Can elaborate more on simi wrong depiction?

Wrong thread for this. Paiseh to TS and fans..
I think it is on official channel, so over 3 mil views.. Don't think will be taken down.
Good topic to chat with ATBs...![]()


Movie version is shooting now.
Liu YiFei.. her rivalry with Yang Mi continues..![]()


過路稻草人™;107128550 said:Hi
Starting of Epi 46 洪七公 supposed to called both 郭靖 and 黃蓉 to 一人各他老人家捶一條腿 。
The 八月十五 fight supposed to be at past midnight. And 歐陽鋒 triggered the fight.
Then a huge fog came by and cloud everyone vision. But not by a horse. Then 歐陽鋒 summoned 蛇陣 and trapped everyone , that they retreated to the top of 醉仙樓。 之後就驅使兵以弓箭如雨下。
周伯通 ran and stay at the top of 醉仙樓。 they fought their way thru to the back alley. And not under a tunnel.
柯老妖怪,kenna arrow on his leg. 黃蓉 gotten two soldier to ferry him, and help bandaged him.
過路稻草人™;107128143 said:Refer to post 1493.

郭靖 Supposed run after 完顏洪烈 but nope in these 2 epi.Agree. Quite a bit of deviation from the novel for these 2 episodes. Huang Yaoshi did not lose to the quanzhen disciples and Guo Jing in the novel. Here it was shown that he lost. Qiu Qianren was also supposed to appear. He didn't. Not correct.
That itself 顛覆了作者筆下之意境和通過文筆所描繪的敘事。some people don't follow storyline worhs
to each of his own
![]()
過路稻草人™;107133073 said:That itself 顛覆了作者筆下之意境和通過文筆所描繪的敘事。

過路稻草人™;107133017 said:郭靖 Supposed run after 完顏洪烈 but nope in these 2 epi.
The 裘千仭 part was missing.
2 Foot soldiers to carry 柯老妖 also missing.
From here it look like the director is making haste toeards the ending to end at epi 52.
Quite disappointing for 醉仙樓之役, suppose to captivate how 黃藥師 skill in handling 天罡北斗陣 amd how 歐陽鋒 tried to eliminate 裘千仭 at the same time battle 全真6雜毛。
How 黃蓉 dislodged 歐陽鋒 蛇杖 into 鴛鴦湖。 all have been skipped。
Instead it highlighted what happened in the 醉仙樓 where they hoohaa about 武穆遺書。。
該做的不做, 不該做的又做了一籮筐,還要做錯。
The novel stated that it was due to mist and not OYK's poisonous gas that created the confusion. some people don't follow storyline worhs
to each of his own
![]()
過路稻草人™;106887162 said:Agree, on the 楊康 plot 已經是離經叛道。
胡歌 just don't cut IT for 郭靖, the 憨厚愚鈍 really come across as 造作, but what makes me switch off completely from the show is AL castinh of 黃蓉, first she lack the what 金庸 depict 黃蓉 to be, first in decorum (首次以女裝登場時,書中描述「黃蓉長髮披肩,全身白衣,頭束金帶,白雪一映更是燦然生光,猶如仙女一般,肌膚勝雪,容貌嬌美無匹,容色絕麗,豔如春花,麗若朝霞)
黃蓉曾唱過一首辛棄疾的《瑞鶴仙》,據推測用以形容黃蓉之美。
節錄瑞鶴仙前段:「雁霜寒透幕。正護月雲輕,嫩冰猶薄。溪奩照梳掠,想含香弄粉,豔妝難學。玉肌瘦弱。更重重、龍綃襯著,倚東風,一笑嫣然,轉盼萬花羞落。」
林依晨 just dont cut it, her decorum just dont befit, next will be her portrayal of 黃蓉 character, she just dont come across as a learned woman from a learned background.
Sje appeared boorish with some of her small action and micro expression. She lacks the 閉月羞花之貌 和 沉魚落雁之美, 少了懷春羞澀之情, 卻充斥傲慢專橫無理之儀。
Except 翁美玲 (有時也屬過於刁蠻, 朱茵 and 周迅will be more rounded, 李一桐 befits in the looks dept, and her verson will be 可圈可點, 剛好到位。
Prior to this version 射雕英雄傳 ,my list of choice actress for the role of 黃蓉 in such a order 翁美玲, 周迅, 朱茵。
But after this 射雕英雄傳 2017 the choice list change and updated as 李一桐, 翁美玲, 周迅, 朱茵。
Exactly.
Those who read the novel will know. Most ppl thought HR appearance is to look cute regardless of looks but in fact, Jin Yong has described HR as exceptionally beautiful with smooth fair complexion, long shiny black hair to the waist, delicate, elegant and graceful with a tinge of girlish giggle, playfulness and a superb captivating smile. Almost all men who first saw HR were captivated by her, including her adversaries. She is well learned, talented, refined and cultured. Her martial arts moves were described to be extremely graceful and the actress must have some dancing background to portray that.
I simply cannot see that in Ariel's HR. I thought she was a nasty spitfire chilli-padi who kept cursing and swearing.
The only two bad points i will point out is that LYT's portrayal lack the 灵气 and the "meanness". HR could be really mean at times especially when jealous or when she didn't see something 顺眼. I rate LYT near to Barbara's portrayal. LYT actually bothered to read the novel to get an understanding of the real HR, and didn't watch how previous actresses acted.
As for GJ, Felix wang's portrayal is still unbeatable. That blank, dull, silly but honest expression is so memorable. Not even julian comes close.
The scenery and the chiobu actresses are the plus points to this drama. Thumbs up!
In front waste too much time and frames on lovey dovey, important parts gitten chop off. Like 黃蓉 智闖 漁樵耕讀, all briefly go over.In front too many things, behind chop chop curry pok
Several webby hosting the streams.finish showing le gotch bukit timah then tell me ok?
thank you.