Need help regarding Specialist memo

DazMozzy

Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2012
Messages
344
Reaction score
0
Hi all, i'm currently serving NS for the SPF. Sometime during my BPT i started to have this back pain near the lower part of my spine/backbone. I didn't seek for help as i thought that it was caused by frequent contact against hard flooring during my PT sessions in HTA. However after i got posted out to my unit, my back pain gets more frequent as my job scope basically requires long periods of either standing or sitting down. There's not much of moving around for my everyday work. So i decided to check out whats the cause of the pain and went to see a private Orthopaedic (bone specialist). After getting some Xray scans and diagnosis, the specialist wrote me a memo and told me to pass it to my camp MO. As my camp doesn't have a MO, i have to travel all the way back to HTA to pass the memo to the MO there. When it was my turn to see the MO, i passed him the memo that the specialist gave me. The MO read the memo and said that he doesnt trust the specialist and told me to get it check at another government hospital. ????? I spent quite an amount of money and all he commented was that he doesnt trust the private specialist?? So basically my question, is my camp MO even allowed to reject specialist letters just like that without even giving a reasonable explanation as to why he doesnt trust my specialist and wanting me to get it check again?

TLTR: Basically I experienced pain in my lower back, seek help from private specialist. Specialist wrote memo to be given to camp MO. MO doesnt trust specialist. Help
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,386
Reaction score
5,902
Hi all, i'm currently serving NS for the SPF. Sometime during my BPT i started to have this back pain near the lower part of my spine/backbone. I didn't seek for help as i thought that it was caused by frequent contact against hard flooring during my PT sessions in HTA. However after i got posted out to my unit, my back pain gets more frequent as my job scope basically requires long periods of either standing or sitting down. There's not much of moving around for my everyday work. So i decided to check out whats the cause of the pain and went to see a private Orthopaedic (bone specialist). After getting some Xray scans and diagnosis, the specialist wrote me a memo and told me to pass it to my camp MO. As my camp doesn't have a MO, i have to travel all the way back to HTA to pass the memo to the MO there. When it was my turn to see the MO, i passed him the memo that the specialist gave me. The MO read the memo and said that he doesnt trust the specialist and told me to get it check at another government hospital. ????? I spent quite an amount of money and all he commented was that he doesnt trust the private specialist?? So basically my question, is my camp MO even allowed to reject specialist letters just like that without even giving a reasonable explanation as to why he doesnt trust my specialist and wanting me to get it check again?

TLTR: Basically I experienced pain in my lower back, seek help from private specialist. Specialist wrote memo to be given to camp MO. MO doesnt trust specialist. Help
The thing about private specialist is, MO may still want you to go to a public hospital specialist to get a second opinion. And since it's public hospital, you are covered by 11B hence if you really want to have your PES review, then go see public hospital lor. There's nothing much you can do about it.
 

DazMozzy

Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2012
Messages
344
Reaction score
0
So you are saying MOs are allowed to do that? Is this official? Sorry not doubting you but i really feel that the MO is unreasonable..
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,386
Reaction score
5,902
So you are saying MOs are allowed to do that? Is this official? Sorry not doubting you but i really feel that the MO is unreasonable..
I mean I am only hearing from you that you said the mo said he "doesn't trust the specialist", I am not sure if he actually said that... But he has every right to send you to a government specialist to get a second opinion.

I would have thought he would just refer you, but apparently he didn't?
 

DazMozzy

Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2012
Messages
344
Reaction score
0
He did said that he doesnt trust the specialist. And yes he did refer me to a government hospital but the appointment is taking quite long
 

reddevil0728

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
66,386
Reaction score
5,902
He did said that he doesnt trust the specialist. And yes he did refer me to a government hospital but the appointment is taking quite long
Well since you said he referred you to a government hospital, that means he is doing what he can do and that's to get a second opinion. Whatever he said it doesn't matter.

In the mean time I supposed he gave you excuse?

Btw if you can neither stand for Long or sit for Long, what can you do?
 

DazMozzy

Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2012
Messages
344
Reaction score
0
Just not happy with how the mo deal with things. Well in my normal life if my back hurts from sitting too long at least i get to walk around my house or go down for a walk lol
 

YYS1995

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2013
Messages
436
Reaction score
0
Just not happy with how the mo deal with things. Well in my normal life if my back hurts from sitting too long at least i get to walk around my house or go down for a walk lol

It's not your "normal life". Its NS.

I can understand how frustrating it can be, sending you to get a second opinion and all, but that's the way things are done. (I went to both Private and Govt Hospital and they had the same diagnosis) > The MO has every right to reject specialist letter (at his own discretion) and ask you to get a second opinion at govt hospital as some private specialists are really lax.
My own condition had to be further validated by a board of specialists as it was kinda rare condition (SAF Specialist Board) before getting my PES changed and obtaining a permanent status.

Just sit back.. since you are already excused... and wait for them. This medical process is about waiting.. and waiting.. and waiting.
 

Godbleseu

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2010
Messages
726
Reaction score
279
Too me honest, private specialist letter can get easily with money.

They will charge you per letter $500 and above etc....and it might be possible that the specialist is under the "blacklist" book.
 

YYS1995

Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2013
Messages
436
Reaction score
0
Too me honest, private specialist letter can get easily with money.

They will charge you per letter $500 and above etc....and it might be possible that the specialist is under the "blacklist" book.

Private Specialist letter is powerful one. So normally if it's a genuine, urgent condition I suggest heading to a private specialist first to get a memo. With that memo, at the very least you would get an excuse for which ever activity you cannot do.

Then, visit the Govt. Hospital specialist that the MO referred you to for a second opinion (usually takes 1-2 months... Govt Hospital waiting time longer), get his memo. Usually the down PES would happen after the MO sees the memo from the Govt. Hospital Specialist.

-For Genuine Conditions Only-
 

God Of Pcc

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2014
Messages
14,015
Reaction score
888
yes,be it private or Govt hosp specialist ,even if ish hospitial director,MO can also order u to see another,but if anything happen to U,he will be held fully responsible.

back issues,usually very clear cut,i have quite similar problems with TS,stand long,sit long ,pain

My personal experience,i did not even see a specialist,was told by clinic doc to go for MRI scan at private clinic(for scaning),get the MRI results,straight away downgrade for slipped disc ,no need specialist letter
Then later i myself go book PT,take medicine,it being a yr already got improvement but slipped disc won't recover one :(

So,to really help you TS,all i can said is,just follow that MO instructions but in the meantime,if u really painful,go report sick,go see your pte specialist for help,while waiting for the govt one.Most likely he will give u pain killers or injection,to relieve your pain,or perhaps PT

In the meantime,do take care of your back
 
Last edited:

God Of Pcc

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2014
Messages
14,015
Reaction score
888
May I add, if the specialist letter is from government specialist, then maybe they wouldn't send for 2nd opinion again at other government specialist.

Be it private or govt,back problems,very clear cut.U do a MRI scan,got problems that fit the MO bible.

Straight away down pes
 

rongguang

Banned
Joined
Nov 17, 2011
Messages
7,853
Reaction score
0
Too me honest, private specialist letter can get easily with money.

They will charge you per letter $500 and above etc....and it might be possible that the specialist is under the "blacklist" book.

Pte specialist letter can easily get,agree but hor whether can downgrade or not,still depend on the Medical diagnosis one lah

For example,if you just have a back pain,nothing else

Pte specialist,even if his a big shot,very experience,at most can help u write letter said,the patient,always have serious back pain,might affect his training deployment ,etc

But most likely MO,medical board will not downgrade

Because not matter what,private or govt,the diagnosis not serious,pte specialist also cannot help u much to downgrade

However if u have a serious slipped disc,ligament torn,u just really need medical documents such as X-ray,MRI scans more than enough liao loh,i mean the injury is there,cannot bluff,unless he can forge the MRI SCAN lah :s13:
 

Godbleseu

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2010
Messages
726
Reaction score
279
Pte specialist letter can easily get,agree but hor whether can downgrade or not,still depend on the Medical diagnosis one lah

For example,if you just have a back pain,nothing else

Pte specialist,even if his a big shot,very experience,at most can help u write letter said,the patient,always have serious back pain,might affect his training deployment ,etc

But most likely MO,medical board will not downgrade

Because not matter what,private or govt,the diagnosis not serious,pte specialist also cannot help u much to downgrade

However if u have a serious slipped disc,ligament torn,u just really need medical documents such as X-ray,MRI scans more than enough liao loh,i mean the injury is there,cannot bluff,unless he can forge the MRI SCAN lah :s13:

Not very true leh, certain condition not serious but a powerful private specialist letter with MRI supporting e.g "slight disc bulging" can be downgraded to C9L9 depending on how powerful is the memo or letter. Back problem is very common due to our daily seating posture but not all back problem will warrant a downgrade IF you never do MRI and most people will suely have some minor issue on back problem as its never a perfect one due to aging. Just like heart. With that evidence, public hospital specialist will not write u a downgrade letter and at most some excuses only. This is the time to go private and get a powerful specialist memo.
 

derrickgoh

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
39,097
Reaction score
13
The issue is most if not all MOs feel that private specialists are more lenient i.e. money can buy whatever report you want them to write. Of course in reality that is not true. No private specialist will write you a letter to say you have a hole in your heart when you don't unless he wishes to face legal action.

But the impression is there. Which is why TS's MO said to go to govt hospital to see specialist. Its like MCs. Some companies feel that private doctor is more relaxed and give MCs easily wherelse polyclinic doctors supposedly stricter and more ngeow with MCs.

When I have a should injury during my NS I went to SGH despite my parents suggesting going to private. Their view was also that "private got more power" but I knew how SAF works. SAF view is private very easy going and thus not counted.

TS seriously should have asked around before wasting time and money.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top