan while u do your best together with the ccs officer to try to get the dmp approved.
 

benoon

Junior Member
Joined
May 2, 2006
Messages
61
Reaction score
0
My CBS rating is HX too....that's due to a insurance claim for traffic accident in late 2014. CBS said only clear up in 2017 Nov.

I shall pray hard for HSBC approval results on Monday or Wednesday....

I applied 4 banks one day apart from each other....really play punk. haha

My NOA is 71k. Calculations of outstanding differ for each of the following banks.

Highest one is calculated by SCB to be 103k. Thats pretty close to 18x the monthly income.

I got a feeling rejected by Maybank is due to too high or they see HX straightaway reject...haizz not sure.

My Citibank rejection earlier is due to the close to 18 times according to the officer that submitted my application.
 

Izumi8

Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2003
Messages
375
Reaction score
5
I have some enquiries below:

1) Anyone heard if BOC or HSBC or any other banks will approve HH ratings? So far only Maybank approve HH?

2) The formula to calculate DTI is NOA/Total Interest-bearing Unsecured Debt.
But some said non-interest bearing will be counted too, some said bonus excluded, only count basics. Anyone know Maybank, BOC, HSBC, Citi calculation methods?

3) I saw previous posts SCB approve an DTI that was 21? Usually will this include the 5% buffers?
If 5% buffers included the DTI is 17 or 18, what are the options left?
If 5% buffers included exceed 18, what are the options left?

4) If some cards are Overlimits, will it means no hope for DCP?

5) If there are some overdued (more than 30 days overdued) min payments not yet paid, that means no hope for DCP?

Thanks.
 
Last edited:

benoon

Junior Member
Joined
May 2, 2006
Messages
61
Reaction score
0
I have some enquiries below:

1) Anyone heard if BOC or HSBC or any other banks will approve HH ratings? So far only Maybank approve HH?

2) The formula to calculate DTI is NOA/Total Interest-bearing Unsecured Debt.
But some said non-interest bearing will be counted too, some said bonus excluded, only count basics. Anyone know Maybank, BOC, HSBC, Citi calculation methods?

3) I saw previous posts SCB approve an DTI that was 21? Usually will this include the 5% buffers?
If 5% buffers included the DTI is 17 or 18, what are the options left?
If 5% buffers included exceed 18, what are the options left?

Thanks.
My rating is HX and was rejected by Maybank, although I have told them its due to a traffic accident not caused by me. I'm not sure if rating was the decision but banks never tell you the reason. So none of us here would know how come our applications were rejected.

The formula for DTI is [(Unsecured+Secured Outstanding) + 5% buffer] / NOA. Banks prefer the NOA after I applied and heard from so many banks.

Banks also will not tell you the upper limit. So far HSBC, Maybank, SCB have not mentioned a ceiling when I asked them. BOC did tell me at some point that if you have a worse rating the DTI will be lesser.

The only way we can do is simply to try with the banks. The upper limit is not disclosed at all....that of course makes it harder. But i can sum up from earlier comments that local banks will take in >12x but <16x.

Overseas bank will tell you it doesn't matter.

DTI includes the 5% buffer.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top