Debt consolidation Plan

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jojodespo

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
589
Reaction score
3
Oh.. I thought DMP approval is much higher than DCP?

if I guess it correctly, dmp chances is like 1 out of hundreds. Imagine every week so many attending the talks, how many actually can get into the plan. Some I think don't even have chance to meetup with the counsellor, its too many people already. Let's say one is lucky to get into the plan, he or she can complete the dmp or not. 3 yrs plan already struggling, don't need to mention 5 yrs or even 8 yrs. Few years down the road, we might get to see the figure on how those on dcp getting on.;)
 

Izumi8

Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2003
Messages
375
Reaction score
5
CCS will filter out those "low chance" case, eg salary 2K, but debt is 100k.

CCS WILL ONLY submit good case for approval.
 

Jojodespo

Senior Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
589
Reaction score
3
DRS would be a public record correct? Means tour employment will know about it, and government has the right to withdraw your HDB?

Try going for the talk and see the crowd there. Also you can try Google on the success rate for finishing the repayment. Fyi other countries also have DMP/dcp, many in same debt situation also. If the success rate for completion is very very low, I wonder what those debtors doing if eventually they can't finish the repayment after the years. Maybe the only way is DRS where no full payment needed.
 

sgman88

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2016
Messages
12,171
Reaction score
1,144
Oh.. I thought DMP approval is much higher than DCP?

Why not try going for the talk and see the crowd there. Also you can try Google on the success rate for finishing the repayment. Fyi other countries also have DMP/dcp, many in same debt situation also. If let's say the success rate for completion is very very low, I wonder what those debtors doing if eventually they can't finish the repayment after the years. Maybe the only way is DRS where i think no full payment is needed.
 

oceanicmanta

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
9,672
Reaction score
1,382
@jojodespo

There is no harm approaching and starting the CCS process. CCS staff carry out their work professionally without vested interest.

I helped my relative throughout his CCS process over 2 months.

Yes, there were many applicants. I can also tell you for a fact that there are also MANY SUCCESSFUL applicants going by the several sessions of full classroom for successful applicants.

My relative was also meeting min. payments monthly, yet his DMP was also approved.

So, whether u see half full bottle of milk or half empty, it's up to you.

I believe CCS looks at the applicant's ability to stick to the proposed repayment plan. Whether person has stable job with stable income, employment history etc, are important considerations (my relative is self-employed, own business for over 10 years).

Family financial background may not play a big part (my relative's spouse is high income).

Lifestyle may be a factor (my relative leads simple life with low cost)

Be open and truthful to CCS and they will do their best to help.
 
Last edited:

sgman88

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2016
Messages
12,171
Reaction score
1,144
DRS would be a public record correct? Means tour employment will know about it, and government has the right to withdraw your HDB?

Ya, I try Google and understand DRS is in public record. I also don't understand how they want the debtors to make payment if the employers know about it and when they have hard time getting a job after that, this is what makes me confused.
 

sgman88

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2016
Messages
12,171
Reaction score
1,144
If the figure is true , ur DMP already approve in priciple , provided that ur salary is around there excluding bonus , u are employ but not self employ ,and also don't own other property besides the hdb u are staying.

Normally this type, very high successful rate in completing the DMP. Just need take up 3 yrs n u r on the right track to debt free again. Some will take their yr end bonus dump in, just need two yrs, everything settled. But if u r married n got yourself a lazy or a gcp, good luck on the hard time during periods of repayment. U will be both side asking for money or else sue u bankruptcy or the other ones get arrested n thrown in prison.
 

Izumi8

Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2003
Messages
375
Reaction score
5
@jojodespo

There is no harm approaching and starting the CCS process. CCS staff carry out their work professionally without vested interest.

I helped my relative throughout his CCS process over 2 months.
HI oceanicmanta,
I have PM you about DMP. Pls check. Look like CCS unlikely to submit my case.
Do you know when need to start paying the first instalment?
 
Last edited:

seeklightsoon

Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2017
Messages
488
Reaction score
65
HI oceanicmanta,
I have PM you about DMP. Pls check. Look like CCS unlikely to submit my case.
Do you know when need to start paying the first instalment?

Have you attended the "clearance" session? The clearance session is the session held after your counselling session? In this clearance session there will be around 10-20 pax and will be given your own debt payment plan and for you to verify and sign the agreement. Once you signed the agreement, this is to give consent for you to submit the proposal to the banks for review.

At this stage, you will be told when you need to make your first instalment based on your proposal. The payment date is likely to be either 8th of 18th of each month based on your salary.

Once the banks have accepted your proposal, you will be given a letter to sign or go down to their office to sign loan agreement. At this stage, you may be shared a different amount (a few dollars higher or lower due to rounding and/or accumulated interest) to repay as well as the payment due date. Some banks have their own internal due date when may differ from that given from CCS.

For me, mine is 8th for most banks, except for some banks where it is a few days earlier. It is currently a struggle for me as I have a loan from licensed moneylender which CCS can't take that into consideration in terms of the loan repayment amount as they say that they can offer to keep my repayment schedule to 8 years only. As such, I am just struggling to cut corners here and there to survive till Q1 next year where I will fully repay my licensed moneylender loan and then my repayment schedule proposed by CCS will not be that stressful for me and hopefully i will then be able to pay off in less than 8 years.

If you may need to travel for work, you may wish to apply for debit card first before your proposal is submitted to bank. Once banks start to approve your credit card, and I tried to apply for debit card with the Bank that I have credit cards with, it is being rejected.

All the best.
 

hclee01

Master Member
Joined
Nov 5, 2003
Messages
4,007
Reaction score
333
Why debit card need to apply? Now all bank atm card also act like debit card is it?

Nope. It depends if you have been issued a ATM card or debit card at point of account opening.

ATM card can only be used to make cash withdrawal and NETS service only. If you need to have a debit card to use for hotel to take a deposit when you check-in, you will need a debit or credit card.

You can refer to the website here for the differences:

https://www.ocbc.com/personal-banking/cards/yes-debit-card.html

http://www.uob.com.sg/personal/cards/debit-cards/uob-debit-card.page
 

MoDiE

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 15, 2000
Messages
8,399
Reaction score
36
First step is to cancel all credit cards and use cash. Credit card is useful to get rebates and don't owe the card $. I know ppl who rather get rebates and pay interest coz they "earn" the rebates... stupid mentality. No rebates that I know of will be more than the prevailing credit card interest of at least 24% p.a. one.
 

Izumi8

Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2003
Messages
375
Reaction score
5
Have you attended the "clearance" session? The clearance session is the session held after your counselling session? I
If you may need to travel for work, you may wish to apply for debit card first before your proposal is submitted to bank. Once banks start to approve your credit card, and I tried to apply for debit card with the Bank that I have credit cards with, it is being rejected.

All the best.

You got my PM? I am going for 1st time next week. ALL the credit cards will be cancelled immediately (next day?) after one to one counselling? I also have to sort out the debit cards issues before tat.
 

seeklightsoon

Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2017
Messages
488
Reaction score
65
You got my PM? I am going for 1st time next week. ALL the credit cards will be cancelled immediately (next day?) after one to one counselling? I also have to sort out the debit cards issues before tat.

Didn't receive any PM.
From my experience, it is cancelled after you have attended the "clearance" session. However, after the one-to-one counselling, I believe the counsellor would have advised you not to use your credit cards as it will affect your repayment plan computation.

For most banks the debit card can be issued immediately at the Branch. So you can head out to the branches to apply.
 

Izumi8

Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2003
Messages
375
Reaction score
5
Didn't receive any PM.
From my experience, it is cancelled after you have attended the "clearance" session. However, after the one-to-one counselling, I believe the counsellor would have advised you not to use your credit cards as it will affect your repayment plan computation.

For most banks the debit card can be issued immediately at the Branch. So you can head out to the branches to apply.

You mean group session? I just sent the PM. CC mostly cannot use anymore. suspended already
 
Last edited:

oceanicmanta

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
9,672
Reaction score
1,382
You got my PM? I am going for 1st time next week. ALL the credit cards will be cancelled immediately (next day?) after one to one counselling? I also have to sort out the debit cards issues before tat.

A brief timeline :
- attend Compulsory Group Session
- Submit "Blue Form" ie the DMP application form
- about 2-3 weeks later, One on One Session with Counsellor scheduled
- after this session, the DMP proposal is reviewed internally. If internal DMP management supports it, the proposal will be forwarded to the banks. If the banks approval (by majority vote), then respective banks will take own action to suspend Credit facilities
- another 2 weeks, Group Session with approved DMP applicants scheduled
- the first DMP payment would be due anytime within the next 1 month of Group Session. In the meantime, all monthly CC payments still have to be paid up until the agreed first DMP monthly payment date
 

Izumi8

Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2003
Messages
375
Reaction score
5
A brief timeline :
- the first DMP payment would be due anytime within the next 1 month of Group Session. In the meantime, all monthly CC payments still have to be paid up until the agreed first DMP monthly payment date

Based on your case study, may I know if the self employ NOA is after 20% CPF deduction?

Lets compare the following scenario:

Salaried employee with 4 months bonus, NOA is 100k, after CPF 20% deduction nett income is 80K, if exclude the 4 month bonus only left 60K?

VS

self employ 80K. (assume voluntary CPF deduction $6480), nett $73.5k

So a salaried employee (with 4 month bonus) NOA 100K CCS use 60k to calculate avg income,?

but a self employ person CCS can use $73.5K? even though if compare gross to gross salaried employee earned 20k more?

In this case, the salaried employee got penalized ? Or my calculation of avg income somehow wrong?
 
Last edited:

oceanicmanta

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
9,672
Reaction score
1,382
@izumi - dont get too bogged down with calculations & guess work at this point.

My relative also had reservations and dragging his feet to initiate CCS process.

Cant worry about things beyond our control. Take the first step.

When u discuss with CCS, things will be clear.
 

sgman88

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2016
Messages
12,171
Reaction score
1,144
Suddenly many ppl interested in DMP instead of choosing dcp , in fact dmp more easier to get approve and interest @3% only , but the disadvantage is perhaps can't apply anymore credit card in future even dmp is completed ,unless the record in credit bureau has been cleaned off which take few year , but that also very doubt coz the bank we owe will have their own record , but after 'see ghost also scared dark' , better no credit card forever.

See so many posted they were rejected by the banks for DCP. So by looking at the failure rate of ppl here applying for DCP, the only way they can go is DMP.
Since DCP is to help debtors pay back their debts to the banks and to avoid bankruptcy, but it makes no sense that many are seems being rejected by the banks for no apparent reason.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top