Fundsupermart's FSMOne $8.8 flat fees

peppermint7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2018
Messages
5,605
Reaction score
676
Don't think any broker is absorbing sgx clearing fees. If you do, let me know!
Yala i was dreaming. I thought FSM so good cos i saw a table they put out (from 1st page of app the Sg60 promo in Red Banner) and they state investment amount from 15k to 250k
Flat Fee $8.80. Savings range from $3.20 to $693.20
 

twosix

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2000
Messages
26,890
Reaction score
7,099
When i saw your post, i immediately thought of FSMOne pricing page and how they advertised themselves as i expected that to be a common misconception / mistake that they only charge 8.8.
In this scenario, i would think that Tiger has a better charges / fee page with everything listed properly and which charge is by who.

Yes. Ignoring the SGX fees and that FSMOne fees are fixed, tiger fees will increase as you buy more.
U mean tiger is cheaper than fsmone?
 

peppermint7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2018
Messages
5,605
Reaction score
676
When i saw your post, i immediately thought of FSMOne pricing page and how they advertised themselves as i expected that to be a common misconception / mistake that they only charge 8.8.
In this scenario, i would think that Tiger has a better charges / fee page with everything listed properly and which charge is by who.

Yes. Ignoring the SGX fees and that FSMOne fees are fixed, tiger fees will increase as you buy more.
Tiger is still ok for SGX trades as now they give us free comms. But for US trades i prefer Moo as the rates will jump for Tiger especially Moo platform fee is 99c PER ORDER
Tiger Commission and Platform Fee is charged by PER SHARE. The pain will come if one trades penny stocks in big volumes.

For Sg stocks, it is good to use FSM if intend to trade $20k and above lets say Tiger stops their free comms. I suspect Tiger started to give free comms this month to lure ppl back to trade with them esp they now stop the quarterly fees which switched many off previously.
 
Last edited:

sibeiTrolled

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
1,345
Reaction score
1,013
U mean tiger is cheaper than fsmone?
Assuming we ignore the exchange fees which includes the 0.35 SI agent and clearing fee. We can work backwards to find the break point where by FSMOne is the "cheaper" broker based on fees pre-GST.

For tiger commission and platform fee of 0.03% each, i would combine them together since the end result cost is the same.

8.8 SGD / 0.06 % = 14,666.67 SGD
So if your order value exceeds the above amount, FSMOne likely is cheaper based on this quick calculation.
If not, Tiger could be the better choice for lower amount.
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
64,634
Reaction score
5,315
When i saw your post, i immediately thought of FSMOne pricing page and how they advertised themselves as i expected that to be a common misconception / mistake that they only charge 8.8.
In this scenario, i would think that Tiger has a better charges / fee page with everything listed properly and which charge is by who.

Yes. Ignoring the SGX fees and that FSMOne fees are fixed, tiger fees will increase as you buy more.
IBKR I thought quite good?

the thing about tiger is if u no longer hold SGX stocks and don’t trade I think got some fee right?
 

peppermint7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2018
Messages
5,605
Reaction score
676
the thing about tiger is if u no longer hold SGX stocks and don’t trade I think got some fee right
Tiger is still ok for SGX trades as now they give us free comms. I suspect Tiger started to give free comms this month to lure ppl back to trade with them esp they now stop the quarterly fees which switched many off previously.
Like i said, Tiger stopped the quarterly fee for good liao. In the past whether you hold or doesn't hold any Sg shares they'll charge you $2+ per quarter. Now they say will stop until further notice. They also throw in Free comms but that one need to ownself go activate it. That is how they can become cheaper than FSM for $20k shares.
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
64,634
Reaction score
5,315
Like i said, Tiger stopped the quarterly fee for good liao. In the past whether you hold or doesn't hold any Sg shares they'll charge you $2+ per quarter. Now they say will stop until further notice. They also throw in Free comms but that one need to ownself go activate it. That is how they can become cheaper than FSM for $20k shares.
oh?! when did they stop? got notice?
 

peppermint7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2018
Messages
5,605
Reaction score
676
oh?! when did they stop? got notice?
Yes. This month. U go into the app see. The banner is there. U go into the banner, they also tell you on top of that, they also give free comms. Got to click the free comms reward card to activate it.

When you pop into Tiger there will also be a pop up that shouts "No Custody Fees & 0 Commission* for SGX Listed Securities!"
It says
No more SGX CDP custody fees for Tiger users - waived until further notice, no additional action required.

It also says
ACTIVATE the reward cards by 17 October 2025 to enjoy Commission Free trading on SGX listed stocks, ETF. REIT, DLC, and SDR thru both Prime and Cash Boost accounts

Along with that there's some campaign for high quantity traders to win some prize.

It's because of this it is cheaper to trade with them for anything $20k and below for SGX listed stocks
 

twosix

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 27, 2000
Messages
26,890
Reaction score
7,099
Too late. I guess many investors like myself sold our sgx shares and moved out of tiger. I'm not going back to them any time soon. Haha.
 

HoGnix

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2006
Messages
1,910
Reaction score
438
Yes. This month. U go into the app see. The banner is there. U go into the banner, they also tell you on top of that, they also give free comms. Got to click the free comms reward card to activate it.

When you pop into Tiger there will also be a pop up that shouts "No Custody Fees & 0 Commission* for SGX Listed Securities!"
It says
No more SGX CDP custody fees for Tiger users - waived until further notice, no additional action required.

It also says
ACTIVATE the reward cards by 17 October 2025 to enjoy Commission Free trading on SGX listed stocks, ETF. REIT, DLC, and SDR thru both Prime and Cash Boost accounts

Along with that there's some campaign for high quantity traders to win some prize.

It's because of this it is cheaper to trade with them for anything $20k and below for SGX listed stocks
May I know, this apply to trading share in CDP, or only for SGX share hold by Tiger?
 

peppermint7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2018
Messages
5,605
Reaction score
676
May I know, this apply to trading share in CDP, or only for SGX share hold by Tiger?
Tiger actually holds whatever shares we trade with them in custodian account and they selected CDP to hold our shares. In the past they hold these custodian shares with DBS if I remember correctly, without charging a single cent. But one day they decided to switch them to CDP and start charging us Quarterly fees though these shares are still UNDER THEIR CUSTODY. i believe many left because of that.

The only economical way for our shares to be in CDP is to buy from DBS Vickers Cash Upfront and sell via FSM sell thru CDP.
 

peppermint7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2018
Messages
5,605
Reaction score
676
Too late. I guess many investors like myself sold our sgx shares and moved out of tiger. I'm not going back to them any time soon. Haha.
I agree they took very long to revert their decision. It is unwise for that in the first place as they charge everyone including those who hold Sg shares there. Inevitably become a burden to have to keep remembering to trade quarterly.
Once i transfered funds into the acc and shocked to see them straight away frozen the amount in the early month of the quarter. Of course i make noise and ask them to wake up to their ideas. Don't be penny wise pound foolish to lose customers like that.
 

highsulphur

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2011
Messages
75,014
Reaction score
38,293
I agree they took very long to revert their decision. It is unwise for that in the first place as they charge everyone including those who hold Sg shares there. Inevitably become a burden to have to keep remembering to trade quarterly.
Once i transfered funds into the acc and shocked to see them straight away frozen the amount in the early month of the quarter. Of course i make noise and ask them to wake up to their ideas. Don't be penny wise pound foolish to lose customers like that.
So far I have no complaints about FSMOne.
 

peppermint7

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2018
Messages
5,605
Reaction score
676
So far I have no complaints about FSMOne.
Indeed if your trade size is big (beyond $25k or so), FSMone is simple and straight forward. But for those who love looking at TA and charts to get the best desired price, then moo and Tiger show better charts.

I love FSM giving us points so i can Change them to small baskets of UT. For now my small baskets grow to $45 already. :ROFLMAO: free money who doesn't like. I have sold some away along the way. Else by now should have more.

I keep them for fun. To look at the direction where the wind blows. Just like 1st August suddenly my whole baskets of 4 UT dips together i know it is something happen that causes mass panic and not due to 1 single fund.
Quite fun to hold them as wind vane.
 

highsulphur

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2011
Messages
75,014
Reaction score
38,293
Indeed if your trade size is big (beyond $25k or so), FSMone is simple and straight forward. But for those who love looking at TA and charts to get the best desired price, then moo and Tiger show better charts.

I love FSM giving us points so i can Change them to small baskets of UT. For now my small baskets grow to $45 already. :ROFLMAO: free money who doesn't like. I have sold some away along the way. Else by now should have more.

I keep them for fun. To look at the direction where the wind blows. Just like 1st August suddenly my whole baskets of 4 UT dips together i know it is something happen that causes mass panic and not due to 1 single fund.
Quite fun to hold them as wind vane.
I recently unwind those UT redeemed from points. Can buy my family a nice meal
 

CrashWire

Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2000
Messages
5,725
Reaction score
702
Tiger is still ok for SGX trades as now they give us free comms. But for US trades i prefer Moo as the rates will jump for Tiger especially Moo platform fee is 99c PER ORDER
Tiger Commission and Platform Fee is charged by PER SHARE. The pain will come if one trades penny stocks in big volumes.
I seem to have a $0 lifetime commission free card in my Tiger account from a referral promo. Just checked a recent US stock trade and I was not charged any commission, just the platform fee.

So Moomoo's flat platform fee is cheaper, but Tiger's options trading is much cheaper for people who trade options.
 

HoGnix

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2006
Messages
1,910
Reaction score
438
Tiger actually holds whatever shares we trade with them in custodian account and they selected CDP to hold our shares. In the past they hold these custodian shares with DBS if I remember correctly, without charging a single cent. But one day they decided to switch them to CDP and start charging us Quarterly fees though these shares are still UNDER THEIR CUSTODY. i believe many left because of that.

The only economical way for our shares to be in CDP is to buy from DBS Vickers Cash Upfront and sell via FSM sell thru CDP.
I am little bit confused about tiger share in CDP holding.
Can I use tiger broker sell my CDP shares which does not bought using tiger broker? Say shares from IPO application.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top