My WD passport essential 500GB just died within 3 months of use...
at first only clicking sound... now totally not accessible... I guess those data in it also gone?
I got it from Challenger... wonder if I can send back to them for exchange or do I need to exchange it from WD RMA procedure?... which would take longer time...
In mean while... I guess I need to get another HDD to backup my data...
need a reliable one this time...
so far, oviation and WD gives me bad impression... not durable!
So any recommendations?
Challenger doesn't do RMA for you.
It all depends on your luck with hard disks. People have different experience with different brands. I have had Samsung as the worse for me as it failed 100%, even RMA brand new set failed again. Toshiba Art Series failed after 4 months, Iomega (Samsung inside) failed after one month. However I have had success with WD, Hitachi and Seagate. So far been using them for years with no incident.
However, if you read the forums there are people cursing Seagate like hell.

So even if someone recommends a good brand like WD, there is no guarantee it won't fail as what you have experienced.