Infraction due to constructive religious discussion

mikeoscar

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2012
Messages
7,770
Reaction score
1
http://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/e...ut-homosexuality-sg-4427955.html#post80545325

1st one was an awareness to an ACTUAL existing talk on homosexuality that ACTUALLY happen at the Al-Raudhah mosque on the 26/10/2013 after the Ishyak prayers.

Ar-raudhah Mosque

The thread's intention was to speculate the purpose of the talk and invite those who would want to attend the free tank.

I have personally went for the talk and even recorded the audio of the talk and it is safe to say that the talk was not a violent one and did not promote any form of discrimination. Though I did not agree with some points, the talk was rather compassionate and give their view on the issue of homosexuality.

There are no bigotry involved and no seditious remarks were used.


http://forums.hardwarezone.com.sg/private.php?do=showpm&pmid=13305814

The second infraction was on the talk of an ACTUAL existing hadith that circulated among the muslim community.

The thread showed that some religious school teaches by fear while other chose via logic and compassion. My exchange with Zed was civil and provided some good insight into the different school of thought.

No bigotry was used, no seditious remarks were used and most of the discussion was fact based.



According to EDMW rule,

3 points:
- Copyrights infringement / Piracy
- Forum Nuisance (trolling, impersonation, troublemaker, clone accounts, etc.)
- Inappropriate Language / Insulted Other (s)
- Others
- Posting/Sharing Pornography or related materials
- Posting Racist Comments
- Unsolicited Content (Commercial solicitation / Ads / Referrals / Spam)


Both these threads did not share any sentiment of racism or bigotry but opened an avenue of constructive religious discussion for fellow Singaporean to learn before it was locked by the mod.


If you do not agree with this, I suggest making it a CLEAR forum rule not to discuss ANY religious topics or make it clear not to discuss ANY Islamic topics be it constructive or not.
 

hwzadmin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2005
Messages
28,788
Reaction score
57
Dear Member,

In your first infraction:

You posted

[GPGT] A muslim group is going to give a talk about homosexuality in SG

Wonder if it is going to be a talk about understanding and tolerance towards the gay community or ish going to be a hate talk...?
www.hardwarezone.com.sg - View Single Post - [GPGT] A muslim group is going to give a talk about homosexuality in SG

You implied in the words that are bold that Muslim talks about homosexuality contain the inclination to contain "hate talk".

In your second infraction:

You posted

Women who don't cover their hair are sinners...

During his travel in Israk and Miraj (spiritual world?), Prophet Muhammad saw women being hung by their hairs and fire entered through their anuses and exit through their mouths. Other womens were seen hung by their ankles and their heads burn upon the fires of hell.

Prophet Muhammad then asked the Angel Gabriel what did these women did to receive such torment. The angel answered that these women did not cover their hair while they were alive, allowing men to see them.



Because god is all loving and all forgiving.........
www.hardwarezone.com.sg - View Single Post - Women who don't cover their hair are sinners...
We have reason to correctly assert that your actions are premeditated with the explicit intention to cause unrest and disturbance between different ethnic and religious groups.

We therefore believe that your content violates section 298A of the Penal Code regarding religious/racial harmony.

It goes without saying that the infractions you received are deserved and will not be reversed.

×”
 

Steve Jobs

Banned
Joined
Jun 10, 2010
Messages
1,783
Reaction score
0
I find it interesting that the threadstarter seems to favor starting forum threads about Malays and Muslims.
 

mynameisjon

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 5, 2007
Messages
5,050
Reaction score
1
So hwzadmin is basically saying that you can bash lgbt people, call for their deaths etc, but you cannot EVER insinuate that Islam is completely intolerant of lgbt people.
 

hwzadmin

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2005
Messages
28,788
Reaction score
57
Dear Member,

Thank you for reporting this thread. The comments inside laughing at the demise of calamity-struck and wishing death on others are distasteful and uncalled for. We have removed the thread, but can also assure you that members making untoward remarks will be dealt with.

Nothing do with religion, but this deserves a ban/infraction for the TS anyway.

Eat-Drink-Man-Woman - www.hardwarezone.com.sg[gvgt]-edmw-favourite-news-1000-cockroaches-estimated-floating-water-4452725.html

Dear Member,

Please direct us to the post in the thread you will like us to look into. The first post involves a direct quote, without any opinions stated.

 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top