Mobile Network Experience (Singtel vs StarHub vs M1 vs SIMBA)

[jess_sy]

IMDA Quality of Service Performance Results for July – September 2023

Source:
https://www.imda.gov.sg/regulations...-to-imda-standards/4g-services/jul---sep-2023

IMDA's Performance Survey Period: Q3 2023​

No of buildings passed/ No of buildings tested
Compliance standard > 85% per building

M1	Singtel Mobile	StarHub Mobile	SIMBA
58/60	59/60	59/60	60/60

Downtown Line (MRT Tunnel)

M1	Singtel Mobile	StarHub Mobile	SIMBA
Fail*	Fail*	Pass	Pass

M1 and Singtel Mobile had failed to meet the 4G QoS standard of >99% in the Downtown Line in Q3 2023.

 

[jess_sy]

Opensignal November 2023 Singapore Report

Source: Opensignal
https://www.opensignal.com/reports/2023/11/singapore/mobile-network-experience

 

[Jurong640]

interesting. Simba is improving, its intrestingly better than M1 in building, and tunnels.

 

[keenklee]

interesting. Simba is improving, its intrestingly better than M1 in building, and tunnels.

IMHO.
Advantage of late comer.

 

[jess_sy]

interesting. Simba is improving, its intrestingly better than M1 in building, and tunnels.

IMHO.
Advantage of late comer.

It will interesting to see how the other 3 telcos perform when 3G network is gone. Some telco in some area cannot even provide proper 4G network connection.

 

[keenklee]

It will interesting to see how the other 3 telcos perform when 3G network is gone. Some telco in some area cannot even provide proper 4G network connection.

IMHO.
Any ideas locations that will switch to 3G ? I don't recall seeing 3G for quite sometime already.

 

[jess_sy]

IMHO.
Any ideas locations that will switch to 3G ? I don't recall seeing 3G for quite sometime already.

Usually are underground (MRT) or shopping malls or industrial estates (indoor). Phone will fallback to 3G/H+ while 4G not stable..... LOL

 

[Food_Lover]

IMHO.
Any ideas locations that will switch to 3G ? I don't recall seeing 3G for quite sometime already.

Some shopping mall's toilets do not have 4G services. Only 3G nia.

 

[keenklee]

Some shopping mall's toilets do not have 4G services. Only 3G nia.

IMHO.
Like that emergency need to call how ???

P.S. I wonder if i start a thread for contribution of places with 3G only, will there be contributors or not.

 

[froztheart]

IMHO.
Like that emergency need to call how ???

P.S. I wonder if i start a thread for contribution of places with 3G only, will there be contributors or not.

What for? Its shutting down next year.

 

[keenklee]

What for? Its shutting down next year.

IMHO.
Then will know which are the places that don't have 4G coverage mah.

 

[Jurong640]

IMHO.
Like that emergency need to call how ???

P.S. I wonder if i start a thread for contribution of places with 3G only, will there be contributors or not.

3g only available in Slums area. Like Lim Chu Kang. But no tracking as its closing down in July.

 

[keenklee]

3g only available in Slums area. Like Lim Chu Kang. But no tracking as its closing down in July.

IMHO.
Any specific areas ? Lim Chu Kang quite long leh.

 

[4D.TOTO&BS]

Singtel owns antique

 

[yusoffb01]

quite accurate with my experience. when on zym, always drop to 3G and nothing loads.

 

[jess_sy]

Singapore’s StarHub shares first place for Games Experience in Group II with SK telecom and LG U+​

Due to a three-way statistical tie, StarHub, SK telecom and LG U+ are Group II’s Global Winners for Games Experience. In addition, StarHub is one of six Global Winners in this group for Video Experience

https://www.opensignal.com/reports/2024/02/global-mobile-network-experience-awards

 

[pohu]

Singtel owns antique

Qns: does this area still able to receive 4G signal despite having a wider 5G coverage?

 

[froztheart]

Qns: does this area still able to receive 4G signal despite having a wider 5G coverage?

It should since without 5G, it should fall back to 4G.

 

[pohu]

It should since without 5G, it should fall back to 4G.

Thanks for the clarification

 

[jess_sy]

IMDA Quality of Service Performance Results for October - December 2023​

IMDA's Performance Survey Period: Q4 2023​

No of buildings passed/ No of buildings tested
Compliance standard > 85% per building

M1	Singtel Mobile	StarHub Mobile	SIMBA
58/60	60/60	59/60	59/60

https://www.imda.gov.sg/regulations...-to-imda-standards/4g-services/oct---dec-2023