IPPT, IPT & RT Questions...

Status
Not open for further replies.

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
confirm based on hearsay?

PPT 1 is known as "Entry Level" for a reason. Check ns.sg.

Your 'read from FAQ' words carry more weight than the trainers there? :s8:

If yes, please go and talk to the Khatib FCC trainers and tell them they made a mistake.

There is actually band 0, if u been to khatib camp, there a board with PPT information on this. E.g if your 2.4km timing is above 14:40 sec or your pull up is 0, automatically you will be in band 0, so the target band to meet is 1.

I have verify with the trainers over there too, target band is the band that you must meet in order to clear the current year PPT. E.g Target band 1 = meet band 1, target band 2 = meet band 2.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
Your 'read from FAQ' words carry more weight than the trainers there? :s8:

If yes, please go and talk to the Khatib FCC trainers and tell them they made a mistake.

it may be the truth but we should not believe based on hearsay.

trainers take order from the management, who sets the rules.
 

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
it may be the truth but we should not believe based on hearsay.

trainers take order from the management, who sets the rules.

you say it might be the true but you said we should not believe based on hearsay? :s22:

I believe all PTIs are briefed on the rules/instructions given by their OC. If they are wrong, means OC also wrong lah. The people there are the experts or 'salesmen', they should have the 'product knowledge' of the program they are conducting. If they give wrong instructions/rules, it's their fault.

There is even a board with info.

There is actually band 0, if u been to khatib camp, there a board with PPT information on this. E.g if your 2.4km timing is above 14:40 sec or your pull up is 0, automatically you will be in band 0, so the target band to meet is 1.

Anyway, like I told you, if you feel they made a mistake, you can tell ns.sg that Khatib FCC is not doing the right thing by having band 0.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
you say it might be the true but you said we should not believe based on hearsay? :s22:

Hearsay is always unreliable (be it true or false).

Get from the horses mouth is the best. Unfortunately, this is the first year of the revised IPPT so many are confused since we can interpret in many ways.
 

Valadur

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2010
Messages
26
Reaction score
0
Sometimes the people from ns.sg also confused one. Like my case as stated in my previous post, I was assigned to ppt band 5 after my first ipt ippt session. So I called up ns.sg and ask what ppt target to hit since I band 5 ( which does not exist btw in ns.sg, faqs, or brochure). The lady (after checking with superior) told me since I am above ppt band 4, means I need to clear my Ippt in order to pass. PPT band does not apply to me (than I join ppt for what? lol).

I decided to double check with the PTI who clarified with his OC and they told me that I just need to hit PPT band 4 and will be considered pass this window. So with this new information, I called up ns.sg again. After a few exchanges, end up my unit called me and told me that the PTI is right. So I went and happily clear my ppt4 with ease hohoho.

Moral of the story is, go check with PTI whether band 0 exist and which ppt target to hit and double check with ns.sg. PTI in most cases is 100% correct one.
 

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
Hearsay is always unreliable (be it true or false).

Get from the horses mouth is the best. Unfortunately, this is the first year of the revised IPPT so many are confused since we can interpret in many ways.

Can you tell us if you are an official in this new E-IPT program? And if yes, can you tell us your name and rank so that people can verify with the FCC OC on what you said? We just cannot go and tell the OC that this temasekcity from hwz say there is no band 0 means no band 0. :s22:

If you don't want to tell us your name and rank, just give Khatib FCC OC a direct call and tell them they interpret the rules wrongly.

NS.sg is just a rough guide, the on-site people will know more.
 

redevils

Master Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2003
Messages
3,866
Reaction score
2
Like what i share here, i have personally check with the trainers at the FCC, target band is the band u must meet to clear your PPT. That is what TARGET BAND means... They have told us countless of time, if the out pro slip stated ppt 1, means you only need to meet band 1 to clear your PPT.

Even the PPT board on the Khatib FCC stated there is band 0, but you can't find this band 0 on ns.sg. And there is a requirement to hit band 0, e.g 2.4km must be more than 14:40s or pull up = 0.
They even have 2 set of examples on how to determine your banding.

When you failed ippt, doesn't mean your target band is 1, if you failed all station marginally, your target band should be 2.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
Sometimes the people from ns.sg also confused one. Like my case as stated in my previous post, I was assigned to ppt band 5 after my first ipt ippt session. So I called up ns.sg and ask what ppt target to hit since I band 5 ( which does not exist btw in ns.sg, faqs, or brochure). The lady (after checking with superior) told me since I am above ppt band 4, means I need to clear my Ippt in order to pass. PPT band does not apply to me (than I join ppt for what? lol).

I decided to double check with the PTI who clarified with his OC and they told me that I just need to hit PPT band 4 and will be considered pass this window. So with this new information, I called up ns.sg again. After a few exchanges, end up my unit called me and told me that the PTI is right. So I went and happily clear my ppt4 with ease hohoho.

Moral of the story is, go check with PTI whether band 0 exist and which ppt target to hit and double check with ns.sg. PTI in most cases is 100% correct one.

Check with PTI is good is a good suggestion. but 100% correct? depend on which PTI.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
Can you tell us if you are an official in this new E-IPT program? And if yes, can you tell us your name and rank so that people can verify with the FCC OC on what you said? We just cannot go and tell the OC that this temasekcity from hwz say there is no band 0 means no band 0. :s22:

If you don't want to tell us your name and rank, just give Khatib FCC OC a direct call and tell them they interpret the rules wrongly.

NS.sg is just a rough guide, the on-site people will know more.

I am not an official and left SAF donkey years ago.

What makes u think what you say in HWZ carry weight? Don't be naive.

Read from the official source ns.sg. Show me where is Band 0 and prove me wrong, son.
 

redevils

Master Member
Joined
Mar 18, 2003
Messages
3,866
Reaction score
2
I am not an official and left SAF donkey years ago.

What makes u think what you say in HWZ carry weight? Don't be naive.

Read from the official source ns.sg. Show me where is Band 0 and prove me wrong, son.

Haha. you mean by calling ns.sg and asking the trainers or PTI is wrong? only the website stated are correct? You make me laugh

You should go down to FCC and take a look on the OFFICIAL ANNOUNCEMENT
 

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
Check with PTI is good is a good suggestion. but 100% correct? depend on which PTI.

But when compared to your words(till u reveal some proof that your words can overrule the pti), it's still more trustworthy. That's all that people needs to know for now.

FCC PTI words v a HWZ member, it's a no brainer who to believe.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
Like what i share here, i have personally check with the trainers at the FCC, target band is the band u must meet to clear your PPT. That is what TARGET BAND means... They have told us countless of time, if the out pro slip stated ppt 1, means you only need to meet band 1 to clear your PPT.

Even the PPT board on the Khatib FCC stated there is band 0, but you can't find this band 0 on ns.sg. And there is a requirement to hit band 0, e.g 2.4km must be more than 14:40s or pull up = 0.
They even have 2 set of examples on how to determine your banding.

I wonder if other FCCs have such info. It is obvious that those cannot even meet the basic are band 0, if it exists. I think PTIs are filling up the grey areas to complete the picture.


When you failed ippt, doesn't mean your target band is 1, if you failed all station marginally, your target band should be 2.

Yes, this is the case so be smart to fail badly in 1 station intentionally.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
Haha. you mean by calling ns.sg and asking the trainers or PTI is wrong? only the website stated are correct? You make me laugh

You should go down to FCC and take a look on the OFFICIAL ANNOUNCEMENT

website info are black and white for all to see. if there is mistake, then you can use that to argue later on.

ns.sg are manned by so many people and there are so many PTIs. They did not set the standards.

always go to the source.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
But when compared to your words(till u reveal some proof that your words can overrule the pti), it's still more trustworthy. That's all that people needs to know for now.

FCC PTI words v a HWZ member, it's a no brainer who to believe.

so how heavy your words carry in HWZ?

i don't even bother to ask your name and rank. u r helpful but not the authority.
 

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
website info are black and white for all to see. if there is mistake, then you can use that to argue later on.

ns.sg are manned by so many people and there are so many PTIs. They did not set the standards.

always go to the source.

If ns.sg and the FCCs decide to have 2 sets of rules, it's not our fault. It's not Nsmen responsibility to ensure they are the both correct.

Since u say that ns.sg got massive manpower and so concerned, tell them to do an investigation.
 

temasekcity

Master Member
Joined
May 4, 2006
Messages
3,045
Reaction score
0
If ns.sg and the FCCs decide to have 2 sets of rules, it's not our fault. It's not Nsmen responsibility to ensure they are the both correct.

Since u say that ns.sg got massive manpower and so concerned, tell them to do an investigation.

if it is in ns.sg, you have a case.

if it is PTI or someone in ns.sg, he/she says sorry cos make mistake, you LLPL.

get real, son.
 

vasilli07

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2005
Messages
60,615
Reaction score
79
so how heavy your words carry in HWZ?

i don't even bother to ask your name and rank. u r helpful but not the authority.

i'm no authority here but unlike u, u are trying to overrule and challenge a pti words. So u should show us some proof your words carry some weight on why people should believe u more than a recognised authority like the on site fcc pti.

for goodness sake, reading just from ns.sg faq doesn't make your words more trustworthy than words from the pti himself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top