Mini-ITX Double Trouble (Dr_Disciple will like this)

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
So I have simultanous Rig problems that need to be solved

What I have are the following rigs:

Websurfing Rig

AMD A10-5700
ZOTAC A75-ITX WiFi
Noctua NH-L9a
2 x 4gb DDR3 1333 mhz
64 gb Crucial M4 SSD
Lian Li PC-Q12
Ubuntu 12.04 LTS


HTPC (Deceased)
Phenom II x4 905e
J&W MINIX 780G
4gb DDR2
160Gb Intel SSD
500gb 2.5” HDD
Silverstone Sugo SG-06
Winows 8.1

So I have to say that the HTPC was originally the Websurfing rig until it started having graphical corruption and general instability. So I pulled it off and replaced it. It continued on as a HTPC which would BSOD about once every time I watched a video on it. The drivers were also old as AMD no longer supports the HD 3200 integrated series. Windows 8 has always been finicky on it.

Yesterday while I was trying to play a video on it, it hung and after that, I couldn't get it to do anything. Inserting a USB drive would immediately hang the machine. Eventually I decided to reinstall Windows 8 and this is the result:

IMG_20150601_104505.jpg


So I can conclude that the HTPC is well and truely dead now. It is at least 6 years old.
I would like the replacement to be able to handle 4K videos in software mode and have a TV tuner so that I can use Kodi on it.

As for the Websurfing rig, it's not broken... except that this particular board has a problem (cannot install) with Ubuntu version 12.10 – 15.04. So it's still stuck on 12.04. I would like to update Ubuntu on it to 14.04 LTS.

This machine is 2 years old.

So I have come up with a number of solutions and would like some feedback

Solution 1:
ml06-e-34right.jpg

Acquire a Silverstone ML-06E, remove the A75 board from the Websurfing rig and place it inside there. Get a PCI-E DVB-T2 Tuner. Replace the A75 solution with some other soltion that's compatible with Ubuntu 14.04

Pros:

Slim case for HTPC
A10-5700 definitely works with an SFX PSU
Ubuntu Compatible solution for Websurfing rig acquired
Internal PCI-E tuner

Cons:
Expensive (requires 1 new Mini ITX board + Processsor + RAM + Silvestone case)

Solution 2:
isk110-vesa.jpg

Acquire an Antec ISK110, remove the A75 board from the Websurfing rig and place it inside there. Get a USB DVB-T2 Tuner. Replace the A75 solution with some other soltion that's compatible with Ubuntu 14.04.

Pros:
Cheaper
Smaller than the Silverstone

Cons:
the 90W PSU on the Antec ISK110 is definitely not able to handle peak loads from the A10-5700
(yoyo20 has done in on VR zone: http://forums.vr-zone.com/hardware-...i-itx-discussion-thread-628.html#post12840761)
USB Tuner may be a bit finicky....

Solution 3:
main_ZBOX-CI540NANO_17.jpg

Acquire a solution like the Zotac CI540 use it for the HTPC, get a USB tuner. Screw the Websurfing rig
http://www.lazada.sg/zotac-zbox-ci540-126669.html

Pros:

Low consumption while watching stuff
Integrated IR remote
Small
No fan on the HTPC

Cons:

Bloody expensive ($629)
Websurfing rig still isn't fixed
Only one 2.5” slot. Not much storage space.


Also, what is a good Mini-ITX solution to replace the A75 if I go down that route? Not thought about it yet. Or if someone has other suggestions then please tell me too
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
Recommended use solution 1

One vote for Solution 1! Is that because of the expansion ability?

BTW what is the recommended solution to replace the Web surfing rig on that PC-Q12 you sold me?
 

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
One vote for Solution 1! Is that because of the expansion ability?

BTW what is the recommended solution to replace the Web surfing rig on that PC-Q12 you sold me?
Solution 5: Spend just $33 on Windows 8.1 Pro and stay put with your current websurfing PC and eliminate the troublesome ubuntu issue.

Solution 6: Consider this for a low power 4K videos HTPC setup:

http://www.lazada.sg/zotac-zbox-id18-plus-windows-81-with-bing-102753.html

Be surprised that the CPU running inside (or rather its IGP) can handle 4K fine...

Troll those Bay Trail chips....

video-4.png

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/athlon-5350-sempron-3850_8.html#sect0
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
Solution 5: Spend just $33 on Windows 8.1 Pro and stay put with your current websurfing PC and eliminate the troublesome ubuntu issue.

Solution 6: Consider this for a low power 4K videos HTPC setup:

http://www.lazada.sg/zotac-zbox-id18-plus-windows-81-with-bing-102753.html

Be surprised that the CPU running inside (or rather its IGP) can handle 4K fine...

Troll those Bay Trail chips....

video-4.png

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/athlon-5350-sempron-3850_8.html#sect0
Don't even need to spend anything on Windows 8 if I take solution 5. I have that Windows 8 pro retail license from my now deceased HTPC. Reason why i haven't done that is because it's a rig used by my parents.

Winodws 8 will cause chaos due to the interface and I can bet my ass that it will be filled with malware, pop ups, toolbars in the span of 2 weeks. Their machine used to run windows and that was a monthly occurrence. It's bliss when you know that they can't install anything.
Option 6 later busy now
 

t258jgn

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2008
Messages
45,271
Reaction score
743
Silverstone Milo ML06 Mini-ITX Case
Asus H81I-Plus Skt1150 Mini-ITX Motherboard
G.Skill F3-1600C11S-4GNT 1x 4GB 1600MHz CL11 DDR3
FSP300-60GHS(80) 300W 80+ SFX (Black)
Intel Pentium G3258 3.2GHz Dual-Core
AVerTV Nova T2
@ $460
 

Dr_Disciple

Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2005
Messages
440
Reaction score
0
Don't waste time DIY. No one is doing that now unless your usage requires you to use a dedicated VGA card. See the full range of Zotac Zbox mini PC. You'll be spoilt with choices and you actually spend more time using it than fixing it up.

A ZBOX with windows 8.1 starts from $360. Any other config just drop me a Facebook text or WhatsApp :). Found a good source of components at a good price.
 

Dr_Disciple

Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2005
Messages
440
Reaction score
0
Don't forget about Lazada credit card discounts on certain days. It's even more worth it. Anyways just text me and talk about what you need in a Zbox. We now have Raid 1/0 with 2.5" HDD AND msata bay in the tiny 18 x 18 cm form factor.
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
Solution 5: Spend just $33 on Windows 8.1 Pro and stay put with your current websurfing PC and eliminate the troublesome ubuntu issue.

Solution 6: Consider this for a low power 4K videos HTPC setup:

http://www.lazada.sg/zotac-zbox-id18-plus-windows-81-with-bing-102753.html

Be surprised that the CPU running inside (or rather its IGP) can handle 4K fine...

Troll those Bay Trail chips....

video-4.png

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/cpu/display/athlon-5350-sempron-3850_8.html#sect0

Ooo I don't trust the Hardware decoders though. Too many times have I run into artifacting and black and white videos while using hardware decoders.

What's the minimum processor for 4k decoding (preferably 60fps) in Software?
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
Don't waste time DIY. No one is doing that now unless your usage requires you to use a dedicated VGA card. See the full range of Zotac Zbox mini PC. You'll be spoilt with choices and you actually spend more time using it than fixing it up.

A ZBOX with windows 8.1 starts from $360. Any other config just drop me a Facebook text or WhatsApp :). Found a good source of components at a good price.

Don't forget about Lazada credit card discounts on certain days. It's even more worth it. Anyways just text me and talk about what you need in a Zbox. We now have Raid 1/0 with 2.5" HDD AND msata bay in the tiny 18 x 18 cm form factor.

Noted. I saw the $360 box but felt that it wasn't up for either the HTPC or the websurfing box. I'll give you a buzz.
 

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
Don't even need to spend anything on Windows 8 if I take solution 5. I have that Windows 8 pro retail license from my now deceased HTPC. Reason why i haven't done that is because it's a rig used by my parents.

Winodws 8 will cause chaos due to the interface and I can bet my ass that it will be filled with malware, pop ups, toolbars in the span of 2 weeks. Their machine used to run windows and that was a monthly occurrence. It's bliss when you know that they can't install anything.
Option 6 later busy now
Give them just normal user account than administrator main account.
 

MoneyFace =p

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2010
Messages
35,380
Reaction score
402
Ooo I don't trust the Hardware decoders though. Too many times have I run into artifacting and black and white videos while using hardware decoders.

What's the minimum processor for 4k decoding (preferably 60fps) in Software?
Tried disabling HW acceleration on Chrome, playing 4K YouTube video on my quad core Sandy Bridge Core i5-2400:

jOYvwZEl.png




Doubt these low-powered dual core can handle them in software mode.
 
Last edited:

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
Tried disabling HW acceleration on Chrome, playing 4K YouTube video on my quad core Sandy Bridge Core i5-2400:

jOYvwZEl.png




Doubt these low-powered dual core can handle them in software mode.
Noted! Tried the same video on my 4770k and this was the result:

4K%20usage%204770k.png


This throws a spanner into plans to get a cheap Zbox.........
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
By the way, this is the real test:


about 75% average usage with acceleration with the 4770k. frame loss without acceleration. :eek:

Okay this might be an excessive test though.

Edit: Tried an i7-4500U @ 1.8ghz (Dual Core). Unable to play 4k at 30 FPS not to mention 60 FPS. Acceleration was on.

This is gonna be tough.....
 
Last edited:

tungsten2

Master Member
Joined
May 30, 2000
Messages
4,147
Reaction score
1
Don't even need to spend anything on Windows 8 if I take solution 5. I have that Windows 8 pro retail license from my now deceased HTPC. Reason why i haven't done that is because it's a rig used by my parents.

Winodws 8 will cause chaos due to the interface and I can bet my ass that it will be filled with malware, pop ups, toolbars in the span of 2 weeks. Their machine used to run windows and that was a monthly occurrence. It's bliss when you know that they can't install anything.
Option 6 later busy now


Simple. Just setup 2 account on the machine.
Admin a/c - for you to manage the machine
Limited User a/c - this account for your parents to use.

Start -> cmd -> controluserpasswords2
I use this command to boot to the Limited account on WinXP and Win7.
Have not tried on windows 8 though.
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
Simple. Just setup 2 account on the machine.
Admin a/c - for you to manage the machine
Limited User a/c - this account for your parents to use.

Start -> cmd -> controluserpasswords2
I use this command to boot to the Limited account on WinXP and Win7.
Have not tried on windows 8 though.

I'm gonna try that.... gonna dig my laptop out... the last time I had windows on their machine I found the browser filled with toolbars and redirecting pages. Thank goodness Internet banking and credit card transactions had not started then.
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
And update. I have tried the following 4K tests on 2 rigs I have at my disposal.

They are the Big Bunny Test:
http://bbb3d.renderfarming.net/download.html
with VLC

And the Coasta Rica 4K test


A10-5700 + A75 (7660D APU graphics)
Bad stuttering with acceleration on both tests. The the Big Bunny Test kept freezing

4k%20Win8.png


Opteron 4180 (Essentially a 2.5ghz Phenom II x6) + GTX 760
runs fine for 2 seconds at a time them skips ahead.

I can conclude that neither of these configurations are suited to 4K decoding. 4K really requires a lot of resources! :eek:

Opteron 4180: 3935 Passmark CPU marks
i7-4770k: 10208
i5-2400: 5820

I think we're looking at something at somewhat above the i5-2400 to decode 4K because the transformer video isn't the most demanding 4K vid. So far the star citizen video on Page 1 is the most demanding I've seen so far.

Hope this thread will be useful for others in the future.
 

tungsten2

Master Member
Joined
May 30, 2000
Messages
4,147
Reaction score
1
Oops, the correct command should be :
Start -> cmd -> control userpasswords2
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top