Looking for Intel Atom ITX Motherboard

loftystew

Master Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2009
Messages
2,926
Reaction score
15
Anyone seen any shops selling cheap Intel Atom ITX Motherboard that comes with:


  • At least 2 on-board Gigabit LAN Ports (Preferably Intel)
  • 1 x Mini PCI-Express card slot (Optional)

Reason for getting Atom processor is due to it's low power consumption. Planning to be used almost 24/7. My definition of cheap is, preferably, below $300.

BTW, AMD Fusion Motherboard will also do so long it fulfill my requirements.

Thanks in advance :s12:
 
Last edited:

coyote

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2000
Messages
86,806
Reaction score
29,246
Atom ITX are plenty... cheap they are definitely NOT.

S$300 for the cpu + motherboard is likely possible... however, ATOM or even AMD Zacate cpu + motherboard has probably missed it's time. As a much better performing Ivy bridge i3 + AsRock B75 can be had for about S$270 & the cpu is rated at a mearge 55W.

So how much power or electricity bill can you save changing from a Ivy Bridge I3 to an ATOM running at 25 or 35W? That's like 25~30W of saving. Try to do the math on your electricity tariff... it's simply makes no economic sense in getting ATOM even though they are cheaper now.

Anyone seen any shops selling cheap Intel Atom ITX Motherboard that comes with:


  • At least 2 on-board Gigabit LAN Ports (Preferably Intel)
  • 1 x Mini PCI-Express card slot (Optional)

Reason for getting Atom processor is due to it's low power consumption. Planning to be used almost 24/7. My definition of cheap is, preferably, below $300.

BTW, AMD Fusion Motherboard will also do so long it fulfill my requirements.

Thanks in advance :s12:
 

loftystew

Master Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2009
Messages
2,926
Reaction score
15
Atom ITX are plenty... cheap they are definitely NOT.

S$300 for the cpu + motherboard is likely possible... however, ATOM or even AMD Zacate cpu + motherboard has probably missed it's time. As a much better performing Ivy bridge i3 + AsRock B75 can be had for about S$270 & the cpu is rated at a mearge 55W.

So how much power or electricity bill can you save changing from a Ivy Bridge I3 to an ATOM running at 25 or 35W? That's like 25~30W of saving. Try to do the math on your electricity tariff... it's simply makes no economic sense in getting ATOM even though they are cheaper now.

I'm not sure how you calculate the power consumption but a core i3 2120 consume about 65W at full load whereas Intel Atom N2800 only consume about 10W at full load. There's plenty of reviews about power consumption. Google it up if you need sources.

How much can I save for 55W? Let's see...



Roughly save about an average of $11.12 per month. About $133.44 per year just the power consumption of processor alone.

As for cheap? Well, I believe it's cheap now for netbook processor.

ASRock E350M1/USB3 AMD Dual-Core E-350 Mini-ITX selling for $199.

Asus AT5IONT-I Intel® Atom D525 Dual-Core CPU Mini-ITX for $245 which comes with Nvidia ION graphics which I do not need. I believe I can get one at cheaper with just the standard Intel Integrated Graphics and without those extra gimmicks.

Both prices are below my definition of cheap but too bad it doesn't fit my 2 x LAN port requirement.

BTW, I'm already running about 6 PCs at home for almost the whole day. Just imagine my electricity bills. :s13:

What's your purpose of this PC?

Nothing too processing-power hungry. Running linux-based OS. Planning to run an IDS/IPS/UTM solution at home for the fun of it.
 
Last edited:

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
I'm not sure how you calculate the power consumption but a core i3 2120 consume about 65W at full load whereas Intel Atom N2800 only consume about 10W at full load. There's plenty of reviews about power consumption. Google it up if you need sources.

How much can I save for 55W? Let's see...



Roughly save about an average of $11.12 per month. About $133.44 per year just the power consumption of processor alone.

As for cheap? Well, I believe it's cheap now for netbook processor.

ASRock E350M1/USB3 AMD Dual-Core E-350 Mini-ITX selling for $199.

Asus AT5IONT-I Intel® Atom D525 Dual-Core CPU Mini-ITX for $245 which comes with Nvidia ION graphics which I do not need. I believe I can get one at cheaper with just the standard Intel Integrated Graphics and without those extra gimmicks.

Both prices are below my definition of cheap but too bad it doesn't fit my 2 x LAN port requirement.



Nothing too processing-power hungry. Running linux-based OS. Planning to run an IDS/IPS/UTM solution at home for the fun of it.
Wrong assumption: TDP does not equate to power consumption.

Another wrong assumption: Both Atom and Core i3 does not accomplish same task at same time.

power-2.png

power-2.png


You can see clearly despite Celeron G440's TDP at 35W and Atom at 10W, power consumption are pretty much same.
Looking at their relativity, Intel dual core Celeron/Pentium doesn't consume much more energy than Intel Atom.

itunes.png

photoshop.png

photoshop.png


However, Atom takes so much longer than even single core Celeron G440 that renders energy savings from Atom worthless and very time-consuming.

As you can see in the charts above, dual core Intel Celeron G540 only spend 25% of time needed by Atom D525 to complete Photoshop CS5 task while only spend 86% more energy than D525, thus saving around 54% of energy used by D525.
 
Last edited:

loftystew

Master Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2009
Messages
2,926
Reaction score
15
Nope, I'm not comparing TDP. I'm comparing i3 2120 with Atom N2800. If we are gonna compare, we have can't use an older technology to compare with a newer one, right? However, even Atom D525 uses significantly lesser power than i3 2120 at full load.


Intel Atom N2800 Power Consumption


Chart taken from Cedar Trail Platform: Intel D2500HN and Intel DN2800MT Mainboards Review. Page 9 - X-bit labs

Intel Core i3 2120 Power Consumption

Chart taken from Core i3-2120 and Core i3-2100 Processors Review. Page 8 - X-bit labs

Looks like the power consumption for i3 2120 is even higher than I previously thought.

We are comparing between Atom and i3 right?
 
Last edited:

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
Nope, I'm not comparing TDP. I'm comparing i3 2120 with Atom N2800. If we are gonna compare, we have can't use an older technology to compare with a newer one, right? However, even Atom D525 uses significantly lesser power than i3 2120 at full load.

Looks like the power consumption for i3 2120 is even higher than I previously thought.

We are comparing between Atom and i3 right?
You do realise the test setups are totally on split ends?

Mainboards:
ASRock E350M1 (AMD E-350 + AMD Hudson M1);
Gigabyte GA-D525TUD (Intel Atom D525 + Intel NM10 Express);
Intel Desktop Board DN2800MT (Intel Atom N2800 + Intel NM10 Express);
Intel Desktop Board D2500HN (Intel Atom D2500 + Intel NM10 Express)
.
Memory:
2 x 2 GB DDR3-800 SDRAM DIMM (Kingston KHX1600C8D3K2/4GX) 6-6-6-18;
2 x 2 GB DDR3-1067 SDRAM SODIMM (Apogee AS2G733-13G) 7-7-7-21.
Hard drive: Crucial m4 256 GB (CT256M4SSD2).
Power supply unit: Tagan TG880-U33II (880 W).
Operating system: Microsoft Windows 7 SP1 Home Premium x86.
Drivers:
AMD Catalyst 12.4 Driver;
AMD Chipset Driver 12.4;
Intel Chipset Driver 9.2.2.1034;
Intel Graphics Media Accelerator Driver 8.14.8.1077;
Intel Graphics Media Accelerator Driver 15.*12.*75.*50.*7.*2230.

Cedar Trail Platform: Intel D2500HN and Intel DN2800MT Mainboards Review. Page 4 - X-bit labs

Processors:
AMD Phenom II X4 955 (Deneb, 4 cores, 3.2 GHz, 6 L3);
Intel Core i5-2300 (Sandy Bridge, 4 cores, 2.8 GHz, 6 MB L3);
Intel Core i5-750 (Lynnfiled, 4 cores, 2.66 GHz, 8 MB L3);
Intel Core i5-680 (Clarkdale, 2 cores, 3.6 GHz, 4 MB L3);
Intel Core i3-2120 (Sandy Bridge, 2 cores, 3.3 GHz, 3 MB L3);
Intel Core i3-2100 (Sandy Bridge, 2 cores, 3.1 GHz, 3 MB L3);
Intel Core i3-560 (Clarkdale, 2 cores, 3.33 GHz, 4 MB L3);
Intel Core 2 Duo E7600 (Wolfdale, 2 cores, 3.06 GHz, 3 MB L2).
Mainboards:
ASUS Crosshair IV Formula (Socket AM3, AMD 890FX + SB850, DDR3 SDRAM);
ASUS P8P67 Deluxe (LGA1155, Intel P67 Express);
ASUS P5Q3 (LGA775, Intel P45 Express, DDR3 SDRAM);
Gigabyte P55A-UD6 (LGA1156, Intel P55 Express).
Memory — 2 x 2 GB DDR3 SDRAM (Kingston KHX1600C8D3K2/4GX):
DDR3-1067 7-7-7-21 with Core 2 Duo E7600 processor;
DDR3-1333 9-9-9-27 with Core i3-560, Core i5-680 and Core i5-750 processors;
DDR3-1600 9-9-9-27 with Phenom II X4 955, Core i5-2300, Core i3-2120 and Core i3-2100 processors.
Graphics card: ATI Radeon HD 6970.
Hard drive: Kingston SNVP325-S2/128GB.
Power supply unit: Tagan TG880-U33II (880 W).
Operating system: Microsoft Windows 7 SP1 Ultimate x64.
Drivers:
Intel Chipset Driver 9.2.0.1025;
Intel Rapid Storage Technology 10.1.0.1008;
ATI Catalyst 11.3 Display Driver.

Core i3-2120 and Core i3-2100 Processors Review. Page 3 - X-bit labs

And you noticed that my comparison for Celeron G440 with D525 as well as G440 with G540 is from the same article here:
http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/celeron-g540-g440_3.html#sect0
 
Last edited:

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
power-2.png


Just another 8W. And Core i3 is already much overkill and (of course) consume more power and is much more expensive, so you should compare something within same price, keeping price at constant to determining other differing factors.
 

loftystew

Master Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2009
Messages
2,926
Reaction score
15
Wrong assumption: TDP does not equate to power consumption.

Another wrong assumption: Both Atom and Core i3 does not accomplish same task at same time.

power-2.png

power-2.png


You can see clearly despite Celeron G440's TDP at 35W and Atom at 10W, power consumption are pretty much same.
Looking at their relativity, Intel dual core Celeron/Pentium doesn't consume much more energy than Intel Atom.

itunes.png

photoshop.png

photoshop.png


However, Atom takes so much longer than even single core Celeron G440 that renders energy savings from Atom worthless and very time-consuming.

As you can see in the charts above, dual core Intel Celeron G540 only spend 25% of time needed by Atom D525 to complete Photoshop CS5 task while only spend 86% more energy than D525, thus saving around 54% of energy used by D525.

And your test setup? Are they the same? The sources?

Your chart doesn't even shows the power consumption of D525 btw.

Edited: Nvm, you added the source. I will take a look. I will change my mind to get Celeron instead if it's doesn't consume significant power compared to Atom.
 
Last edited:

uncle168

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
17,871
Reaction score
0
please don't get n2800, it is very very slow, i regret buying my asus netbook

get g540 instead, cheap & fast in my diy pc
 

jaywalkra

Banned
Joined
Oct 28, 2010
Messages
1,034
Reaction score
0
please don't get n2800, it is very very slow, i regret buying my asus netbook

get g540 instead, cheap & fast in my diy pc

OT here, but I just wanna make a comment about my personal experience with Intel's G Pentium/Celeron series. Somehow, the boot-up times and system responsiveness were better & faster on my customer's G860 system (H61 mobo running SATA2 w/ Intel 330 60GB) than my own 3570K system (Z77 mobo running SATA3 w/ Intel 520 120GB)
 

watzup_ken

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2003
Messages
25,669
Reaction score
2,124
Having used such a low power solution, I find that the price to performance ratio is really poor. To be honest, I think you are better off getting a Intel Celeron solution over an Atom.

In terms of power consumption, the Atom chip draws less power at load. But do note it does take longer to complete a task as oppose to a proper desktop chip, even a lowly Celeron G540. The idea of low power is for the processor to complete the task as fast as possible and go into idle mode. At idle, I do feel that is comparable. The power consumption you see on the review depends heavily on the test bed specs. The review for G540 has a HD6970 which probably will affect the total power draw.

Intel Celeron G540 and Celeron G440 Processors Review. Page 3 - X-bit labs

Ultimately, the choice is yours, but just trying to create this awareness where potential buyers can rely on to make a purchase. ;)
 

coyote

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 20, 2000
Messages
86,806
Reaction score
29,246
I should have gotten the dlink dns 320L for $89 introductory offer, no need to compare what electricity, $ whatever....
 

Lippyt

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2007
Messages
911
Reaction score
0
Go blue forums n look for rimblock, he is a distributor for intel mobos n may have what u need.
 

ArcticCheetah

Banned
Joined
Apr 16, 2009
Messages
35,817
Reaction score
2,017
Anyone seen any shops selling cheap Intel Atom ITX Motherboard that comes with:


  • At least 2 on-board Gigabit LAN Ports (Preferably Intel)
  • 1 x Mini PCI-Express card slot (Optional)

Reason for getting Atom processor is due to it's low power consumption. Planning to be used almost 24/7. My definition of cheap is, preferably, below $300.

BTW, AMD Fusion Motherboard will also do so long it fulfill my requirements.

Thanks in advance :s12:
SLS 5F Laser Distribution has Intel Atom Boards if you are still interested.

Btw when comparing the power consumption you need to consider Mobo as well for socketed CPU.
 

pantss

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 2, 2008
Messages
2,309
Reaction score
777
bump thread.

anyone knows if atom has been superseded by another processor in terms of low power consump and if it's available in SLS?

thanks
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top