New crane tips over at Tuas Port

[jeff79]

Crane number 2304. The same one as in the sany marine video. So strange can survive loading onto the ship and voyage to Singapore but buckled upon unloading.

 

[beanstalk6]

Crane number 2304. The same one as in the sany marine video. So strange can survive loading onto the ship and voyage to Singapore but buckled upon unloading.

It was probably taken apart before it was unloaded at Tuas and then reassembled on the pier. The assembly was not done properly.

 

[gaul_ads]

MPA & PSA ought to be ashamed of themselves to say that there are no damage.

The integrity of their report is calling into question now with video showing tremendous damages.

Maybe mean no damage to their bonus

 

[weiess]

heng..no injuries..
but heads going to roll..

 

[BigMonkey]

don’t quite understand the last statement made by MPA and PSA.

 

[Apparatus]

what’s the cost of the dmg?
the crane can still use or have to dismantle and order a new crane?
the port no damage or safety inspection?

You think PSA would want a repaired crane or a totally new crane?

 

[archie7]

You think PSA would want a repaired crane or a totally new crane?

you tot
i think
tiang eh sai confirm?

 

[Apparatus]

It was probably taken apart before it was unloaded at Tuas and then reassembled on the pier. The assembly was not done properly.

Don't know don't anyhow say lah

There are a few people who worked or is working in PSA container ports from the way they talk

 

[Apparatus]

you tot
i think
tiang eh sai confirm?

If you are PSA what would you do? Want a repaired crane or a totally new crane?

 

[Itsthatguy]

There is missing words in the first post vs the ST article.

adjacent is missing

Inadvertent omission

 

[Itsthatguy]

heng..no injuries..
but heads going to roll..

If PSA foundation ok, then it should be manufacturers liability. Manufacturer should be responsible to load and unload and installation.

 

[Atrina_Boy]

Curious to know whether able to claim insurance for the damaged?

 

[Globe]

Inadvertent omission

they updated the memo after being called out i think

 

[archie7]

If you are PSA what would you do? Want a repaired crane or a totally new crane?

 

[jeff79]

New video posted from a container ship. Confirmed my earlier post that the wheels bogies had snapped and had lodged between the berth and the ship. There are ＂bumpers＂ at edge of the berth. I think those ＂bumpers＂ prevented the wheels bogies from dropping into the sea.

First screehshot. With reference to the forklift truck on the ship at lower left. The yellow with black diagonal stripes to the right near the forklift are the snapped wheels bogies. The horizonal yellow black line above the forklift is the edge of berth and edge of ship.

2nd screenshot. The snapped wheel bogie viewed from side.

3rd screenshot. View of tuas port from a ship showing the yellow and black horizonal marking edge of berth and the ＂bumpers＂.

 

[BuffBuffForevaAttached]

you’ll be surprised how many mic cranes are used by PSA in sg i can say probably more than half are mic, but partly due to them being the market leaders in this segment.

for this case i would say is whoever was in charge of handling the crane screwed up sure tio kan

leaders in what sense? high quality or low price?

Where is the other half from?

 

[PiKa]

 

[jeff79]

leaders in what sense? high quality or low price?

Where is the other half from?

China zpmc alone has more than 70% share of the global market. Read that 3 companies make up the other 20%.
Germany’s Liebherr, Japan’s Mitsui e&s, and S. Korea’s HD Hyundai Samho.

This sany marine is relatively new player to the port crane business.

https://www.msn.com/en-xl/news/othe...-as-tariffs-target-chinese-rivals/ar-AA1FCu0I

 

[cute_togepi]

Last year Sengkang crane topple onto van is also Sany.

 

[106gunner]