Hard Disk Failure?

Cupid Stunt

Banned
Joined
Sep 9, 2021
Messages
83
Reaction score
23
Hello,

My HDD seems to have failed. When I plug it into computers, it only shows up as external drive D:. Is there any way to save it?

If not, do I need to use a data recovery service? How much is that going to cost?
 

existential_reality

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2017
Messages
639
Reaction score
36
Which brand of harddisk is this, is it one of those external ones?

Anyway your best bet is to
- As much as possible try not to move the drive at all, if its a mechanical damage any movement will further degrade the drive. (I.e try to keep the drive in situ as much as possible
- Data recovery if the drive is still functional is no different then getting a recovery software and trying to recover it yourself, the company might have more hardware to place the drive into for extraction but the approach is quite similar
- In a situation where the mechanical parts are damages the cost from what I know is not economically viable (unless you have some million dollar work stuff on it)

Those external type drives are usually stuffed with crappy harddrives and do suffer wear and tear much easier (hence they're so cheap). The 2.5 inch ones are more durable as they are designed to be moved around.

Also if it appears on the computer as D there is still some hope, I would get a good recovery software and try to extract it. Do also note the earlier advise about the noise from the drive.


Hello,

My HDD seems to have failed. When I plug it into computers, it only shows up as external drive D:. Is there any way to save it?

If not, do I need to use a data recovery service? How much is that going to cost?
 

Cupid Stunt

Banned
Joined
Sep 9, 2021
Messages
83
Reaction score
23
Thanks for all the replies

It's a WD external hard disk.

I also have an old HP hard disk that makes sounds when i plug it in, and has very slow write speeds.
The slow speed makes it impossible to copy out most of the data inside, however i believe i have managed to copy out most of the important ones from it (some might be lost I fear).

For this one, I suppose data recovery is the only way?

Also, teach me the best way to to back up my personal data. Please don't recommend a 3-2-1 system or whatever because I'm too cheap and lazy to have so many backups...
 

existential_reality

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2017
Messages
639
Reaction score
36
Hrmm

WD or Seagate external drives are known to give issues after awhile, for your situation I would attempt the data myself (use a spare laptop and just run the recovery software which might take a few days assuming the drive works okay without weird scratchy noises.

For backup its hard to say pending on your data storage, if small just go cloud solutions or get a reputable SSD and stuff the data.

Or if larger capacity you can get a 2 bay USB enclosure and run a Raid 1, This way if one HDD goes down you have the other as a backup. As a Raid 1 the data will copy to 2 drives at once when used.

i.e,
https://www.startech.com/en-us/hdd/s352bu33hr
Thanks for all the replies

It's a WD external hard disk.

I also have an old HP hard disk that makes sounds when i plug it in, and has very slow write speeds.
The slow speed makes it impossible to copy out most of the data inside, however i believe i have managed to copy out most of the important ones from it (some might be lost I fear).

For this one, I suppose data recovery is the only way?

Also, teach me the best way to to back up my personal data. Please don't recommend a 3-2-1 system or whatever because I'm too cheap and lazy to have so many backups...
 

Cupid Stunt

Banned
Joined
Sep 9, 2021
Messages
83
Reaction score
23
Looks like the data cannot be read with Crystaldiskinfo, so I need to send it to data recovery services.

What's a good hard disk i can buy to use for backing up? Don't think i need to go the RAID route. A few terabytes is good enough for me.
 

existential_reality

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2017
Messages
639
Reaction score
36
Depends on how many TB

I would just get a large reliable SSD which should last for yonks

Looks like the data cannot be read with Crystaldiskinfo, so I need to send it to data recovery services.

What's a good hard disk i can buy to use for backing up? Don't think i need to go the RAID route. A few terabytes is good enough for me.
 

pwongkk

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2006
Messages
32,229
Reaction score
16,382
If getting external drives, please avoid WD unless you are fully aware of the consequences of the onboard hardware disk encryption.

I have been using a number of Seagate drives and to date all have worked fine for me. But many will disagree with me LOL.
I agree with you. So far those Seagate drives I had are very stable. I bought a 500gb one from TB for torrenting, expecting it to die off after 1-2 years of usage. Now into the 3rd year still running well.

My other drives are also Seagate. All served me well.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top