IPPT, IPT & RT Questions...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Casio2010

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2010
Messages
9,427
Reaction score
829
Is it true that is better to do RT than IPT?

Because the RT is 20 sessions. However, IPT though you are doing 10 Sessions but every year you need to improve your PPT if not you are require to do 8 sessions of RT which is a total of 18 sessions might as well complete the normal RT.
 

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
Is it true that is better to do RT than IPT?

Because the RT is 20 sessions. However, IPT though you are doing 10 Sessions but every year you need to improve your PPT if not you are require to do 8 sessions of RT which is a total of 18 sessions might as well complete the normal RT.

Depends...even if you couldn't improve after 10 IPT sessions, you just need to just do another 8 sessions. Total 18 sessions vs RT 20 sessions.

And IPT starts at 7pm, so less disruptions to work. RT during weekdays would surely mean you have to leave office early.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
Is it true that is better to do RT than IPT?

Because the RT is 20 sessions. However, IPT though you are doing 10 Sessions but every year you need to improve your PPT if not you are require to do 8 sessions of RT which is a total of 18 sessions might as well complete the normal RT.


RT is 4 hrs. IPT is 3 hrs. Do your maths.

If you want more hours in exercising, RT is specially designed for you.

If you never turn up for RT, just pay S$50/session. No sweat. If you miss all, compound with S$1,000 and 5 days free meals in DB. Free security and haircut provided. Best of all... FOC.
 

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
RT is 4 hrs. IPT is 3 hrs. Do your maths.

If you want more hours in exercising, RT is specially designed for you.

If you never turn up for RT, just pay S$50/session. No sweat. If you miss all, compound with S$1,000 and 5 days free meals in DB. Free security and haircut provided. Best of all... FOC.

I'm not too sure if you attended RT before. But RT normally last only 2.5 to 3 hours max and IPT is also about 2.5 hours. Even during NS time, no PT session last for 4 hours. And the PTI also say it's impossible to exercise 3 hours. So technically speaking, the hours is about the same for both.
 
Last edited:

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
I'm not too sure if you attended RT before. But RT normally last only 2.5 to 3 hours max and IPT is also about 2.5 hours. Even during NS time, no PT session last for 4 hours. And the PTI also say it's impossible to exercise 3 hours. So technically speaking, the hours is about the same for both.

I agree unfit people cannot exercise for long. My point is IPT is shorter than IPT and it is designed so on paper.

When I see unfit people walk all the way during RT, we never push you guys to jog or run, did we? But we can make you walk longer for upto 4 hrs. For IPT, we can only make them walk 3 hrs. That's the point. So do not take our kindness for granted.
 

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
I agree unfit people cannot exercise for long. My point is IPT is shorter than IPT and it is designed so on paper.

When I see unfit people walk all the way during RT, we never push you guys to jog or run, did we? But we can make you walk longer for upto 4 hrs. For IPT, we can only make them walk 3 hrs. That's the point. So do not take our kindness for granted.

I believe most people had never experienced 4 hours of RT or your eg pushing people to do 4 hours of walking(which could be potentially be a 20-24km walk based on my route march with fatigue speed), maybe in the older days where RT was held in Tekong, then I don't know.

I believe most people do not take kindness for granted, that's why PTI normally released NSmen earlier than official timing for their efforts.
 

Casio2010

Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2010
Messages
9,427
Reaction score
829
Depends...even if you couldn't improve after 10 IPT sessions, you just need to just do another 8 sessions. Total 18 sessions vs RT 20 sessions.

And IPT starts at 7pm, so less disruptions to work. RT during weekdays would surely mean you have to leave office early.

OK. Sure thanks for the information because i still baffled about the IPT system whereby you need to improve every year for your PPT score.
 

cct75

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,436
Reaction score
0
You are so right. We can make IPT a 20-sessions and RT a 40-sessions to make you guys train harder for your fitness.

Else, 52 sessions for weekly training also not bad. We welcome any ideas to make Singaporeans fitter.

First, if you can suggest that to Goverment and they take it, I bow down to you.

Do you think Singaporeans are so Free? Fitness is up to individual. I am honest to say that I do not train. I do know time is up to individual to allocate and they should never be any excuse of having no time to train since it's our own individual health and not train for other's health.

Still, I dare to say 75% of those (I even dare to say 85-95%) taking RT/IPTs are lazy to train.

In the first place, SAF could have scrap IPT and force peeps to do RTs which is NON-VOLUNTERRING and continue to pay each and every RT NS-men the meager 1/2 day rank pay per session.

To be honest, cost-savings would be one major consideration when SAF implemented IPT else why is it that being "VOLUNTEER" trainings are not being given the incentives of 1/2 day rank pay or even better?

Do whatever you want and end up more Opposition Parties will take over SMC & GRCs :p

To bad that even ICT, SAF cannot hold NS Men per fiscal year of more than 40 days so forcing NS Men to traing every week for 52 weeks is out of the question unless there is no ICT that year :)
 
Last edited:

cct75

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,436
Reaction score
0
You have been told NOT TO BRING camera phone to camp.

If you dun understand, read again.

Yes I know "I have been told not to bring in camera phone to camp" and I fully understand the sentence and what it means but unfortunately, I have been doing so every single RT/IPT/IPPT sessions and even during my ICTs. So how? :D

Also, handphone is no longer a "good to have" item. It's now a "must to have" and being a non Military Personnel or Not-working in Restricted Zone adults, we have our every rights to own a camera phone and now smart phone. I had already stessed ZILLIONTHS time that I bring my camera phone into FCC not to use it. It's just for convenient sake that I can straight out-pro withought having the hassle to retrieve my camera phone from the Guard Post Lockers. There are those who bring in to FCC and use them in Camps, why does not RPs or anyone catch them?

There are non-camera phones still available and they are targeted for Military Personnels and those who works in restricted zone. But why is that I still seing some Regulars using Camera Phones within Restricted Zones?

Don't be naive. Everyone can catch you if you break the rules. No need me to dirty my own hand.

I know "everyone" can catch me if I break the rule. But so far, sadly, no one has caught me as yet.

I even asked my current colleague who used to worked with Nave 3rd Flotila. She said most of them working in Tuas Naval Base still bring in Camera Phones. Of course they have to bare the consquence of sudden spot checks but so far till now she is out of SAF back into non-military life, nothing happened.

And some Chief Clerks who know the RPs better even will not be checked at all.

So, I welcome anyone who is so FREE to come catch my on 7th June, Khatib Camp. I openly said that I will bring in my Camera Phone into the FCC but I am not going to use it while inside FCC. My phone will be either in silent mode or switch off and kept inside my bag at the FCC lockers :D
 
Last edited:

cct75

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,436
Reaction score
0
I believe most people had never experienced 4 hours of RT or your eg pushing people to do 4 hours of walking(which could be potentially be a 20-24km walk based on my route march with fatigue speed), maybe in the older days where RT was held in Tekong, then I don't know.

I believe most people do not take kindness for granted, that's why PTI normally released NSmen earlier than official timing for their efforts.

Actually, there were instances that PTI even wanted to release IPTs earlier than 2 hours but they cannot because of the Incehs. At times, I experienced trainings for maybe an hour or longer and chit-chating for the rest of the period and eventually out-processed slightly longer than 2 hours.

I would say go for RTs if you wanna get the meager 1/2 day Rank Pay and if RT's earlier in-pro of 18:00 does not interrupt your work which you have to leave much earlier compared to 19:00 for IPT.
 

cct75

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,436
Reaction score
0
OK. Sure thanks for the information because i still baffled about the IPT system whereby you need to improve every year for your PPT score.

I guess this was the "backfire" results of SAF implementing IPT couple years ago as it was meant for NS-Men to report later at 19:00 instead of RT's 18:00 and set-up in the mindset that those who opted for IPT will really try and train ourselves up to get better fitness and pass IPPT.

However, it end up that 85-95% of us taking IPT for the sole purpose of fulfilling IPT will excuse us from RT and consider IPPT clearance.

This end up that the "objective" of IPT was not met. So now, SAF enforce some improvement indicators via the PPT bands I guess :D
 

bakasora

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2007
Messages
2,386
Reaction score
934
Can I take the SBJ station without my shoes? (Bare foot)
I know this is stupid, but the tip and back of the sport shoes takes up a few cm.
Which make me just failed. lol
If not can I take IPPT with a normal shoes? Maybe something like tom shoes.
 

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
Can I take the SBJ station without my shoes? (Bare foot)
I know this is stupid, but the tip and back of the sport shoes takes up a few cm.
Which make me just failed. lol
If not can I take IPPT with a normal shoes? Maybe something like tom shoes.

I think it's better to ask the PTI on the spot. If PTI lenient, maybe can. :o
 

stinky_shawn

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2008
Messages
27,017
Reaction score
0
You are so right. We can make IPT a 20-sessions and RT a 40-sessions to make you guys train harder for your fitness.

Else, 52 sessions for weekly training also not bad. We welcome any ideas to make Singaporeans fitter.

aiya why make nsmen train so hard for wat????...use the $$$$ to pay nsmen for going to rt n invest in more those remote control planes or watever thingy better....we no need to march or go so far so no need fitness......just need nimble thumbs.....or do u think u can train to run faster n last longer than a speeding bullet?????
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
First, if you can suggest that to Goverment and they take it, I bow down to you.

Do you think Singaporeans are so Free? Fitness is up to individual. I am honest to say that I do not train. I do know time is up to individual to allocate and they should never be any excuse of having no time to train since it's our own individual health and not train for other's health.

Still, I dare to say 75% of those (I even dare to say 85-95%) taking RT/IPTs are lazy to train.

In the first place, SAF could have scrap IPT and force peeps to do RTs which is NON-VOLUNTERRING and continue to pay each and every RT NS-men the meager 1/2 day rank pay per session.

To be honest, cost-savings would be one major consideration when SAF implemented IPT else why is it that being "VOLUNTEER" trainings are not being given the incentives of 1/2 day rank pay or even better?

Do whatever you want and end up more Opposition Parties will take over SMC & GRCs :p

To bad that even ICT, SAF cannot hold NS Men per fiscal year of more than 40 days so forcing NS Men to traing every week for 52 weeks is out of the question unless there is no ICT that year :)

Till then, enjoy your IPT and RT.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
Yes I know "I have been told not to bring in camera phone to camp" and I fully understand the sentence and what it means but unfortunately, I have been doing so every single RT/IPT/IPPT sessions and even during my ICTs. So how? :D

Also, handphone is no longer a "good to have" item. It's now a "must to have" and being a non Military Personnel or Not-working in Restricted Zone adults, we have our every rights to own a camera phone and now smart phone. I had already stessed ZILLIONTHS time that I bring my camera phone into FCC not to use it. It's just for convenient sake that I can straight out-pro withought having the hassle to retrieve my camera phone from the Guard Post Lockers. There are those who bring in to FCC and use them in Camps, why does not RPs or anyone catch them?

There are non-camera phones still available and they are targeted for Military Personnels and those who works in restricted zone. But why is that I still seing some Regulars using Camera Phones within Restricted Zones?



I know "everyone" can catch me if I break the rule. But so far, sadly, no one has caught me as yet.

I even asked my current colleague who used to worked with Nave 3rd Flotila. She said most of them working in Tuas Naval Base still bring in Camera Phones. Of course they have to bare the consquence of sudden spot checks but so far till now she is out of SAF back into non-military life, nothing happened.

And some Chief Clerks who know the RPs better even will not be checked at all.

So, I welcome anyone who is so FREE to come catch my on 7th June, Khatib Camp. I openly said that I will bring in my Camera Phone into the FCC but I am not going to use it while inside FCC. My phone will be either in silent mode or switch off and kept inside my bag at the FCC lockers :D

Your logic is wrong. For example:

If someone brings drug into Singapore and claimed that he will not use it when he is inside Singapore. Do you buy the story?

If you broke the rule, you broke the rule. No excuse. As an adult, you should bear the responsibility (and punishment) as an adult, if you are caught.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
I guess this was the "backfire" results of SAF implementing IPT couple years ago as it was meant for NS-Men to report later at 19:00 instead of RT's 18:00 and set-up in the mindset that those who opted for IPT will really try and train ourselves up to get better fitness and pass IPPT.

However, it end up that 85-95% of us taking IPT for the sole purpose of fulfilling IPT will excuse us from RT and consider IPPT clearance.

This end up that the "objective" of IPT was not met. So now, SAF enforce some improvement indicators via the PPT bands I guess :D

Good. You agree that 5-15% has jumped out from the unfit group. Partial success. More good years...
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
aiya why make nsmen train so hard for wat????...use the $$$$ to pay nsmen for going to rt n invest in more those remote control planes or watever thingy better....we no need to march or go so far so no need fitness......just need nimble thumbs.....or do u think u can train to run faster n last longer than a speeding bullet?????

A solid example of Singapore investing $$$ into its own NSmen for better health.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top