Don't be so hard up over Return.

ValueInvestor

Banned
Joined
Jul 2, 2015
Messages
5,252
Reaction score
1
this kinda market , hard to get capital gains LOL

can only collect dividends and interests hehehe

SSB is good ^^
 

Some-one

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
52,829
Reaction score
3,803
If you are not hard up for returns, why do you invest? By the way, returns mean capital appreciation + dividends.
 

wahkao3

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2005
Messages
26,802
Reaction score
24
Why u copy my "dont be hard up" trade mark??

actually hor, I disagree. We must be hard up over return
 

coolhead

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2007
Messages
52,590
Reaction score
13,704
Allow me to offer a personal advice: In times of recession, the best return is cash. We should look at returns and each circumstance and I think we are looking at recession soon. Save the money, u won't gain much by investing even in this dip. There are alot of financial stresses in china, countries which depend on oil for revenue and heavily indebted entities. The Fed may not be able to force the rates down much longer as fed treasury as debt does not become monetized and investors chase for higher returns. Hence, fed will eventually forced by this market circumstance to increase interest rates.
 

GiraffeValue

Banned
Joined
May 24, 2015
Messages
437
Reaction score
0
Would love to hear your reason. I guess u mean short term gains?

I mean 2-3 years actually

The reason why I said that is because, investment returns are not something that we have control over. And to get so hard up on something that is beyond our control will invite a lot of unnecessary pains in our investing journey.

What we can do is to make sure that we make the best investing decision out of it.

Moreover, market underperformance for 2-3 years are normal even for the legendary investors.

The problem I see is that if investor gets too hard up over returns. Let's use STI ETF 7% CAGR over the past 10 years as an example.

The investors who are so hard up on that would expect to see his investment to gain 7% next year.

What if it doesn't happen? What if it only achieve a mere 1%. Or down 5%. The amount of pain he suffers will be a lot isn't it.

And when investors lost his temperance. You'd probably guessed what happens next.
 

Shiny Things

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2009
Messages
9,605
Reaction score
854
Allow me to offer a personal advice: In times of recession, the best return is cash. We should look at returns and each circumstance and I think we are looking at recession soon. Save the money, u won't gain much by investing even in this dip.

This seems counterintuitive. Singaporean stocks are off 20% or so from their recent highs - are you saying future returns are going to be lower when you buy the stock 20% cheaper?

There are alot of financial stresses in china, countries which depend on oil for revenue and heavily indebted entities. The Fed may not be able to force the rates down much longer as fed treasury as debt does not become monetized and investors chase for higher returns. Hence, fed will eventually forced by this market circumstance to increase interest rates.

Also not to be blunt, but this doesn't make sense. The Fed isn't going to be "forced" to increase interest rates if long rates go higher; and the argument that "oh blah blah debt becoming monetised therefore treasury yields will skyrocket" hasn't worked for three years; I'm not sure what's going to make it start working now.

(That said, I don't disagree with the view - I think long-term Treasury yields are headed higher, I'd be astonished if they didn't. I just don't think it's going to be a Zerohedgian meltdown.)
 

Perisher

Greater Supremacy Member
Deluxe Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2015
Messages
84,156
Reaction score
10,088
Last edited:

coolhead

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2007
Messages
52,590
Reaction score
13,704
This seems counterintuitive. Singaporean stocks are off 20% or so from their recent highs - are you saying future returns are going to be lower when you buy the stock 20% cheaper?



Also not to be blunt, but this doesn't make sense. The Fed isn't going to be "forced" to increase interest rates if long rates go higher; and the argument that "oh blah blah debt becoming monetised therefore treasury yields will skyrocket" hasn't worked for three years; I'm not sure what's going to make it start working now.

(That said, I don't disagree with the view - I think long-term Treasury yields are headed higher, I'd be astonished if they didn't. I just don't think it's going to be a Zerohedgian meltdown.)

To the first paragraph, because you will gain more by buying when it goes lower.

On 2nd paragraph, I didn't clarify this statement but the Fed is only able to influence short term rates the most. Long term rates are mostly out of their reach. Hence, the Fed will not be able to forced down short term interest rates any longer.

Actually, I wrote that debt not becoming monetized instead of debt becoming monetized.
 

limster

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2000
Messages
13,147
Reaction score
4,134
To the first paragraph, because you will gain more by buying when it goes lower.

In other words you are predicting that the prices of shares will be lower tomorrow than it is today.

Obviously, if you are 100% confident in your prediction, then you should be in 100% cash.

Before we follow your advice, we need to know, what is the method you use to predict that the prices of shares will be lower tomorrow compared to today? FA, TA or ???? Then we can see the credibility of your prediction/analysis.


Similar, what is the method you use and what are the indicators that you rely on to tell you that it is time to buy, and following your logic of being in 100% cash because market is going down, your strategy will be to immediately go from 100% cash to 100% equities overnight based on some magic indicator?
 

coolhead

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2007
Messages
52,590
Reaction score
13,704
In other words you are predicting that the prices of shares will be lower tomorrow than it is today.

Obviously, if you are 100% confident in your prediction, then you should be in 100% cash.

Before we follow your advice, we need to know, what is the method you use to predict that the prices of shares will be lower tomorrow compared to today? FA, TA or ???? Then we can see the credibility of your prediction/analysis.


Similar, what is the method you use and what are the indicators that you rely on to tell you that it is time to buy, and following your logic of being in 100% cash because market is going down, your strategy will be to immediately go from 100% cash to 100% equities overnight based on some magic indicator?
I don't invest in Singapore or Asian equities. I'm now only 40% in US equities and 60% cash. I'm just sharing my opinion, not asking people to follow my advice lol...
However, as the focus now is on Singapore market, the first correct assumption to make is that Singapore is a small open economy. I don't use Ta. The fa i use here will be more of global/regional economic fundamentals instead of stock specific/index specific fundamentals.
Being a small open economy means Singapore will feel the first impact of any economy slowdown. I didnt take into account the recent downward revision in Singapore's gdp but that is one of the indicators that the world economy is not doing well.
There is also a commodities slump which is a signal that there is no demand for electricity or raw materials to meet new economic demand and infrastructure. And china is a major source of demand for these commodities. Just to share an interesting fact that in July this year, electrical demand for china's secondary industry dropped 0.5 and heavy industry dropped 0.9%. Yet china acclaims 7% economic growth. While commodities can be stored, electricity cannot be stored and imo, one of the most objective indicators around. Was there supposed to be a sudden transition/increase in manufacturing to services industry? I doubt so. So it leaves me to doubt the 7% figure. In addition, for china to unwind the overcapacity will take time before its economic can improve again.
Secondly, the impending rate hike would drive capital out of Asian markets like china and perhaps Singapore into US.
Now the next factor im going to bring in will aggravate the economic recession if it takes place: Singapore's population bubble. Singapore's big increase in population drove economic growth by positioning itself as a land of economic opportunity.but there is none of this vision when Singapore is in recession. And im taking a gamble here that corporations will be forced to retrench foreigners instead of singaporeans, aided by the govt's policy, which will result in significant amounts of foreigners leaving Singapore. This will not bode well for rental markets amongst other methods of expenditure by these foreigners into the market. Hence, I will expect higher levels of defaults and npls whereby banking stocks will be one of the hardest hit. I gtg work now, will update more this evening.
 

Shiny Things

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2009
Messages
9,605
Reaction score
854
I don't invest in Singapore or Asian equities. I'm now only 40% in US equities and 60% cash. I'm just sharing my opinion, not asking people to follow my advice lol...
However, as the focus now is on Singapore market, the first correct assumption to make is that Singapore is a small open economy. I don't use Ta. The fa i use here will be more of global/regional economic fundamentals instead of stock specific/index specific fundamentals.
Being a small open economy means Singapore will feel the first impact of any economy slowdown. I didnt take into account the recent downward revision in Singapore's gdp but that is one of the indicators that the world economy is not doing well.

OK, so your argument is that "buying when the economy is good and stock prices are high" is better than "buying when the economy is weak and stock prices are lower". I mean, I still disagree - when everyone else is panicking and selling is when you should be buying with both hands - but that's a fair point.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top