ifixit, ai summary below, can't copy youtube transcript, and don't know the 3 a.m. posted this or not
Google’s Pixel 9 Pro XL: Designing for Durability
Google’s Pixel 9 phones are marketed as durable and sustainable, with a promise of 7 years of software updates. However, despite improvements, these phones can still break. The question is, how repairable are they?
The Teardown
Starting the teardown, I expected a similar construction to past Pixels. The screen opening process seemed smoother, but on closer inspection, I found signs of delamination, which resulted in a broken screen. This type of damage highlights the problem with screen entry designs, which are not ideal for battery replacement.
The back cover removal was less stressful. The exterior shell of the camera bump is incorporated into the cover, making it easier to replace the battery without removing the screen. However, the execution of the dual entry design needs improvement.
Battery Removal
The battery removal process is challenging due to the sliding saw style pull tab mechanism. Despite online guides, it’s not easy to use. After soaking the battery in isopropyl alcohol, I managed to remove it, but not without damaging the heatsink for the screen.
Internal Components
The lower speaker and daughterboard, which now houses the USB-C port, are more approachable. The haptic motor comes away easily, and after removing all visible screws, the mainboard and rear camera assembly are freed.
Camera Assembly
The camera assembly is held in place by three press connectors accessible from the rear side of the mainboard. From left to right, the cameras have a 50-megapixel Samsung ISOCELL GNK sensor, a 48-megapixel Sony IMX858 sensor on the ultrawide, and another 48-megapixel Sony IMX858 sensor on the 5X optical zoom camera.
Increased Durability
Google claims the Pixel 9 increases durability by twofold during drop tests. The internal structure has changed, and CT scans by Lumafield show that the dual entry design provides additional structural rigidity.
Pros and Cons
The Pixel 9 Pro XL has some interesting surprises, but also some drawbacks. The battery removal experience is poor, and the screens are fragile. However, Google’s claims of doubling durability seem true, and the dual entry design increases durability and improves overall repairability.
Repairability Score
Considering these factors, the Google Pixel 9 Pro XL receives a provisional repairability score of 5 out of 10. There’s room for improvement, but Google is showing a genuine desire to design for sustainability.
