EV caught fire inside Sin Ming workshop (Porsche Taycan)

Comage

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
9,950
Reaction score
3,240
Is the car a total write off?

Workshop have to compensate owner new car?
So for this question, I would personally say - yes, it should be a write off.

Workshop / insurance would never compensate owner a new car (I don't think got so good). They will only compensate the "paper value" of what's remaining of the car.

Which most likely is according to prices of what the guy paid for back then - and wouldn't really be sufficient to buy anything at today's car prices.

Still recall that AMK carpark fire where that lady owner got her car with a couple years COE remaining get burnt down by another car that caught fire - she suck thumb end up still had to fork out some money after minus off all the costs of towing etc...

Only if you're lucky then you will get back "a replacement car".
 

koster

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
11,129
Reaction score
3,792
Really hope insurance companies or LTA or SCDF can come out and share what's the cause of such fire, else people will just speculate.
 

EJB

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
May 24, 2001
Messages
53,349
Reaction score
9,683
So for this question, I would personally say - yes, it should be a write off.

Workshop / insurance would never compensate owner a new car (I don't think got so good). They will only compensate the "paper value" of what's remaining of the car.

Which most likely is according to prices of what the guy paid for back then - and wouldn't really be sufficient to buy anything at today's car prices.

Still recall that AMK carpark fire where that lady owner got her car with a couple years COE remaining get burnt down by another car that caught fire - she suck thumb end up still had to fork out some money after minus off all the costs of towing etc...

Only if you're lucky then you will get back "a replacement car".
Workshops has insurance else how they cover the car when it's in their premise?

However, like you say, old for new doesn't apply to the workshop, they pay as per car value, old for new is only under the personal insurance of the driver.

EV is goner when burn, no need to talk old for new.
 

Comage

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
9,950
Reaction score
3,240
Workshops has insurance else how they cover the car when it's in their premise?

However, like you say, old for new doesn't apply to the workshop, they pay as per car value, old for new is only under the personal insurance of the driver.

EV is goner when burn, no need to talk old for new.
Would be real funny if the workshop has to settle privately with the car owner due to the claims being bounced.

But we will never know as our local journalists never has the balls to chase the story to the ends of the world.

The way these workshops work, if I am the assessor, I would simply reject all their claims.

This incident clearly is due to human error.
 

EJB

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
May 24, 2001
Messages
53,349
Reaction score
9,683
Would be real funny if the workshop has to settle privately with the car owner due to the claims being bounced.

But we will never know as our local journalists never has the balls to chase the story to the ends of the world.

The way these workshops work, if I am the assessor, I would simply reject all their claims.

This incident clearly is due to human error.
Somebody has to pay... the taycan owner is the richest in this scenario...
 

Comage

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
9,950
Reaction score
3,240
Somebody has to pay... the taycan owner is the richest in this scenario...
After seeing that Taycan uncle purchasing the used tyres and then crying foul on his rejected insurance claim for skidding and crashing into the roadside in that incident a while back... I think we can't say that they are all the "richest" anymore... Lol.

The real rich Porsche owners certainly wouldn't do such nonsense like buying used tyres. Or sending their vehicles to this unheard of workshop for Porsche servicing.
 
Last edited:

koster

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
11,129
Reaction score
3,792
Taycan is my dream car but it's always in the news for the wrong reason - car shaking in mscp, used tyres and this incident now.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top