Disruption for uk uni?

Weezykhaled

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2016
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Hi I've got a place in a uk university as I studied there prior to enlistment. However I enlisted in January this year and ORD at the start of January 2018. Uk uni starts at the end of September and I was wondering if it was possible to disrupt for uni so that I can start sept 2017? I've read you can disrupt up to 3 months before ord but its pretty sticky for overseas unis. Thanks! Would really help if anyone has any info as my place in uni is held for 2 years as well and I am not guranteed a place if I apply in 2018.
 

pikafunk3

Banned
Joined
Apr 28, 2013
Messages
37,820
Reaction score
4,624
first, you need to decide if you want to disrupt or not. some people dont like to do NS after studies. its a very crappy feeling. but i understand you want to save 1 year of your life.

if you are sure you want to disrupt, you can APPLY for it.

there is no guarantee it will be approved. so dont assume that it will definitely go through.

in the worst case scenario, your education will just be delayed for a year, at least u wont have to worry about NS AFTER your studies.

life's like that for a singaporean male.
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,387
Reaction score
5,903
Hi I've got a place in a uk university as I studied there prior to enlistment. However I enlisted in January this year and ORD at the start of January 2018. Uk uni starts at the end of September and I was wondering if it was possible to disrupt for uni so that I can start sept 2017? I've read you can disrupt up to 3 months before ord but its pretty sticky for overseas unis. Thanks! Would really help if anyone has any info as my place in uni is held for 2 years as well and I am not guranteed a place if I apply in 2018.
There are a batch of people who did JC in Singapore also enlist in January, so they will ORD in January and they still need to wait till Sep/Oct of 2018 to matriculate... So you can go figure the answer...
 
Joined
Jun 14, 2016
Messages
132
Reaction score
0
Hi I've got a place in a uk university as I studied there prior to enlistment. However I enlisted in January this year and ORD at the start of January 2018. Uk uni starts at the end of September and I was wondering if it was possible to disrupt for uni so that I can start sept 2017? I've read you can disrupt up to 3 months before ord but its pretty sticky for overseas unis. Thanks! Would really help if anyone has any info as my place in uni is held for 2 years as well and I am not guranteed a place if I apply in 2018.

Probably not. You can read from the MINDEF website that the purpose of disruption is to ensure cohort equity but almost all JC students who enlist in the earlier parts of the year will matriculate at the same time compared to poly students.
 

Weezykhaled

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2016
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
There are a batch of people who did JC in Singapore also enlist in January, so they will ORD in January and they still need to wait till Sep/Oct of 2018 to matriculate... So you can go figure the answer...




Thing is thats if you go by the singapore system, if you compare the years lost with my uk counterparts theyd have already completed all 3 years of undergraduate before i go in in sept 2018. And my concern is that my place won't be held till 2018 as the university already told me that they can't guarantee they'll keep my place till then, they can only hold it for 2 years. Thus if i go in sept 2017 I'd have slightly under 3 months of ns left which fits perfectly into the summer break I can complete when im back.
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,387
Reaction score
5,903
Thing is thats if you go by the singapore system, if you compare the years lost with my uk counterparts theyd have already completed all 3 years of undergraduate before i go in in sept 2018. And my concern is that my place won't be held till 2018 as the university already told me that they can't guarantee they'll keep my place till then, they can only hold it for 2 years. Thus if i go in sept 2017 I'd have slightly under 3 months of ns left which fits perfectly into the summer break I can complete when im back.
Well firstly you are not a British, that's the reason why you have to serve NS in the first place, hence your point about comparing with your British counterparts is moot.

Secondly, you are already lucky that they can hold it for 2 years. unless things changed or I heard wrongly, I was told they can only hold it for one, so those guys in NS have to apply in their second year of NS to keep their place.

The thing about disruption is such that those people who are from the same cohort aren't disadvantaged by the fact that they enlisted with the second batch.

For the UK/US/SG system where school year starts in July-October period, a good example will be those from POLY. They will enlist either June or around September from what I know. Those people who enlist in June will ORD in time for their school year, whereas those who enlist in sept wouldn't hence they can disrupt so that they wouldn't lose out to those peers in the same cohort as them but enlisted earlier.

For those in JC, the AUS/NZ system will be a good example. School starts around Feb? Those who enlist in Jan will ORD in time, those enlist in April. Hence they can disrupt.

Since you don't fall into either of these category, you can convince us as much as you want here, but we aren't the decision maker, so there's no point in trying to convince us.

If you so wish, you can go AWOL.
 

Weezykhaled

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2016
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Well firstly you are not a British, that's the reason why you have to serve NS in the first place, hence your point about comparing with your British counterparts is moot.

Secondly, you are already lucky that they can hold it for 2 years. unless things changed or I heard wrongly, I was told they can only hold it for one, so those guys in NS have to apply in their second year of NS to keep their place.

The thing about disruption is such that those people who are from the same cohort aren't disadvantaged by the fact that they enlisted with the second batch.

For the UK/US/SG system where school year starts in July-October period, a good example will be those from POLY. They will enlist either June or around September from what I know. Those people who enlist in June will ORD in time for their school year, whereas those who enlist in sept wouldn't hence they can disrupt so that they wouldn't lose out to those peers in the same cohort as them but enlisted earlier.

For those in JC, the AUS/NZ system will be a good example. School starts around Feb? Those who enlist in Jan will ORD in time, those enlist in April. Hence they can disrupt.

Since you don't fall into either of these category, you can convince us as much as you want here, but we aren't the decision maker, so there's no point in trying to convince us.

If you so wish, you can go AWOL.




Erm not here to argue but firstly I'm a pr, i lived and studied in britain and thus my former classmates and neighbors are definitely considered my counterparts in my opinion.
Second my concern is that if i do not disrupt and apply for uni in sept 2018 my place there is not guaranteed as my the uni already told me they cant keep my place till 2018. Thus it would be a pretty bad waste if after finishing ns my qualifications aren't valid and I can't enter university while all my peers have already completed their undergraduate studies.
What I'm wondering is whether it's possible to appeal or something? Cos disrupting for that 2.5-3 months would really help solve this issue and i can finish the remaining during the summer break in june 2018.
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,387
Reaction score
5,903
Just letting you know in advance that it's pointless to trying to convince any of us here. We can only point you in a certain direction.

Well the point is you are a PR and you have to serve. Hence it doesn't matter where you grew up and whom you grew up with. The law applies equally to everyone regardless of their locale. Had you not have to serve, then the problem of not being on par with your British counterparts wouldn't be an issue anymore. The part about why PR should serve is besides the point here. Cause your parents had the option not to apply PR for you but they did knowing the consequences. Hence, it's probably too bad for you. If you want to find someone to blame, you know who to go to.

Well you are not the only one with the issue where universities cannot hold your place for more than 2 years. Hence, every male who has to serve and are in similar situation as you will face the same problem, then you are not disadvantaged. Your British counterparts are not the concern of the government cause they cannot control them. They can only control what they control.

Well think of it this way, if they grant you your appeal, it will open pandora Box and set a precedent and they have to grant everybody else in similar situation as you, i.e. missing matriculation by 2.5-3 months disruption.
 

elnewbie

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2015
Messages
2,118
Reaction score
1
Can't your leave days plus the 3 months disruption cover this sufficiently ??

Hi I've got a place in a uk university as I studied there prior to enlistment. However I enlisted in January this year and ORD at the start of January 2018. Uk uni starts at the end of September and I was wondering if it was possible to disrupt for uni so that I can start sept 2017? I've read you can disrupt up to 3 months before ord but its pretty sticky for overseas unis. Thanks! Would really help if anyone has any info as my place in uni is held for 2 years as well and I am not guranteed a place if I apply in 2018.
 

Magickiller9

Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 15, 2010
Messages
6,451
Reaction score
0
Can't your leave days plus the 3 months disruption cover this sufficiently ??

lol off cannot go oversea. Only leave. 14 days not enough de. He just have to suck it up. Going in 2017 means he's 1 year earlier than current batch which isn't allowed
 

elnewbie

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2015
Messages
2,118
Reaction score
1
In that case, can't he skip the first week of school ? I'm not sure about UK system but for US system, skipping the first week of school is still ok and one can still catch up during the semester.

lol off cannot go oversea. Only leave. 14 days not enough de. He just have to suck it up. Going in 2017 means he's 1 year earlier than current batch which isn't allowed
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,387
Reaction score
5,903
Can't your leave days plus the 3 months disruption cover this sufficiently ??
In that case, can't he skip the first week of school ? I'm not sure about UK system but for US system, skipping the first week of school is still ok and one can still catch up during the semester.
the problem is he almost certainly wouldn't meet the criteria to disrupt.
Yea definitely, thats the question, whether they can let me disrupt for 3 months
You almost certainly can't meet the criteria for disruption. But that doesn't not preclude you from trying. But had you read what I said, you probably should be mentally prepared of the worse case scenario.
 

Weezykhaled

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2016
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
the problem is he almost certainly wouldn't meet the criteria to disrupt.

You almost certainly can't meet the criteria for disruption. But that doesn't not preclude you from trying. But had you read what I said, you probably should be mentally prepared of the worse case scenario.


Yea I guess, no harm trying. Thanks guys!
 

pikafunk3

Banned
Joined
Apr 28, 2013
Messages
37,820
Reaction score
4,624
you are a PR here, that means your parents were the original immigrants.

why still talk about the UK when you will spend most of your life here?

unless of course you decided to leave for the uk, then you wont be doing NS in the first place.
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,387
Reaction score
5,903
you are a PR here, that means your parents were the original immigrants.

why still talk about the UK when you will spend most of your life here?

unless of course you decided to leave for the uk, then you wont be doing NS in the first place.
He didn't give up his PR in time hence need to serve lor
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top